TV Talk Best Ever Tournament: Round 3
 

Haven't seen the other thread? No big deal, just vote for which of the two shows you think has a better claim to "Best Ever" television show.

Let's have this round stop, let's say, Friday at midnight. That way we can use the weekend for the Sweet 16.

THE THIRD ROUND

BRACKET 1
8 The Shield vs 1 Sopranos
5 Law and Order vs 4 The West Wing
6 Hill Street Blues vs 3 NYPD Blue
7 The Wire vs 2 Six Feet Under

BRACKET 2
8 Farscape vs 1 Buffy the Vampire Slayer
5 Babylon 5 vs 4 Angel
11 Star Trek vs 3 Twin Peaks
10 The Twilight Zone (original) vs 2 The X-Files

BRACKET 3
8 Arrested Development vs 1 Seinfeld
5 The Dick Van Dyke Show vs 4 Cheers
11 Frasier vs 3 MASH
10 Friends vs 2 All in the Family

BRACKET 4
9 South Park vs 1 The Simpsons
5 The Office vs 4 Saturday Night Live
14 Monty Python vs 6 Sports Night
7 Absolutely Fabulous vs 2 The Wonder Years

BRACKET 1
8 The Shield
4 The West Wing
2 Six Feet Under

BRACKET 2
1 Buffy the Vampire Slayer
3 Twin Peaks
10 The Twilight Zone (original)

BRACKET 3
1 Seinfeld
10 Friends

BRACKET 4
9 South Park
2 The Wonder Years

Bracket 1
The West Wing
Six Feet Under

Bracket 2
Farscape
Babylon 5
Star Trek
Twilight Zone

Bracket 3
Arrested Development
Cheers
Frasier
Friends

Bracket 4
The Simpsons
The Office
Sports Night
Absolutely Fabulous

THE THIRD ROUND

BRACKET 1
4 The West Wing
6 Hill Street Blues

BRACKET 2
1 Buffy the Vampire Slayer
11 Star Trek
10 The Twilight Zone (original)

BRACKET 3
1 Seinfeld
5 The Dick Van Dyke Show
3 MASH
2 All in the Family

BRACKET 4
1 The Simpsons
4 Saturday Night Live
14 Monty Python
7 Absolutely Fabulous

BRACKET 1
The Shield
The West Wing
NYPD Blue
The Wire

BRACKET 2
Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Babylon 5
Twin Peaks
The X-Files

BRACKET 3
Seinfeld
Cheers
MASH
All in the Family

BRACKET 4
The Simpsons
The Office
Sports Night
The Wonder Years

THE THIRD ROUND

BRACKET 1
8 The Shield vs 1 Sopranos
5 Law and Order vs 4 The West Wing
6 Hill Street Blues vs 3 NYPD Blue
7 The Wire vs 2 Six Feet Under

BRACKET 2
8 Farscape vs 1 Buffy the Vampire Slayer
5 Babylon 5 vs 4 Angel
11 Star Trek vs 3 Twin Peaks
10 The Twilight Zone (original) vs 2 The X-Files

BRACKET 3
8 Arrested Development vs 1 Seinfeld
5 The Dick Van Dyke Show vs 4 Cheers
11 Frasier vs 3 MASH
10 Friends vs 2 All in the Family

BRACKET 4
9 South Park vs 1 The Simpsons
5 The Office vs 4 Saturday Night Live
14 Monty Python vs 6 Sports Night
7 Absolutely Fabulous vs 2 The Wonder Years

THE THIRD ROUND

BRACKET 1
8 <b>The Shield</b> vs 1 Sopranos
5 <b>Law and Order</b> vs 4 The West Wing
7 <b>The Wire</b> vs 2 Six Feet Under

BRACKET 2
10 <b>The Twilight Zone (original)</b> vs 2 The X-Files

BRACKET 3
8 Arrested Development vs 1 <b>Seinfeld</b>
5 The Dick Van Dyke Show vs 4 <b>Cheers</b>
11 Frasier vs 3 <b>MASH</b>
10 Friends vs 2 <b>All in the Family</b>

BRACKET 4
9 South Park vs 1 <b>The Simpsons</b>
7 Absolutely Fabulous vs 2 <b>The Wonder Years</b>

My votes are in bold:

BRACKET 1
8 The Shield vs 1 Sopranos
5 Law and Order vs 4 The West Wing
6 Hill Street Blues vs 3 NYPD Blue
7 The Wire vs 2 Six Feet Under

