Terminator: Sarah Connor Chronicles *Season Prem.* - "Samson and Delilah" - 9/08/08
#101
DVD Talk God
I guess I am in the minority here with Deftones, this premiere was really bad. Lacked depth and originality. Honestly I don't see this show will last either.
Lack of story, boring characters (the FBI agent is the only mildly interesting character), no real/memorable villain ( I can't even tell you the bad terminator's name), Shirley Manson can't act worth a shit.
Predictable as hell. Terrible flow. Terrible dialog. How many times are we going to have Sarah Connor ask "John are you ok" then John just gives a blank stare and says nothing. That shit got old real quick. The SAME stupid tension between John and Sarah, over and over and over again. We got a full season of that shit in S1, have we not developed these characters any more than that?
There is no depth to this show either. Week after week are we going to have people running from Terminator's? Where is the depth, mystery and character development?
The "I love you" from Cameron to John was just cheesy. Summer is a beautiful woman IMO, but this angle they are using, this love/sexual tension between robot and human, is really lame, and lacks originality.
Very unimpressed. It's going to stay on my DVR for now, but its on life support, I will give it a couple more shots, if it doesn't improve, Its gone. I won't miss it.
Lack of story, boring characters (the FBI agent is the only mildly interesting character), no real/memorable villain ( I can't even tell you the bad terminator's name), Shirley Manson can't act worth a shit.
Predictable as hell. Terrible flow. Terrible dialog. How many times are we going to have Sarah Connor ask "John are you ok" then John just gives a blank stare and says nothing. That shit got old real quick. The SAME stupid tension between John and Sarah, over and over and over again. We got a full season of that shit in S1, have we not developed these characters any more than that?
There is no depth to this show either. Week after week are we going to have people running from Terminator's? Where is the depth, mystery and character development?
The "I love you" from Cameron to John was just cheesy. Summer is a beautiful woman IMO, but this angle they are using, this love/sexual tension between robot and human, is really lame, and lacks originality.
Very unimpressed. It's going to stay on my DVR for now, but its on life support, I will give it a couple more shots, if it doesn't improve, Its gone. I won't miss it.
I disagree with you regarding character development. In season 1, they actually developed the characters really well even though it was a really short season. Also, every week isn't going to be a Terminator chasing them even though Cromartie is still an intregal part of the storyline. The episode "Dungeons and Dragons" last season that jumped forward into the future and explored the relationship between Kyle and Derek and their struggles for survival I thought that was one of the best episodes last season. I actually really like Headey's portrayal of Sarah. Even though she's not as badass with a killer instinct, she's caring and nuturing to her son. I don't think we got to see that side of her in T2.
Last edited by DJariya; 09-09-08 at 08:47 PM.
#102
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Jan 2000
Location: Chicago, IL
Posts: 9,334
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Just watched this...I was cracking up at the end with the T-1000. I figured she was sitting in the john hearing them talk ..ala Dick Jones in Robocop. In fact that whole scene was a rip from Robocop, with the exception of the robot in the urinal.
#104
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Sep 1999
Posts: 1,702
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Linda Hamilton drives me nuts in T2. Her acting is so extreme, it's distracting. I didn't orignially feel that way, but that's kind of how it's grown to be with me, over time. I much prefer Lena Headey as Sarah.
Great opening. It looks like things will get complicated real quick.
Great opening. It looks like things will get complicated real quick.
#105
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
In agreement with those who said that the first few minutes of the premier were shaky. Between Manson's "acting" and the annoying emo stares by John, I was ready to stop the ep. Picked up considerably when Austin Green appeared and I'm digging the FBI agent.
A nitpick: Granted, it's a show about cyborgs and time travel so I expect some absurd things to happen (Cameron staples her face! Austin Green is actually good on this show!), but MY GOD, the show almost lost me when Sarah was speeding away in the truck and Cameron, despite a severe limp and slow walk, managed to beat the truck to the other end of the tunnel. That shit may fly on Friday the 13th (because it's JASON, duh), but not on this show. Lazy plotting there.
A nitpick: Granted, it's a show about cyborgs and time travel so I expect some absurd things to happen (Cameron staples her face! Austin Green is actually good on this show!), but MY GOD, the show almost lost me when Sarah was speeding away in the truck and Cameron, despite a severe limp and slow walk, managed to beat the truck to the other end of the tunnel. That shit may fly on Friday the 13th (because it's JASON, duh), but not on this show. Lazy plotting there.
#106
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
...the show almost lost me when Sarah was speeding away in the truck and Cameron, despite a severe limp and slow walk, managed to beat the truck to the other end of the tunnel. That shit may fly on Friday the 13th (because it's JASON, duh), but not on this show. Lazy plotting there.
