Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
#426
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
Anyone who watches a show like L&O and thinks it either mirrors real life or is being used as cop propaganda is hilariously misinformed.
#427
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
#429
Banned
#430
DVD Talk God
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Directionally Challenged (for DirecTV)
Posts: 128,229
Received 418 Likes
on
342 Posts
Re: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
Great posts, Count. 
I admit I enjoyed the original L&O for pure entertainment value in the Jerry Orbach days. But while I respected their legal precedents cited, I never thought it was an accurate reflection of the police and prosecutors. They don't care about truth and justice. They care about arrests and convictions - as a bottom line.
And that CSI effect is so true - that show is so much worse to warping the minds of people.
Always thought SVU was total garbage and CI was really bad. Then we have the new Stabler show which is basically a cartoon.

I admit I enjoyed the original L&O for pure entertainment value in the Jerry Orbach days. But while I respected their legal precedents cited, I never thought it was an accurate reflection of the police and prosecutors. They don't care about truth and justice. They care about arrests and convictions - as a bottom line.
And that CSI effect is so true - that show is so much worse to warping the minds of people.
Always thought SVU was total garbage and CI was really bad. Then we have the new Stabler show which is basically a cartoon.
#431
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
Having had a day or two to mull all this over, maybe Oliver's point is that the L&O franchise purports to be more "realistic" in its depiction of police, when it obviously isn't. And sure, I know that, I watch it for entertainment value. Like if there's a noted guest star (not the before-they-were-famous appearances, like Samuel L. Jackson or Philip Seymour Hoffman) in a very small role early on, you already know they did the crime and will be prominent in both halves of the ep. But maybe a lot of Lionel Hutzes in the world watch L&O in a bar with the sound turned down and think they're qualified to try a case.
One thing I've thought about, is that Oliver only mentioned two shows for the most part: Dragnet and L&O. But there were definitely cop shows in between, hundreds of them. He didn't mention them, because people already know that California Highway Patrol officers do not spend their time in roller discos (like I sarcastically referred to earlier), or that vice cops in Miami don't tool around in jet boats wearing pastel suits. Cop shows in general are ridiculous, featuring car chases, shootouts (that no one ever gets shot in, except maybe the leg or shoulder), last second rescues, etc. You know, generally obvious escapist fare. Law and Order always does the "ripped from the headlines" cases, then throws in the disclaimer "even though this is similar to a real case, the details in this show were fictitious" for half a second after the credits.
And again, I want to emphasize that I'm not that familiar with SVU or the other shows in the franchise, just the "classic", so if those are more over the top and yet pretend to be realistic, I'm not aware of it. I guess I just got a little miffed at JO taking the wind out of the sails of a good Sunday Law and Order rerun marathon where they air some of my favorites, and a couple I haven't seen before (and also, I just saw one for the first time, where a high school kid got shot in a drug deal gone wrong, but then it turns out he was a snitch for a dirty narc so they tried the narc for manslaughter since he put the kid in the position to be killed. Realistic? Of course not. Entertaining? Hell yes!).
One thing I've thought about, is that Oliver only mentioned two shows for the most part: Dragnet and L&O. But there were definitely cop shows in between, hundreds of them. He didn't mention them, because people already know that California Highway Patrol officers do not spend their time in roller discos (like I sarcastically referred to earlier), or that vice cops in Miami don't tool around in jet boats wearing pastel suits. Cop shows in general are ridiculous, featuring car chases, shootouts (that no one ever gets shot in, except maybe the leg or shoulder), last second rescues, etc. You know, generally obvious escapist fare. Law and Order always does the "ripped from the headlines" cases, then throws in the disclaimer "even though this is similar to a real case, the details in this show were fictitious" for half a second after the credits.
And again, I want to emphasize that I'm not that familiar with SVU or the other shows in the franchise, just the "classic", so if those are more over the top and yet pretend to be realistic, I'm not aware of it. I guess I just got a little miffed at JO taking the wind out of the sails of a good Sunday Law and Order rerun marathon where they air some of my favorites, and a couple I haven't seen before (and also, I just saw one for the first time, where a high school kid got shot in a drug deal gone wrong, but then it turns out he was a snitch for a dirty narc so they tried the narc for manslaughter since he put the kid in the position to be killed. Realistic? Of course not. Entertaining? Hell yes!).
#432
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
Like I said before, I watched about 250 episodes of LO:SVU this year in about 6-7 months, so more than an episode a day. When you watch A LOT of a show in a concentrated period of time, you notice its tendencies, and Oliver's observations are correct from my point of view.
#433
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
Pretty good episode on bail reform this week (Oct. 30th episode). Those stories about lengthy prison stays (sometimes years) before even having a trial are infuriating.
The following users liked this post:
BDB (11-05-22)
#434
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
Especially when they spend more time in jail awaiting trial than if they'd had the trial, were found guilty, and sentenced to the maximum. Isn't there some document somewhere that talks about a "speedy trial"?
The following 2 users liked this post by Paff:
BDB (11-05-22),
devilshalo (11-04-22)
#435
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
Another thing that affects this situation is lack of state funding for public defenders. Since these accused criminals typically rely on free legal aid, when there are a severe lack of public defenders available to provide that service, the trial dates get put off.
I heard an NPR story that Oregon had one-third of the public defender staff that it was supposed to have, but when the subject of increasing funding comes up, it gets connected to being soft on crime. And the general public does not care because having a free lawyer available to accused criminals is something they don't expect will ever impact them personally.
Last edited by Count Dooku; 11-05-22 at 02:18 PM.
#436
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
But but but... Darren Bailey's commercials here in IL say cashless bail is the "Purge Law!" There's no way that's just rhetoric to scare the white suburbanites and southern Illinoisans, right?
#437
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
I assume he has a beef with Colbert if he goes on Fallon to plug the new season
#438
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
Here's all his other Fallon appearances:
https://www.youtube.com/results?sear...r+jimmy+fallon
John Oliver was on Colbert about 2 months ago:
He was also on Amber Ruffin's show right before Christmas:
And on Late Night with Seth Meyers 4 months ago: