DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   New Fall Shows Round-up (rank em as you see em) (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/512198-new-fall-shows-round-up-rank-em-you-see-em.html)

Jadzia 09-17-07 09:17 PM

New Fall Shows Round-up (rank em as you see em)
 
I thought I would do this thread for the new fall season.
Which shows will you be watching?
What shows have you watched and what did you think?

Edit your post as you see the new pilots.


ALREADY WATCHED:

Watched it, liked it, will stick it out for the season:
Pushing Daisies
Dirty Sexy Money
Bionic Woman
Private Practice
Search for the American Band

Watched it, it was ok, will keep watching for awhile:
Gossip Girl
Journeyman
Life is Wild
Samantha Who?

Watched it, hated it, will not watch again:
Nashville
K-Ville
Kid Nation
Kitchen Nightmares
Big Bang Theory
Moonlight
Cane
Carpoolers
Viva Laughlin

Tried a few episodes and already dropped it:
Chuck
Life
Reaper
Women’s Murder Club
Big Shots
Cavemen
Back to You

Derrich 09-17-07 09:28 PM

I saw the tivo premiere of Big Bang Theory. I liked it.

D

mugwump 09-17-07 10:04 PM

Here's mine so far courtesy of Comcast HD OnDemand

YET TO PREMIERE:

Really excited about/interested to watch:
Reaper

Not that excited but will give it a shot:
Cane

ALREADY WATCHED:

Watched it, liked it, will stick it out for the season:
None yet

Watched it, it was ok, will keep watching for awhile:
Chuck
Life

Watched it, hated it, will not watch again:
Bionic Woman
Journeyman

Quake1028 09-18-07 12:09 AM

Really excited about/interested to watch:
Pushing Daisies
Eli Stone
New Amsterdam
The Sarah Connor Chronicles

Not that excited but will give it a shot:
Women's Murder Club
Cashmere Mafia
Samantha Who?
Canterbury's Law
The I.T. Crowd
Miss/Guided
The Captain

No interest/not going to watch:
Nashville
Kitchen Nightmares
CW Now
Online Nation
Private Practice
Life is Wild
Viva Laughlin
Next Great American Band
Unhitched
The Return of Jezebel James
Lipstick Jungle
Swingtown

Watched it, liked it, will stick it out for the season:
K-Ville
The Big Bang Theory
Chuck
Journeyman
Bionic Woman
Reaper

Watched it, it was OK, will keep watching for awhile:
Back to You
Life

Watched it, hated it, will not watch again:
Kid Nation

Queue:
Gossip Girl
Cane
Dirty Sexy Money
Big Shots
Moonlight
Aliens in America
Cavemen
Carpoolers

Overall Rankings:
1.Journeyman
2.The Big Bang Theory
3.Bionic Woman
4.Chuck
5.Reaper
6.Life
7.K-Ville
8.Back to You
9.Kid Nation

DJariya 09-18-07 12:57 AM

Hmmm, Interesting thread.

YET TO PREMIERE:

Really excited about/interested to watch:
Lipstick Jungle (Midseason)

Not that excited but will give it a shot:
Eli Stone (Midseason)

No interest/not going to watch:
Cavemen
Carpoolers
Viva Laughlin
Nashville
Aliens in America
Kid Nation (I refuse to watch this because this show lead to Jericho's initial cancellation)
Big Bang Theory
Canterbury's Law (Midseason)....Shark and Boston Legal fulfill my lawyer show needs.
New Amsterdam (this show is DOA since production was shut down)

ALREADY WATCHED:

Watched it, liked it, will stick it out for the season:
Bionic Woman
Sarah Connor Chronicles (January)
Gossip Girl (will watch re-air on Sunday)
Kitchen Nightmares
Journeyman
Chuck
Dirty Sexy Money
Cane
Life
Pushing Daisies
Private Practice
Moonlight

Watched it, it was okay, will stick it out awhile:
Women's Murder Club
Big Shots
Reaper

Watched it, hated it, will not watch again:
Saving Grace (watched 2 episodes from the summer and didn't care for it)

Dropped due to too much programming:
Back to you
K-Ville
The Next Great American Band

Daniel-A 09-18-07 02:36 AM

Watched it, liked it, will stick it out for the season:
Pushing Daisies (1) - It isn't often that something lives up to the hype. The premiere of this exceeded my expectations. Gonna take a lot to get me off this bandwagon.
The Big Bang Theory (2) - Being a nerd (not so much the smart kind) I'm in love with the show. I wish there was a different female lead, though.
Reaper (2) - Like the campy feel it has. Reminds me of Buffy.
Journeyman (2) - Good 1st 2 episodes. Seems really genre-specific. Expect it to get canceled.
Gossip Girl (3) - I'm a sucker for teen dramas. Ill watch this til it gets axed.
Life (2) - Really like the lead. I just don't see how he is such a knowitall with the detective work.

