DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Video Game Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk-15/)
-   -   I have no idea whether to get a PS3 or 360... (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk/541113-i-have-no-idea-whether-get-ps3-360-a.html)

Michael Corvin 10-13-08 08:31 AM

I'm still waiting on Roboblitz to drop below $12. :sad:

darkside 10-13-08 09:36 AM

I've been a sucker for those PSN sales. Most of the games I bought were on sale. The PSN store does have less, but I have liked the quality and the promotions. To be fair though you can make your own sales on the Wii store and Xbox Marketplace by scoring a deal on the points cards. Happens from time to time.

Save Ferris 10-13-08 10:36 AM


Originally Posted by Decker (Post 8999113)
Sometimes I really don't get the hate for Sony.

Ill try to put this gently. I DO have a PS3 as well as a 360 but as I said before I favor the 360 much more for gaming.

Sony has kind of gotten an image of snobbery with the PS3. An attitude that seems shared with the user community online. Now all systems have their share of stupid immature fanboys, but it seems PS3 has an extra dose of nasty ones.

Some Sony quotes that might alienate users:

"You can look at the software that they sell. All their licensed kid stuff. So, what we're doing with the PlayStation Portable is really establishing a new marketplace, and establishing, frankly, a new beachhead."
- Peter Dille, Sony US Senior Vice President of Marketing, on comparing PSP to DS


“The idea of a handheld rivalry with Nintendo is an irrelevance. Those formats don't appear in our planning. It's not a fair comparison; not fair on them, I should stress. That sounds arrogant, maybe, but it's the truth. With the DS , it's fair to say that Nintendo stepped out of the technical race and went for a feature differentiation with the touch screen. But I fear that it won't have a lasting impact beyond that of a gimmick - so the long-lasting appeal of the platform is at peril as a direct result of that."
- Phil Harrison, president of Sony Worldwide Studios, on comparing PSP to DS in an interview with MCV


"The first five million are going to buy it (PS3), whatever it is, even [if] it didn't have games."
- David Reeves, Sony Computer Entertainment Europe CEO

"Microsoft does not concern us. Microsoft is not a technology company."
- Nobuyuki Idei, Sony chief corporate adviser in an interview with BBC NEWS

"Nintendo knows its target audience, because it has really narrowed that down; and it’s pretty much defined by a boy or girl’s ability to admire Pokemon."
- Phil Harrison, president of Sony Computer Entertainment's Worldwide Studios

"I don’t think we’re arrogant."
– Phil Harrison, regarding consumer perception of Sony

"We're certainly not interested in Gimmicks."
- Kaz Hirai0 E32k6, right before showing off Eye of Judgement.


...and there are just so many more funny ones if you google 'sony quotes'.

xmiyux 10-13-08 11:26 AM

So the 360 gets exclusive DLC for Tomb Raider and for GTAIV while the PS3 is getting exclusive DLC for Mirror's Edge.

Is MS just throwing large amounts of money to these developers to get the exclusive add-ons? I'm very much looking forward to Mirror's Edge but it doesn't have the name recognition Tomb Raider or GTA have... so is Sony not writing checks to get exclusive DLC?

Do you guys think this will be the future? No 3rd party exclusive titles... instead it will be exclusive DLC?

The Bus 10-13-08 11:35 AM

I was going to find quotes by Sony execs I disagreed with and found a lot strange ones. Then I realized I had looked for "Karzai" instead of "Kaz Hirai"... :lol:

Michael Corvin 10-13-08 11:36 AM


Originally Posted by xmiyux (Post 9001099)
Is MS just throwing large amounts of money to these developers to get the exclusive add-ons? I'm very much looking forward to Mirror's Edge but it doesn't have the name recognition Tomb Raider or GTA have... so is Sony not writing checks to get exclusive DLC?

Well look at the quotes above, they've gotten better but I think there was one recently about not needing exclusives. So they clearly aren't courting it which gives MS free reign to come in and woo developers, moneyhat or not(helped Harmonix with programming).


Originally Posted by almarsguides (Post 9001014)
360 all the way

New member & 17 posts all as generic as this one in a matter of minutes including spam. No offense, but, what's your agenda?

sracer 10-13-08 11:36 AM


Originally Posted by Save Ferris (Post 9000962)
Ill try to put this gently. I DO have a PS3 as well as a 360 but as I said before I favor the 360 much more for gaming.

Sony has kind of gotten an image of snobbery with the PS3. An attitude that seems shared with the user community online. Now all systems have their share of stupid immature fanboys, but it seems PS3 has an extra dose of nasty ones.

