The Godfather: The Coppola Restoration Blu-ray Collection - 9/23/08
#128
Member
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 101
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
just got the bluray set...and I'm a little disappointed.
Picture is a tad sharper and colors are improved over the 2001 dvd...but I was expecting more. Even these improvements aren't obvious unless you compare them side by side.
I bet the new DVD restoration looks almost as good as this...because I wouldn't say that this is a huge leap from the 2001 DVDs(a nice improvement, but not the leap I was expecting).
I understand that they didn't want to lose it's "film" look...but I wish some work was done to make the picture at least a little bit more pristine.
Most other old movies I've seen on bluray look great. Picture is sharp, but doesn't lose the "film" look.
Picture is a tad sharper and colors are improved over the 2001 dvd...but I was expecting more. Even these improvements aren't obvious unless you compare them side by side.
I bet the new DVD restoration looks almost as good as this...because I wouldn't say that this is a huge leap from the 2001 DVDs(a nice improvement, but not the leap I was expecting).
I understand that they didn't want to lose it's "film" look...but I wish some work was done to make the picture at least a little bit more pristine.
Most other old movies I've seen on bluray look great. Picture is sharp, but doesn't lose the "film" look.
Last edited by wd65733; 09-20-08 at 07:12 PM.
#129
DVD Talk Legend
Good comparison pics thread from the one and only Xylon over at the AVS forum.
These are better than DVD Beavers comparison shots IMO.
The new transfers look phenomenal.
These are better than DVD Beavers comparison shots IMO.
The new transfers look phenomenal.
#130
DVD Talk Reviewer
Either way, the grabs of the blu ray alone without anything to compare to, still looks really damn good.
I wonder how many people say that films like 'Halloween' or 'Dawn of the Dead' (original) look like crap on Blu-Ray, when they actually look pretty damn good.
I'm sure these are going to look great for their age.
I wonder how many people say that films like 'Halloween' or 'Dawn of the Dead' (original) look like crap on Blu-Ray, when they actually look pretty damn good.
I'm sure these are going to look great for their age.
#131
Member
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 101
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
One thing to keep in mind -
The bluray version of this may have been rushed.
Bringing this Coppola restoration to bluray was a pretty recent decision, as this coppola restoration project was almost complete by the time the HD format war was over....it wasn't until 2 or 3 months ago that it was announced that this collection would be coming to bluray as well.
I wish they had delayed the bluray version so that they could spend more time to make sure to take full advantage of blurays capabilities.
The bluray version of this may have been rushed.
Bringing this Coppola restoration to bluray was a pretty recent decision, as this coppola restoration project was almost complete by the time the HD format war was over....it wasn't until 2 or 3 months ago that it was announced that this collection would be coming to bluray as well.
I wish they had delayed the bluray version so that they could spend more time to make sure to take full advantage of blurays capabilities.
#132
One thing to keep in mind -
The bluray version of this may have been rushed.
Bringing this Coppola restoration to bluray was a pretty recent decision, as this coppola restoration project was almost complete by the time the HD format war was over....it wasn't until 2 or 3 months ago that it was announced that this collection would be coming to bluray as well.
I wish they had delayed the bluray version so that they could spend more time to make sure to take full advantage of blurays capabilities.
The bluray version of this may have been rushed.
Bringing this Coppola restoration to bluray was a pretty recent decision, as this coppola restoration project was almost complete by the time the HD format war was over....it wasn't until 2 or 3 months ago that it was announced that this collection would be coming to bluray as well.
I wish they had delayed the bluray version so that they could spend more time to make sure to take full advantage of blurays capabilities.
#133
Member
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 101
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#134
Member
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 101
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Fact is...the goal of this restoration was to recreate the true original presentation of these films...and the fact is that HD wasn't necessary to fulfill this goal.
Had there not been a BD version of this restoration....I'm sure the dvd version would have gotten many reviews filled with quotes such as "this was how the GF was meant to be seen".
#135
Well, I don't have a Blu-ray player yet, but this latest rendition of The Godfather Trilogy looks pretty darn good. Count me in when I get a player in the near future.
#136
The restoration was approved by the film's cinematographer, Gordon Willis and director, Francis Ford Coppola. I will most definitely take their word as this being the way The Godfather was meant to be seen over member wd65733.
#137
Member
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 101
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It had everything to do w/ the STYLE of the film...not with the clarity/sharpness of the picture. And they succeeded in that respect.
They created a restoration for DVD, they worked on it for ages...then a few months before the release date, they say "Hey...bluray just won the format war....lets slap this transfer onto bluray real quick"
the result is that the bluray version is probably similar to the new DVD transfer with improved colors.
Last edited by wd65733; 09-21-08 at 01:28 PM.
#138
Putting them out on DVD and Blu-ray is just the next logical step, since the studio can showcase the new transfers, and of course, make money, plus people want to see them without necessarily going to a screening.
