DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Supernatural -- "Hook Man" -- 10/25/05 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/442724-supernatural-hook-man-10-25-05-a.html)

LorenzoL 10-25-05 05:32 AM

Supernatural -- "Hook Man" -- 10/25/05
 
"Hook Man"
Spoiler:
When a mythical, vengeful creature terrorizes a small college town in Iowa, Sam and Dean race to find and destroy the Hook Man's bones before he comes for them.

Cast: Jared Padalecki, Jensen Ackles.
Director(s): David Jackson.
Producer(s): Eric Kripke, Robert Singer.
Writer(s): John Shiban.

Original Airdate: October 25, 2005.

kakihara1 10-25-05 11:12 AM

Lorenzol you get bonus points for posting this every week even thought nobody watches it.

This show is fucking awesome. I'll be watching....nuff said, oh and plus it got Xander's seal of approval and that's enough for me :D

I've only missed one episode so far and that was beyond my control, I don't understand why people aren't tuning in, the show is fun. They can do urban legends for years hell a couple weeks ago a buddy and me were talking about it and started naming all the urban legends we could think of "The Hook" was on the list :)

boogieman03 10-25-05 11:14 AM

This one from last week's previews looks to be pretty damn good.

MEJHarrison 10-25-05 11:53 AM


Originally Posted by kakihara1
Lorenzol you get bonus points for posting this every week even thought nobody watches it.

I might be quiet around here, but I certainly wouldn't call me a nobody. :sad:

garmonbozia 10-25-05 12:47 PM


Originally Posted by kakihara1
Lorenzol you get bonus points for posting this every week even thought nobody watches it.

I watch every week, haven't missed an episode.
Ok, so I watch TAR live and tape this.....but I still watch it every week.

Chew 10-25-05 12:58 PM

It's the not first priority of the timeslot, but I watch it without fail.

kakihara1 10-25-05 02:05 PM

It's the only thing I watch on Tuesday nights, but I still record it; I record everything commercials drive me insane.

MEJHarrison YOU ARE SOMEBODY!!! don't forget that ;)

I'm not trying to say that this show is some serious drama or anything, it's just damn fun TV.

GameGenie 10-25-05 04:33 PM

I love this show, i watch every week. Anyways this episode looks and sounds really cool.

kenage 10-25-05 06:13 PM

I tape it every week and watch it later. It is a fun show that lets you relax from a hard day at work.

LorenzoL 10-25-05 08:34 PM


Originally Posted by kakihara1
Lorenzol you get bonus points for posting this every week even thought nobody watches it.

Thanks for the compliment but as indicated above, I think that they are enough people in this forum for me to continue the episodes thread for this show. For now, this is one of my favorite new show of the season.

Unfortunately because of other commitments, I still have to watch last week episode and probably this week too.

Kittydreamer 10-25-05 08:40 PM


Originally Posted by MEJHarrison
I might be quiet around here, but I certainly wouldn't call me a nobody. :sad:

You're not a nobody; you're a tyrant who doesn't let doesn't let your wife open the windows.


;)

TruBuffyFan 10-25-05 09:45 PM

This episode was probably the scariest episode of the season. This show needs another cast member... I am tired of the guys finding a new GF every week and then leaving to get a new one! The plot should continue instead of a new story every week.

Jazzbutcher 10-26-05 08:39 AM

great show.

Daniel-A 10-26-05 10:00 AM

Lots of people watch it. The thread gets more play than you do I bet. I keed.

They are really running out of ideas on the show. I've never even heard of hookman before.

kakihara1 10-26-05 11:11 AM


Originally Posted by Daniel-A
Lots of people watch it. The thread gets more play than you do I bet. I keed.

They are really running out of ideas on the show. I've never even heard of hookman before.

You're kidding right :lol:

MEJHarrison 10-26-05 11:44 AM

Well, I thought it was a great episode once again. This is my second favorite new show this year after Prison Break. And the sound track continues to impress week after week. In fact, after watching last night's episode, I was inspired to dust off my old Boston CD for the drive into work today. :up:

I disagree that this show needs a running story line. With everyone trying to do arc shows now, it's nice to just have a moster of the week type show.

boogieman03 10-26-05 12:06 PM

Probably my favorite episode so far. Really enjoyed this episode, and thought it was actually a little scary. I do like that it is a monster of the week, but I wish they made a little more progress with finding thier dad. Either way, I'm watching this show and having fun.

