View Poll Results: Who do you think killed Rosie Larsen?
Nicole Jackson
0
0%
Michael Ames
0
0%
Voters: 16. You may not vote on this poll
The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
#51
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Waco, TX
Posts: 1,628
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
I've been defending this show from day 1. This was a very satisfying ending to me. The only thing I had a problem with was Richmond turning scummy at the end. But, it showed what kind of man he was all along. So, it WAS consistent with his character in that regard. I just didn't like it.
I have also agreed that the writing took huge leaps of faith to keep me going in the story. Terry had been struggling with something all through the series, but I agree she probably should have had more scenes of her breaking down.
If it comes back for a third season, it should be Holder and a new partner. And it should wrap up one mystery at the end of the season. That's probably all you could hope for. Maybe Linden comes in as a consultant at some point.
I have also agreed that the writing took huge leaps of faith to keep me going in the story. Terry had been struggling with something all through the series, but I agree she probably should have had more scenes of her breaking down.
If it comes back for a third season, it should be Holder and a new partner. And it should wrap up one mystery at the end of the season. That's probably all you could hope for. Maybe Linden comes in as a consultant at some point.
#52
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
I laughed when they police chief, captain, whatever told them that they "did good work", because they so did not!
#53
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
I liked the little video Rosey filmed, but I'd like to know who helped film it. In some of those shots someone else was holding the camera. Or did we know about this already?
#55
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
His tattooed hand appeared in another of Rosie's films, IIRC.
#56
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
Didn't they say they had to develop the film at the police station? But what we see was a fully edited movie. Am I correct that she was shooting with film? Why not use a video camera?
I can't remember but did they show the aunt having a connection to Ames prior to this episode?
I can't remember but did they show the aunt having a connection to Ames prior to this episode?
#57
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
Why couldn't she have had a mental condition (resulting from the stress of realizing she'd killed her sister's child) preventing her from dealing with it, until they realized what was going on and confronted her with it?
I think it's plausible, and was a pretty good ending to a series that was far too long.
I think it's plausible, and was a pretty good ending to a series that was far too long.
#58
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
I don't have a problem with Ames's mistress being the killer -- that works. But she's coincidentally Rosie's aunt? It's not like Seattle is a small town or something.
Also, I'm not sure why Ames is walking around free and hanging with the Mayor-elect. He's definitely an accessory to the murder. Even the Chief was an accessory after the fact, and she's living it up like nothing happened as well.
Also, I'm not sure why Ames is walking around free and hanging with the Mayor-elect. He's definitely an accessory to the murder. Even the Chief was an accessory after the fact, and she's living it up like nothing happened as well.
#59
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
#60
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
And they did have to send the film to the lab to be developed. It should've been raw and unedited - not like the version the Larson's watched. Did Linden decide to get creative with it before giving it to the Larsons?
#61
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Northern New Jersey...or as we say it "Sopranos Country USA"
Posts: 3,905
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
I had Jamie as the killer from the beginning...but adding in the sister was a nice touch.
As for the show as a whole, yeah it had problems. The writers made some strides in the right direction, should the show continue. But, I do want it to come back for a third season.
No idea what AMC is going to do. The ratings were pretty much the same, so I guess that is a positive.
As for the show as a whole, yeah it had problems. The writers made some strides in the right direction, should the show continue. But, I do want it to come back for a third season.
No idea what AMC is going to do. The ratings were pretty much the same, so I guess that is a positive.
#62
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Apr 2000
Location: Cincinnati, Ohio/Aguadilla, Puerto Rico
Posts: 10,201
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
I had Jamie as the killer from the beginning...but adding in the sister was a nice touch.
As for the show as a whole, yeah it had problems. The writers made some strides in the right direction, should the show continue. But, I do want it to come back for a third season.
No idea what AMC is going to do. The ratings were pretty much the same, so I guess that is a positive.
As for the show as a whole, yeah it had problems. The writers made some strides in the right direction, should the show continue. But, I do want it to come back for a third season.
No idea what AMC is going to do. The ratings were pretty much the same, so I guess that is a positive.
#63
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
I think it's a goner...there was not significant increase in viewership for the finale. Can't blame AMC for the show's demise though...it's all on the producers/writers...they had a potential hit on their hands and they went and pulled a "Twin Peaks" on us - promising to reveal the killer and then giving us a cliffhanger. This is one of the reasons "Revenge" is so popular over on ABC...it "rewards" its audience every six episodes or so with a resolution to an ongoing storyline.
#64
DVD Talk God
Thread Starter
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
It got a 0.5 and 1.4M viewers. It's doubtful that AMC will renew it. I'm fine with how the show ended. The main arc was resolved wth closure as all the characters storylines. Hopefully AMC will develop something good to replace it next Spring.
#65
Senior Member
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
Terry was an emotional mess for most of the series. How many times did we see her crying during the first season? She also freaked out about the boys playing in the trunk. Terry being the killer makes perfect sense. It's something the writers did not cheat on.
The killer or co-killer had to be someone involved in the Richmond campaign because there was no other point to that story if it wasn't tied in somehow. I figured it might be Jamie (but still hoped it was Gwen) when they had that scene in the locker room where he punches the guy from the other campaign. The scene added nothing to the plot so I figured it was a bit of foreshadowing. I don't know if I buy Jamie's involvement in the murder. While I think Terry was always going to be the killer, I wonder if the show was hedging its bets and decided to go with Jamie.
