DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   New Andy Richter comedy: "Andy Barker P.I." (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/458199-new-andy-richter-comedy-andy-barker-p-i.html)

TheKing 03-23-07 03:34 AM

The first episode was not very good. The second episode was pretty damn funny. Hopefully it gets better as it keeps going.

wetsprockets 03-23-07 03:50 AM

I thought this was a huge improvement over the pilot since there were actual laughs to be found, even if those laughs basically kept referencing the same thing. For whatever reason, those flashbacks to Guy running and Andy's reaction to what the women were saying just cracked me up.

Cardiff Giant11 03-23-07 06:10 AM

agreed, this episode was much better even if it did reuse the same joke a number of times. Guy Halverson running in slo-mo complete with giant ham sandwich in hand :thumbsup:

LasVegasMichael 03-23-07 07:01 AM

This was certainly a destined to fail show, no doubt. I am surprised it lasted past the pilot.

Geofferson 03-23-07 08:41 AM

I agree that the second episode showed more promise than the pilot. I'll continue to tune in to see where it goes...

Brent_MN 03-23-07 10:56 AM

wow, if this episode was better than the pilot, I'm glad I missed it.

while funny at times, I thought to myself "there is no way this is going to be a hit" what is NBC thinking? or hoping?

Tony Hale's stuff with the secretary was great. :lol:
and like others have said, the flashbacks to Guy with his sandwich. good stuff.

I sort of hope it sticks around for awhile. There's something about it...

Ravenous 03-23-07 02:50 PM

Saw it for the first time and really liked it. It seemed a bit off at times and I hate the bitch playing his wife, but ill tune in next time, Hopefully they keep the show.

Rogue588 03-23-07 02:53 PM

The secretary loks a helluva lot like Gina Torres.

I liked the ep. I hope it lasts so I can see

http://i.imdb.com/Photos/Ss/0775349/1ABPIadN06.jpg

rfduncan 03-23-07 03:25 PM


Originally Posted by Ravenous
Saw it for the first time and really liked it. It seemed a bit off at times and I hate the bitch playing his wife, but ill tune in next time, Hopefully they keep the show.

I tend to agree. I missed the pilot and while watching last night thought the character would have a lot more to explore without the wife character existing. It was mildly amusing (while nowhere NEARLY as good as ARCtU). I'll watch the rest of the episodes.

TGM 03-23-07 05:21 PM

Andy Barker, D.O.A.

Nth Power 03-23-07 09:10 PM

Much better episode than the premiere. Hopefully it can keep improving and I'll keep watching.

movieking 03-23-07 10:13 PM

I'm out. Richter is not made to be a lead. He needs to be a second banana.

B.A. 03-24-07 01:08 AM

I've been amused by both episodes.

LorenzoL 03-24-07 12:11 PM

The second episode was much better than the pilot especially the scenes with Tony Hale and the black secretary.

SonOfAStu 03-25-07 08:43 AM


Originally Posted by Cardiff Giant
agreed, this episode was much better even if it did reuse the same joke a number of times. Guy Halverson running in slo-mo complete with giant ham sandwich in hand :thumbsup:


THREE kinds of ham at that! :eek: rotfl

I really enjoyed the second ep. Then again, I liked the pilot as well. I'm glad there are at least six of these.

SonOfAStu 03-25-07 08:44 AM


Originally Posted by movieking
I'm out. Richter is not made to be a lead. He needs to be a second banana.


Just curious, did you ever catch Andy Richter Controls the Universe?

Jimmy James 03-25-07 11:18 AM

Do those of you who miss 30 Rock and think this is terrible remember how bad the first couple episodes of 30 Rock were? I think there is hope for this series yet (at least as long as the ratings are decent -- I haven't checked).

boogieman03 03-25-07 10:59 PM


Originally Posted by B.A.
I've been amused by both episodes.


So have I. Still, I thought the 2nd episode was much funnier than the first.

Chew 03-26-07 07:07 AM

If the third episode improves on the second as much as the second did the first (and so on), this will be a good show. I just wonder if it'll be around long enough.

mmconhea 03-26-07 10:17 AM

Finally caught an episode. Not sure cronologically which one... the one with the heart attack fat guy. I liked it. has potential as the characters develop. I'll watch again.

boogieman03 03-26-07 10:28 AM

Did the flashbacks of the fat guy running feel like a Conan joke to anybody else?

Achtung 03-26-07 11:17 AM


Originally Posted by boogieman03
Did the flashbacks of the fat guy running feel like a Conan joke to anybody else?

Absolutely. Which is cool, because I love Conan.

I just worry that some of the jokes in this show will be a problem because they won't also advance the plot. When its only a 30-minute show (22 mins with commercials), you don't really have a lot of time for extraneous comedy.

The guy running with the sandwich was funny because it came up when Andy was trying to imagine a woman being attracted to him. The Tony Hale "Jungle Fever" jokes, though funny, didn't add to the main plot.

Groucho 03-26-07 11:19 AM

The plots aren't that great. They should focus on the jokes.

Zwerchfell 03-26-07 02:05 PM

I didn't like the 1st episode at all but thought the 2nd was great. However the show will not go very far.

obscurelabel 03-30-07 03:06 PM

Hmm, almost a day after the most recent airing and no comments ...

I thought this episode continued the trend of improvement, although the show's lack of laugh-out-loud moments is probably hurting it. There was plenty that I enjoyed:

Harve Presnell was terrific, stealing all of his scenes (as usual).

A great absurd joke was the chicken flying into Andy's face, making you think it was pecking his eyes out, but revealed to be just flapping its wings to no ill effect.

Andy's wife having trouble pronouncing "Wally" as if it were some exotic foreign name.

Simon exiting the car via the window instead of just opening the door.

More absurdity with inspector 78 trying to shoot Andy with a 200 year old antique pistol.

Where was Nicolle? This episode must have been shown out-of-order.

Again, I like this show a lot. I hope NBC can find a place for it next year but it may be too droll to find a large enough audience.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:04 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.