DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/617867-true-detective-who-goes-there-2-09-14-a.html)

DJariya 02-09-14 12:32 PM

True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 
https://scontent-a-lax.xx.fbcdn.net/...73039736_n.jpg


Hart (Woody Harrelson) and Cohle (Matthew McConaughey) follow a series of dangerous leads in an effort to locate prime suspect Reggie Ledoux.

Written by Nic Pizzolatto; directed by Cary Joji Fukunaga.



Episode 4 of 8

Brian Gentz 02-09-14 08:21 PM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 
Haha, when they showed the police sketch, I thought to myself that looks like the guy from Raising Hope.

dex14 02-09-14 09:00 PM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 
That was in fact all one take wasn't it? I was so engaged I couldn't keep track. Amazing.

Lt Ripley 02-09-14 09:01 PM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 
Can we just have a 4 hour marathon of the final episodes next week? Time to change the channel.

Geofferson 02-09-14 09:32 PM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 

Originally Posted by dex14 (Post 12006160)
That was in fact all one take wasn't it? I was so engaged I couldn't keep track. Amazing.

And I think I was holding my breath during most of it. An amazing sequence for sure. Will need to watch this one again.

sauce07 02-09-14 09:35 PM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 

Originally Posted by Geofferson (Post 12006197)
And I think I was holding my breath during most of it. An amazing sequence for sure. Will need to watch this one again.

I think they cut away to everybody in the second house at one point

edit: Nope, the camera moves around the outside of the house, follows a gang banger inside, then the camera catches back up with Cohle behind the house.

Nausicaa 02-09-14 10:19 PM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 
That was an incredible episode. The entire second half was just amazingly well done.

Deftones 02-09-14 10:23 PM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 
Yeah that was absolutely amazing.

Michael T Hudson 02-09-14 10:44 PM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 
That was intense.

alfredog1976 02-09-14 10:59 PM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 
Wow, awesome episode!

Rypro 525 02-10-14 12:00 AM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 
Whats even more impressive about that shot that it was done on a TV budget. an incredible hour of TV

Neil M. 02-10-14 12:06 AM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 
That was exactly what this show needed. I think the only cut during the whole sequence was when the camera tilts up to show the helicopter.

Rypro 525 02-10-14 12:08 AM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 

Originally Posted by Neil M. (Post 12006283)
That was exactly what this show needed. I think the only cut during the whole sequence was when the camera tilts up to show the helicopter.

if the blu ray version has like a 'sequence breakdown' extra, i will buy it

Neil M. 02-10-14 12:10 AM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 

Originally Posted by Rypro 525 (Post 12006284)
if the blu ray version has like a 'sequence breakdown' extra, i will buy it

I'll be completely pissed if it doesn't have that feature. Plus a behind the scenes look at the Daddario nude scene.

bluetoast 02-10-14 12:18 AM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 
Great sequence.

boogieman03 02-10-14 12:33 AM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 
Yes! It was Frank from Raising Hope!

Amazing sequence. Want to rewatch this episode again.

HN 02-10-14 12:40 AM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 

Originally Posted by Neil M. (Post 12006283)
That was exactly what this show needed. I think the only cut during the whole sequence was when the camera tilts up to show the helicopter.

Not one take but definitely cut to appear as one shot. I think it was at the helicopter also but the way they did it was you see the spotlight and the camera follows the light up to the helicopter. It was fcking beautiful.

That last 8-10 minutes...jeezus. -eek-

Rob V 02-10-14 07:49 AM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 
One of the most intense hours on TV in quite a while. Awesome episode.

Geofferson 02-10-14 08:06 AM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 
This show is turning out to be not so much about the unsolved case as it is about the two detectives. Last night's was basically a detour episode harking back to Cohle's days as an undercover narc. Glad they chose to inject this into the story especially after we've heard Cohle talk about what the experience was like for him.

Also, I knew that was Frank from Raising Hope once we saw the sketch. ;)

creekdipper 02-10-14 08:38 AM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 
What everyone else said about the last five minutes. Riveting. Just...riveting.

Had to wash out my scorched eyeballs afterward.

dex14 02-10-14 09:00 AM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 
The shot that aired was in 1 single take.


Four episodes into its run on HBO, "True Detective" is earning the kind of high praise usually saved for drama series with two or three seasons under their belts, thanks to its stunning visuals, pitch-black worldview and career-best performances from Woody Harrelson and Matthew McConaughey. Cary Fukunaga helmed each installment of the eight-episode run, and his careful direction has been a key factor in "True Detective's" success, even if it's not as apparent as Harrelson's and McConaughey's acting.

But if you watched the fourth episode, "Who Goes There," tonight on HBO, by the end, it's likely you are very aware of just how good Cary Fukunaga is.

