DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Video Game Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk-15/)
-   -   witcher 2 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk/590599-witcher-2-a.html)

mattysemo247 09-05-12 10:24 AM

Re: witcher 2
 
Best Buy has Witcher 2 (360) for $9.99 after using the $30 coupon that you can find under your rewards zone member coupons. You can be a free member and still get it.

Larry C. 12-14-12 09:53 AM

Re: witcher 2
 
I'm new to the whole RPG thing and lately I have had an itch to get into a game with a good story. This game looks freaking awesome!!!

I have Skyrim and played for a while but was never truely ever sucked in to were I needed to know what happened next.

I have stayed away from Dark Souls becaue frankly it sounded complicated and a pain in the ass when you died. Is this a bit less forgiving? Can you save anywhere you want?

The Dark Souls combat looks much slow than this and the hit detection looks much better in this.

Am I making the right choice? Anyone know of any good deals on this game right now?

Noonan 12-14-12 10:20 AM

Re: witcher 2
 
This game received amazing reviews but I did not enjoy it at all. I thought it was clunky and generic from the beginning. The Elder Scroll games do everything better, IMO. Are you planning on getting a title for PC or 360?

Larry C. 12-14-12 10:37 AM

Re: witcher 2
 
For the 360 and I hear what your saying, but in Skyrim the gameplay is good but the substance is missing. The story here seems really deep and the cut scenes are amazing.

Noonan 12-14-12 10:43 AM

Re: witcher 2
 
The cut scenes were good but that's where it ended for me. I had a hard time even getting through the intro parts. Have you played Kingdom of Amalur? I enjoyed that one quite a bit more than Witcher 2.

I don't know if there is one but I would suggest trying a demo first. I bought it on PC based on the reviews alone and ended up wasting my money.

Larry C. 12-14-12 10:58 AM

Re: witcher 2
 

Originally Posted by Noonan (Post 11506284)
The cut scenes were good but that's where it ended for me. I had a hard time even getting through the intro parts. Have you played Kingdom of Amalur? I enjoyed that one quite a bit more than Witcher 2.

I don't know if there is one but I would suggest trying a demo first. I bought it on PC based on the reviews alone and ended up wasting my money.

I played the demo for Kingdom and I was not overwhelmed. The gameplay videos I have seen from Witcher 2 look great.

Noonan 12-14-12 11:11 AM

Re: witcher 2
 
The story in KoA was bland but the game play was very fun.

I know I'm probably in the minority concerning W2. The combat system was terrible and not fun at all. I LOVED the first Witcher. It was more of a point & click combat system like Diablo.

Larry C. 12-14-12 11:30 AM

Re: witcher 2
 

Originally Posted by Noonan (Post 11506324)
The story in KoA was bland but the game play was very fun.

I know I'm probably in the minority concerning W2. The combat system was terrible and not fun at all. I LOVED the first Witcher. It was more of a point & click combat system like Diablo.

From what I have seen and correct me if I'm wrong in the Witcher 2 you have to plan ahead and have more of systematic approach with lots of dodging sprinkled in.

Noonan 12-14-12 11:40 AM

Re: witcher 2
 
Maybe but that wouldn't effect if I liked it or not. Demon/Dark Souls are two of my favorite games. I had no issues with the combat in those and played through each twice.

I'm not trying to deter you from getting the game; just giving my impressions based on the 6-7 hours I put into it before uninstalling.

gryffinmaster 12-14-12 11:52 AM

Re: witcher 2
 

Originally Posted by Noonan (Post 11506324)
I know I'm probably in the minority concerning W2. The combat system was terrible and not fun at all.

Probably a minority, but I'm there with you. Solid story, great consequences of choices, rickety gameplay.

foxdvd 12-14-12 12:46 PM

Re: witcher 2
 
As I said above I personally loved the game, though it really did not open up for me until I put it on the hardest difficulty. I thought the combat was smooth and fantastic. You are very powerful as long as you don't mess up. The story is well done. It is not as good a game as Skyrim, but I would put it on the same level as Dark Souls...though it is different enough that you might not like one or the other.

brainee 12-14-12 01:23 PM

Re: witcher 2
 

Originally Posted by Larry C. (Post 11506223)
I have stayed away from Dark Souls becaue frankly it sounded complicated and a pain in the ass when you died. Is this a bit less forgiving? Can you save anywhere you want?

Yes, you can! About difficulty, I wrote about it earlier in the thread. Hard at first, but gets a lot easier as you move on. And read earlier posts for good tips about managing combat


Originally Posted by Larry C. (Post 11506223)
Am I making the right choice? Anyone know of any good deals on this game right now?

Don't see any good deals at the moment ... but I don't have a 360, so I don't follow that so closely.

