DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Dancing with the Stars - Week #9 (5/4 & 5/5) - Two Unlearned Dances (w/ 15-sec Solos) (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/554476-dancing-stars-week-9-5-4-5-5-two-unlearned-dances-w-15-sec-solos.html)

Goldberg74 05-04-09 05:39 PM

Dancing with the Stars - Week #9 (5/4 & 5/5) - Two Unlearned Dances (w/ 15-sec Solos)
 
Night Nine - 5/4
Mondays 8/7c - 2 hrs


Back to 2-hours of dancing! Two unlearned dances (one Ballroom, one Latin) from Week 1 to Week 6, with a 15-second solo during the Latin routine.

Unlearned Dance list:
Spoiler:
  • Waltz / Salsa - Lil' Kim (Grammy Award Winning Rapper) & Derek Hough
  • Foxtrot / Rumba - Gilles Marini (Actor) & Cheryl Burke
  • Arg. Tango / Rumba - Ty Murray (Rodeo Champion) & Chelsie Hightower
  • Quickstep / Paso Doble - Shawn Johnson (Olympic Gold Medalist Gymnast) & Mark Ballas
  • Vien. Waltz / Samba - Melissa Rycroft (The Bachelor star) & Tony Dovolani


Night Nine Results - 5/5
Mondays 9/8c - 1 hr


It's time for another elimination. One couple will be eliminated. Jamie Cullum performs "I Get a Kick out of You" with a dance by Agnieszka Kazmierczak and Urs Gaisenhainer. Marty Kudelka & Dee Caspary also perform.

astrochimp 05-04-09 06:29 PM

Re: Dancing with the Stars - Week #9 (5/4 & 5/5) - Two Unlearned Dances (w/ 15-sec So
 
Ty's been a great guy and shown lotsa improvement but its time for him to go.Cant really imagine what his "solo" will be like :lol: Oh and if he does go he can leave Chelsie behind ;)

tommyp007 05-04-09 09:24 PM

Re: Dancing with the Stars - Week #9 (5/4 & 5/5) - Two Unlearned Dances (w/ 15-sec So
 
Damn it! Melissa has a boob pop out, and we don't see it :(

Ranger 05-04-09 10:40 PM

Re: Dancing with the Stars - Week #9 (5/4 & 5/5) - Two Unlearned Dances (w/ 15-sec So
 
Ty gets lowest total score at 46 and lil KIm is next last at 52. And I doubt he is popular like Melissa. His solo was pretty bad but the rumba was ok.

Judges were right that shawn/mark should not break apart in quickstep.

RocShemp 05-05-09 12:36 AM

Re: Dancing with the Stars - Week #9 (5/4 & 5/5) - Two Unlearned Dances (w/ 15-sec So
 

Originally Posted by tommyp007 (Post 9425201)
Damn it! Melissa has a boob pop out, and we don't see it :(

I have a fanboyish adoration for her and am glad she didn't get embarassed like that on TV yet I was simultaneously so pissed we didn't see that slip. :(

I like Ty a lot but I think it's time for him to go. I'll miss Chelsie a lot. I've started crushing on her through this season.

And it was great to see Lacey yet again. :drool:

Is it me or was the false drama during the rehearsals worse this episode than it's ever been this season?

zuffy 05-05-09 09:35 AM

Re: Dancing with the Stars - Week #9 (5/4 & 5/5) - Two Unlearned Dances (w/ 15-sec So
 
If Ty is gone tonight, the final 4 would easily beat out last season's winner, Brooke. Last season just suck.

Septemberbaby 05-05-09 09:02 PM

Re: Dancing with the Stars - Week #9 (5/4 & 5/5) - Two Unlearned Dances (w/ 15-sec So
 
Didn't expect that!

Lil Kim goes home!

Goldberg74 05-05-09 09:03 PM

Re: Dancing with the Stars - Week #9 (5/4 & 5/5) - Two Unlearned Dances (w/ 15-sec So
 
No! No! No! No! I call bullrider.

That wasn't suppose to go down like that.

What a shocker! :jawdrop:

magiccmom 05-05-09 09:19 PM

Re: Dancing with the Stars - Week #9 (5/4 & 5/5) - Two Unlearned Dances (w/ 15-sec So
 
:wtf:

Ranger 05-05-09 10:18 PM

Re: Dancing with the Stars - Week #9 (5/4 & 5/5) - Two Unlearned Dances (w/ 15-sec So
 
Wow, apparently Ty was much more popular than anyone expected. Is next week the finals or that's May 18?

Thoughts about other pro dancers/celebs? I liked Lisa Rianna and Mayo the best. Anyone remember her?

RocShemp 05-05-09 10:21 PM

Re: Dancing with the Stars - Week #9 (5/4 & 5/5) - Two Unlearned Dances (w/ 15-sec So
 
Wisky Tango Foxtrot?!

I am still in shock. First, how does Lil' Kim get into the bottom two and Shawn pass? Then, how the hell did Lil' Kim lose to Ty? Even Chelsie was shocked!

