DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/590020-killing-super-8-4-24-11-a.html)

DJariya 04-24-11 01:28 PM

The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 
<img src="http://img269.imageshack.us/img269/8625/thekilling3.jpg" alt="Image Hosted by ImageShack.us"/><br/>By <a target="_new" href="http://profile.imageshack.us/user/djariya">djariya</a> at 2011-04-03

Synopsis:

Spoiler:
One of Rosie's teachers provides Sarah and Holder with crucial new evidence. Meanwhile, the Richmond campaign comes up with an anticrime TV spot; and Stan steps up his search for Rosie's killer and enlists Belko's help.


Day 5 of 13

Promo:

<iframe title="YouTube video player" width="480" height="390" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/1U3oLCgvNQw" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

PopcornTreeCt 04-24-11 10:00 PM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 
Hmm...

Still looks like Bennett.

joefrog91 04-24-11 10:12 PM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 
This show is so good. I see AMC has several things on their site to help guess the killer, but I'm going to just watch the shows to try and figure it out. This reminds me of trying to figure out who killed Laura Palmer. Every show has to be watched with a keen eye to see what's being presented.

Anubis2005X 04-24-11 10:36 PM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 
I kinda wish I didn't have to wait a week between each episode...

valkyrie 04-24-11 11:45 PM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 

Originally Posted by Anubis2005X (Post 10740442)
I kinda wish I didn't have to wait a week between each episode...

No kidding, this weekend I watched e01 to e04 back-to-back, then caught tonight's episode live. Now, it kills me that I have to wait 7 days for the next one. :)

mwbmis 04-25-11 01:26 AM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 
Since he clearly can't be the killer at this point, it looks like Bennett might be the red herring suspect that gets arrested.

MrX 04-25-11 01:32 AM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 
Damn, Bennett married Chrissy Seaver:lol:

JumpCutz 04-25-11 02:13 AM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 
Love this show. It's absolutely hypnotic.

DJariya 04-25-11 03:39 AM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 
Good episode, but I think it focused a little too much on Darren's campaign than the murder investigation. I'm not sure I get what Darren and Jaime are trying to do other than Jaime being his mole.

Not surprised to see Stan finally break down and have a moment to mourn. Being the man of the house, I know he was trying to stay strong for Mitch and his 2 sons.

Sarah's partner Holder is looking more sleazier as the weeks go by. What was up with him counting all that cash and then dropping it off at some mystery house?

As far as Bennett goes, there still isn't really any concrete evidence against him. Okay, so he has some cleaner in his house from working on it. That's just a fluke coincidence IMO. Also, he dated and married a slightly younger woman. So what? He's definitely a Red Herring.

dalbowski 04-25-11 05:15 AM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 

Originally Posted by DJariya (Post 10740656)
Sarah's partner Holder is looking more sleazier as the weeks go by. What was up with him counting all that cash and then dropping it off at some mystery house?

Ex/separated wife? It also looked like there were children running in the house. So I'm thinking she left him because she didn't like the "narc" life or wanted its influence with their children.

I also figured that it tied in with the celibacy comment.

Cusm 04-25-11 08:35 AM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 

Originally Posted by dalbowski (Post 10740670)
Ex/separated wife? It also looked like there were children running in the house. So I'm thinking she left him because she didn't like the "narc" life or wanted its influence with their children.

I also figured that it tied in with the celibacy comment.

I kinda figured he stepped out, and got kicked out and that is why he is celibate.

Cory02 04-25-11 11:55 AM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 
I think Bennett is a red herring because there are still too many episodes left for them to be identifying the killer. I was a bit surprised that they didn't rule him out in this episode; I was expecting them to move on to another red herring.

I still don't like Holder. So far, I don't see anything that shows me he deserved a promotion to homicide.

Anubis2005X 04-25-11 12:57 PM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 
Hmm, new suspect, Darren Richmond, mastermind...

Coral 04-25-11 07:33 PM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 
This show seems to be following a formula. Show someone who looks very suspicious under circumstances that could be damning, then provide an explanation that gets them off the hook. It's almost like a fake-out plot-twist every episode. Eventually when they get to the last episode, they'll find something on someone that will actually stick. If they continue with this formula, it'll be like basketball where you'll only need to watch the last 2 minutes of the game.

Also, it seems like every character is hiding something (related to the murder or not).

valkyrie 04-25-11 08:06 PM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 

Originally Posted by Coral (Post 10741751)
This show seems to be following a formula. Show someone who looks very suspicious under circumstances that could be damning, then provide an explanation that gets them off the hook. It's almost like a fake-out plot-twist every episode. Eventually when they get to the last episode, they'll find something on someone that will actually stick. If they continue with this formula, it'll be like basketball where you'll only need to watch the last 2 minutes of the game.

Sure, and you can turn to the end of the book and read the last 2 pages, but the journey is the thing, right? I love the slow movements toward finding out just what really happened. I'm hooked, completely.


Also, it seems like every character is hiding something (related to the murder or not).
Absolutely. I think this is the best part. EVERYONE has secrets. Put anyone under the microscope, and you'll find something. ;) The question is...is it relevant to the murder?

Cory02 04-25-11 08:24 PM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 
From an interview with Exec Producer Veena Sud in Entertainment Weekly a few weeks ago:


What can you tease about the rest of the season going forward?

