DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Season 5 of the Shield - how was it? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/459777-season-5-shield-how.html)

jkberden 03-22-06 09:11 AM

Season 5 of the Shield - how was it?
 
***PLEASE KEEP SPOILER FREE*** Thanks

I know the season just wrapped up, but I did not see any of it. I am one of those annoying people who just wait for the Dvd release. To me, this is THE show on TV (apologies to the Sopranos). I have been so tempted to read the weekly reviews of the shows in this forum, but did not want all the spoilers that come with it.

So what did you think of Vic and company's latest exploits? Did the show maintain its level of excellence? I cannot wait for this to make it to Dvd.

Flay 03-22-06 09:30 AM

Technically, the season isn't over. On NPR yesterday, the creator of the show, Shawn Ryan, said the season is broken up over two sections. The final 10 episodes will come later in the year or perhaps early 2007.

But the first half of the season has been nothing but stellar.

movieking 03-22-06 09:31 AM

I have yet to see the season finale yet, but up to this point, it's been awesome.

chrisih8u 03-22-06 09:33 AM

It was my favorite season.

Geofferson 03-22-06 09:41 AM

Arguably, one of its best seasons.

DeanoBKN 03-22-06 09:44 AM

So last night was the end of "Part 1"?

I sure hope so, I only caught the first couple of the new season, then lost track, so I would love to catch up.

Tommy Ceez 03-22-06 10:01 AM

Best season yet...hands down

DVD Josh 03-22-06 10:04 AM


Originally Posted by Tommy Ceez
Best season yet...hands down

I'm debating that, but it's definitely been an incredible season, I would probably rank it 1,5,2,3,4.

You will be blown away. This is the season that Sheild takes the crown back for best drama on TV.

Geofferson 03-22-06 10:39 AM


Originally Posted by DVD Josh
I would probably rank it 1,5,2,3,4.

Same here.


This is the season that Sheild takes the crown back for best drama on TV.
I definitely can see that happening.

jkberden 03-22-06 12:20 PM

Damn, from the sampling of comments so far, this season sounds amazing. I may have to actually watch these when FX inevitably re-runs them instead of just waiting for the Dvd.

Geofferson 03-22-06 12:27 PM

Keep in mind that The Shield will be aired on Spike Friday's (starting this week). I imagine they will start from the beginning, but am not sure.

superfro 03-22-06 12:29 PM

This season almost put me in a coma. Take that as you will.

jkberden 03-22-06 12:32 PM


Originally Posted by superfro
This season almost put me in a coma. Take that as you will.

So you were bored with it? Or knocked out by it? Just wondering what way you meant it, if either way.

Chew 03-22-06 12:54 PM

I have yet to see the mid-season finale as well, but also think this season has been top notch. I haven't had a letdown in quality with a single episode this season.

Bell65 03-22-06 12:55 PM

i LOVE the sopranos, buffy, deadwood, battlestar, rescue me, and lots of other great some day classic shows...but ive never felt so attached emotionally to a show, EVER...ive broken shit, yelled at the tv, choked on food, cried, and even farted at inappropraite times during the show to make my buddies laugh at an otherwise serious plot turn (hey its taco tuesdays too) this show is absolutely awesome!!! i sent out an email telling people if they took a week off of work to catch up on the first 5 seasons in time for the 2nd half of season 5 it would be totally worth reprecussions from work, family, friends, everything...

hows that for a stellar review of the season?

JayDerek 03-22-06 12:59 PM


Originally Posted by Bell65
i LOVE the sopranos, buffy, deadwood, battlestar, rescue me, and lots of other great some day classic shows...but ive never felt so attached emotionally to a show, EVER...ive broken shit, yelled at the tv, choked on food, cried, and even farted at inappropraite times during the show to make my buddies laugh at an otherwise serious plot turn (hey its taco tuesdays too) this show is absolutely awesome!!! i sent out an email telling people if they took a week off of work to catch up on the first 5 seasons in time for the 2nd half of season 5 it would be totally worth reprecussions from work, family, friends, everything...

hows that for a stellar review of the season?

that's awesome. :thumbsup:

superfro 03-22-06 01:33 PM


Originally Posted by jkberden
So you were bored with it? Or knocked out by it? Just wondering what way you meant it, if either way.

The latter. :)

BEST SHOW EVER.

Tommy Ceez 03-22-06 02:18 PM


Originally Posted by Chew
I have yet to see the mid-season finale as well, but also think this season has been top notch. I haven't had a letdown in quality with a single episode this season.

The mid season finale is PHENOMINAL(!!!), the Shield always made me feel like I was developing an Ulcer rooting for Vic and the ST, last night I almost vomited, its that compelling.

TK-421 03-22-06 02:28 PM

Incredible. I rank it up there with Season 1 of the Sopranos and Season 1 of the Shield as the best episodic drama I've ever seen.

adamblast 03-22-06 02:37 PM


Originally Posted by Tommy Ceez
...last night I almost vomited, its that compelling.

For most shows, I wouldn't know how to relate to that comment. For The Shield it makes perfect sense. I know better than to root for people like Vic and the Strike Team, but damn if I don't keep hoping they get away with it each time...

DVD Josh 03-22-06 02:44 PM


Originally Posted by TK-421
Incredible. I rank it up there with Season 1 of the Sopranos and Season 1 of the Shield as the best episodic drama I've ever seen.

Great company. I'd include LOST and N/T in that group as well.

Jimmy James 03-22-06 02:48 PM

I don't think it is any better than S4 of The Shield was. That said, I thought S4 was really great and was a big improvement on S3. I'd probably rank them 1, 4/5, 2, 3

sauce07 03-22-06 03:14 PM

okay, i'm going to step out on a Lem here (see bad shield jokes do exist), This season was the best of the shows history. I love every season of this show, and this season completely impressed me. Forrest Whitaker was the best addition this show has ever had, sorry Glen Close and Anthony Anderson. He added an incredible amount of energy to a show that was already overflowing. He was so weird, and made every scene with him uncomfortable.

Does anybody know if they are going to release the first half on DVD before the second half gets started?

i rank them 5,1,4,2,3

jkberden 03-22-06 03:32 PM


Originally Posted by TK-421
Incredible. I rank it up there with Season 1 of the Sopranos and Season 1 of the Shield as the best episodic drama I've ever seen.


This is high praise indeed. I also feel that Season 1 of the Sopranos and the Shield are about the best episodic drama I have ever seen. While I have greatly enjoyed Seasons 2,3, and 4 of the Shield, I don't think any have matched the greatness of Season 1. Likewise with the subsequent seasons of the Sopranos. I am somewhat skeptical that Season 5 can live up to all this praise that is being heaped upon it. However, I absolutely cannot wait to see for myself. Thanks for all the comments and opinions. :)

Tommy Ceez 03-22-06 07:42 PM


Originally Posted by jkberden
This is high praise indeed. I also feel that Season 1 of the Sopranos and the Shield are about the best episodic drama I have ever seen. While I have greatly enjoyed Seasons 2,3, and 4 of the Shield, I don't think any have matched the greatness of Season 1. Likewise with the subsequent seasons of the Sopranos. I am somewhat skeptical that Season 5 can live up to all this praise that is being heaped upon it. However, I absolutely cannot wait to see for myself. Thanks for all the comments and opinions. :)

You have to understand, that we just watched the 1/2 finale last night, and woke up from a nights sleep just as emotionally spent as we were when we went to bed last night


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:34 AM.


Copyright 2018 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.