If I remember correctly, season one had an episode where the police thought the person committed suicide, while others thought hate crime (house party episode).

In this episode, the police think the mother committed suicide. I think it was an abduction by someone she knew. I believe the witnesses who say that the car was gone from the parking lot when they left the church, but it returned later. If that’s the case, a random attacker isn’t going to return the car after a carjacking/robbery.

Oh damn, this episode was hard to watch and really sad. I can’t even imagine being a parent who has a child taken from them. I agree it’s most likely people taking children to raise them, in these Harlem cases. I think they should do a spin-off series focused on missing children.

To me the fourth episode wasn’t bad, but it wasn’t much of a mystery really. Past ghost episodes have been better in my opinion. It was definitely a sad episode though.

I think the lady in episode five was probably killed because of her brother’s business problems. My guess is that maybe whoever killed her intended to scare her to get to the brother, but wound up killing her.

The sixth episode is sad. Unfortunately sounds like some carelessness on behalf of the parents in both cases.

Overall I liked the first two episodes the best.

...an elaborate ruse by young people posing as ghosts to give everyone a little thrill. Like, not a prank, and nothing malicious, but people pretending as a sort of LARP adventure that plays on people's desires to see ghosts and be helpful and friendly. I don't know, it just felt like most of the encounters seemed like regular people with odd behavior.

I think their hypothesis about the brother's trouble coming to her is spot-on. There are a few pieces of speculation the family makes that feels like 20/20 hindsight but she was clearly cleared, not suicide. Bad police work.

Seems like a valid mystery and not suicide. Definitely a group of people from the grad party know what happened.

Probably related to the girl’s credit card she fraudulently used. I imagine maybe 3 girls from the party assaulted her in retaliation, stabbed her, and placed her body on the train tracks. Whether they had the foresight that a train would be coming really soon is questionable. It just ended up that way and made a perfect cover story.

First episode of season three seems to be one that’s bound to be a true mystery.

At first I thought maybe the family was in denial as to the reality that Tiffany committed suicide but as it went on some things don’t seem to make sense.

Big questions in my mind- why walk all that distance to commit suicide and also why would she have taken off a good amount of her clothing, especially her shoes?

Unfortunately it seems like a perfect storm of things going wrong to not be able to solve this case. Shoddy police work (really can’t believe the uncle and cousin had to go out and still pick up parts of her…).

Plus there’s no true leads or witnesses or anything to go off of and the fact that her body was cremated and there’s no way of doing any testing. I get that she was mangled by the train though but still.

I do wonder why the convenience store worker and the three kids weren’t re-questioned or given polygraph tests to see if they were being truthful. Also was anyone at the party who knew her questioned in regards to an argument?

The only other things I can think of- was the breakup actually as clean as thought or was there some bad feelings? Possibly something involving the new girlfriend or an ex-lover?

Really going to be a tough one to crack.

So apparently the first episode from season three is missing a lot of details about Tiffany’s case. There are some Reddit threads about various bits of information as well as an article here:

https://screenrant.com/unsolved-myst...tails-missing/

Similar to a previous episode, not much of a mystery and more of a fugitive case.

But I can imagine Tammy being in a new relationship. Her boyfriend fires up Netflix this week and decides to watch Unsolved Mysteries and is about to get the shock of his life….

Second episode of season three was okay. Not really a lot to say about it. Basically a standard fare paranormal episode. I didn’t mind it but not my favorite episode either.

Wow, some really good detective work in this one. From the Pontiac car, the Yahoo personals info, and the photo headshots they dropped in there (you’d probably hate to see yourself appear in an Unsolved Mysteries episode).

Joshua definitely tried to meet up with someone. Probably got a cell phone call from a mystery person and stepped outside the apartment party. I remember having a cell phone in 2002, so it’s possible.

He probably met his hookup on the bridge and…

Sounds like there is a single valid theory, but they just can't prove the mob guy / Crazy Horse Too owner was involved. Definitely used a stripper to trick Buffalo Jim into taking some cut / laced cocaine and it was OD / lethal poison.

Another good one. Like mentioned though really not a mystery but more of a fugitive case and needing help locating Tammy.

Regardless though a messed up story. David had to have been dead when DJ was at his apartment and he probably would have been killed or at least hurt if he went into the room.

Another episode that’s not a full on mystery but more of a who done it. I mean it’s pretty clear that it was something with the mob, but actually proving that will probably be next to impossible.

Wondering if Buffalo Jim willingly took cocaine and it was way too strong or laced with something else or if it was forced into him (maybe he was held down or something).

I didn’t dislike the episode. It’s another where it depends on what you believe. Personally it’s hard for me to discount anything that was said, but there also is no solid proof so who really knows.

Very interesting episode. I feel like Katie and Nick probably weren’t involved. If so I don’t think they would be so willing and open to talk on the show.

The discrepancy between the time Katie said Nick left her place and when he said he left is the main thing, but that can be easily mistaken. Other than that if Joshua and Nick had a fight but they didn’t go much into that so I don’t think that was it.

The online dating profile seems like the most likely theory to me. Especially as mentioned in the show- if Joshua was posing as a female and met up with someone, maybe they got upset and killed him.

That or he just met someone that wound up not being safe and they did something to him. That just makes the most sense to me.

Like theorized above he probably received a call at the party and maybe went to hookup in secret and things took a turn.

Damon - guilty! He for sure did it. I imagine Patrick Mullins noticed his friend in the bay, pulled up along side him, and caught Damon smoking some crystal meth.

Patrick probably tried to help Damon stop using meth in the moment (like a teacher would stop a student doing something bad). He was a librarian, so maybe he got in “teacher” mode.

Damon, in a high state, got mad and shot Patrick with the shotgun. The moment of shock “sobered” him up, did the unique boat rope tie, and disposed of the body with the anchor.

I really liked this one. Very sad, especially all the Missing headshots at the end. One of them said Wanted - 1988!


The mom whose kids are in Egypt probably has zero chance at seeing her kids again.

The Aziz case seems more likely to be solved. The justice system is slow as shit. Too much red tape.

Yikes, this episode was all over the place.

Was it a paranormal ghost episode? Or a Marliz homicide episode? Or was it about the Girl in the Box incident that’s already been covered by other true crime shows? Choose one…

No way this was a suicide. Not even sure how that idea was seriously considered honestly.

I feel it’s likely Damon was involved in some capacity. Whether or not he did it is up in the air in my opinion.

I feel like Patrick could have come across him and maybe a drug dealer. The drug dealer killed him and Damon had to help cover it up and get rid of the body. Might explain why he took Patrick’s death so hard.

That or Damon was seen using drugs by Patrick and he freaked out and shot him.

I was expecting another paranormal case but an interesting cold case episode. I haven’t ever heard the story of the girl in a box from other true crime shows so this was new to me.

We essentially know what happened so it’s only unsolved in the sense of where is Marliz’s body buried. I guess also in the sense of how do you explain Jody’s dreams and everything that happened?