#108
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Just watched the premiere and loved it
Thought it was better than anything done last year, I was happy to see the show return for season 2, but was not terribly excited about it.
After that premier, I am now looking forward to the season.
a great start!
Thought it was better than anything done last year, I was happy to see the show return for season 2, but was not terribly excited about it.
After that premier, I am now looking forward to the season.
a great start!
#109
Watched the 1st episode of the second season last night. What a huge let down. The whole opening with the Shirley Manson song playing and the cut photography was bloody awful. Then the sheer number of things that happened in the episode that were just plain stupid. Guy drops his lighter and accidently knocks over a cannister of lighter fuel....said fuel then just so happens to pour out all next to a large petrolium tank that just so happened to be located under the stairs of a house. Giving the gun to the female terminator at the end. The terminator overiding its termination order. Just plain stupid stuff and very poor writing. Add to which you have the actor who was playing the internal affairs guy interviewing the cop. This guy really needs to get out of the acting game and improve his voice skills. I could hardly hear what he was saying and his acting consisted of opening his eyes as wide as possible and not blinking. Way to go moron. Then the single worst thing about it all.....Shirley Manson. I like Garbage, but that is how i would describe her character and acting. The character was horrible, the whole morphing into a urinal was so bad it made me want to laugh out loud. She deserves being pissed on though for even thinking she could act. The woman cannot act to save her life and we do not need a T-1000 type character brought in at this early a stage. In the end i felt pretty cheated. I had enjoyed the first season and was expecting more of the same. What we got was little action, and lots of running around and being emotional. Thats fine, but we need moderation with these things. I said to my mate after watching it that it felt more like a bloody episode of Dawsons Creek than a Terminator show. I hope that this series gets better and loses the crap thats its suddenly picked up after season 1.
Last edited by james2025a; 09-10-08 at 07:38 AM.
#110
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Watched the 1st episode of the second season last night. What a huge let down. The whole opening with the Shirley Manson song playing and the cut photography was bloody awful. Then the sheer number of things that happened in the episode that were just plain stupid. Guy drops his lighter and accidently knocks over a cannister of lighter fuel....said fuel then just so happens to pour out all next to a large petrolium tank that just so happened to be located under the stairs of a house. Giving the gun to the female terminator at the end. The terminator overiding its termination order. Just plain stupid stuff and very poor writing. Add to which you have the actor who was playing the internal affairs guy interviewing the cop. This guy really needs to get out of the acting game and improve his voice skills. I could hardly hear what he was saying and his acting consisted of opening his eyes as wide as possible and not blinking. Way to go moron. Then the single worst thing about it all.....Shirley Manson. I like Garbage, but that is how i would describe her character and acting. The character was horrible, the whole morphing into a urinal was so bad it made me want to laugh out loud. She deserves being pissed on though for even thinking she could act. The woman cannot act to save her life and we do not need a T-1000 type character brought in at this early a stage. In the end i felt pretty cheated. I had enjoyed the first season and was expecting more of the same. What we got was little action, and lots of running around and being emotional. Thats fine, but we need moderation with these things. I said to my mate after watching it that it felt more like a bloody episode of Dawsons Creek than a Terminator show. I hope that this series gets better and loses the crap thats its suddenly picked up after season 1.
#111
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Dec 2002
Posts: 2,934
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Just watched it last night on my laptop.
Regarding why that Terminator didn’t kill the FBI agent, IMO he was about to but since he laid down his gun the agent was no longer a threat to him. And his objective is to kill John Conner.
AHHHHHHHHHHHH HA HA HA HA
But this Terminator never had that order. It was an error. So she simply reverted back.
Regarding why that Terminator didn’t kill the FBI agent, IMO he was about to but since he laid down his gun the agent was no longer a threat to him. And his objective is to kill John Conner.
AHHHHHHHHHHHH HA HA HA HA
But this Terminator never had that order. It was an error. So she simply reverted back.
#112
DVD Talk Legend
I thought it was a pretty crappy opening episode, especially after the high that season 1 ended on. Manson was horrible; looking and acting. Not even a burn on Cameron's face after the explosion? Brilliant. Cameron pulls a Jason and is now faster than a speeding truck. Sure.
Did I miss something at the end? Where did Cromartie come from when he was talking to the FBI guy. All of a sudden it cut to Cromartie talking to him and it didn't make any sense where they were. I don't know if I fastforwarded too far after a commercial break or forgot something earlier in the episode.
Did I miss something at the end? Where did Cromartie come from when he was talking to the FBI guy. All of a sudden it cut to Cromartie talking to him and it didn't make any sense where they were. I don't know if I fastforwarded too far after a commercial break or forgot something earlier in the episode.
