Andor (S1E08) - "Narkina 5" - 10/26/22
#1
Moderator
Thread Starter
Andor (S1E08) - "Narkina 5" - 10/26/22

#2
DVD Talk Legend
re: Andor (S1E08) - "Narkina 5" - 10/26/22
This week's episode kicks off a two-episode story arc.
Per an interview clip I just heard this weekend with Tony Gilroy, the episodes and seasons will follow this structure for timeline/story arcs:
Season One - 5 BBY
Eps 1-3 are an arc (killing the cops & fallout from that)
Eps 4-6 are an arc (the heist)
Ep 7 is an "interstitial" episode
Eps 8-9 are an arc
Eps 10-12 are an arc
Season Two - Various Years
Eps 1-3: a story in 4 BBY
Eps 4-6: a story in 3 BBY
Eps 7-9: a story in 2 BBY
Eps 10-12: a story in 1-0 BBY, leading up to Andor taking off for where we first see him in Rogue One
Per an interview clip I just heard this weekend with Tony Gilroy, the episodes and seasons will follow this structure for timeline/story arcs:
Season One - 5 BBY
Eps 1-3 are an arc (killing the cops & fallout from that)
Eps 4-6 are an arc (the heist)
Ep 7 is an "interstitial" episode
Eps 8-9 are an arc
Eps 10-12 are an arc
Season Two - Various Years
Eps 1-3: a story in 4 BBY
Eps 4-6: a story in 3 BBY
Eps 7-9: a story in 2 BBY
Eps 10-12: a story in 1-0 BBY, leading up to Andor taking off for where we first see him in Rogue One
The following 4 users liked this post by GuessWho:
#3
re: Andor (S1E08) - "Narkina 5" - 10/26/22
Seeing as the Empire are looking for Cassian, and he's in a prison facility under the name Keef, reckon they'll eventually track him down, and the Empire itself will pull him out of there, to interrogate him about who Axis is, with the promise of freedom or the safety of Bix and his mom and his mining friend, if he divulges info. Cassian doesn't know yet (?) that Luthen (Axis) wants him dead before he can talk. So, it would seem not feasible he would talk, as then Luthen and the push of the Rebellion would get found out too soon. So there must be something else happen. Some kind of change of heart, a rescue.
Last edited by xe.kilroy; 10-26-22 at 06:38 AM. Reason: testing
#4
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: Andor (S1E08) - "Narkina 5" - 10/26/22
I know some have mentioned they like the different kind of music featured in this series, but it reminds me of bad sci-fi flicks from the 70's and 80's when I hear it. It takes me out of the story. I'm glad George Lucas went with classic full orchestra music for the films. I wish this show had done the same. Anyway, do you think Syril will join the rebellion down the road now that the Empire has turned down his offer to help them track down Andor? I bet Dedra's instructions to him to stop raising the alarm don't sit well with him.
#5
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Andor (S1E08) - "Narkina 5" - 10/26/22
I've been saying/thinking that Syril will flip after slowly realizing what the Empire really is. From the dismissal of the original even that set him on this path to being "kicked down the road" at every turn. I wonder if he ends up finding/meeting Andor on his own.
Another fantastic episode. You are starting to feel the Empires oppressiveness. I kept waiting to see the torture droid from ANH since you could hear it in the background when they were bringing Bix in for interrogation.
Another fantastic episode. You are starting to feel the Empires oppressiveness. I kept waiting to see the torture droid from ANH since you could hear it in the background when they were bringing Bix in for interrogation.
#6
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Andor (S1E08) - "Narkina 5" - 10/26/22
If episodes 1-3 had a fugitive theme…
and episodes 4-6 had a heist theme…
then I expect episodes 7-9 to end as a prison break.
I love prison breaks, so hopefully.
and episodes 4-6 had a heist theme…
then I expect episodes 7-9 to end as a prison break.
I love prison breaks, so hopefully.