You won't know if you'll like it unless you give it chance!

Larry C. 12-14-12 02:02 PM

Re: witcher 2
 
Thanks guys. I know the 360 got the Enhanced Edition. Is this title ok to buy Pre-Owned? Or did it come with special codes required to play or access special content?

Larry C. 12-14-12 04:10 PM

Re: witcher 2
 

Originally Posted by Larry C. (Post 11506666)
Thanks guys. I know the 360 got the Enhanced Edition. Is this title ok to buy Pre-Owned? Or did it come with special codes required to play or access special content?

Anyone? I'm getting off from work in an hour and was gonna head to the store.

brainee 12-14-12 04:26 PM

Re: witcher 2
 

Originally Posted by Larry C. (Post 11506666)
Thanks guys. I know the 360 got the Enhanced Edition. Is this title ok to buy Pre-Owned? Or did it come with special codes required to play or access special content?

The version I played didn't have any special things that would've provided a barrier to playing a used version. Maybe stuff like achievements would be messed up, but I don't see why the game itself wouldn't play just fine.

Remember, Quen is your best friend! Realize it gets a lot easier as your progress (and like Witcher 1, the early boss fights are much harder than the later ones). And have fun with making decisions that definitely impact the story ... and when you get to the big branching decision of
Spoiler:
Iorvath vs Roche
, many of us (me included) recommend going with
Spoiler:
Iorvath
for the more satisfying story.

Larry C. 12-15-12 08:39 AM

Re: witcher 2
 
OK got the game and played a little last night. I ended up at the part where you storm the castle and I got up the fight with the guy dressed in green. I kept dying with only 2 guys left to kill. As I was playing my son came in and after my 3rd attempt he said "Dad have you checked if you leveled up to make your character better in battle?" Sure enough I had a point to assign. :lol: I'm new to RPGs.

I was using my Quen by pressing Y I'd glow blue for 30 seconds but what does that do?

Can I regenerate health while engaged in a battle?

I love the game so far after the tutorial it said I should start on easy but I started on normal. Everyone seemed pretty easy to kill specially when using the block and dodge until I got to where I'm stuck.

foxdvd 12-15-12 09:51 AM

Re: witcher 2
 
Quen lets you get hit without taking any damage. The amount of damage is based off the level of Quen (and your level actually) but at lower levels it basically allows you to get hit once free. At higher levels it also will stun and hurt the attacker. It is one of the best powers in the game...

I am going to quote myself from an earlier post...this is not the only way to play, but it worked wonders for me..

my tips to dark difficulty...

...roll...roll...roll.

Never get surrounded. I just finished on Dark and here are some tips that will make the game actually really easy.

I stayed away from Alchemy tree. Never spent one point. I did not want to worry about preparing myself for a fight, and many times you don't know what you are going to face.

So what I did was level up magic about half way and then went into Sword.

The 6 points I spent in the training were as follows...all points listed in the order I took them.

1-Vigor Regeneration

1-Parrying

1-Fortitude

1-Fortitude(max this out)

1-Arrow Red (can mutate it)

1-Dagger Throw (though I never used it..so this one is up to you)

Then I went to magic

1-Destructive magic

1-Enhanced Quen Sign(best skill in game..get out of jail free card)

1-Enhanced Quen

1-Venting

1-Magical Vigor

1-Enhanced Igni (this is why I never used daggers)

1-Enhanced Igni

Then I went to sword

1-Feetwork

1-Position

1-Schemer

1-Tough Guy

1-Hardy

1-Whirl

1-Fitness

1-Invincible

1-Invincible

Back to magic

1-Magic Intensification

1-Magic Intensification

After this you need to make up your mind if you want to upgrade your magic to get HELIOTROPE (slows down time) or the swords finishers. Heliotrope is the stronger choice, but it can take a while to build up...but comes in handy in boss fights...(I took Heliotrope)

Combat involves you putting down QUEN at the start. If you have a large group of enemies hit them with fire...a few blast even on dark difficulty will drop them quick...remember your vigor will not come back while quen is up...so if you lose it...roll away from the combat if you can and let it recharge before using quen again.

In fights where fire does not work...stay on the outside of combat...roll around and dive in for a quick strike...and roll away. If they do get a hit in, quen will hurt a big group...giving you time to get out and recharge quen. This works in just about every situation.

brainee 12-15-12 12:22 PM

Re: witcher 2
 

Originally Posted by Larry C. (Post 11507563)
Can I regenerate health while engaged in a battle?

Not in the sense of downing potions (like most RPGs). Though your guy normally regenerates health over time. And potions (which need to be used before battle) can speed this up.