One thing we’ll be seeing is that every single one of our characters has our secrets. Under the microscope of a murder investigation, no one’s secret remains safe. That includes the family, Sarah Linden, Darren Richmond, and that includes the victim. One of the big questions we’re gonna start thinking about as the series progresses is: How well do you ever really know anybody? You think you know your wife. You think you know your best friend. You think you know your child. But do you really?

lordwow 04-25-11 09:14 PM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 
I am wondering why Sarah's fiance keeps hinting at about this happening again with Sarah's obsession with the murder.

Dave99 04-25-11 10:43 PM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 

Originally Posted by lordwow (Post 10741922)
I am wondering why Sarah's fiance keeps hinting at about this happening again with Sarah's obsession with the murder.

Didn't her boss make a similar comment? I'm guessing she cracked at some point and had a breakdown.

slop101 04-25-11 10:45 PM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 
So are the parent's broken up by their daughter's death? It's hard to tell...

Seriously though, besides being redundant as hell, every scene with the family slows the show to a fucking crawl, and it's not exactly fast-paced to begin with.

valkyrie 04-25-11 10:55 PM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 

Originally Posted by slop101 (Post 10742079)
So are the parent's broken up by their daughter's death? It's hard to tell...

Seriously though, besides being redundant as hell, every scene with the family slows the show to a fucking crawl, and it's not exactly fast-paced to begin with.

Really? Do you have ADD or something? J/K, but honestly, if you want fast-paced, watch a serial action show. This story would typically be told as a 2-hour movie, but is told in 10 hours so that you get to know the characters inside and out. I think every scene has given the characters depth in a way that few shows can really pull off. I'm impressed as hell and I hope the typical on-demand audience can appreciate it. Sounds like it might not be your cup of tea, but it is mine.

DJariya 04-25-11 11:03 PM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 

Originally Posted by slop101 (Post 10742079)
So are the parent's broken up by their daughter's death? It's hard to tell...

Did you not see the scene in this episode where Stan went into the restroom and broke down crying for 2 minutes?

Mitch has been a wreck. She's spent alot of time sleeping and locked up in her room.

valkyrie 04-25-11 11:28 PM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 

Originally Posted by DJariya (Post 10742112)
Did you not see the scene in this episode where Stan went into the restroom and broke down crying for 2 minutes?

Mitch has been a wreck. She's spent alot of time sleeping and locked up in her room.

I would wager your sarcasm filter may be working too well. ;)

coladar 04-25-11 11:50 PM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 
I said it yesterday, my thoughts about it being Sarah's fiancee, in last weeks episode thread, but I had not watched this episode yet. Now I have, and I'm more convinced they are going to go with him as the killer, and that's just so stupid and poor, cheap writing... From this episode, the clue seemed to be when she was watching the movie. It seemed awfully odd, him standing there, watching her watch the movie through the door's window. The expression on his face toward the end? Odder. Then I think he made some comment about her putting the movie on her wall like last time, which, how would he know that it was a movie Rosie made? I think he was the one that filmed the scenes with Rosie.

I hope to goodness I am wrong. I just think it is awful, awful, awful writing to have it be the detectives fiancee no matter what they reveal. Like I said the night the pilot aired, the teacher makes sense. He should be the killer, IMO. And it would have worked perfectly if they'd revealed all this crap, the wife being a student, everything, the second to last episode. They didn't, so clearly it won't be him. It's way too early to reveal this much this early, they have to get him off next week or else they'll just drop it and focus on someone else until the end, when all this gets picked back up, which might be just as bad writing wise as having it be the fiancée.

Right now, I want to love this show, but I'm afraid its going to turn out to be a poorly written mess. It's following the formula someone mentioned above, reveal massive clues about someone, red herring, point the finger, then some magic explanation comes up and move on to suspects 2-2,000. That's just not good writing for this type of a show. Harper's Island had it's faults, plenty of them, but it did it right in that regard. All the clues were there from the start, and they didn't do the "new suspect every week" crap this show seems like it wants to do.

DJariya 04-26-11 12:01 AM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 
Here's the latest breakdown on who fans think the killer is:

http://suspecttracker.amctv.com/breakdown.php

slop101 04-26-11 12:07 AM

Re: The Killing -- "Super 8" -- 4/24/11
 

Originally Posted by DJariya (Post 10742112)
Did you not see the scene in this episode where Stan went into the restroom and broke down crying for 2 minutes?

Mitch has been a wreck. She's spent alot of time sleeping and locked up in her room.

You need one of these:



Originally Posted by valkyrie (Post 10742097)
Really? Do you have ADD or something? J/K, but honestly, if you want fast-paced, watch a serial action show. This story would typically be told as a 2-hour movie, but is told in 10 hours so that you get to know the characters inside and out. I think every scene has given the characters depth in a way that few shows can really pull off. I'm impressed as hell and I hope the typical on-demand audience can appreciate it. Sounds like it might not be your cup of tea, but it is mine.

Wasn't asking for a fast-paced show and I enjoy the rest of the show, I just don't like the scenes with the parents, especially since after 5 similar scenes, it gets more than a little redundant, and really drags the rest of the show down. This isn't depth, it's bad editing.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:18 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.