Some Sony quotes that might alienate users:

"You can look at the software that they sell. All their licensed kid stuff. So, what we're doing with the PlayStation Portable is really establishing a new marketplace, and establishing, frankly, a new beachhead."
- Peter Dille, Sony US Senior Vice President of Marketing, on comparing PSP to DS


“The idea of a handheld rivalry with Nintendo is an irrelevance. Those formats don't appear in our planning. It's not a fair comparison; not fair on them, I should stress. That sounds arrogant, maybe, but it's the truth. With the DS , it's fair to say that Nintendo stepped out of the technical race and went for a feature differentiation with the touch screen. But I fear that it won't have a lasting impact beyond that of a gimmick - so the long-lasting appeal of the platform is at peril as a direct result of that."
- Phil Harrison, president of Sony Worldwide Studios, on comparing PSP to DS in an interview with MCV


"The first five million are going to buy it (PS3), whatever it is, even [if] it didn't have games."
- David Reeves, Sony Computer Entertainment Europe CEO

"Microsoft does not concern us. Microsoft is not a technology company."
- Nobuyuki Idei, Sony chief corporate adviser in an interview with BBC NEWS

"Nintendo knows its target audience, because it has really narrowed that down; and it’s pretty much defined by a boy or girl’s ability to admire Pokemon."
- Phil Harrison, president of Sony Computer Entertainment's Worldwide Studios

"I don’t think we’re arrogant."
– Phil Harrison, regarding consumer perception of Sony

"We're certainly not interested in Gimmicks."
- Kaz Hirai0 E32k6, right before showing off Eye of Judgement.


...and there are just so many more funny ones if you google 'sony quotes'.

I'll add another one...

"Anyone who looks at the comments of executives in determining which console best fits their needs is a dope, pure and simple."
- sracer, DVDtalk thread

darkside 10-13-08 12:08 PM

The best thing Sony ever did was get the father of the Playstaton as far away as possible. He was beyond delusional and his quotes about the PS3 showed just how out of touch he was toward the end of his time in charge.

The new guy they have been using at E3 isn't slick by any means, but at least he comes across as somewhat honest and down to earth. I think he has helped a bit with turning around the bad Sony PR.

Save Ferris 10-13-08 12:31 PM


Originally Posted by sracer (Post 9001121)
I'll add another one...

"Anyone who looks at the comments of executives in determining which console best fits their needs is a dope, pure and simple."
- sracer, DVDtalk thread

I posted the list as an example of why some people hate SONY, because he asked, it was not listed as a reason to buy one console or the other

There are corporations out there that tend to alienate the core users. MS is guilty of that too and people dont ask why MS is 'hated'. PS3 just really blew it this generation and their attitude was consistently 'its not us, its you'.

Every coroporation is clueless sometimes. Some more than others, but the lengths Sony went to deny any mistakes became legendary. The reason why there are so many funny quote lists on the subject out there.

They did fire (or laterally promote) one of the head PS3 guys, so perhaps they are humbling out and changing for the better. I believe they are.

pinata242 10-13-08 12:33 PM

If you consider late 20s and 30s gamers to be Nintendo's traditionally core audience, they've done a lot in the last few years to alienate them as well. I welcome market expansion, but it should never be at the expense of your devotees.

Liver&Onions 10-13-08 12:38 PM


Originally Posted by Michael Corvin (Post 9001120)
New member & 17 posts all as generic as this one in a matter of minutes including spam. No offense, but, what's your agenda?

that WAS his agenda.

darkside 10-13-08 12:44 PM


Originally Posted by pinata242 (Post 9001212)
If you consider late 20s and 30s gamers to be Nintendo's traditionally core audience, they've done a lot in the last few years to alienate them as well. I welcome market expansion, but it should never be at the expense of your devotees.

Agree. I'm happy for the mainstream success, but I wish they would do more to keep the 30 year olds that have been with them since the 80s a little happy. On the Wii software front there hasn't been a lot to look forward to, but at least Super Mario RPG and Secret of Mana are recent releases so that is something. They are at least starting to show some effort on VC.

Michael Corvin 10-13-08 12:57 PM


Originally Posted by Liver&Onions (Post 9001218)
that WAS his agenda.

I figured, I just didn't want to come across as a complete dick to a potential new user. I was putting it politely.