The show was a mess this season. I never cared they didn't reveal the killer last season, but the first two episodes this season were such a mess, and I think it was a big mistake to sideline Mitch for most of the season when Michelle Forbes is the show's best actor. The horrified look on Mitch's face during Terry's confession and "don't be mad at me" speech is something I'll never forget.
I really liked the last four episodes, and I grew to appreciate the Linden/Holder dynamic, but so much of the episodes this season felt like killing time or just annoying.
The killer or co-killer had to be someone involved in the Richmond campaign because there was no other point to that story if it wasn't tied in somehow. I figured it might be Jamie (but still hoped it was Gwen) when they had that scene in the locker room where he punches the guy from the other campaign. The scene added nothing to the plot so I figured it was a bit of foreshadowing. I don't know if I buy Jamie's involvement in the murder. While I think Terry was always going to be the killer, I wonder if the show was hedging its bets and decided to go with Jamie.
The show was a mess this season. I never cared they didn't reveal the killer last season, but the first two episodes this season were such a mess, and I think it was a big mistake to sideline Mitch for most of the season when Michelle Forbes is the show's best actor. The horrified look on Mitch's face during Terry's confession and "don't be mad at me" speech is something I'll never forget.
I really liked the last four episodes, and I grew to appreciate the Linden/Holder dynamic, but so much of the episodes this season felt like killing time or just annoying.
#67
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
#68
Senior Member
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
I do wonder if the show plays better in a marathon viewing because family members who watched all the episodes of the series over the weekend thought the show was fantastic. I never cared how long it took to solve the murder as long as the writing was first rate so I doubt a marathon viewing would have made much difference in my case.
#69
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
I don't see a renewal with those #s and AMC's penny pinching ways....
They screwed up big time, its like they never worked in TV before.. why coudn't they just have put those final couple of eps into last season and voila, good solid show with a solid ending..
what a mistake... you have to wrap up a murder plotline in a single season....
They screwed up big time, its like they never worked in TV before.. why coudn't they just have put those final couple of eps into last season and voila, good solid show with a solid ending..
what a mistake... you have to wrap up a murder plotline in a single season....
#70
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Bay Area, California
Posts: 8,939
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
I really liked the last two episodes. I felt the show sorta redeemed itself... Maybe even bumping up the average grade to a "B" for me.
#71
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
I just want to say my wife and I just finished watching the 20 episode Season 1 of the Danish show. Since the episodes were almost a full hour long, this was pretty close in running time to the 26 episode two seasons of the American series.
The Danish series is one of the best things I have seen on TV in many years. Trust me, it is far superior to the American show in every way: writing, directing, acting, the musical score, everything. It is fucking brilliant. Sofie Gråbøl puts Mireille Enos to shame (in all fairness, Gråbøl has much more to work with). Ditto for the rest of the cast. The American show is radically dumbed down and clumsily plotted. It's like the YA version. I'm not saying the Danish show is perfect (I thought it bogged down a little around Episodes 11-13, for example, but soon gained back all of its momentum and more) but it's pretty close. You simply will not believe many of the plot developments you will see on the Danish show and marvel at how superior they are to anything on the American show.
I can't wait to start on the 10 episode Season 2 which we will do in a day or two.
You can click on this and I promise it won't spoil anything:
Oh yeah, I got the British DVD version from Amazon UK:
http://www.amazon.co.uk/The-Killing-...0683484&sr=1-2
Although I'm pretty much a blu-ray person now, this DVD is extremely high quality. Of course, you will need a region free DVD player.
--------------------------------
Edit: Good article on how the American series went wrong (warning: contains spoilers for the Danish series; nothing crucial is revealed but some plot points are touched on):
http://www.thedailybeast.com/article...ent-wrong.html
The Danish series is one of the best things I have seen on TV in many years. Trust me, it is far superior to the American show in every way: writing, directing, acting, the musical score, everything. It is fucking brilliant. Sofie Gråbøl puts Mireille Enos to shame (in all fairness, Gråbøl has much more to work with). Ditto for the rest of the cast. The American show is radically dumbed down and clumsily plotted. It's like the YA version. I'm not saying the Danish show is perfect (I thought it bogged down a little around Episodes 11-13, for example, but soon gained back all of its momentum and more) but it's pretty close. You simply will not believe many of the plot developments you will see on the Danish show and marvel at how superior they are to anything on the American show.
I can't wait to start on the 10 episode Season 2 which we will do in a day or two.
You can click on this and I promise it won't spoil anything:
Spoiler:
Oh yeah, I got the British DVD version from Amazon UK:
http://www.amazon.co.uk/The-Killing-...0683484&sr=1-2
Although I'm pretty much a blu-ray person now, this DVD is extremely high quality. Of course, you will need a region free DVD player.
--------------------------------
Edit: Good article on how the American series went wrong (warning: contains spoilers for the Danish series; nothing crucial is revealed but some plot points are touched on):
http://www.thedailybeast.com/article...ent-wrong.html
Last edited by movielib; 07-28-12 at 09:01 AM.
#72
DVD Talk Hero
#73
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
#74
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
#75
Re: The Killing -- Season/Series? Finale -- "What I Know" -- 6/17/12
Lets hope not.