Watched it, it was good enough to keep watching for awhile:
Cane (2) - Like it a lot, but don't think it can draw in the numbers. Expect it to get canceled like Kingpin did.
Big Shots (2) - I like each of the leads. I hope the tranny story goes away soon.
Bionic Woman (2) - I dont care about any of the characters. Hope it changes.
Private Practice (2) - Too much stuff. And this isn't really different. 1 more chance.
Carpoolers (1) - I wish they just kept Goss' other show alive (Sons & Daughters)
Dirty Sexy Money (2) - Still not hooked. This was getting a lot of hype preseason. I feel like it is a let down. Characters are too peculiar for a drama.

Watched it, it was ok, will watch if bored:
Chuck (2) - Gave it 2 episodes to pull me in. It didn't.
K-Ville (3) - Same ole same ole - just in Nawlins. I wanted to like it, though.
Kid Nation (3) - I'm over it.

Watched it, hated it, will not watch again:
Moonlight (1.5) - Meh.
Tell me you love me (1) - Not for me.
Back to you (1) - I didn't like the pilot at all. Only like Frasier on Cheers.
Cavemen (0.5) - I wasn't even supposed to watch this. I wish I didn't.

No interest in:
Nashville
Kitchen Nightmares
Next Great American Band
Most anything on cable

Going to try:
Everything else

(#) - is the number of episodes watched. Mainly to see how many I watch before I give shows the axe or the season pass.

esc24 09-18-07 08:52 AM


Really excited about/interested to watch:

Gossip Girl
Dirty Sexy Money

Not that excited but will give it a shot:
Viva Laughlin
Big Shots
Cane
Moonlight
Kid Nation
Samantha Who?
Back to You

ALREADY WATCHED:

Watched it, liked it, will stick it out for the season:

Chuck
Reaper
Pushing Daisies

Watched it, it was ok, will keep watching for awhile:
KVille
Bionic Woman
Journeyman
Life
Big Bang Theory

Watched it, hated it, will not watch again:

Flay 09-18-07 09:29 AM

NOT WATCHED: (based on premise)

:thumbsup: Viva Laughlin
:thumbsup: New Amsterdam
:thumbsup: Eli Stone
:thumbsup: Search for the American Band

:thmbsdwn: Private Practice
:thmbsdwn: Lipstick Jungle
:thmbsdwn: Women's Murder Club
:thmbsdwn: Aliens in America
:thmbsdwn: Moonlight
:thmbsdwn: Cavemen
:thmbsdwn: Carpoolers
:thmbsdwn: Gossip Girl
:thmbsdwn: Dirty Sexy Money
:thmbsdwn: Big Shots
:thmbsdwn: Kid Nation
:thmbsdwn: Samantha Who?
:thmbsdwn: Back to You

ALREADY WATCHED:

:thumbsup: Journeyman
:thumbsup: Reaper
:thumbsup: Pushing Daisies

:thmbsdwn: Chuck
:thmbsdwn: KVille
:thmbsdwn: Bionic Woman
:thmbsdwn: Life
:thmbsdwn: Big Bang Theory

magiccmom 09-18-07 10:05 AM

Not gonna watch it, but I did enjoy the commericial for "Carpoolers" with the Phil Collins "In the Air" drum solo. That made me laugh.

Gonna sound stupid here, but how do you already watch a show that hasnt premiered yet?