#139
Member
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 101
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
No. The restoration was to fix the damaged original prints, for preservation, all that stuff, not simply to come out with a new home video release.
Putting them out on DVD and Blu-ray is just the next logical step, since the studio can showcase the new transfers, and of course, make money, plus people want to see them without necessarily going to a screening.
Putting them out on DVD and Blu-ray is just the next logical step, since the studio can showcase the new transfers, and of course, make money, plus people want to see them without necessarily going to a screening.
#141
Banned by request
At least one theater in Los Angeles has received a print of the restored Godfather I and II. So you are incorrect in saying that this restoration was only done for DVD. It was done for a limited theatrical release as well, which means Harris and Coppola had to worry about how this would look on a 60 foot screen, not a 60 inch screen. Blu-ray is in a perfect position to benefit from this, as its increased resolution and color output allows it to better recreate the film as the director intended it to be seen. It should not be about smoothing away grain or artificially sharpening the image. The Godfather films look fantastic on Blu-ray. I say this as someone who has seen hundreds of Blu-ray discs, and the Godfather films multiple times on multiple formats (VHS, cable, laserdisc, DVD, film). Your suggestion that they only planned for it to look good on DVD and therefore couldn't take advantage of Blu-ray is a fallacy that, to me, suggests an ignorance of how film restoration works.
#145
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: NJ
Posts: 1,243
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The films were restored to the best of their abilities at 4k, a resolution greater than that of Blu-Ray. From these files, new masters were created for DVD and Blu-Ray. As has been indicated, the BDs have been maxed out, taking up nearly the 50 GBs afforded by the format. So how could they have done any better for the format?
Even if the SD-DVD and Blu-Ray look similar, what does that prove? They were created from the same files. So they should look pretty similar, detail and compression aside.
#146
Member
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 101
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I really don't understand the point you're trying to drive at. Even if HD was a last minute decision, which I doubt, it wouldn't have made any difference. As others have mentioned, the goal wasn't to double dip fans on DVD, but rather to save the films (or at least the first two) from complete deterioration by restoring them to their original conditions for archival purposes. A new home video release is just the natural conclusion to any film restoration effort - a way of showing off the work they've done and a way of recouping the millions of dollars they put into the project.
The films were restored to the best of their abilities at 4k, a resolution greater than that of Blu-Ray. From these files, new masters were created for DVD and Blu-Ray. As has been indicated, the BDs have been maxed out, taking up nearly the 50 GBs afforded by the format. So how could they have done any better for the format?
Even if the SD-DVD and Blu-Ray look similar, what does that prove? They were created from the same files. So they should look pretty similar, detail and compression aside.
The films were restored to the best of their abilities at 4k, a resolution greater than that of Blu-Ray. From these files, new masters were created for DVD and Blu-Ray. As has been indicated, the BDs have been maxed out, taking up nearly the 50 GBs afforded by the format. So how could they have done any better for the format?
Even if the SD-DVD and Blu-Ray look similar, what does that prove? They were created from the same files. So they should look pretty similar, detail and compression aside.
It proves that perhaps some could save some $$ and purchase the dvd version of this restoration.
#147
Banned by request
You could make the claim for any movie that has a day and date release on both formats. Oh, Casino Royale? Well, the Blu-ray and the DVD came from the same source files, so you can save some cash and buy the DVD. Transformers? Same source files, buy the DVD. Do you see the flaw in that logic? The source file is of a greater resolution than either format. The Blu-ray is capable of greater transperancy to the source than DVD ever can. Thus, any movie, no matter how old or new, shot on 16mm or above (or, in digital, 720p or above), should look better on Blu-ray.
#148
Member
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 101
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
You could make the claim for any movie that has a day and date release on both formats. Oh, Casino Royale? Well, the Blu-ray and the DVD came from the same source files, so you can save some cash and buy the DVD. Transformers? Same source files, buy the DVD. Do you see the flaw in that logic? The source file is of a greater resolution than either format. The Blu-ray is capable of greater transperancy to the source than DVD ever can. Thus, any movie, no matter how old or new, shot on 16mm or above (or, in digital, 720p or above), should look better on Blu-ray.
Thne same cannot be said of The Godfather.
#150
Banned by request
Have you seen the Coppola restoration DVDs? Do you know for a fact that the PQ isn't "leaps and bounds" better?
I don't even know why we're arguing this. It's clear that to you, a clear picture is what's important, regardless of whether or not the movie is actually meant to look this way. According to Coppola, this is the way these movies are meant to look. We should be praising them for keeping the look of the films as intended on the Blu-ray, and not ruining the movies by modifying them to look clearer and sharper because they're in HD.
I don't even know why we're arguing this. It's clear that to you, a clear picture is what's important, regardless of whether or not the movie is actually meant to look this way. According to Coppola, this is the way these movies are meant to look. We should be praising them for keeping the look of the films as intended on the Blu-ray, and not ruining the movies by modifying them to look clearer and sharper because they're in HD.