DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns) (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/579402-andy-whitfield-forced-quit-spartacus-cancer-returns.html)

DJariya 10-04-10 04:13 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 
http://ausiellofiles.ew.com/2010/10/...d-with-recast/

It's official....Starz is recasting Spartacus. They have already started a search.

Key thing mentioned in this article is the actor must be prepared to sign a "3-year contract"

That pretty much rules out Whitfield playing the role ever again if he does get better.

Dr. DVD 10-04-10 04:27 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 

Originally Posted by DJariya (Post 10410764)
http://ausiellofiles.ew.com/2010/10/...d-with-recast/

It's official....Starz is recasting Spartacus. They have already started a search.

Key thing mentioned in this article is the actor must be prepared to sign a "3-year contract"

That pretty much rules out Whitfield playing the role ever again if he does get better.

Sucks for Whitfield. Maybe the new Spartacus will have facial hair to hide the obvious difference? Doesn't matter, doubt it will be the same or seem the same. Only way it might make sense is to warp ahead a few years and cast an older actor, but I don't think there was much of a time gap between the revolt and the formation of armies in history.

Geofferson 10-04-10 04:30 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 
In the article, Ausiello goes on to say that Grant Bowler has a resemblance. Curious to see how Starz re-casts this...

Bowler
http://t0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:A...gMeYA0iwrqwhk=

redrum 10-04-10 05:19 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 
why would they make the new guy sign a 3 year contract?

they better get someone awesome or this show will fail, i dunno if i even care to watch it without Andy coming back

DJariya 10-04-10 05:29 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 

Originally Posted by redrum (Post 10410917)
why would they make the new guy sign a 3 year contract?

they better get someone awesome or this show will fail, i dunno if i even care to watch it without Andy coming back

It doesn't neccessarily mean that Spartacus will last 3 more seasons. It's basically so that the producers can retain his services for 3 seasons should the show last that long. The broadcast networks sign their talent to 7 year contracts for new shows.

zuffy 10-05-10 03:07 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 

Originally Posted by redrum (Post 10410917)
they better get someone awesome or this show will fail, i dunno if i even care to watch it without Andy coming back

Sure Andy was good but I don't think he's the only person carrying the show. The other casts and storyline sold for me, not just Andy.

arminius 10-05-10 03:23 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 

Originally Posted by zuffy (Post 10412807)
Sure Andy was good but I don't think he's the only person carrying the show. The other casts and storyline sold for me, not just Andy.

I agree, though I really think it sucks that he cannot return to the role. He was very good in it.

redrum 10-05-10 05:17 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 
the violence and tits carry this show but Andy was awesome

mwbmis 10-05-10 06:33 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 
Like I mentioned earlier in the thread, Viva Bianca isn't going anywhere so I'm good.

mike7162 10-05-10 07:30 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 
Every time I click on this thread, I expect to hear the worst about Andy, but Spartacus or not, I hope he recovers

stingermck 10-14-10 06:14 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 

Exclusive: Wentworth Miller eyeing 'Spartacus'?
by Michael Ausiello and Andy Patrick
Categories: News, Scoop, Spartacus

Wentworth-Miller-Andy-WhitfieldImage Credit: C. Hodes/FoxI’m hearing ex-Prison Break con Wentworth Miller has expressed interest in taking over the title role in Spartacus: Blood and Sand.

As I reported last week, the Starz series — which briefly considered “closing up shop” after leading man Andy Whitfield dropped out to resume treatment for his Non-Hodgkin lymphoma — is moving forward with the recast option.

But is Miller right for the part? Since his Fox series wrapped, he’s been largely out of the limelight. And when he has been spotted, he hasn’t quite been the picture of buffness that the sand-and-sandals epic demands. Of course, that’s nothing a month or two with a personal trainer couldn’t fix. Your thoughts?

Personally, while I’m kinda psyched that the actor — who’ll always be Popular cheerleader Adam to some of us — is finally ready to get back in the game, he doesn’t seem quite right for Sparty. My first pick remains True Blood‘s ill-fated Cooter, Grant Bowler.