MILD SPOILERS FOR EPISODE 4 AHEAD

Before reaching the halfway point of the series, Fukunaga decided to end the episode with a six-minute oner, or long take, that follows Cohle into a heist inside a housing project, through a number of shootouts, outside to escape from swarming police, through another house, over a fence and finally into Hart's car. It's the kind of incredible shot that's worth watching again and again to catch every detail in it and further blurs the line between television and film.

To find out how he pulled off the complex sequence, I reached out to Fukunaga to see if he would walk me through the planning and execution of the best "True Detective" scene yet.

Off the bat, it's important to know that the oner is nothing new to Fukunaga. Having used the technique in both of his feature films, "Sin Nombre" and "Jane Eyre," Fukunaga signed onto "True Detective" knowing that he wanted to include a long take at some point, because he considers it a tenser kind of directing. "The best ones, you don't even realize that they're oners," Fukunaga said. "They're the most first-person experience you can get in a film."

Reading Nic Pizzolatto's script for "Who Goes There," Fukunaga knew almost immediately that the heist was the scene to make his oner. All he had to do was convince the entire crew that it wasn't impossible to pull off.

To cover as much ground as he wanted to in the sequence, Fukunaga needed to shoot in an actual housing project, and that was the first complication in planning the oner. It took weeks to even get permission to film on-location, but once he received it, Fukunaga went straight into mapping the shot and finding "the most interesting path, but also the most logical path" for Cohle to escape with Ginger. That interesting and logical path eventually takes Cohle and Ginger over a chain-link fence, a maneuver that proved to be the most complicated of the intricate sequence.

Watching just the fences portion of the oner back, the camera floats over the high barrier in a movement that almost looks effortless. Getting the shot, however, was anything but. Because the location was an actual housing project, the "True Detective" crew wasn't allowed to take down any portion of the fence, so they had to improvise. "At one point, we were going to build a ramp, and the operator was going to walk up it," Fukunaga said. "But that wasn't very safe." The solution ended up involving placing the Steadicam operator on an elevated jib, or a weighted crane, which carried him over the fence and back down to earth.

Once the camera movements were figured out, the production carefully choreographed everything that had to happen in front of the lens with the help of a stunt team led by Mark Norby, who personally worked with McConaughey to develop a fighting style for Cohle. The crew even built a replica of the stash house for the stunt team to practice in before the big shoot.

"We had ADs [assistant directors] all over the neighborhood because we had to release extras, crowd running background, police cars, stunt drivers. There were actual gun shots and stones being thrown through windows. There were a lot of things to put together," Fukunaga said. "Even the action, the stunt sequences were complicated. We're working on a television schedule. It isn't like a film where you can spend a lot of time working the stunts out with the actors. We only had a day and a half to get Matthew and everyone else on the same page."

All told, the sequence clocks in at around six minutes. Fukunaga and the crew ran through the whole thing seven times while the cameras were rolling. The director built in possible edit points if two takes had to be combined to make the perfect version of the shot, but anyone who is wondering should know that the sequence everyone saw in the episode is, in fact, a true single take and one of the great achievements of filmmaking for television.
http://www.mtv.com/news/articles/172...ong-take.jhtml

johnnysd 02-10-14 09:14 AM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 

Originally Posted by Rypro 525 (Post 12006279)
Whats even more impressive about that shot that it was done on a TV budget. an incredible hour of TV

It's not TV it is HBO :) But yes it was a terrific sequence. Seems like they may wrap up the previous investigation and move away from the interview segments and into the present in the next episode.

HN 02-10-14 10:11 AM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 

Originally Posted by dex14 (Post 12006453)
The shot that aired was in 1 single take.

http://www.mtv.com/news/articles/172...ong-take.jhtml

Incredible!

Watching it a 3rd time, i think only baseball bat guy was a bit of a pansy -- Cohle doesn't hit him that hard and he pretty much goes out cold :lol:

dex14 02-10-14 10:23 AM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 

Originally Posted by HN (Post 12006534)
Incredible!

Watching it a 3rd time, i think only baseball bat guy was a bit of a pansy -- Cohle doesn't hit him that hard and he pretty much goes out cold :lol:

I think that was due more to him using the butt of his gun with his strikes to take them out.

hanshotfirst1138 02-10-14 11:40 AM

Re: True Detective -- "Who Goes There" -- 2/09/14
 
Sounds pretty damned impressive for a TV series on a budget. I can never bad-mouth HBO because they allowed The Wire to run for all five seasons even though its ratings were so bad, but that was just the tip of the iceberg. Sunset Limited, Game of Thrones, the list goes on. Nice to know they're giving good art a place.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:27 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.