#113
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Philadelphia
Posts: 1,385
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Guys, regarding the "Jason" moment at the end of the tunnel: The truck had to turn around because it was blocked by Paper-Boy like obstructions, ie-bum with a shopping cart, trash truck (which in itself was ridiculous), and then proceeded BACK the way they came TOWARDS Cameron. Granted she would have had to jump into the aquaduct with a bad leg, but it's not like she teleported 50 yards down the road.
-Doc
-Doc
#114
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Did I miss something at the end? Where did Cromartie come from when he was talking to the FBI guy. All of a sudden it cut to Cromartie talking to him and it didn't make any sense where they were. I don't know if I fastforwarded too far after a commercial break or forgot something earlier in the episode.
#115
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
#116
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Aug 2004
Posts: 1,716
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Guys, regarding the "Jason" moment at the end of the tunnel: The truck had to turn around because it was blocked by Paper-Boy like obstructions, ie-bum with a shopping cart, trash truck (which in itself was ridiculous), and then proceeded BACK the way they came TOWARDS Cameron. Granted she would have had to jump into the aquaduct with a bad leg, but it's not like she teleported 50 yards down the road.
-Doc
-Doc
#117
Moderator
#118
I don't think anyone can fault Summer Glau for acting too human in the first episode and not applaud Shirley Manson's amazing performance as a robot from the future with little to no instruction on social interaction.
#119
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Aug 2004
Posts: 1,716
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I assume you are in fact referring to Ralph Ellison, author of The Invisible Man? Or perhaps you mean Atiyyah Ellison, former defensive tackle for the 49ers?
Although, I suppose you could be implying that the homage is to Harlan Ellison, but that just sounds crazy.
Although, I suppose you could be implying that the homage is to Harlan Ellison, but that just sounds crazy.
#120
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Jan 2000
Location: Chicago, IL
Posts: 9,334
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Dropping the gun did not convince the Terminator not to kill him. This guy is not the Predator. IMHO he didn't kill him because the Terminator knew that Agent Ellison was tracking down Sarah Conner and he could follow where Ellison leads him...and that reading is confirmed by the subsequent meeting between the two towards the end.
#121
DVD Talk Gold Edition
#122
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Seattle and sometimes hell
Posts: 6,199
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
7 Posts
I'm going to write fan fiction where John has sex with his mom and becomes his own father. Then he'll have a reason to be brooding. Unless it has been done already. Probably has. Oh forget it.
#123
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Philadelphia
Posts: 1,385
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#124
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Miami, FL
Posts: 1,091
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From the moment she first appeared on-screen, I pegged her as a Terminator. I'm not sure yet whether Shirley Manson's performance is bad acting, or the way they're directing her to act like a T-1000.
There's a difference between homage and repetition ... the kill at the end of the episode was definitely the latter. This was the big moment, the big reveal. They should've figured out a different way for the T-1000 to take the guy out; something that would've been impressive, or shocking, or scary, not something we've already seen.
That's how I took it too, especially since her malfunction was caused by a piece of shrapnel in her head, so her body being squished between two trucks wouldn't have changed anything in her head chip. Knowing John, she knew the emotional act had a good chance of working on him (just as she knew he wouldn't come back for his mother when she screamed), and when it didn't work at first she continued to ramp it up until he pulled the plug. She can act human moderately well, especially when it comes to tricking someone to terminate them; it's the day-to-day social interaction that she hasn't quite figured out. My only gripe with it was the fact that apparently wiping the chip with a rag was enough to fix it. Who knows, though, maybe it was knocked loose and just needed to be re-seated.
There's a difference between homage and repetition ... the kill at the end of the episode was definitely the latter. This was the big moment, the big reveal. They should've figured out a different way for the T-1000 to take the guy out; something that would've been impressive, or shocking, or scary, not something we've already seen.
I thought she was clearly 'faking' emotion to convince John not to dismantle her... which I considered a survival mechanism that, if successful, would have ended in her killing John and everyone else. Other terminators have shown the ability to 'act' human if the situation called on it.
My only gripe with this is consistency. Look at Cameron in the very first episode of the show. She's clearly acting like a normal teenage girl when she first meets John. But every episode after that she's weird and awkward and, well, robotic around her classmates and everyone else, as if she is no longer able to properly 'play her role'.
My only gripe with this is consistency. Look at Cameron in the very first episode of the show. She's clearly acting like a normal teenage girl when she first meets John. But every episode after that she's weird and awkward and, well, robotic around her classmates and everyone else, as if she is no longer able to properly 'play her role'.
#125
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Philadelphia
Posts: 1,385
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
There's a difference between homage and repetition ... the kill at the end of the episode was definitely the latter. This was the big moment, the big reveal. They should've figured out a different way for the T-1000 to take the guy out; something that would've been impressive, or shocking, or scary, not something we've already seen.
-Doc