#7
Moderator
Re: Andor (S1E08) - "Narkina 5" - 10/26/22
I really liked this one.
Honestly, I'm surprised this is only going to be two seasons. It seems like people are really enjoying this and I'd think they'd have at least three seasons' worth of stories. Star Wars people have been wanting "plans" lately, but this plan seems short.
Honestly, I'm surprised this is only going to be two seasons. It seems like people are really enjoying this and I'd think they'd have at least three seasons' worth of stories. Star Wars people have been wanting "plans" lately, but this plan seems short.
#8
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Andor (S1E08) - "Narkina 5" - 10/26/22
I really liked this one.
Honestly, I'm surprised this is only going to be two seasons. It seems like people are really enjoying this and I'd think they'd have at least three seasons' worth of stories. Star Wars people have been wanting "plans" lately, but this plan seems short.
Honestly, I'm surprised this is only going to be two seasons. It seems like people are really enjoying this and I'd think they'd have at least three seasons' worth of stories. Star Wars people have been wanting "plans" lately, but this plan seems short.
#9
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Andor (S1E08) - "Narkina 5" - 10/26/22
This show just gets better and better. If George made the OT as a vague commentary on Vietnam, this show is a brutalist essay on all our modern ills like the prison-industrial complex or the merging of corporations and government.
I have trouble believing we are getting this quality caliber of a live action Star Wars show, I mean, I've enjoyed Mandalorian and even Obi Wan a lot, but this one truly feels like they're making a good TV show first, then decided to make it fit in the Star Wars universe.
I have trouble believing we are getting this quality caliber of a live action Star Wars show, I mean, I've enjoyed Mandalorian and even Obi Wan a lot, but this one truly feels like they're making a good TV show first, then decided to make it fit in the Star Wars universe.
The following users liked this post:
JeremyM (10-28-22)
#11
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Andor (S1E08) - "Narkina 5" - 10/26/22
This show just gets better and better. If George made the OT as a vague commentary on Vietnam, this show is a brutalist essay on all our modern ills like the prison-industrial complex or the merging of corporations and government.
I have trouble believing we are getting this quality caliber of a live action Star Wars show, I mean, I've enjoyed Mandalorian and even Obi Wan a lot, but this one truly feels like they're making a good TV show first, then decided to make it fit in the Star Wars universe.
I have trouble believing we are getting this quality caliber of a live action Star Wars show, I mean, I've enjoyed Mandalorian and even Obi Wan a lot, but this one truly feels like they're making a good TV show first, then decided to make it fit in the Star Wars universe.
#12
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Andor (S1E08) - "Narkina 5" - 10/26/22
This show continues to look incredible and bore me to tears. So Andor was randomly picked up by the Empire and put in prison for no reason? And we have to spend an entire episode watching him make random crap with a group of random characters?
I love that when they were doing the flashbacks without subtitles everyone was saying they weren’t needed but now they bring the show to a halt to make sure you know every single member of his prison group by name. All while the Empire (who already has him IN PRISON by pure coincidence) is running around looking for him?
My eyes glaze over just thinking about it.
I love that when they were doing the flashbacks without subtitles everyone was saying they weren’t needed but now they bring the show to a halt to make sure you know every single member of his prison group by name. All while the Empire (who already has him IN PRISON by pure coincidence) is running around looking for him?
My eyes glaze over just thinking about it.
#13
Moderator
Re: Andor (S1E08) - "Narkina 5" - 10/26/22
I was watching the episode 8 recap on Nerdist and Dan mentioned something we more than likely missed: they brought back Duncan Pow's Rogue One character Ruescott Melshi as a member of Andor’s work team.




The following users liked this post:
xe.kilroy (10-31-22)
#14
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#15
Moderator
Re: Andor (S1E08) - "Narkina 5" - 10/26/22
I was watching the episode 8 recap on Nerdist and Dan mentioned something we more than likely missed: they brought back Duncan Pow's Rogue One character Ruescott Melshi as a member of Andor’s work team.
