Stephen King's Under The Dome - Season 1 Discussion - CBS
#227
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
The third episode was a slight improvement on the awful second episode, but it is starting to look like just another lame summer show. I guess I was hoping for tighter plotting and less Jericho-like situations, the storyline with Junior should have been excised entirely from the show.
The show should have narrowed its audience focus from everyone possible to certain demos. There is way too much pandering here, spread out over all age groups and every possible identity group.
I will stick around, but I can see why CBS kept this as a summer show.
The show should have narrowed its audience focus from everyone possible to certain demos. There is way too much pandering here, spread out over all age groups and every possible identity group.
I will stick around, but I can see why CBS kept this as a summer show.
#228
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 1,917
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
And for goodness sake, if I'm down to my last few matches and will have no light, extraneous clothing is coming off to make a torch. It's not like it's the dead of winter there anyway as everyone walks around with their jackets open.
I'd much rather spend 1 minute each week reading the thread and watch it on DVD if it improves because so far it's a boring unenjoyable mess.
#229
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
I don't mind the fact that not everyone is freaking out yet for living under the dome. In Monday's episode they made a point to say only a day and a half had passed in show time. So the characters have only lived with this for two waking days.
That said, a LOT of this show wears on me. It feels so much like LOST...with everyone having deadly hidden motives, lots of secrets and not enough communication. I don't want to sit through hours of this without enough payoff.
The Junior storyline is about enough to make me stop watching. I want the girl he's captured either out of the bunker or dead by next episode please.
All that said, this would be SO much better if they took a Jericho approach where we see how they have to cope without food, water, etc. I think they're planning this, but they're not moving fast enough with it. Jericho started that in episode one.
That said, a LOT of this show wears on me. It feels so much like LOST...with everyone having deadly hidden motives, lots of secrets and not enough communication. I don't want to sit through hours of this without enough payoff.
The Junior storyline is about enough to make me stop watching. I want the girl he's captured either out of the bunker or dead by next episode please.
All that said, this would be SO much better if they took a Jericho approach where we see how they have to cope without food, water, etc. I think they're planning this, but they're not moving fast enough with it. Jericho started that in episode one.
#231
Member
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Canada
Posts: 199
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
+1 for the tired Junior storyline. Just finish it up already, and move on.
Why is it that every time we get a Stephen King television adaptation of one of his works someone tries to tinker with it, to make it more watchable? This could have been some spellbinding TV, but instead its just a hot mess of a show, with no clear plot line going forward.
Think I might just reread the book again. Some of my favourites from the book are not written into the show (yet?).
Why is it that every time we get a Stephen King television adaptation of one of his works someone tries to tinker with it, to make it more watchable? This could have been some spellbinding TV, but instead its just a hot mess of a show, with no clear plot line going forward.
Think I might just reread the book again. Some of my favourites from the book are not written into the show (yet?).
#233
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
Why is it that every time we get a Stephen King television adaptation of one of his works someone tries to tinker with it, to make it more watchable? This could have been some spellbinding TV, but instead its just a hot mess of a show, with no clear plot line going forward.
Think I might just reread the book again. Some of my favourites from the book are not written into the show (yet?).
Think I might just reread the book again. Some of my favourites from the book are not written into the show (yet?).
King also works in a lot of characters and elements in his works that aren't acceptable to the mainstream. It wasn't a shock when they left out the kids having sex plot in the It mini-series.
#234
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
I don't think King's densely plotted books with dozens of characters translate that well to movies and television, at least if you want to make commercial entertainment. The better adaptations have always been from his books with a tighter focus and a handful of primary characters. Sprawl works on the written page much better.
#235
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: B-more, Murdaland
Posts: 325
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
#236
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
I don't think King's densely plotted books with dozens of characters translate that well to movies and television, at least if you want to make commercial entertainment. The better adaptations have always been from his books with a tighter focus and a handful of primary characters. Sprawl works on the written page much better.
King also works in a lot of characters and elements in his works that aren't acceptable to the mainstream. It wasn't a shock when they left out the kids having sex plot in the It mini-series.