The Bus 10-13-08 01:56 PM

Nintendo began abandoning its core 80s audience sometime during the N64 era.

bunkaroo 10-13-08 02:41 PM


Originally Posted by brianluvdvd (Post 9000708)
I agree but at the same time it is retarded that the Wii does not include an ethernet port for us hardwirers out there. I never have been a fan of wireless gaming and always have preferred to hardwire it. The Wii charges you $25 for a "lan adapter" when they could have just put in a port.

You have a point. However, the lack of ethernet port on the Wii probably has more to do with the console's compact size than a desire to extort $25 out of non-wireless enabled users. Also, I'd argue the 360 relies much more on its online capabilities than the Wii.

With the 360, you get the feeling everything is a la carte.

The Bus 10-13-08 02:48 PM

I still don't know why people bother paying $100 for the 360's adapter. It's not like that is the only thing that will let you go online.

xmiyux 10-13-08 02:56 PM


Originally Posted by The Bus (Post 9001466)
I still don't know why people bother paying $100 for the 360's adapter. It's not like that is the only thing that will let you go online.

It's the same thing like people not knowing you can change the batteries in a PS3 controller.

Your average person doesn't know any better. Hell, had i wanted to go wireless i would have assumed i needed to buy the 360 adapter since everything else on the 360 is proprietary.

Granted i would have asked on here and someone would have enlightened me but your average consumer doesn't do that.

spainlinx0 10-13-08 04:01 PM

I wired it, and I know you can set it up wirelessly without paying for their adaptor, but I don't know what people are referring to about bridging it. I just didn't want to figure it out. I just moved my cable modem next to my TV, and I only have a laptop so I didn't need to buy anything else.

darkside 10-13-08 04:20 PM

On the wireless front I did want to mention that the old Xbox wireless adapter works fine with the 360. Someone I ran into didn't know that and basically gave me the old Xbox one and then spent the $100 on the 360 one. I'm not complaining because it got my Xbox wireless for free, but they could have saved money on that one if they had checked first.

Imprint 10-13-08 04:28 PM


Originally Posted by darkside (Post 9001709)
On the wireless front I did want to mention that the old Xbox wireless adapter works fine with the 360. Someone I ran into didn't know that and basically gave me the old Xbox one and then spent the $100 on the 360 one. I'm not complaining because it got my Xbox wireless for free, but they could have saved money on that one if they had checked first.

I think the old one doesn't support WPA encryption though.

PJsig08 10-13-08 06:16 PM

Jesus, this thread took on a life of its own...

Well I bought an XBOX 360 (60GB), so thanks everyone for the advice. When it came down to it, the XBOX was the way to go. I am enjoying it, love the controller and NBA2K9 which I bought. I'll get Guitar Hero 4 and GTA4 soon.

How do I load MP3/music on my hard drive? I'd love to play games while listening to my own MP3s...is it possible to play music and also have the background sound effects while playing a game?

xmiyux 10-13-08 06:25 PM


Originally Posted by PJsig08 (Post 9001999)
Jesus, this thread took on a life of its own...

Well I bought an XBOX 360 (60GB), so thanks everyone for the advice. When it came down to it, the XBOX was the way to go. I am enjoying it, love the controller and NBA2K9 which I bought. I'll get Guitar Hero 4 and GTA4 soon.

How do I load MP3/music on my hard drive? I'd love to play games while listening to my own MP3s...is it possible to play music and also have the background sound effects while playing a game?

Put in a CD. Choose rip to HDD.

Yes it will play during a game and still give you the background sound effects.

darkside 10-13-08 06:29 PM


Originally Posted by PJsig08 (Post 9001999)
Jesus, this thread took on a life of its own...

Well I bought an XBOX 360 (60GB), so thanks everyone for the advice. When it came down to it, the XBOX was the way to go. I am enjoying it, love the controller and NBA2K9 which I bought. I'll get Guitar Hero 4 and GTA4 soon.

How do I load MP3/music on my hard drive? I'd love to play games while listening to my own MP3s...is it possible to play music and also have the background sound effects while playing a game?

I think we all like the differenct consoles, but they all have their shortcomings and it can be hard to narrow down what works for every individual. That is why these threads can go all over the map, but it was a very civil discussion and it is interesting to go over some of it.

The important thing is you found the console right for you and I can guarantee you will enjoy the 360. Solid thread for that reason alone.

mhg83 10-13-08 06:43 PM

Thank god he didnt post this thread in the gametrailers forum.

xmiyux 10-13-08 06:46 PM

It's also been a nice thread for general discussion of PS3 vs. 360. I'm really interested to see how the exclusivity on the DLC front will shake out.

I also would love to see Live take on some of the PSN features.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:53 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.