Daniel-A 10-26-05 12:15 PM

Well no, I wasn't kidding about the hookman bit. Asied from IKWYDLS and Peter Pan I haven't. Guess the hookman urban legend isn't cool enough to run around my parts. :D

crankyman 10-26-05 06:38 PM

liking this show more and more......this episode had some good scares in it.

def. heard of the hookman before. great story to tell when camping......boo!

IdgIe49 10-26-05 08:27 PM

I have to watch it on Saturday or Sunday (I forget at the moment) because my Fox turns in to the WB after 9 but because of Baseball it pushes the shows on the WB back a few hours. In which case, Im asleep. Sux0rz

But I watch this show when I can.

Chew 10-27-05 06:02 AM

Watching this show is an education. We'll all know how to handle various urban legends if it ever becomes necessary. ;)

Edit: Bulldog as clergy. :lol:

rfduncan 10-27-05 09:43 AM


Originally Posted by boogieman03
Probably my favorite episode so far. Really enjoyed this episode, and thought it was actually a little scary. I do like that it is a monster of the week, but I wish they made a little more progress with finding thier dad. Either way, I'm watching this show and having fun.

I would imagine they're staying "Monster of the Week" for now until November sweeps. That would make sense. The previous week's episode about the shape-shifter (Dean is jealous of Sam) combined with the "college dorm" stuff this one contained is likely to be building up to something. It is very subtle but there is an arc to some degree.

I'm thinking as some point they're going to need to explain from where their financing is coming. They got a parking ticket this week and gasoline ain't free!

Unfortunately, I too usually have to wait until Sunday to record this show. So I don't usually get to post in this thread b/c it is always a moot point. By the time *I* get to watch the episode, the new one has usually already aired! But I AM watching!!!!

hongkongdvd 10-27-05 10:40 AM


Originally Posted by rfduncan
I'm thinking as some point they're going to need to explain from where their financing is coming. They got a parking ticket this week and gasoline ain't free!

They explained in one of the earlier episodes that they apply for credit cards under false names and use the cards until the credit card company catches on.

Also, Dean plays poker to get cash.

Daniel-A 10-27-05 01:38 PM


Originally Posted by hongkongdvd
They explained in one of the earlier episodes that they apply for credit cards under false names and use the cards until the credit card company catches on.

Also, Dean plays poker to get cash.

What he said. Though I think the poker part was more of a rarity than the CC fraud.

bboisvert 10-27-05 01:58 PM

... and I suspect that the ain't gonna pay that ticket. :)

Damed 10-27-05 02:28 PM

This is the best new show this year, and I watch it whenever possible. This and LOST are the only 2 shows I follow.

DeadLamb 10-27-05 09:20 PM


Originally Posted by Daniel-A
Well no, I wasn't kidding about the hookman bit. Asied from IKWYDLS and Peter Pan I haven't.

Ya but I'm sure you have heard the story that played out in the ep of the girl who hears something, but then goes to sleep anyways.. only to wake up to a dead room mate and "I bet your glad you did not turn on the lights" on the wall next to her..

pretty much can plug in any old boogie man into that story line.. I'm also not really sure I have ever heard of a guy with a hook. Then again I too am in california and I think all our boogie man stories as kids just star your plain old run of the mill psycho.. hehe None of that fancy hooked handed blah blah stuff

As for the show, I find it sort of funny that a new show like Supernatural has a really good mix of horror + some humor in it.. Sort of like the old eps of Night Stalker do.. Only to then have a new modern version of Night Stalker get that mix totaly wrong, maybe even to the point of having next to no humor in the first place.. Oh they have LOTS of talk talk talk talk in some dark office but not much else. Sort of strange really, as if Supernatural is a better remake of Night Stalker theme wise then the real remake is, IMO of course.

AGuyNamedMike 10-28-05 07:35 AM


Originally Posted by DeadLamb
As for the show, I find it sort of funny that a new show like Supernatural has a really good mix of horror + some humor in it.. Sort of like the old eps of Night Stalker do.. Only to then have a new modern version of Night Stalker get that mix totaly wrong, maybe even to the point of having next to no humor in the first place.. Oh they have LOTS of talk talk talk talk in some dark office but not much else. Sort of strange really, as if Supernatural is a better remake of Night Stalker theme wise then the real remake is, IMO of course.