I don't have anywhere near as detailed a level-up guide as foxdvd. I played on normal. My preferred style of play is a front-line fighter who can wade into battles and deal out ass kickings. Advanced tactics are needed for higher difficulties, but I like my characters and gameplay to be low-maintenance.

I only used the Magic Tree to get to all the Quen-related skills (which I maxed out). I put nothing in Alchemy (potions are a pain in the ass since you can't drink them during battle). I didn't bother with Throwing Daggers. And I didn't get into blocking-related skills much. All the skills I put points into helped me dish out and handle damage. So the combat style I settled into involved me keeping Quen active (so don't forget about Vigor), rolling around, and hitting enemies (preferably from behind after a roll). It looked kind of silly, but it worked.

Larry C. 12-15-12 02:07 PM

Re: witcher 2
 
Well I got past that section I was having was having trouble with but only cause I switched up my dialog and the guy laid down his sword..... pussy :lol:

Got the gate opened and now I died trying to run from a fucking Dragon. Break time.

Larry C. 12-19-12 08:36 AM

Re: witcher 2
 
Ok loving the game. I noticed how much your choices really change this game.
Spoiler:
Towards the beginning when I am given the key to escape I do so and the castle catches fire and there is an explosion. As I was looking for something online I noticed a gameplay video which has him escaping only to find the Mother of the bastards and getting to the ship with no explosions. Pretty cool.


Also I had totally forgot about the save feature in the menus after trying for an hour and a half to go far in a level die and have to restart from the beginning.

foxdvd 12-19-12 09:34 AM

Re: witcher 2
 

Originally Posted by Larry C. (Post 11511987)
Ok loving the game. I noticed how much your choices really change this game.
Spoiler:
Towards the beginning when I am given the key to escape I do so and the castle catches fire and there is an explosion. As I was looking for something online I noticed a gameplay video which has him escaping only to find the Mother of the bastards and getting to the ship with no explosions. Pretty cool.


Also I had totally forgot about the save feature in the menus after trying for an hour and a half to go far in a level die and have to restart from the beginning.

most rpg games for me I always max out save files...it is almost comical how many save files I get in games like Skyrim or Fallout...

Larry C. 12-20-12 06:58 PM

Re: witcher 2
 
I need someone's help. I went to the cave behind the waterfall and defeated everyone and got the Ostmurk. It says I need to use it or make something but I'm not clear on what I have to do.

Larry C. 12-20-12 08:02 PM

Re: witcher 2
 
Never mind I got it.

mattysemo247 09-19-13 01:47 PM

Re: witcher 2
 
So I think this is going to be my next game I start instead of getting GTA5.

Fox, any pointers when starting?

Rex Power Colt-Robot Man 09-19-13 05:17 PM

Re: witcher 2
 
Upgrade Quen (shield) and roll distance. Dont try to go toe to toe, youll get crushed. Couple of hits in till Quen is down, roll away and recast.

MoviePage 09-19-13 05:47 PM

Re: witcher 2
 
Haven't posted in this thread, but I started and completed this game a couple of months ago. 2 playthroughs, once on Normal difficulty and once on Dark.

Tips for a beginner:
- Don't be intimidated by the poorly-designed, overly-complicated menu system. It's not as difficult to figure out as it seems at first.
- The map, however, is as bad as it seems at first and doesn't get better. Use your own sense of direction to figure out areas (they're not as big as they first appear).
- Make sure you're using the right weapon for the right encounters. Regular for human, silver for any type of monster.
- Everyone recommends Quen, and it is helpful on the hardest difficulty, but I concentrated more on Igni (fire magic) and used it far more often. You can use it to attack while keeping your distance.
- When distributing your skill points to level up, don't bother with the bottom (Alchemy) tree.
- Make a hard save before the big decision at the end of Act I so you can reload later and play the alternate path as well. The rest of the game plays out very differently with new locations, quests, and characters depending on your choice.

RocShemp 05-11-15 09:47 PM

Re: witcher 2
 
So I am on my second playthrough of this game and decided to give the Roche path a shot. At first it seemed interesting to me.
Spoiler:
For instance, I liked that Roche went after Loredo and how we found Moril.
However, after that, other than the tournaments
Spoiler:
and bedding Ves
it's been a snooze fest. The whole conspiracy plot is really failing to grasp my interest and even the sidequests seem dull. I'm thinking of going back to the branching path and choosing Iorveth again. There are some sidequests I bungled in my first playthrough and I simply find that path far more engaging.

Anyone else try the Roche path. Does it get better?

gerrythedon 02-28-18 09:31 PM

Re: witcher 2
 
<iframe width="620" height="349" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/DVfd0eMXwxE" frameborder="0" allow="autoplay; encrypted-media" allowfullscreen></iframe>

https://www.xboxachievements.com/new...----Video.html


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:42 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.