I like Ty but he isn't in Lil' Kim's league. I firmly expected him to be eliminated tonight and Shawn next week. Then the finale would have been Gilles, Melissa, and Lil' Kim.

http://images.dvdtalk.com/images/smilies/wtf.gif

RocShemp 05-05-09 10:25 PM

Re: Dancing with the Stars - Week #9 (5/4 & 5/5) - Two Unlearned Dances (w/ 15-sec So
 

Originally Posted by Ranger (Post 9427273)
Thoughts about other pro dancers/celebs? I liked Lisa Rianna and Mayo the best. Anyone remember her?

Yeah, it was great to see her again. Although I also like how well Anna did with someone who's never danced the Tango.

magiccmom 05-05-09 10:30 PM

Re: Dancing with the Stars - Week #9 (5/4 & 5/5) - Two Unlearned Dances (w/ 15-sec So
 
I liked Anna. I hope she makes it. She would be a great fit.

zuffy 05-05-09 10:30 PM

Re: Dancing with the Stars - Week #9 (5/4 & 5/5) - Two Unlearned Dances (w/ 15-sec So
 
That was a major shocker. I guess Ty do have more fans than Lil Kim.

Patman 05-06-09 12:25 AM

Re: Dancing with the Stars - Week #9 (5/4 & 5/5) - Two Unlearned Dances (w/ 15-sec So
 
Chelsie probably had an inner "Ugh! Another week of dragging Ty around on the dance floor" when Lil' Kim got the boot.

Burgundy LaRue 05-06-09 09:35 AM

Re: Dancing with the Stars - Week #9 (5/4 & 5/5) - Two Unlearned Dances (w/ 15-sec So
 
The final three--Shawn, Melissa, and Gilles--have been locked in since Week 2. Shawn is the Olympic sweetheart, Melissa is the redeemed scorned woman, and Gilles is the surprisingly good unknown that has the popular Cheryl for a partner. If Kim had been saved this week, her and Derek's fans would have went into overdrive to get them into the finals where, with Derek's chereography and Kim's legit hip hop background, they would have buried the competition in the freestyle dance. They would have been too hard of an out next week, so let them fall now and then paint Ty as the undeserving semifinalist for an easy out next week. It makes for a really boring finale.

I liked Anna the best, but I wouldn't be upset with Mayo being the new pro. Both he and Anna are very good and would fit in well with the show.

wirefan 05-06-09 01:54 PM

Re: Dancing with the Stars - Week #9 (5/4 & 5/5) - Two Unlearned Dances (w/ 15-sec So
 
Blame the judges - if they actually scored it as a competition, the results would be different. After about week 6 or so, the floor on the scoring is a 7 and there are a few 10's sprinkled in, so basically everyone gets a 7, 8 or 9 - meaning little separation on the judges and it all coming down to the fan vote for the bottom 3-4 dancers.

They take a % of total points for the judges portion - so for 5 dancers and 2 dances there is 300 points - a 10 point range from to to bottom is all of 3% - think there could be a 3% differential in the fan votes for some of the couples? I'm not sure why they actually bother with the judges scores (esp the last 2 shows where everyone gets a 9 or 10 and the range is even smaller). As a result expect the judges to put a huge gap between Ty and the rest of the dancers next week (if you recall they needed to go down to the 4 range to get rid of the Apple guy and even that didn't work right away). They will suddenly find religion and blast Ty on his technique and say "it's the semis, sorry Ty, but we have to judge to higher standards". They of course will throw out the standards as they give the rest of the folks inflated 9's and 10's.

The judges need to spend a little less time acting for the camera - what's up with Bruno is he on speed? (must he stand up every time he talks and flail his arms around?) and Carrie Ann is all about the 'emotion' (until of course her favorites suck in that dep't, then it's about the 'flawless' technique). They judge against their expectation of the dancer as opposed to how they did compared to other dancers. An 7 or 8 for Giles, would be a 9 or 10 for Ty. Len is the only one who seems to take it seriously, is not hamming it up for the camera, and actually looks at technique.

mraw 05-06-09 04:44 PM

Re: Dancing with the Stars - Week #9 (5/4 & 5/5) - Two Unlearned Dances (w/ 15-sec So
 

Originally Posted by wirefan (Post 9428460)
Blame the judges - if they actually scored it as a competition, the results would be different. After about week 6 or so, the floor on the scoring is a 7 and there are a few 10's sprinkled in, so basically everyone gets a 7, 8 or 9 - meaning little separation on the judges and it all coming down to the fan vote for the bottom 3-4 dancers.

I've noticed this, too. No matter how bad someone's dance is, when they get down to the final five couples no one gets below a 7 from the judges no matter how bad the dance is. Ty's dance would've easily gotten a 5 had it been performed during the first several weeks of the competition. This show has fallen into the same rut that Idol has in that the voters at home are causing a loss of credibility due to making a joke of it. Idol changed it's rules this season, maybe Dancing will as well?

Red Dog 05-06-09 07:51 PM

Re: Dancing with the Stars - Week #9 (5/4 & 5/5) - Two Unlearned Dances (w/ 15-sec So
 
Carbon blobs. -ohbfrank-


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:50 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.