woody5254

Please select your favorite character from each matchup. For characters that are in multiple shows(Buffy & Angel, etc), consider all their performances not just the show I list.

Matchup #1

#4 Homer Simpson(The Simpsons)
vs
#61 Hawkeye(M.A.S.H.)


Matchup #2

#100 Oscar the Grouch(Sesame Street)
vs
#36 Stewie Griffin(Family Guy)


Matchup #3

#13 Michael Scott(The Office:US)
vs
#52 Captain Kirk(Star Trek: Original)


Matchup #4

#20 Vic Mackey(The Shield)
vs
#84 Maxwell Smart(Get Smart)


Matchup #5

#5 G.O.B. Bluth(Arrested Development)
vs
#69 Jack Tripper(Three's Company)


Matchup #6

#28 Ari Gold(Entourage)
vs
#37 Archie Bunker(All in the Family)


Matchup #7

#12 Dr. Frasier Crane(Frasier)
vs
#53 Dr. Heathcliff Huxtable(Cosby Show)


Matchup #8

#108 Sayid(LOST)
vs
#44 Angel(Angel)

Palaver

Matchup #1: Hawkeye(M.A.S.H.)
Matchup #2: Stewie Griffin(Family Guy)
Matchup #3: Michael Scott(The Office: US)
Matchup #5: G.O.B. Bluth(Arrested Development)
Matchup #6: Archie Bunker(All in the Family)
Matchup #7: Dr. Frasier Crane(Frasier)
Matchup #8: Sayid(LOST)

superdeluxe

Homer Simpson(The Simpsons)
Oscar the Grouch(Sesame Street)
Captain Kirk(Star Trek: Original)
Vic Mackey(The Shield)
Jack Tripper(Three's Company)
Archie Bunker(All in the Family)
Dr. Frasier Crane(Frasier)
Sayid(LOST)

sauce07

I don't know if this has been answered before but For Dr. Frasier Crane can we use his time on Cheers in our reasoning or only the Frasier show?

superdeluxe

Both (I think I have seen woody explain it).

woody5254

Yes, consider both Cheers and Frasier. It is a favorite character tourney, and he played the same guy in both shows.

sauce07

I loved Cheers and Dr. Crane on it but could never get into Frasier, thanks for the help.

superdeluxe

Wow vic mackey was up 10-0 at one point in time.

Cardsfan111

Go Agent 86!

NoDAK

Matchup #1: Homer Simpson(The Simpsons)
Matchup #2: Oscar the Grouch(Sesame Street)
Matchup #3: Captain Kirk(Star Trek:Original)
Matchup #4: Maxwell Smart(Get Smart)
Matchup #5: G.O.B. Bluth(Arrested Development)
Matchup #6: Ari Gold(Entourage)
Matchup #7: Dr. Heathcliff Huxtable(Cosby Show)
Matchup #8: Angel(Angel) -- grrrr...you keep putting Sayid up against Angel characters.

Last time I voted for him, I felt much the same way and chose to think of it as a vote for the Frasier from Cheers.

Arthur Dent

Homer
Oscar
Michael Scott
---
G.O.B.
Ari
Dr. Huxtable
Angel

CapRockBrewingCo.

Ari Gold vs. Archie Bunker was a tough one to decide on. Man oh man. Went with Ari in the end.

WallyOPD

Go Oscar! Go!

JuryDuty

You make me choose between GOB and Jack Tripper?! That's just not right...

Jimmy James

I continue to marvel at many of these results (Homer over Hawkeye? *really*?).

With that said, I do think the battle of the doctors (Huxtable versus Crane) is an intriguing one. I think they have just about equal merit overall but for very different reasons.

Rockmjd23

Homer - easy. Hawkeye was the most boring part of MASH
Stewie - As much as I'd love to see Oscar move on (and it appears he will), I'll go with Stewie.
Kirk - I like The Office as much as anyone, but come on, it's Kirk.
Mackey - tough one.
Jack Tripper - easy
Archie - lol yeah right, Ari.
Huxtable - like others have said, I love Cheers but couldn't get into Frasier. Funny how Cheers was so blue collar and Frasier was white collar.
Sayid One of the best Lost characters vs. the Whedonverse? Hmm..I wonder what I will choose...

Charlie Goose

Matchup #1: Hawkeye(M.A.S.H.) - Toughest one.

Matchup #2: Stewie Griffin(Family Guy)

Matchup #3: Captain Kirk(Star Trek:Original)

Matchup #4: Maxwell Smart(Get Smart)

Matchup #5: Jack Tripper(Three's Company) - Super easy.

Matchup #6: Archie Bunker(All in the Family)

Matchup #7: Dr. Heathcliff Huxtable(Cosby Show)

Matchup #8: Sayid(LOST)

superdeluxe

epic battle between abramverse and whedonverse lol.

nateman

Matchup #1: Hawkeye (M*A*S*H) - This was a really tough one.
Matchup #2: Oscar the Grouch (Sesame Street)
Matchup #3: Captain Kirk (Star Trek: Original)
Matchup #4: Maxwell Smart (Get Smart)
Matchup #5: Jack Tripper (Three's Company)
Matchup #6: Archie Bunker (All in the Family)
Matchup #7: Dr. Frasier Crane (Frasier) - This was a really tough one.
Matchup #8: Sayid (LOST)

woody5254

There are a few very close matchups in this group, so keep on voting!!

islandclaws

Homer
Stewie
Capt. Kirk

Tarantino

How in the hell is Vic Mackey, one of the best characters of ALL TIME losing to Maxwell Smart?

Homer
Stewie
Michael Scott
Vic Mackey
GOB
Ari
Huxtable
n/a

WallyOPD

Because Maxwell Smart is also one of the best characters of all time.

woody5254

We have one matchup within one vote and 3 others within striking distance. We need some voters in this one.

woody5254

We have 2 matchups within one vote with less then 24 hours left. Keep the votes coming!!