Anyway, I’ve said it before, I’ll say it again: Your thoughts?

zuffy 10-14-10 06:36 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 
No way Wentworth Miller can play the Spartacus character. The guy can't look mean or tough.

dan30oly 10-14-10 06:38 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 
I'm interested.

Miller was good in Prison Break and might be able to pull off Spartacus.

JasonF 10-14-10 08:57 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 
Pass. I don't want to see a tatted-up Spartacus.

DJariya 10-14-10 10:52 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 

Originally Posted by JasonF (Post 10431253)
Pass. I don't want to see a tatted-up Spartacus.

:lol: The Tattoos Wentworth had on Prison Break were fake. You knew that right?

I think Wentworth is too slender to play Spartacus and even if he bulked up in the weightroom, he doesn't have the voice.

JasonF 10-14-10 11:28 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 

Originally Posted by DJariya (Post 10431414)
:lol: The Tattoos Wentworth had on Prison Break were fake. You knew that right?

That's crazy talk. Next you'll tell me that Robert Knepper didn't really lose a hand.

chowderhead 10-15-10 12:34 AM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 

Originally Posted by DJariya (Post 10431414)
:lol: The Tattoos Wentworth had on Prison Break were fake. You knew that right?

I think Wentworth is too slender to play Spartacus and even if he bulked up in the weightroom, he doesn't have the voice.

what do you mean? I remember Season 3 in Sona where Wentworth wore that sweatshirt all season in 100+ degree weather because he didn't want the others to see his prison tattoos.

DJariya 10-15-10 12:50 AM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 

Originally Posted by chowderhead (Post 10431510)
what do you mean? I remember Season 3 in Sona where Wentworth wore that sweatshirt all season in 100+ degree weather because he didn't want the others to see his prison tattoos.

I don't know if your being serious or not, but the tattoo's were a map for Michael's escape in season 1 of Prison Break. Wentworth said in an interview I read it took many hours to apply the fake artwork on his body during season 1 and he got tired of wearing them. So, he wore the long sleeved shirts in season 3 even though it was very hot when they shot the show in Texas so he wouldn't have to have them re-applied.

Remember in season 4 Michael underwent overnight Tattoo removal surgery to magically remove all of them to get rid of that aspect of his character.

But, back to the point of this thread. Wentworth is not a good choice to play Spartacus. I think they need to cast an unknown from the UK, Ireland or Australia with a very husky voice like Whitfield.

Geofferson 10-15-10 10:11 AM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 
I can't see Wentworth Miller in this role (tattoos or not).

Gunde 10-15-10 11:56 AM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 
No no no, just.... no.
We don't need a fucking puppy playing a gladiator!

Thrush 10-15-10 01:14 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 

Originally Posted by Gunde (Post 10432185)
No no no, just.... no.
We don't need a fucking puppy playing a gladiator!

This

The only role Wentworth could pull off on this show would be that of the new resident boy toy. Since the young lad who Barca was with is now gone.

Boba Fett 10-15-10 02:20 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 
Miller is awful.

valkyrie 10-15-10 05:11 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 
This is the crappiest news I've heard in a while. Andy was fantastic in ths role. I honestly wish they'd take the story in a new direction and come back to him down the road.

Miller is a crappy choice. I loved Prison Break, but this is a whole new level. He plays the same character time and again. Shoot, I even saw him in Resident Evil 3D and said "gee, I wonder how he's going to get out of the jail?" He's NOT the guy for this role. For the love of Jupiter, don't cast him.

TGM 10-15-10 05:37 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 
who the fuck names their kid Wentworth?

Boba Fett 10-15-10 08:08 PM

Re: Andy Whitfield forced to quit Spartacus (Cancer returns)
 
I'd take the King of Wooden, Sam Worthington (I know he's "too big for TV now") at this point over Miller.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:14 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.