How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

BARNEY BEGS TED TO CONTINUE SEEING HIS YOUNGER, WILDER GIRLFRIEND, EVEN THOUGH TED HAS NOTHING IN COMMON WITH HER, ON "HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER," MONDAY, JAN. 21

Ashley Benson ("Pretty Little Liars") Guest Stars as Carly, Ted's New Girlfriend

"Ring Up" - Barney begs Ted to continue seeing his much younger, much wilder girlfriend, even though Ted has nothing in common with her. Meanwhile, Robin must adjust to the power of the bling, on HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER, Monday, Jan. 21 (8:00-8:30 PM, ET/PT) on the CBS Television Network. Ashley Benson ("Pretty Little Liars") guest stars as Carly, Ted's new girlfriend.

SERIES REGULARS:

Josh Radnor (Ted)
Jason Segel (Marshall)
Cobie Smulders (Robin)
Neil Patrick Harris (Barney)
Alyson Hannigan (Lily)

RECURRING CAST:

Bob Saget (Narrator)

GUEST CAST:

Carly (Ashley Benson)
Jason Watson (Barista)
Chauncey Jenkins (Business Man)
Sachin Bhatt (Man #1)
Zach Bandler (Man #2)
Jason Heymann (Man #3)
Nikki Tuazon (Hot Girl)

WRITTEN BY: Jennifer Hendriks

DIRECTED BY: Pamela Fryman



Read more: Listings - HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER on CBS | TheFutonCritic.com http://www.thefutoncritic.com/listin...#ixzz2If6GV5jf

Episode 14 of 24

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

rotfl

Well there goes that theory.

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

The fact that Ted had to be talked into banging that blonde further proves I could never hang with Ted. Being in my mid 30s, my single friends and I would battle in a Hunger Games like contest to hook up with a 20 year old whos that hot.

As for the rest of the episode, the Robin ring thing was ammusing, but the rest felt like filler.

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

You can hear the internet screaming because the writers just killed the one thing so many fans were ABSOLUTELY SURE they had known for the last couple of years.

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

Thought that was a decent episode. Loved the "thing" it took Ted to connect with the 20 year old chick.

I didn't think that chick was that hot seemed like a butterface to me.

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

I'll go down speculating that the writers called an audible. I find that more plausible than thinking the writers made a specific, throwaway reference to a character we've never met just so she could appear in a random episode that no one will ever care about.

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

Agree. Although in my case, her face looked good in some scenes and in some other not that good. Really weird, like they were using two actresses.

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

I'm drawing a blank, what theory? That Ted marries Barneys sister?

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

Yep. Fans everywhere have been speculating that idea since she was first mentioned offhand by LIthgow when he first came on the show because for the past two years after no one had ever mentioned or seen her yet.

Therefore it turned into "She must be the Mom!"

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

I don't see it as an audible. I see at as the writers going seeing how many fans on the net have speculated that this was how it was going to go and therefore giving them a proverbial SLAP as if they lost a bet.

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

Perhaps it's the fact I watched this really late, but I laughed continuously throughout the episode. One of my favorite in the last few years.

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

I dont know... didnt they already establish the mother was Rachel Bilson's roommate? And given the age of Bilson in the show (looks to be at least in the mid to late 20's in that subway scene where she recommended the band to Ted), I just dont see how Barney's sister could be the mother.

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

Yeah, they already established the mother as being Bilson's roommate.

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

That didn't mean the roommate couldn't also have been Barney's sister. All the info we've been given on her up to this episode never disproved it.

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

Except that he dated Bilson, what, like 7 years ago? So she would have been living with a 13-year-old roommate back then? ;)

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

Well at least 17 since it was three years ago... but good point.

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

I totally laughed when she said she had only seen the prequels, because in my office there's a 22 year-old guy, and we were talking about Star Wars and he said he'd only seen the prequels. We were all aghast.

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

Does anyone really give a shit about who the "mom" ends up to be? Really? This is a great comedy and I don't really care about the titular character.

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

Whoa, whoa whoa.... I think we're throwing around the word "great" a little to casually here. ;)

And no, no one gives two shits about who it actually is, that's not the point. The show is stuck in a creative rut because they painted themselves into a corner with the show title(of course I doubt the creators predicted a 9 year run). Either meet the bitch and move on with them dating or end the show. Either way, 9 years of bullshit story after bullshit story that has nothing to do with meeting this chick is absurd. Apparently with another season we will be reaching 200 episodes of this gigantic butterfly effect story.

And yes I'm exaggerating to get the full effect. :)

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

Well put. :thumbsup:

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

Next season will be the show's last... we'll finally meet the mother!

http://insidetv.ew.com/2013/01/30/ho...-final-season/

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

How many other comedies have completed a 9-year run with the original creators and full original cast intact the entire time?

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

Seinfeld, Friends, Cheers (more or less).

That's some esteemed company.

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

Larry David left Seinfeld...

I hope the introduce the mother at the end of this season.

Re: How I Met Your Mother -- "Ring Up" -- 1/21/13
 

Cheers, no.

But I did find some other examples:

Everybody Loves Raymond
King of Queens