The Wheel of Time (Amazon) -- premieres 11/19/21
#126
Suspended
Re: The Wheel of Time (Amazon) -- premieres 11/19/21
Spoiler:
#129
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
#130
Re: The Wheel of Time (Amazon) -- premieres 11/19/21
As a book fan, I went and looked at the last three episode titles - and based on that…holy shit they are blasting through the first book 
For example - there are some major flashbacks that happen in the books and explain more about what the previous “age” was like. They haven’t done that at all here. So it’ll be interesting to see if those things eventually come up.
As for “purists” - I never get that. Just go read the books again. I’m a big fan of the series but I know this is an adaptation. It would have to be the longest series in history to fit everything in.
PS. Nyaneve somehow has RBF in the books too, so it works here
She’s dead-on for her character.

For example - there are some major flashbacks that happen in the books and explain more about what the previous “age” was like. They haven’t done that at all here. So it’ll be interesting to see if those things eventually come up.
As for “purists” - I never get that. Just go read the books again. I’m a big fan of the series but I know this is an adaptation. It would have to be the longest series in history to fit everything in.
PS. Nyaneve somehow has RBF in the books too, so it works here

Spoiler:
#131
Senior Member
Re: The Wheel of Time (Amazon) -- premieres 11/19/21
#133
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Wheel of Time (Amazon) -- premieres 11/19/21
Just finished the newest episode (episode 6 is live) and it was ok. Looks like the final episodes will have to REALLY make up for the lack of action in the middle of the series so far. Here's hoping it finishes strong since I am still interested.
#134
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: The Wheel of Time (Amazon) -- premieres 11/19/21
Now I know the true definition of "pillow friends"
#135
Banned
Re: The Wheel of Time (Amazon) -- premieres 11/19/21
I have to say that the scene in the city when they’re on the terrace was one of the best looking pictures I’ve seen on my Vizio (it was in HDR10+).
The following users liked this post:
Rodney2187 (12-11-21)
#136
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Nashville and Crossville, TN
Posts: 9,023
Received 624 Likes
on
485 Posts
Re: The Wheel of Time (Amazon) -- premieres 11/19/21
That opening scene was intense. I'm glad we got the answer to who the dragon was and didn't have to wait for multiple seasons.
#137
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: The Wheel of Time (Amazon) -- premieres 11/19/21
The arguing/fighting scene with the Two Rivers crew drove me nuts. Too much CW teen angst for my liking, but loved the reveal of the baby being born on Dragonmount and Tam's fever mutterings. The Aiel are going to be so badass!
#138
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: The Wheel of Time (Amazon) -- premieres 11/19/21
Yeah the stuff that is good is a grand slam, but then there's the teen drama stuff.
Very curious how the finale plays out especially with Mat not there.
I hope they do the cold open/come back to later device they used for Rand's birth next week with the prologue.
Very curious how the finale plays out especially with Mat not there.
I hope they do the cold open/come back to later device they used for Rand's birth next week with the prologue.
#139
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Seattle and sometimes hell
Posts: 6,260
Likes: 0
Received 15 Likes
on
14 Posts
Re: The Wheel of Time (Amazon) -- premieres 11/19/21
Loved ep 7. The opening fight was fantastic. I'm not sure what happen to the troll after they came out of the gate. I didn't notice anything odd with the actor playing Mat leaving. If I didn't know he left I would have thought this is always how the show would go in story.
#140
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The Wheel of Time (Amazon) -- premieres 11/19/21
Loved the opening scene as well. Best of the series so far.
I couldn’t follow some of the discussion previously. Was Mat recast before episodes aired, or you’re saying he was recast next time (?) we see him it’ll be somebody else?
I actually thought it was Mat or that minstrel who was following them in the darkness.
I rolled my eyes so hard when wolf man said he thought he saw the old trader, only for the other one to say, “Oh - that’s not him. Everybody died.” With everything you’ve seen; 1) how are you so dismissive, and 2) you can’t just walk around the corner to find out. Especially since it was implied he came through the gate.
I couldn’t follow some of the discussion previously. Was Mat recast before episodes aired, or you’re saying he was recast next time (?) we see him it’ll be somebody else?
I actually thought it was Mat or that minstrel who was following them in the darkness.
I rolled my eyes so hard when wolf man said he thought he saw the old trader, only for the other one to say, “Oh - that’s not him. Everybody died.” With everything you’ve seen; 1) how are you so dismissive, and 2) you can’t just walk around the corner to find out. Especially since it was implied he came through the gate.
#141
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: The Wheel of Time (Amazon) -- premieres 11/19/21
I rolled my eyes so hard when wolf man said he thought he saw the old trader, only for the other one to say, “Oh - that’s not him. Everybody died.” With everything you’ve seen; 1) how are you so dismissive, and 2) you can’t just walk around the corner to find out. Especially since it was implied he came through the gate.
At least they didn't make someone else the Dragon. One of the few things that tracks with the books. The whole it can be anyone of you or a 5-headed Dragon was sheer nonsense. The Dragon has to be male because of the taint on Saidin that causes male channelers to go mad. A female channeling Saidar would not be a danger.
#142
Re: The Wheel of Time (Amazon) -- premieres 11/19/21
Loved the opening scene as well. Best of the series so far.
I couldn’t follow some of the discussion previously. Was Mat recast before episodes aired, or you’re saying he was recast next time (?) we see him it’ll be somebody else?
I actually thought it was Mat or that minstrel who was following them in the darkness.
I rolled my eyes so hard when wolf man said he thought he saw the old trader, only for the other one to say, “Oh - that’s not him. Everybody died.” With everything you’ve seen; 1) how are you so dismissive, and 2) you can’t just walk around the corner to find out. Especially since it was implied he came through the gate.
I couldn’t follow some of the discussion previously. Was Mat recast before episodes aired, or you’re saying he was recast next time (?) we see him it’ll be somebody else?
I actually thought it was Mat or that minstrel who was following them in the darkness.
I rolled my eyes so hard when wolf man said he thought he saw the old trader, only for the other one to say, “Oh - that’s not him. Everybody died.” With everything you’ve seen; 1) how are you so dismissive, and 2) you can’t just walk around the corner to find out. Especially since it was implied he came through the gate.
Not sure what will happen in Ep 8. They are pretty far off the rails and many expected them to make changes to the Eye anyway. This was actually one of my least favorite episodes as some of the changes they made will have far reaching implications I dont think were necessary.
I suspect Season 2 will have a big uptick in quality. The Book is more TV adaptable to start and pretty straightforward, and they clearly are settling in as the episodes go on.
#143
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Wheel of Time (Amazon) -- premieres 11/19/21
The fact is that they are going to have to HACK major stuff out of these books to adapt for television. You'd need like 30+ seasons to cover everything and they aren't going to do that. They can't even be planning 14 seasons to go with the 14 books.
I wouldn't be surprised if they skipped entire books and basically hit the highlights with only a fraction of the same relationships.
I wouldn't be surprised if they skipped entire books and basically hit the highlights with only a fraction of the same relationships.
The following users liked this post:
chowderhead (12-20-21)
#144
Re: The Wheel of Time (Amazon) -- premieres 11/19/21
The fact is that they are going to have to HACK major stuff out of these books to adapt for television. You'd need like 30+ seasons to cover everything and they aren't going to do that. They can't even be planning 14 seasons to go with the 14 books.
I wouldn't be surprised if they skipped entire books and basically hit the highlights with only a fraction of the same relationships.
I wouldn't be surprised if they skipped entire books and basically hit the highlights with only a fraction of the same relationships.
#146
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: The Wheel of Time (Amazon) -- premieres 11/19/21
I've seen it brought up more than once. Curious, Why is casting more unknown actors matter at all? Skill, talent?
I think it's one of those things I do not care about. Sure I can like an actor in a given roll and once they are set I want them to likely play that character. I'm watching a show or movie for the concept and story.
I think it's one of those things I do not care about. Sure I can like an actor in a given roll and once they are set I want them to likely play that character. I'm watching a show or movie for the concept and story.
#147
Senior Member
Re: The Wheel of Time (Amazon) -- premieres 11/19/21
I thought that was a great first season, much better than I was expecting. I didn’t like how Foundation was adapted and thought this would be similarly disappointing. I ended up liking this even more than The Witcher.
#148
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Nashville and Crossville, TN
Posts: 9,023
Received 624 Likes
on
485 Posts
Re: The Wheel of Time (Amazon) -- premieres 11/19/21
Skill and experience matters. Also, when you're spending $10 million an episode, you can hire better experienced actors. Sometimes you strike gold with unknown actors. Anya Chalotra (Yennefer on The Witcher) was an unknown and she's been fantastic. You couldn't say that of any of the 5 potential dragons on this show are as talented or show promise like Chalotra has on The Witcher. Sometimes shows cast unknown actors just for the sake of it and to save money. I think it's one of the biggest flaws of this series. Game of Thrones had some unknown actors, but I feel like they nailed casting Kit Haringtion, Emilia Clake, Sophie Turner, and Maisie Williams. It's just my opinion, but I don't see Madeline Madden, Zoe Robbins, Josha Stradowski, or Marcus Rutherford in the same league as Chalotra and the Thrones cast, but they have time to grow and get better. Maybe they will surprise me.
#150
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: The Wheel of Time (Amazon) -- premieres 11/19/21
As someone who's read the entire series more than once, there's stuff I like and some I don't. In general though I'm happy and just really excited to see this in live action. Hopefully Amazon will allow it to get the planned 8 seasons.
The following users liked this post:
Rodney2187 (12-24-21)