#16
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Andor (S1E08) - "Narkina 5" - 10/26/22
This show continues to look incredible and bore me to tears. So Andor was randomly picked up by the Empire and put in prison for no reason? And we have to spend an entire episode watching him make random crap with a group of random characters?
I love that when they were doing the flashbacks without subtitles everyone was saying they weren’t needed but now they bring the show to a halt to make sure you know every single member of his prison group by name. All while the Empire (who already has him IN PRISON by pure coincidence) is running around looking for him?
My eyes glaze over just thinking about it.
I love that when they were doing the flashbacks without subtitles everyone was saying they weren’t needed but now they bring the show to a halt to make sure you know every single member of his prison group by name. All while the Empire (who already has him IN PRISON by pure coincidence) is running around looking for him?
My eyes glaze over just thinking about it.
What I'm getting from the show is "Who is this Andor guy and how did he end up on a mission to steal the Death Star plans and become a hero?" It's simaliar to BEN-HUR. Who was this guy who came forward and gave Jesus a drink of water when he was carrying the cross? A story was developed around who this guy was and events that led him to be at that particular place at that that particular time. Ben-Hur didn't have a beef with the Romans. Resisted those who wanted to rebel. Wouldn't snitch on those who spoke of rebellion to Messala. Then the Romans fucked with him and threw him in the galley when he did nothing. Then he chose a side.
Even though he's already in prison, the Imperial gestapo have made a connection between him and the robbery/rebellion. They need to interrogate him.
Last edited by rw2516; 10-29-22 at 10:36 AM.
The following users liked this post:
xe.kilroy (10-31-22)
#17
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Andor (S1E08) - "Narkina 5" - 10/26/22
This show continues to look incredible and bore me to tears. So Andor was randomly picked up by the Empire and put in prison for no reason? And we have to spend an entire episode watching him make random crap with a group of random characters?
I love that when they were doing the flashbacks without subtitles everyone was saying they weren’t needed but now they bring the show to a halt to make sure you know every single member of his prison group by name. All while the Empire (who already has him IN PRISON by pure coincidence) is running around looking for him?
My eyes glaze over just thinking about it.
I love that when they were doing the flashbacks without subtitles everyone was saying they weren’t needed but now they bring the show to a halt to make sure you know every single member of his prison group by name. All while the Empire (who already has him IN PRISON by pure coincidence) is running around looking for him?
My eyes glaze over just thinking about it.
I don't understand what not using subtitles in one scene has to do with learning character names for characters that are clearly going to be used going forward. And the introductions took maybe a minute? We also learned the prisoner names in prison films like Escape from Alcatraz and The Great Escape and saw glimpses of their daily lives as the story of their eventual escape unfolded. This did not seem unusual to me.
If the show is not for you, cool. But your takeaways from the episode certainly differ from mine!
#18
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Andor (S1E08) - "Narkina 5" - 10/26/22
Yeah, I don't get the problem with no subtitles when those scenes communicated exactly what they needed too. And of course, the entire point of the hunt for Andor while he is already in custody proves Andor's "They are so fat and satisfied" point that the Empire thinks way too much of itself. I really don't get watching a show that is obviously not for you (not really picking on you-Draven- specifically) but there's always these types of posts in pretty much every series thread.
I forgot to point out in my earlier post that it was cool seeing Andor process everything around him when he arrived at the prison facility. His eyes constantly scanning and taking in every detail. I know everyone is probably wondering what they are making and the best suggestion I have heard is the lower appendage assembly of a Probe Droid.
I forgot to point out in my earlier post that it was cool seeing Andor process everything around him when he arrived at the prison facility. His eyes constantly scanning and taking in every detail. I know everyone is probably wondering what they are making and the best suggestion I have heard is the lower appendage assembly of a Probe Droid.