:up: I agree.

rfduncan 10-28-05 07:38 AM


Originally Posted by hongkongdvd
They explained in one of the earlier episodes that they apply for credit cards under false names and use the cards until the credit card company catches on.

Okay - I remember Dean saying that when he had a home base to return to in the beginning. However, they now seem to be on an extended road-trip with no mailing address. How can this method of credit card scamming continue to work? I mean they'd need 4-6 weeks after applying to get a new card, no?

dhmac 10-28-05 08:19 AM

This was the first episode I've watched of the show, and it was fairly good. I'd add it to my DVR, but its Tuesday timeslot is terrible because there are already (IMO) better shows on at the same time: My Name Is Earl + The Office. Also on at this time is Commander in Chief (which I don't watch but may start because everyone at work does). WB does repeat it on Sundays, but that timeslot has Family Guy + American Dad as well as Desperate Housewives in it.

So until WB puts Supernatural on in a different timeslot, I'll miss it until these other shows are showing reruns or being preempted.

rfduncan 10-28-05 08:29 AM


Originally Posted by dhmac
So until WB puts Supernatural on in a different timeslot, I'll miss it until these other shows are showing reruns or being preempted.

Every episode is re-aired the following Sunday.

Chew 10-28-05 08:30 AM


Originally Posted by rfduncan
Every episode is re-aired the following Sunday.

Apparently, his affiliate runs it against other shows on Sunday:


Originally Posted by dhmac
WB does repeat it on Sundays, but that timeslot has Family Guy + American Dad as well as Desperate Housewives in it.

Mine repeats at 4:00 :)

rfduncan 10-28-05 08:33 AM


Originally Posted by Chew
Apparently, his affiliate runs it against other shows on Sunday:

Mine repeats at 4:00 :)

Oh - mine too. Didn't realize it re-ran in the primetime slots elsewhere. Lame.

Xander 11-04-05 09:53 AM


Originally Posted by kakihara1
Lorenzol you get bonus points for posting this every week even thought nobody watches it.

This show is fucking awesome. I'll be watching....nuff said, oh and plus it got Xander's seal of approval and that's enough for me :D

I've only missed one episode so far and that was beyond my control, I don't understand why people aren't tuning in, the show is fun. They can do urban legends for years hell a couple weeks ago a buddy and me were talking about it and started naming all the urban legends we could think of "The Hook" was on the list :)

:blush: You're too kind. :)

Didn't get to watch this until last night. Cool ep! Still loving this show.

Daniel-A - can't BELIEVE you have never heard of the hook man. The guy hanging over the car, and the "aren't you glad you didn't turn on the light" urban legends are like two of the most famous ones I know, especially in the college environment. I liked how they addressed both. Still a great soundtrack, and they are still at least mentioning their dad in every ep, even though I am liking the monster of the week format, for now.

Yeah, I'm still tuning in. Haven't missed an ep yet. Haven't not liked one either, for that matter. :)

I try not to think about how they're getting the funds to travel around the country. :)

cajun_junky 11-04-05 01:22 PM

I love the show and record every episode and watch it later without commercials.

bboisvert 11-04-05 01:54 PM


Originally Posted by Xander
I try not to think about how they're getting the funds to travel around the country. :)

They addressed that in the first episode -- through credit card scams. Not the most solid of plot devices, but they at least thought to mention it.

Xander 11-07-05 10:27 AM


Originally Posted by bboisvert
They addressed that in the first episode -- through credit card scams. Not the most solid of plot devices, but they at least thought to mention it.

Right, but as someone above pointed out, now that they are traveling the country, not living in the same place long enough to set up a mail box, unless they got a LOT of credit cards set up before they left, they should be hurting for money by now. Anyway, I don't really think about it during the show, so it's not enough to really bug me. Just a little nitpick. :)

SonOfAStu 03-30-06 08:54 AM

I had also never really heard this particular urban legend. Went to college in the midwest. Now that I think about it, we never really paid much attention to ANY urban legends except of course the black market kidney scam.

Anyway, I get why the hookman went after her date and her dad, but the roommate didn't make sense. She wasn't really being immoral. Also, when she got back to her house the night the roommate was killed, weren't they supposed to be taking tequila shots and watching movies?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:31 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.