Groucho 09-18-07 10:25 AM

YET TO PREMIERE:

Not that excited but will give it a shot:
Women's Murder Club

ALREADY WATCHED:

Watched it, liked it, will stick it out for the season:
Pushing Daisies

Watched it, it was ok, will keep watching for awhile:
Back to You
Bionic Woman
Reaper

Watched it, hated it, will not watch again:
K-Ville

B.A. 09-18-07 10:30 AM

YET TO PREMIERE:

Really excited about/interested to watch:

Not that excited but will give it a shot:

Dirty Sexy Money

No interest/not going to watch:
Carpoolers
Cavemen
Search for the American Band
Women’s Murder Club
Kitchen Nightmares
Viva Laughlin
Cane
Life is Wild
Kid Nation
Samantha Who?
Back to You
Private Practice
Big Shots
Moonlight

ALREADY WATCHED:

Watched it, liked it, will stick it out for the season:

Pushing Daisies, Chuck, Journeyman, Reaper, Life

Watched it, it was ok, if not awful, will keep watching for awhile:
Gossip Girl, Bionic Woman

Watched it, hated it, will not watch again:
K-Ville, Big Bang Theory

Patman 09-18-07 10:37 AM

Really excited about/interested to watch:
Gossip Girl
Dirty Sexy Money
Private Practice
Samantha Who?
Big Shots
Back to You

Not that excited but will give it a shot:
Search for the American Band
Viva Laughlin
Cane
Moonlight
Life is Wild
Kid Nation
New Amsterdam

No interest/not going to watch:
Carpoolers
Women’s Murder Club
Kitchen Nightmares

ALREADY WATCHED:

Watched it, liked it, will stick it out for the season:
Bionic Woman
Life
Reaper
Big Bang Theory

Watched it, it was ok, will keep watching for awhile:
Chuck
Pushing Daisies
Journeyman
K-Ville
Sarah Connor Chronicles

Watched it, hated it, will not watch again:
Nashville (well, maybe one more episode since nothing else is on this week, just to see Terry Bradshaw's daughter get played again)
Cavemen
Lipstick Jungle
Aliens in America

JuryDuty 09-18-07 10:51 AM

Haven't yet seen, but interested in:
Dirty Sexy Money
Viva Laughlin
Sarah Conner Chronicles
That Battlestar Galactica Spin-off


Have seen and...

LOVED:

Pushing Daisies

VERY GOOD:
Bionic Woman

HAS POTENTIAL:
Journeyman
Chuck

"OK":
Back to You

NOT WASTING ANOTHER MOMENT:
Big Bang Theory
Life
Big Brother 9

cisman 09-18-07 10:56 AM

YET TO PREMIERE:

Really excited about/interested to watch:
Bionic Woman
Moonlight
Journeyman
Sarah Conner Chronicles

Not that excited but will give it a shot:
Private Practice
Pushing Daisies


No interest/not going to watch:
Cavemen
Carpoolers
Life is Wild
Kid Nation
Samantha Who?
Back to You
Big Bang Theory
Reaper
Dirty Sexy Money
Search for the American Band
Women’s Murder Club
Kitchen Nightmares
Viva Laughlin
Life
Big Shots
Gossip Gir
Cane


ALREADY WATCHED:

Watched it, liked it, will stick it out for the season:
(none yet)

Watched it, it was ok, will keep watching for awhile:

Watched it, hated it, will not watch again:

Gizmo 09-18-07 11:22 AM

Holding Spot

DJariya 09-18-07 11:34 AM

I'm assuming that not a single person who has commented so far is a Gordon Ramsay Hell's Kitchen/Ramsay's Kitchen Nightmares fan. This is one of the few new reality shows that I am really looking forward to.

mrpayroll 09-18-07 12:15 PM

Plan to watch:

Viva Laughlin (CBS)
The Sarah Connor Chronicles (Spring) (FOX)


Do not plan to watch:

CW Now (CW)
Online Nation (CW)
Lipstick Jungle (Jan 2008) (NBC)
The Big Bang Theory (CBS)
K-Ville (FOX)
Aliens In America (CW)
Cavemen (ABC)
Cashmere Mafia (ABC)
Cane (CBS)
The Singing Bee (NBC)
Private Practice (ABC)
Dirty Sexy Money (ABC)
Kitchen Nightmares (FOX)
Return of Jezebel James (FOX)
Gossip Girl (CW)
Big Shots (ABC)
Canterbury's Law(FOX)
Women's Murder Club (ABC)
Moonlight (CBS)
Next Great American Band (FOX)
Nashville (FOX)
New Amsterdam (FOX)

ALREADY WATCHED:

Watched it, liked it, will stick it out for the season:

Journeyman (NBC)
Life (NBC)
Kid Nation (CBS)
Carpoolers (ABC)
Samantha Who? (ABC)

Watched it, it was ok, will keep watching for awhile:


Back to You (FOX)
Reaper (CW)
Chuck (NBC)
Bionic Woman (NBC)
Pushing Daisies (ABC)


Watched it, hated it, will not watch again:

Updated!


