DJariya

By djariya at 2011-05-04


Wednesday: 90 minute performance show. Contestants are performing 2 songs. One modern and One oldie

Thursday: 1 hour results show.

SexualPudding

My pick before anyone sings: Haley. I hope it's Jacob but I think he'll hang on for one more week.

MikahC

I was thinking Jacob. Haley has really been coming on in both performances and the votes. Casey is begging his fans to vote for her. I'm happy that Jacob made it this far. I got a few good performances out of him, and that's all I can really ask for (he's not winning material).

DJariya

I see we have 2 trigger happy voters in the poll once again.

arminius

Bastards

SexualPudding

I'd like to think that Haley has seen an uptick in votes but I'm really not so sure. Remember, they had Scotty as one of the "bottom 3" last week- not because he actually was one, but because either his votes were starting to decline and they wanted to get him some sympathy, or because they wanted to give Haley a break from being trotted out there in the bottom 3 again.

I'll agree that she has really stepped up her performances recently, but it often does not matter.

mwbmis

Well, Haley has gotten a lot of endorsements lately (Lambert, Kris Allen, Kelly Clarkson, and Casey has been plugging her since he got voted off). I'd love to see her stick around, but I can't see her cracking the top 3. I just hope she lasts till next week.

Howiefan

I think it's bullshit that the judges bashed Hailey when she had the best vocals so far...

Rypro 525

I did kinda laugh that Randy said of You and I "its not that good a song anyways" when thats prob the only rendition of the song he's heard

GuessWho

Lucky bastard

starman9000

Based on tonight, I think Scotty should go home (whenever he gets out of the super low almost caricature country, he is so awful). I think Jacob will go and was a close second in being bad for me.

I give Haley credit, I thought shed be gone a while ago, but she's actually grown. Sadly, she still has some Casey growly issues, but when she's on she's on.

Tonight was James' worst night. The 3 guys should all be in the bottom.

magiccmom

Lauren always stops short of amazing for me. I never think she takes the songs all the way where it needs to go.

I think it is Jacob's week to go, but I have been thinking that for about 6 weeks now, so who knows.?

astrochimp

Glad it wasn't just me that thought that. I've liked him so far but i didn't like his first song at all. Didn't make it back from hockey to see anything else tonight.

mgbfan

Sporadic watcher of the show here. Haley was outstanding. Holy balls, that girl just looks and sings sexy. I didn't get the love for James. I love his taste in music - Muse and 30 Seconds to Mars have been two of my favorite bands for years, but he completely butchered both songs. And crying during your other song tonight doesn't make it a great song. These judges are so easily manipulated.

Otherwise, I think Scott is just obnoxious. Jacob seems like little more than the punch line to a joke I don't get. The blonde is pretty good.

Iron_Giant

Please get Jacob voted off, glad he has had this chance, but it is time to leave.

chowderhead

I bet he has. Jacob is going home tomorrow.

DarthVong

Jacob, Scotty and James will be in the bottom 3 with Jacob going home.

SexualPudding

I think it will be Jacob, Haley, and James in the bottom 3 with Jacob going home. Good God I cannot stand to listen to that guy. Everything has to be so over the top with the vocal gymnastic bullshit. I've heard cats die more gracefully than that noise.

freshticles

Fuck, I'm one song in, and I'm done with this show. what a joke. James just blew the shit out of a song that shouldn't be that hard because it was written by an extremely untalented actor who's an even worse musician. Seriously, the worst most out of tune, all over the place vocals I've ever heard on this show and the judges PRAISE it? Incredible.

Joeboo835

He's in it to win it

writer106

I agree with you on Scotty and that description. I hope Jacob goes home. I hope Scotty doesn't make it the top 3.

Howiefan

Scotty has been crowned the winner a long time ago unfortunately.

Goat3001

Here's how I think America would vote... favorite to least favorite:

Scotty
Lauren
James
Haley
Jacob

Here are my favorites:

Pia
James
Haley
Scotty
Lauren
Jacob

mgbfan

30 Seconds to Mars is one of the best progressive rock bands out there. This Is War is probably one of my top-ten desert island records. But it's not for everyone, I'll agree to that.

In any event, James butchered it.

SkullOrchard

@ Jacob's way-the-fuck-over-the-top swan song. He was still hollering as the show ended. Just horrible.