dhmac

Although 1080p is the "HD Holy Grail", this is just a poll on these two Hi-Def formats: 720p or 1080i

Which of these two do you prefer?

mbs

I like 720p, just because my LCD is 760p natively. 720p upscaled (TV does it with its scaler) to 760p looks better to me than 1080i downscaled to 760p.

speedyray

On my set they both appear nearly identical. I will be eager to see if there is a difference when we get the higher data rate of BR or HD-DVD if there is a more noticable difference.

joshd2012

720p looks a lot better on my LCD than 1080i.

Spiky

Unless someone here has a CRT front projector that can do both natively for a direct comparison, this poll will be match which kind of TV people have right down the line. 720 sources look better on 720 TVs, and 1080 sources look better on 1080 TVs.

Xytraguptorh

720p on my Optoma H31 projector is better than 1080i. That's with a Voom set top box for OTA and a Dish 6000 receiver. I guess the projector just scales that resolution better.

For my TV, a Toshiba 65H81, 1080i is the only way to go. I have a Samsung Directv set top box, and HD sat channels and OTA look good at 1080i.

I also have an Infocus X1 projector, and I can't tell much difference at all between 1080i and 720p. Both look good (better than DVD), with 1080i maybe looking a little bit sharper.

I'm hoping that by the time Bluray players become affordable, 1080p front projectors also drop in price a lot. That will be a sweet setup.

Adam Tyner

Right. Maybe it's just a factor of my older HDTV's size, but on my 36" VVega, 720p and 1080i both looked great. On my 50" Panasonic plasma, the scaler doesn't handle 720p that well, leaving 1080i looking much, much better.

ShagMan

I voted 720P, since that's what most displays are native right now... my projector looks a LOT better in 720P because of this... when 1080P native sets/projectors are common, my vote will change to 1080i

darkside

I can't tell the difference on my Sony rear projection.

cornflakeguy

I can't tell the difference on my 46 in Sony RP HDTV.

But most of the time my Comcast box stutters on 1080i so I go with 720p. When 1080i is working normally, it looks the same anyway.

I wonder if it wasn't going to a hard drive first if my HD would look better than it does now? I'd bet so, but alas I have no way to find out. My Comacast DVR is my only HD source.

cfg!

sparks

My Mit 65711 only does 480/1080i. I couldn't tell the difference between 480 and 1080, but then my 1080 connection hasn't been calibrated.

mdc3000

My Sony RP HDTV doesn't seem to like 720 much...but it LOVES 1080i and it looks stunning to me, so that is definitely my pick.

MATT

Spiky

My TV is 720p. When comparing the HDTivo and the TV to see which downconverted the 1080i signals better, I couldn't see enough difference to care which was better. And the differences were able to be fixed via calibration. So for input issues, it didn't matter.

However, watching the 2 different types of sources reveals some obvious differences. All of this is SERIOUSLY affected by compression/downrezzing from the provider, as well. Or my reception. So, this is really comparing the best of both that I've seen to take out the possibility of compression skewing it.

1080 sources can appear to have better resolution, when compared to a similar show from a 720 channel. They really can be sharp due to this, even when downrezzed to 720p. 720 sources can have REALLY smooth action, just incredible. When ABC does football well, it is the best source I've seen at my house. Without ever being interlaced, the progressive signal is awesome.

Other than that, they both look great. I don't have any preference. I just want HDLite to STOP!!

dhmac

My set is 768p in resolution, so I figured 720p would look better because it's basically my set's native format and has the strong advantage of being true progressive.

So I was very surprised to see that 1080i programming does look better on my set. It's just sharper and more detailed than 720p programming. I may be wrong, but I suspect that the local 720p DTV channels aren't sending a full 720-line signal, because the extra 48-lines in my set just aren't enough to explain the difference I see, while the downconverted and de-interlaced 1080i signals are using the full 768-line resolution of my set. However, on the other hand, 720p does look better on images with fast-motion, with 1080i having more apparent blurring during such images (this is only something I notice in comparing NFL football between the networks).

So it was tough to choose, but I selected 1080i as my preferred format, although 720p is the better choice for football in HD.

DthRdrX

Right now my bedroom TV is 1080i native and my Projector is 720p native. Both look outstanding given their native resolution. I don;t think I could pick which one is better though since one is 110' and the other is 30'.

Given how great 720p looks on a big screen I just can't wait until we start seeing the 1080p LCD Projectors within the next year or so. The increase in resolution plus the addition of Epson's C2Fine technology is going to make for some really amazing displays.

RockyMtnBri

Gotta go with Spiky - I have a JVC 52" D-ila that's 720p, and a Sony 34" XBR 960 CRT that's 1080i native. The thing I like better about my Sony is that it'll display the resolution from each source in the initial menu.

Adam Tyner

It'll take 720p input, but it's a 1080i display.

RockyMtnBri

Adam...

I remembered my mistake and corrected it - thanks. BTW, nice avatar!