Chris

mdc3000 09-18-07 12:43 PM

Going to try but not expecting to really like
Life is Wild
Viva Laughlin

Watched it, liked it, will stick it out for the season:
Aliens In America
Chuck
Dirty Sexy Money
Journeyman
Life
Moonlight
Pushing Daisies

Watched it, it was ok, will keep watching for awhile:
Back to You
Bionic Woman
Cane
Gossip Girl
Kid Nation
Private Practice (hated the pilot, ep 3 (aired as 2) was decent)
Reaper

Watched it, hated it, will not watch again:
The Big Bang Theory
Big Shots
Carpoolers
Cavemen
K-Ville

Not tuning in - know I will hate it:
Nashville

LorenzoL 09-18-07 02:58 PM

No interest/not going to watch:
Cavemen
Carpoolers
Private Practice
Kid Nation
Search for the American Band
Big Shots
Viva Laughlin
Life is Wild
Samantha Who?
Women’s Murder Club

ALREADY WATCHED:

Watched it, liked it, will stick it out for the season:
Pushing Daisies
Chuck
Life

Watched it, it was ok, will keep watching for awhile:
Dirty Sexy Money

Watched it, hated it, will not watch again:
Reaper
Cane
Back to You
Gossip Girl
Big Bang Theory
Kitchen Nightmares
Journeyman
Moonlight
Bionic Woman

rkndkn 09-18-07 03:04 PM

Really excited about/interested to watch:

Dirty Sexy Money
Kitchen Nightmares
New Amsterdam (mid-season)

Not that excited but will give it a shot:

Search for the American Band
Moonlight
Journeyman
Back to You

No interest/not going to watch:

all the rest

ALREADY WATCHED:

Watched it, liked it, will stick it out for the season:

Kitchen Nightmares
Dirty Sexy Money

Watched it, it was ok, will keep watching for awhile:

Journeyman

Watched it, hated it, will not watch again:

Back to You

DRG 09-18-07 04:37 PM

YET TO PREMIERE:

Really excited about/interested to watch:
Pushing Daisies
Reaper
Chuck
Kitchen Nightmares
Gossip Girl
Carpoolers

Not that excited but will give it a shot:
Bionic Woman
K-Ville
Journeyman
Cane
Aliens in America
Big Bang Theory
Kid Nation

ALREADY WATCHED:

Watched it, liked it, will stick it out for the season:
None yet

Watched it, it was ok, will keep watching for awhile:
None yet

Watched it, hated it, will not watch again:
None yet

invisiblegt 09-18-07 05:19 PM

Watched it, liked it, will stick it out for the season:
(none yet)

Watched it, it was ok, will keep watching for awhile:


Watched it, hated it, will not watch again:

K-Ville

riley_dude 09-18-07 06:49 PM

Wow. How does everyone find time to sample 10 or more new shows? I thought 5 was alot.
I watched Pushing Daisies and Loved it.
Sarah Connor Chronicles was ok.
Bionic Woman was a bit too dark for me and I like Dark.
Reaper was pretty good though the fat guy got on my nerves.

Looking forward to Journeyman, Dirty Sexy Money, Gossip Girl.

Update 9/20 Watched Gossip Girl and wasn't impressed. Dark and dreary and hard to identify with any of the characters wo are super upity and spoiled rich kids. This is coming from someone who likes shows with young people in them like The OC and Veronica Mars.

innocentfreak 09-18-07 10:06 PM

I try everything.

Watched it, liked it, will stick it out for the season:
Chuck
Journeyman
Kitchen Nightmares
Reaper

Watched it, it was ok, will keep watching for awhile:
Back To You
Big Bang Theory
Big Shots
Bionic Woman
Gossip Girl
K-Ville
Life
Private Practice

Watched it, hated it, will not watch again:
CW Now
Kid Nation
Nashville
Online Nation

Joe Molotov 09-18-07 11:52 PM

Watched it, liked it, will stick it out for the season:
The Sarah Conner Chronicles

Watched it, it was ok, will keep watching for awhile:
(None yet)

Watched it, hated it, will not watch again:
Cavemen
Big Bang Theory
Flash Gordon


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:12 AM.


Copyright © 2018 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.