DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Video Game Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk-15/)
-   -   X-Box 360 vs. PS3 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk/531810-x-box-360-vs-ps3.html)

fujishig 05-19-08 10:24 PM


Originally Posted by fumanstan
Yeah, it's kind of funny about the whole JRPG thing. The Playstation brand has always been so big on JRPG games with both the PS1 and PS2 while the PS3's been out well over a year without any major titles.

And the only major game in the first few months of the PS3's life was a FPS with Resistance when the perception that's an XBox thing. Weird.

Probably because of the time it takes to develop an rpg, the last few console launches haven't had any kinds of rpgs available, at least not that I can remember... the last one I do remember is the SNES with Final Fantasy.

Also, the PS2 is cheaper to develop for, more familiar, and is still a great system for non-graphics-intensive rpgs.

It is a bit odd not only that Resistance was an FPS, but that the premiere games for the PS3 launch pretty much came from outside of Japan. I mean, Genji was ok, but Gundam was just atrocious (even though I own it).

FatTony 05-19-08 10:30 PM

I've been on the fence about this decision too. I thought I'd made up my mind to get a 360, but then a friend's 360 RROD'd on him and he said he was sans-xbox for like 6 weeks. I figure if I'm dropping that much money on a system, it better work properly.

Ultimately that's the biggest deterrent from a 360 for me. Even though it has the superior controller (I like the placement of the main analog stick more than day one of the PS controller), the lack of built-in wireless is inexcusable. Blu-ray is another point in the PS3's column, but with the PS3, it'd be like I'm buying a Blu-ray player that happens to play games.

Don't mind me, I'm just thinking out loud. :D

prozac80 05-19-08 10:36 PM

wow! This is more of a response than I planned on. I'm getting ready for bed now, but I'll read all the replies tomorrow. Just want to say thanks to everyone for thier input and I wasn't trying to start a x vs ps3 thread for arguments sake :)

prozac80 05-19-08 10:36 PM

BTW...what is RROD?

edstein 05-19-08 11:02 PM

Red Ring of Death. One of the more common hardware problems with the 360. I believe they have reduced the frequency of this problem with the new chip. You get a free 3 year warranty to cover that problem though so no worries.

If you want a great game library get a 360. If you want Blu support get a PS3. It's that simple.

slop101 05-19-08 11:02 PM


Originally Posted by prozac80
BTW...what is RROD?

Red Ring Of Death, for when your 360 dies and has to be shipped off for repair - at least they upped the warranty to 3(?) years, and it's an inconvenience, but there has been a drop in RRODs lately - especially considering GTAIV just came out, and most dead 360s pop up around the launch of a huge game, since that's when people play most.

Chris_D 05-20-08 12:18 AM


Originally Posted by FatTony
I've been on the fence about this decision too. I thought I'd made up my mind to get a 360, but then a friend's 360 RROD'd on him and he said he was sans-xbox for like 6 weeks. I figure if I'm dropping that much money on a system, it better work properly.

I hear you but I think it's fair to say if you follow all the forum advice to the letter in terms of getting the right chipset(s) and a recent manufacturing date, then you should end up with a console that's close to reliability of the Wii and PS3. Of course for those of us with older consoles it's tough.

Anyway, if you lived in Japan you can get a 5-7 day turn around I gather, CS guys have a lot of time on their hands over here!

fumanstan 05-20-08 12:24 AM

To be fair, the last few posts in the RROD thread mentioned that the turn around time has been far far shorter.

Michael Corvin 05-20-08 12:33 AM

Yeah, a friend of mine had his back in little over a week.

sracer 05-20-08 08:48 AM


Originally Posted by Michael Corvin
Yeah, a friend of mine had his back in little over a week.

How are you measuring that time? It is impossible to experience an RRoD, phone it in (or submit online), receive a coffin, ship it out, and have it returned in "a little over a week".

RichC2 05-20-08 08:59 AM

I'm assuming he means from shipped til returned. Which is possible in little over a week.

Getting a coffin takes a day or two.

Save Ferris 05-20-08 11:14 AM

My RROD was fixed in 10 days last month. From phone call to getting the fixed console back. Thats pretty damn good.

Michael Corvin 05-20-08 11:51 AM


Originally Posted by Save Ferris
My RROD was fixed in 10 days last month. From phone call to getting the fixed console back. Thats pretty damn good.

... and that would be, "a little over a week." :)

sracer 05-20-08 12:44 PM


Originally Posted by Save Ferris
My RROD was fixed in 10 days last month. From phone call to getting the fixed console back. Thats pretty damn good.

Wow, that's' nuts!

It took them 4 weeks total turn around time for mine (AZ). (Aug/Sept 07) 4 weeks for my brother(NY) (a little later than that), and 4 weeks for my nephew (FL) ( Nov 07)

MasterofDVD 05-21-08 01:13 AM

The turnaround on my RROD was about 4 weeks but I am sure it's way faster now. It's a given that the process gets streamlined when they have had to fix such a high number of consoles. I am sure that MS is producing better units now but there are still far too many problematic ones out in circulation.

Michael Corvin 05-21-08 07:28 AM


Originally Posted by MasterofDVD
The turnaround on my RROD was about 4 weeks but I am sure it's way faster now. It's a given that the process gets streamlined when they have had to fix such a high number of consoles. I am sure that MS is producing better units now but there are still far too many problematic ones out in circulation.

I think I've read it has to do with them just gutting your system instead of just dealing with the isolated problem. I, of course, have no idea how accurate that is.

edstein 05-21-08 08:08 AM

I shipped mine out last Friday and got a notice this morning that it's on it's way back to me.

raven56706 05-21-08 08:19 AM

the turnaround for my RROD was 1 week and a half

MasterofDVD 05-21-08 11:08 AM


Originally Posted by edstein
I shipped mine out last Friday and got a notice this morning that it's on it's way back to me.

That is astounding. :)

The only good thing about the RROD was that is allowed me time to catch up on the games I wanted to play on my other systems.

I will be curious to see what system I use more once I get my LCD TV I am shopping for. I've tried the PS3 on a LCD sets and it looks impressive. I hope the 360 can keep up or I may start to buy more PS3 games.

Michael Corvin 05-21-08 12:52 PM


Originally Posted by MasterofDVD
The only good thing about the RROD was that is allowed me time to catch up on the games I wanted to play on my other systems.

...and that is really why gamers aren't so up in arms about the RROD. Sure it sucks, but MS handled it well. Plus, the 360 came out a year early and a lot of gamers have picked up a second system(Wii, PS3) in that time. So it's hard to bitch when you have another system to play while your console is out for repairs. I imagine it's really not a huge deal to most. Only those with a single system will gripe the loudest.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:46 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.