Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
#51
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Aug 2010
Posts: 2,080
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
I used to be a huge Kevin Smith fan (see the username) but I've definitely lost most of my love for him. For whatever reason the change started to happen around the time he was doing Green Arrow. I got the first three issues or so but apparently that's when I went from "must see/read/own everything he touches" to not really giving a crap. I never saw "Jersey Girl" in theaters. I only saw "Cop Out" at the dollar theater. I still haven't seen "Red State". "Zack and Miri" was OK but it was like he knew Apatow was doing his thing better and he was desperately trying to catch up.
I've outgrown him but I actually think he's become underrated and unfairly-bashed. I don't really listen to his podcasts but I've enjoyed the ones I've listened to, not to mention his Q&A/standup stuff. He's a funny and likeable guy and for the most part his friends are too.
I watched this show last night and I think the staged stuff seemed a little more organic than similar shows. These guys are lifelong friends as opposed to people put together by a casting agent and it showed.
I've outgrown him but I actually think he's become underrated and unfairly-bashed. I don't really listen to his podcasts but I've enjoyed the ones I've listened to, not to mention his Q&A/standup stuff. He's a funny and likeable guy and for the most part his friends are too.
I watched this show last night and I think the staged stuff seemed a little more organic than similar shows. These guys are lifelong friends as opposed to people put together by a casting agent and it showed.
#52
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
I'm SHOCKED anyone like this. I've been a fan of Kevin Smith since Clerks, but lately the guy has just failed. This was like watching a very poor man's Pawn Stars. I didn't think it was possible to make the cast of that show likable. I stand corrected universe. I didn't get the sense that these guys knew much about anything.
The scenes in the studio as they were recording the podcast were OK, but the stuff inside the store was awful. Being a fan of Smith and a big comic book geek I thought this would be watchable at very worst. Boy was I wrong.
The scenes in the studio as they were recording the podcast were OK, but the stuff inside the store was awful. Being a fan of Smith and a big comic book geek I thought this would be watchable at very worst. Boy was I wrong.
#53
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
#54
Suspended
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
I caught the last half of the show with my wife and we both dug it as mindless popcorn TV. Lately, when there's nothing else to watch, we've been putting on Pawn Stars or Storage Wars or Shipping Wars or American Pickers, and this scratches that same itch.
#55
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
I'm not really a fan of this type of show, but the first episode was interesting enough to keep me tuning in.
#56
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
Is hating Kevin Smith the new "in vogue" thing? I've been disappointed by some of his recent work, but I don't think the guy's a sell out or anything like that. I do still think he's passionate about the work he does, whether it "clicks" with his fans or not.
#57
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
I've got one friend who goes to ridiculous lengths to bash everything Smith does. He even manages to work a Smith dis into reviews for movies having nothing to do with him.
#58
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#59
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
His work has lacked... something the last five or six years. I don't know if its ego. I don't know if it's because he's become a pot head. But his work just doesn't hit the mark with me. I guess there's also the chance I've matured, but I still find his old stuff great.
I've read interviews with the guy where he just seems mean these days. I continue to at least be fan enough that I sample whatever he puts out there, but I'm just not enjoying it much anymore. I wouldn't call it passionless, but I would maybe call it direction-less.
#60
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
I don't know that dick and fart jokes are ever "quality work," but there was certainly a certain charm to most of what Smith did in the first half of his career. There's not denying that the guy was funny and charismatic, something very evident in his live performances.
His work has lacked... something the last five or six years. I don't know if its ego. I don't know if it's because he's become a pot head. But his work just doesn't hit the mark with me. I guess there's also the chance I've matured, but I still find his old stuff great.
I've read interviews with the guy where he just seems mean these days. I continue to at least be fan enough that I sample whatever he puts out there, but I'm just not enjoying it much anymore. I wouldn't call it passionless, but I would maybe call it direction-less.
His work has lacked... something the last five or six years. I don't know if its ego. I don't know if it's because he's become a pot head. But his work just doesn't hit the mark with me. I guess there's also the chance I've matured, but I still find his old stuff great.
I've read interviews with the guy where he just seems mean these days. I continue to at least be fan enough that I sample whatever he puts out there, but I'm just not enjoying it much anymore. I wouldn't call it passionless, but I would maybe call it direction-less.
#61
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
And if someone is holding onto something valuable, they're going to sell it on eBay or Craigslist and not take it into a comic book shop for a fraction of what they can get for it elsewhere.
#62
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
It might help the show and the comicbook industry in general, if the producers find some teens and kids to play customers.
Another neat idea, would be having guys like Larsen and Kirkman to stop in and talk about the books and characters they have work on over the years.
Another neat idea, would be having guys like Larsen and Kirkman to stop in and talk about the books and characters they have work on over the years.
#63
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
It might help the show and the comicbook industry in general, if the producers find some teens and kids to play customers.
Another neat idea, would be having guys like Larsen and Kirkman to stop in and talk about the books and characters they have work on over the years.
Another neat idea, would be having guys like Larsen and Kirkman to stop in and talk about the books and characters they have work on over the years.
on the plus side i find the guys likable which is amazing as i generally cant stand most workers at comic book stores. im not a hardcore comic fan but drop 50$ or so every so often when i get in a comic/toy mode and i drive by 2 stores to a third one because its the only store with a people person owning it.
#64
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
Cinema in it's present state NEEDS more unique voices-- whether or not they can compose a shot.
#65
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: online!
Posts: 983
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
Although I've been lax in catching his later stuff the work of Todd Solondz reminds me of John Waters much more.
