Shameless -- "A Great Cause" -- 3/18/12
#1
DVD Talk God
Thread Starter
Shameless -- "A Great Cause" -- 3/18/12
#4
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Shameless -- "A Great Cause" -- 3/18/12
Why not leave the mom's dumbass in jail?
#5
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2011
Posts: 747
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#6
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Shameless -- "A Great Cause" -- 3/18/12
The reveal that Mandy's dad is the father of her child was incredibly fucked up.
I feel bad for Fiona too. That scene at the end with Lip lashing out and her coming to the realization that she can't do what she wants to do was pretty sad.
I feel bad for Fiona too. That scene at the end with Lip lashing out and her coming to the realization that she can't do what she wants to do was pretty sad.
#7
#9
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Bay Area, California
Posts: 8,939
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Shameless -- "A Great Cause" -- 3/18/12
I have a question regarding the UK version. I really enjoy the US version and decided to give the UK one a shot, but after the first 20 minutes I discovered that it was basically identical. Not only were the scenes the same, but the dialog was often word for word with just the slang swapped out for the entire episode. Does that continue after the first episode or does it start to break away pretty quick? I recall The Office was pretty similar at first, but it quickly became it's own show.
I'm not too interested in just rewatching the show the with different actors, but if they move away from each other I'd be more interested in sticking with the UK one. Any thoughts? Thanks!
I'm not too interested in just rewatching the show the with different actors, but if they move away from each other I'd be more interested in sticking with the UK one. Any thoughts? Thanks!
#10
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: Texas
Posts: 467
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Shameless -- "A Great Cause" -- 3/18/12
I watched the first 6 seasons of the U.k. version and while the first season does follow alot of what happened in the u.k. series the rest is really different. The second season is pretty much all original. it's like the office. Season one was exactly identical to the british version but the rest was all original.
#11
DVD Talk God
Thread Starter
Re: Shameless -- "A Great Cause" -- 3/18/12
Felt really bad for Fiona at the end. Was kind of hoping she was grab her Mom out of the bed and throw her ass out.
Why didn't Fiona just hide the money in her room or better yet, open a savings account?
Lip shouldn't have bailed her out and wasted what was left of their winter funds.
The whole incest reveal with Mandy was beyond fucked up.
at the Mexicans in the truck screwing around with Frank.
at Sheila being unable to resist Jody's seduction.
at Estefania's boyfriend being locked up and lost in the shipping container and threatening to kill Steve.
Why didn't Fiona just hide the money in her room or better yet, open a savings account?
Lip shouldn't have bailed her out and wasted what was left of their winter funds.
The whole incest reveal with Mandy was beyond fucked up.
at the Mexicans in the truck screwing around with Frank.
at Sheila being unable to resist Jody's seduction.
at Estefania's boyfriend being locked up and lost in the shipping container and threatening to kill Steve.
#12
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Shameless -- "A Great Cause" -- 3/18/12
You feel bad for Fiona, but the writers make her character too fucking stupid.
Hide the fucking money better! Coffee can in the kitchen? Really? With Frank around?
She's had enough of her mother I assume, but she still lets Frank off the hook? Frank may not have known exactly where the money came from, but he's still an accomplice... and where ever he is, trouble manages to find him.
At this point Frank should be out of the house for good. No excuses, but Fiona is a moron so nothing will happen to him.
Lip shouldn't have bailed her out and wasted what was left of their winter funds.
#13
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Shameless -- "A Great Cause" -- 3/18/12
Did Lip forget that he spoke Italian the last episode? He had to go get an instant Portuguese translator for her phone call, but can understand her now when she is threatening Steve?
And Finona needed to bitch slap Lip and tell him she might not be able to do what she wants, but it is because of her fucking siblings and that means he can go back to school or take over for her so she can.
And Finona needed to bitch slap Lip and tell him she might not be able to do what she wants, but it is because of her fucking siblings and that means he can go back to school or take over for her so she can.
#14
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: Shameless -- "A Great Cause" -- 3/18/12
I work with poor people who receive large sums of money every day. We often recommend opening a bank account, or at the very least going to our bank to cash the check without fees. But invariably we get a call an hour or two later where people are trying to cash 4 and 5 figure checks at a local checks cashed store and losing 3-4%.
It just doesn't enter their thought process. They don't know how to deal with saving. You'd think Fiona would be smarter than that, but I say the same thing about a lot of people we deal with.
It just doesn't enter their thought process. They don't know how to deal with saving. You'd think Fiona would be smarter than that, but I say the same thing about a lot of people we deal with.
#16
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Shameless -- "A Great Cause" -- 3/18/12
I fucking hate Frank. He's the most despicable character I've ever seen. And now the mom is back in the picture? Just as equally despicable. I wish the show was just about the kids surviving on their own, and get rid of Frank.
#17
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Shameless -- "A Great Cause" -- 3/18/12
Really enjoyed Frank being at Shiela's and the mom away with Bob. I like Frank around, but not in the house.
#18
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Shameless -- "A Great Cause" -- 3/18/12
Lip only understands certain words that are similar between the two languages. He must have recognized a word in the last episode and wanted to see exactly what the conversation was about. He didn't understand everything she was saying. During the argument he was only picking up on certain words as well.
#21
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Formerly known as Groucho AND Bandoman/Death Moans, Iowa
Posts: 18,295
Received 372 Likes
on
266 Posts
Re: Shameless -- "A Great Cause" -- 3/18/12
Didn't she tell Lip he wasn't the only possible dad? I assume she was hitting up every guy she had slept with in the last six months or so to score some cash.
#22
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Shameless -- "A Great Cause" -- 3/18/12
She's a scumbag. She asked him for abortion money but obviously didn't get one. She was just extorting the guy for money.
That said, it's very possible Lip isn't the father and this is the kind of show to pull off such a Deus Ex Machina and have the baby be black. Everything goes back to normal in the end.
However, I can also see the clear cut ending where it is Lips baby and they give it up for adoption. Lip is distraught about it but realizes that it needs to happen because he can't support a kid. This leads to the epiphany that he should be in college. It would bring his story line this season full circle.
That said, it's very possible Lip isn't the father and this is the kind of show to pull off such a Deus Ex Machina and have the baby be black. Everything goes back to normal in the end.
However, I can also see the clear cut ending where it is Lips baby and they give it up for adoption. Lip is distraught about it but realizes that it needs to happen because he can't support a kid. This leads to the epiphany that he should be in college. It would bring his story line this season full circle.
#23
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Shameless -- "A Great Cause" -- 3/18/12
She's a scumbag. She asked him for abortion money but obviously didn't get one. She was just extorting the guy for money.
That said, it's very possible Lip isn't the father and this is the kind of show to pull off such a Deus Ex Machina and have the baby be black. Everything goes back to normal in the end.
That said, it's very possible Lip isn't the father and this is the kind of show to pull off such a Deus Ex Machina and have the baby be black. Everything goes back to normal in the end.
#24
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Shameless -- "A Great Cause" -- 3/18/12
So I assume Marco was left to die in the shipping container...or will we get a resolution in the next episode. When they starting yelling Marco in the shipyard, I expected one of them to start yelling "Marco...Polo."
#25
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Socal
Posts: 4,137
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Shameless -- "A Great Cause" -- 3/18/12
Frank says it in the first couple of minutes of the pilot episode where he is describing the his family; since it was in the actual episode I would consider it cannon. Also, I wouldn't be surprised if Frank had attended AA, especially since it was when his wife was still around - but just because he attended doesn't mean he participated.