King also works in a lot of characters and elements in his works that aren't acceptable to the mainstream. It wasn't a shock when they left out the kids having sex plot in the It mini-series.
#237
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
What stops them from following the book this season and then branching out the next season? Different city and different people. I thought that would be the only way to keep it going.
#238
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
Watching the last match burn out while she had the perfectly flammable matchbox in her other hand (not to mention clothes and whatever else they had) was so stupid I'm out based on just that. Maybe I'll read the book someday once I can do so without any associations to the badly written/acted characters on this show.
#239
Moderator
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
I agree the third episode was marginally better than the second. I liked the shout out to The Simpsons movie (which I don't think was in the book), but that's about it.
#240
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
That would seriously be it. This concept for one town does not lend itself to several seasons.
#241
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
If you don't care for Junior
Spoiler:
#242
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
Watching the last match burn out while she had the perfectly flammable matchbox in her other hand (not to mention clothes and whatever else they had) was so stupid I'm out based on just that. Maybe I'll read the book someday once I can do so without any associations to the badly written/acted characters on this show.
#243
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
we don't know when gas will ever be available again? i know, i will drive to follow junior and then drive back, even though my entire world isn't bigger than the length of this town and i can walk. who wants to take a road trip to the other side of the dome?
#244
Moderator
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
+1 for the tired Junior storyline. Just finish it up already, and move on.
Why is it that every time we get a Stephen King television adaptation of one of his works someone tries to tinker with it, to make it more watchable? This could have been some spellbinding TV, but instead its just a hot mess of a show, with no clear plot line going forward.
Think I might just reread the book again. Some of my favourites from the book are not written into the show (yet?).
Why is it that every time we get a Stephen King television adaptation of one of his works someone tries to tinker with it, to make it more watchable? This could have been some spellbinding TV, but instead its just a hot mess of a show, with no clear plot line going forward.
Think I might just reread the book again. Some of my favourites from the book are not written into the show (yet?).
granted it's not King, but Spielberg had it right sense to produce a mini-series formatted show: Taken for the Sci-Fi Channel in 2002 - with a definite ending and set number of episodes (ten).
Last edited by Giles; 07-15-13 at 10:36 PM.
#245
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
I enjoyed tonight's episode more than last week's episode about teens searching for a way to charge their electronic devices, but that's not saying much since this show disappoints on many levels. Maybe the chained up girl will now get out of the bunker and that storyline can move on.
#246
DVD Talk God
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
Ditto. Thought this was a much better episode than the last 2 weeks. Even though it was meningitis, at least now the dome presented some kind of widespread threat to the town.
Also, Barbie kinda told the truth to Julia. At least she was finally smart enough to put 2 and 2 together after finding the map.
Are we finally moving away from Junior and Angie? Hmmm, wonder what Big Jim does? I would be really annoyed if he continues to keep Angie hostage to protect his kid.
Also, Barbie kinda told the truth to Julia. At least she was finally smart enough to put 2 and 2 together after finding the map.
Are we finally moving away from Junior and Angie? Hmmm, wonder what Big Jim does? I would be really annoyed if he continues to keep Angie hostage to protect his kid.
#248
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
I think I'm done with this now. It's not as adult or edgy as I would have preferred. I watched the first two eps. and now it's a chore.
I don't like feeling like watching and/or committing to a show is a 'chore'. Life's too short.
I don't like feeling like watching and/or committing to a show is a 'chore'. Life's too short.
#249
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
Hollywood always thinking their smarter than the source material
Spoiler:
#250
DVD Talk Hero
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: In the straps of boots
Posts: 27,997
Received 1,181 Likes
on
834 Posts
Re: Stephen King's Under The Dome - Spielberg Produced - CBS
Also, Barbie kinda told the truth to Julia. At least she was finally smart enough to put 2 and 2 together after finding the map.
Are we finally moving away from Junior and Angie? Hmmm, wonder what Big Jim does? I would be really annoyed if he continues to keep Angie hostage to protect his kid.
I told my wife that that storyline was WAY more fucked up in the book... but I wouldn't explain it to her. I told her she had to read it.