|
Originally Posted by DJ_Longfellow
I rented MVP (XBOX) yesterday. I thought the game was pretty decent overall. Owner mdoe is kinda lame...unless you are a BIG SIMS fan.
Gameplay seems decent. Haven't noticed any bugs yet, but I only played about 3 games. Sometimes it seems as though the outfielders run too slow after a flyball (no run your ass off button) The rosters are wrong also. Magglio and Delgado are STILL Free agents. I thought ESPN got this right (correct?) I went on LIVE and it said to dl new rosters, so I did....and they were STILL WRONG. Now Schilling is a free agent....weird. I'm not passing full judgement yet. I have 2K5 on the way....it shipped yesterday I believe....so hopefully I'll have it early next week. I may switch from ESPN to MVP, but we'll see. I've liked ESPN the past few years.... |
Originally Posted by Decker
That's a horrible bug. Hope it's really rare. Are you sure that the ball didn't bounce off Jose Canseco's head or something?
IGN's review is up. As usual they're falling over themselves praising EA and mourning the loss of the series (which as we all know is just Take Two's response to the hardball game that EA started). I really need to see some MLB 2K5 reviews before I open up my game. If MVP is really a lot better, I'll return my copy of the other; but I need to hear from someone other than the baffoons who praised Madden 2005 to high heaven when it was released and then four months later picked ESPN NFL as the sports GOTY. |
Originally Posted by nickdawgy
Ordonez was a free agent in ESPN, so I had to manually assign him to the Tigers. Delgado was already with the Marlins, though. Sammy was still with the Cubs, too.
Awww crap......I was hoping ESPN had it right. I mean they have pics on their site of Sammy on the Orioles. The Tigers are my team too....looks like I will have to make some adjustments. Hopefully DL rosters come quick, just to correct the current offseason transactions. We'll see what game I like better though ALSO, does 2K5 have a way to control the velocity of a fielders throw...ala MVP? |
Originally Posted by DJ_Longfellow
Awww crap......I was hoping ESPN had it right. I mean they have pics on their site of Sammy on the Orioles. The Tigers are my team too....looks like I will have to make some adjustments.
Hopefully DL rosters come quick, just to correct the current offseason transactions. We'll see what game I like better though ALSO, does 2K5 have a way to control the velocity of a fielders throw...ala MVP? |
As Third Baseman pointed out, the rosters are up for MVP. I've been through them quickly, and they seem pretty solid. All big name FAs prior to 1/12 are on their teams, Sammy's an O, and quickly glancing at the Sox, even the jersey numbers for guys like Wells and Payton have been updated. Another bright spot, since I don't want to sit here and edit every non-MLBPA guy and top 100 prospect is that you can now edit any player on any team in Dynasty mode. Now if they would allow new roster updates in the middle of Dynasty, that would be cool, but it looks like they don't.
|
Noticed a couple more minor bugs in ESPN 2k5. John Miller said something about how my team was 3-7 in my last 10 games. I was actually 5-3 for the season, so there was no way that was true.
Then in another game, John asked Joe Morgan how my team did last game, and he says something like "Not so good, they're coming off a loss, hopefully they can win today to make up for it." The problem was, I'd won my last game 7-0. So they're like I said, minor, but still annoying. |
Is there a home run derby in MLB 2k5?
|
Originally Posted by Demontooth
Is there a home run derby in MLB 2k5?
|
Originally Posted by Mad Dawg
Now if they would allow new roster updates in the middle of Dynasty, that would be cool, but it looks like they don't.
|
Well, it looks as though IGN's review of MLB 2K5 is up as well.
They clearly like MVP better, but this doesn't sount too bad, either Closing Comments If all you care about is online, MLB 2K5 is the way to go. It plays great and the addition of online leagues is a huge plus. However, MLB 2K5 still has a ways to go if it intends to compete with the memory of MVP next year. The animations need a complete overhaul, the AI definitely needs a reworking, and the Franchise Mode has to see significant innovation outside of a nicer interface. Stop adding mini-games and take a stand on the type of pitching and hitting interfaces you want players to use. As long as there are a half-dozen options, there's no way to tune gameplay to perfect fit each hitting style. Pick one and make a great game. Though 2K Games and Visual Concepts don't have to sweat competition from EA next year, that doesn't mean they get a free pass. This is the only hope for a cross-platform baseball game. For that reason MLB 2K6 needs to be an awesome display. The groundwork is there, but it remains to be seen if VC has the vision and ability to make the greatest baseball game the world has ever known. We'll find out next March. Until then, MLB 2K5 is a great experience worthy of a spot on your shelf. IGN's Ratings for MLB 2K5 (Xbox) Rating Description out of 10 click here for ratings guide 9.5 Presentation Wow. Fantastic presentation that comes as close to an ESPN broadcast as I've ever seen. 8.0 Graphics Great stadiums and nice crowds, but the animations hurt considerably. 9.0 Sound Johnny Damon at the plate and from the crowd comes, "Cut your hair Hippie!" Brilliant. 8.5 Gameplay It's a simple game. You throw the ball, you hit the ball, you catch the ball. MLB 2K5 does all of this just fine, but isn't as polished as it could be. 8.0 Lasting Appeal The Franchise Mode seems a bit old, but the online play is great. All of the gimmicky stuff like bonus modes make me want to play less, not more. 8.5 OVERALL (out of 10 / not an average) |
I picked up Powered by Espn tonight and it seems pretty cool, except for the ridiculous amount of web gems.
|
Originally Posted by Third Baseman
How exactly would you expect that to work? -confused- -eek- -screwy-
I think the happy medium would have been to have included a single season option with the capability to use roster updates. I just prefer to keep accurate rosters, and I'm sure I'm not alone. Once I get 15 games into dynasty and teams start making silly trades, I begin to lose interest. |
Some more weird bugs for ESPN 2k5...
3 weeks into my season, and there hasn't been one player of the week award. Also, the hot/cold hitters section is always empty. You telling me not a single player in the majors is having a hot or cold streak? Also, not a bug, but I thought it was funny in the training video, John Miller calls the game ESPN Major League Baseball 2k5 :lol: Holding on to the past, I guess :D |
Is anyone else having a problem adjusting their lineups in franchise mode? Half the time it says I have a bad lineup vs. LHP or something, and also when I go to move people around in the batting order, alot of times nothing happens. Also, in my lineup vs. RHP with DH, one of my players is missing and I dont know how to get him in the lineup which for some reason has 2 DH's and no SS. The player isnt listed on my bench even though he is in my other lineups and I have adjusted my depth charts all around. I think this could be a major bug.
|
Originally Posted by Mad Dawg
:lol: Don't bring me down with your silly details.
I think the happy medium would have been to have included a single season option with the capability to use roster updates. AKA ... start a new dynasty. :blush: Which game, Deadman? |
Sounds like Deadman is referring to MVP. I think I had the same problems with MVP 2004.
|
Sorry. I just realized I didnt say which game. It is actually Powered by ESPN. :)
|
Wow, so they both have the same bugs in the lineup.
|
I think I found another ESPN bug and this one really sucks. If the computer throws a low pitch and you swing at it(doesnt appear to be a full swing just a tap of the button but it will be called a strike anway) with a runner on base, it will be a wild pitch. This has happened to me at least 10 times.
As far as the lineup bug, the only way I have found to fix it is to let the computer set the lineup for you. |
Originally Posted by nickdawgy
Wow, so they both have the same bugs in the lineup.
|
Sounds like the commentary is pretty lackluster in both games. I've been playing MVP and the commentary is pretty bad.
They said my pitcher is not likely to striek anyone out, then in the next breath he said he WAS a strikeout pitcher.... Not much variety with MVP commentary either. The vendors are nice in the surround sound though |
So...any word on which one to get yet?
Does any website yet list the unlockables for the games? |
Originally Posted by DJ_Longfellow
Sounds like the commentary is pretty lackluster in both games. I've been playing MVP and the commentary is pretty bad.
They said my pitcher is not likely to striek anyone out, then in the next breath he said he WAS a strikeout pitcher.... Not much variety with MVP commentary either. The vendors are nice in the surround sound though |
Originally Posted by Tarantino
So...any word on which one to get yet?