#66
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Southside Virginia
Posts: 6,457
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
KS does film work these days? I thought he "retired" after Red State to run a podcast network.
#67
Banned
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
I did like Smith's appearance of Talking Dead, and I do like his live storytelling abilities and willingness to take questions and answer forthrightly in a 'concert' setting even when I don't always appreciate some of his vulgarity.
Wish he'd concentrate on writing for a while and quit trying to be a "persona". I wear comfy clothes (jerseys, sweats, shorts) most of the time, too, but I do change every month or two.
#68
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Land of the Lobstrosities
Posts: 10,300
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
I know I said the podcast they record on the show was fake, and I was wondering why the didn't just do some cross promotion and actually put it out. Well, it turns out they did. I looked for it but missed it. I blame Ming for his shitty web design.
I haven't listened yet so I don't know if it's the conversations from the show uncut or just a companion pod.
He's making one more movie. It's called "Hit Somebody" (I think) and it will be about hockey.
I listen a few of the podcasts, but I don't listen to the live radio "SIR" network. I know when it launched he was doing like 4+ hours a day live. Two hours in the morning with his wife and then another two with Jason Mews. I think he cut way back since then though.
I haven't listened yet so I don't know if it's the conversations from the show uncut or just a companion pod.
I listen a few of the podcasts, but I don't listen to the live radio "SIR" network. I know when it launched he was doing like 4+ hours a day live. Two hours in the morning with his wife and then another two with Jason Mews. I think he cut way back since then though.
#69
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
Watched it last night. Not bad, but not a home run either. I couldn't get into the "it couldn't be more obvious we staged this" scenes with people selling shit. Toy Hunters on the Travel Channel was 1000% more entertaining in that regard. That guy knew his shit. The show really needed some customers to shoot the shit.
I did like the podcast segments. They seemed to balance out the show and gives it a unique flavor compared to all the other shows out there. I also liked the interstitials between segments talking about an item, comic info, etc.
I also found it quite ironic Brian blasting the flea market crowd as people that aren't allowed in a mall. Has he looked in a mirror lately? Dude looks like a homeless stray wondering where he's going to find his next meal.
Also at all the Walking Dead figures on the checkout counter so it's in frame when the camera shows the staff and a shelf full of Walking Dead comics on the wall behind the customer when the camera is on them. Well played AMC, well played.
Like many, I have kinda have lost my taste for Smith but I liked him quite a bit more here in more of a neutered "can't rely on sucking cock shtick" role.
I did like the podcast segments. They seemed to balance out the show and gives it a unique flavor compared to all the other shows out there. I also liked the interstitials between segments talking about an item, comic info, etc.
I also found it quite ironic Brian blasting the flea market crowd as people that aren't allowed in a mall. Has he looked in a mirror lately? Dude looks like a homeless stray wondering where he's going to find his next meal.
Also at all the Walking Dead figures on the checkout counter so it's in frame when the camera shows the staff and a shelf full of Walking Dead comics on the wall behind the customer when the camera is on them. Well played AMC, well played.
Like many, I have kinda have lost my taste for Smith but I liked him quite a bit more here in more of a neutered "can't rely on sucking cock shtick" role.
#70
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#71
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
I watched it and was entertained. I'm not sure what I expected, but the whole "Pawn Stars" aspect of it didn't really appeal to me. I'll probably tune in again, since I don't have much going on Sunday nights.
#72
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
It's okay as background tv... something to have on while you cook dinner, pick up around the house, etc. But that's how I feel about all these sorts of shows -- Storage Wars, Oddities, and so on.
#73
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: Guelph, Ontario
Posts: 9,921
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
I like Kevin Smith and Comics but life is too damn short to spend hours watching shows like this IMO - there are too many quality scripted shows and if I was dying to see exchanges like this, I could literally just go down and hang out at the local comic shop. Out.
#74
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
In their defense, Walking Dead is huge. It's one of the top-selling titles in single comics and graphic novels, and it has a lot of cross-over appeal, so any decent comic store is going to have WD stuff prominently displayed.
#75
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Southside Virginia
Posts: 6,457
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
I'm not sure if he's a worse director or editor, but he's not great at either. It's one thing to write a movie and direct it (and maybe even edit it) without the best skills. I think what pissed Bruce Willis off so much about Cop Out was that Smith didn't even know how to choose a lens for a shot and was there as the DIRECTOR on something he didn't even write. That is pretty fucking outrageous.
By the way, the only way I know Willis was pissed is that I heard it out of Kevin's mouth at a live event in DC. The way he explained it was clearly the tilted toward Kevin Smith version of what happened, but even in it Willis comes off as mostly a guy who was just pissed he somehow got talked into a shit movie with a director barely above amateur status.
I'm no pot smoking expert. Maybe Kevin doesn't need to cut out the ganja. I do think he needs to take a step back and figure out what he does well and poorly in life and move his work in the direction of the good stuff. I'd really love to see his take on a cable TV show, preferably a drama.
By the way, the only way I know Willis was pissed is that I heard it out of Kevin's mouth at a live event in DC. The way he explained it was clearly the tilted toward Kevin Smith version of what happened, but even in it Willis comes off as mostly a guy who was just pissed he somehow got talked into a shit movie with a director barely above amateur status.
I'm no pot smoking expert. Maybe Kevin doesn't need to cut out the ganja. I do think he needs to take a step back and figure out what he does well and poorly in life and move his work in the direction of the good stuff. I'd really love to see his take on a cable TV show, preferably a drama.