Does any website yet list the unlockables for the games? 119 jerseys I believe There are also a handful of stadiums....like Tiger Stadium, OLD Fenway (in classic mode...a sepia colored screen) and a bunch of other ones I think there are also 50 old-time greats to unlock. I'm really liking MVP....I have ESPN on the way because I ordered it. But from the sound of it, MVP looks to edge it out, just a little bit. |
Ok, I'm addicted to the Pitching mini game in MVP. It actually took away from my WoW playing this weekend. :lol:
|
Originally Posted by Setzer
Ok, I'm addicted to the Pitching mini game in MVP. It actually took away from my WoW playing this weekend. :lol:
|
Originally Posted by Mad Dawg
I'm hooked on the hitting game, even though I can't seem to get past level 11. The pitching mini-game is driving me up the wall. Are you doing timed or untimed?
|
Well, I seem to have discovered why the pitching mini-game was driving me crazy. I didn't realize that the black blocks corresponded with a pitch. I thought they were just obstacles. I'm so ashamed. :lol:
|
Another bug in ESPN, at least I think so....whenever I foul a ball off, whether it bounces in the dirt or grass, it never bounces into the stands. Never. If it's a fair ball, sure, it will bounce in the stands. Kind of annoying.
Oh and I also noticed the "wild pitch" bug happens constantly in the same situations. |
Originally Posted by Mad Dawg
Well, I seem to have discovered why the pitching mini-game was driving me crazy. I didn't realize that the black blocks corresponded with a pitch. I thought they were just obstacles. I'm so ashamed. :lol:
So don't feel too ashamed man. :) |
Yet another ESPN bug.
No night games in GM and franchise modes. I have played 15 games, and all were day games. Even if the time was for a night game. This is really annoying. I love the game, but the glitches and bugs are really starting to make me want to switch to MVP. Only that annoying Tessie song has kept me from trying MVP out. |
ESPN sounds like last years MVP. rotfl
MVP this year has been perfect for me. No bugs. No glitches. No "what the fuck, this sucks" comments from myself. I love it. I wish I had MORE time to play it. |
I'm starting to dread picking up 2K5, even though the presentation is supposed to be spectacular. I'll still probably bit the bullet, but I'm disappointed with what I hear. I guess the bright spot of MVP being so similar to last year's is that I have yet to run into a non-commentary bug.
And nick, I like Tessie, but I'm starting to hate it. For some reason, I don't think it really plays as Hideki Matsui steps up to the plate at Yankee Stadium like it does in the game. :lol: |
Mad Dawg, I liked Tessie, too. At least the first few times I heard it. I thought it was awesome with the Sox winning and all. But now it's like they sold out, it's all over the place, and I even hear it alot in CA.
As for 2k5, if you haven't played it, definitely play it. The bugs annoy the shit out of me, but the game more then makes up for it. Just hearing the baseball tonight theme in between innings is enough to keep me playing :lol: I am seriously still thinking of picking up MVP for PC, I really want to try it. Also, since it's on the PC, I can use the ditty importer and can avoid hearing Tessie 20,000 times :D |
Well, if there is any reason for you to get MVP, it's that Vlad is a monster in the game. He crushes everything, plus he gets to balls quickly in the OF, and of course he's got a gun. One of the best, if not the best, overall player I've used in the game.
|
Anyone having more trouble hitting in MVP 2005 than last year's? It was tricky at first last year, but I caught on quickly. This year, the strike zone is lower to correspond with the pitcher's mound, so perhaps the "new" K Zone is what's throwing me off, but holy shit, I suck ass at hitting. My team in Owner's Mode is the bomb at pitching, but thanks to my pitiful hitting, I'm like 3-6. Anyone having similar problems or got any tips to improve my hitting?
|
Originally Posted by Mad Dawg
Well, if there is any reason for you to get MVP, it's that Vlad is a monster in the game. He crushes everything, plus he gets to balls quickly in the OF, and of course he's got a gun. One of the best, if not the best, overall player I've used in the game.
|
Originally Posted by Third Baseman
ESPN sounds like last years MVP. rotfl
|
I played some MVP 2005 on Live today and it was great. The last game went to 22 innings and i ended up finally scoring 4 runs to win it. Struck the other guy out 24 times (he got me 13 times). First time i've played a baseball game online and it was a fucking blast. It's a great game for $30.
|
Originally Posted by Al Padrino
Anyone having more trouble hitting in MVP 2005 than last year's? It was tricky at first last year, but I caught on quickly. This year, the strike zone is lower to correspond with the pitcher's mound, so perhaps the "new" K Zone is what's throwing me off, but holy shit, I suck ass at hitting. My team in Owner's Mode is the bomb at pitching, but thanks to my pitiful hitting, I'm like 3-6. Anyone having similar problems or got any tips to improve my hitting?
-NiCK |
| All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:02 AM. |
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.