BRACKET 2
8 Farscape vs 1 Buffy the Vampire Slayer
5 Babylon 5 vs 4 Angel
11 Star Trek vs 3 Twin Peaks
10 The Twilight Zone (original) vs 2 The X-Files

BRACKET 3
8 Arrested Development vs 1 Seinfeld
5 The Dick Van Dyke Show vs 4 Cheers
11 Frasier vs 3 MASH
10 Friends vs 2 All in the Family

BRACKET 4
9 South Park vs 1 The Simpsons
5 The Office vs 4 Saturday Night Live
14 Monty Python vs 6 Sports Night
7 Absolutely Fabulous vs 2 The Wonder Years

(I didn't vote in match-ups where I've never seen either show)

BRACKET 1
1 Sopranos
5 Law and Order
6 Hill Street Blues
2 Six Feet Under

BRACKET 2
N/A
N/A
11 Star Trek
2 The X-Files

BRACKET 3
8 Arrested Development
4 Cheers
3 MASH
2 All in the Family

BRACKET 4
1 The Simpsons
4 Saturday Night Live
14 Monty Python
2 The Wonder Years

BRACKET 1
1 Sopranos
5 Law and Order
6 Hill Street Blues
2 Six Feet Under

BRACKET 2
1 Buffy the Vampire Slayer
4 Angel
3 Twin Peaks
10 The Twilight Zone (original)

BRACKET 3
1 Seinfeld
4 Cheers
11 Frasier
2 All in the Family

BRACKET 4
1 The Simpsons
5 The Office
6 Sports Night
2 The Wonder Years

RACKET 1
8 The Shield vs 1 Sopranos
5 Law and Order vs 4 The West Wing
6 Hill Street Blues vs 3 NYPD Blue
7 The Wire vs 2 Six Feet Under

BRACKET 2
8 Farscape vs 1 Buffy the Vampire Slayer
5 Babylon 5 vs 4 Angel
11 Star Trek vs 3 Twin Peaks
10 The Twilight Zone (original) vs 2 The X-Files

BRACKET 3
8 Arrested Development vs 1 Seinfeld
5 The Dick Van Dyke Show vs 4 Cheers
11 Frasier vs 3 MASH (this was hard, because I like Frasier better)
10 Friends vs 2 All in the Family

BRACKET 4
9 South Park vs 1 The Simpsons
5 The Office vs 4 Saturday Night Live
14 Monty Python vs 6 Sports Night
7 Absolutely Fabulous vs 2 The Wonder Years

THE THIRD ROUND

BRACKET 1
Sopranos
Law and Order
NYPD Blue
Six Feet Under

BRACKET 2
Farscape
Angel
Star Trek
the X-Files

BRACKET 3
Arrested Development
Cheers
MASH
All in the Family

BRACKET 4
the Simpsons
the Office
Monty Python
the Wonder Years

BRACKET 1
8 The Shield vs 1 Sopranos
5 Law and Order vs 4 The West Wing
6 Hill Street Blues vs 3 NYPD Blue - abstain since I'm not really knowledgable about HSB
7 The Wire vs 2 Six Feet Under

BRACKET 2
8 Farscape vs 1 Buffy the Vampire Slayer
5 Babylon 5 vs 4 Angel
11 Star Trek vs 3 Twin Peaks
10 The Twilight Zone (original) vs 2 The X-Files

BRACKET 3
8 Arrested Development vs 1 Seinfeld
5 The Dick Van Dyke Show vs 4 Cheers
11 Frasier vs 3 MASH
10 Friends vs 2 All in the Family

BRACKET 4
9 South Park vs 1 The Simpsons - Recent Simpsons seasons have made me think less and less of the show.
5 The Office vs 4 Saturday Night Live - Which office?
14 Monty Python vs 6 Sports Night - Unfair to MP with all the SN fans on this forum.
7 Absolutely Fabulous vs 2 The Wonder Years

Glad to see this up and running again, though I almost think it should start over.

Edit: just noticed it actually did start over while I wasn't looking. Maybe the 1st post should have links to the previous posts?

THE THIRD ROUND

BRACKET 1
1 Sopranos
5 Law and Order
3 NYPD Blue
2 Six Feet Under

BRACKET 2
1 Buffy the Vampire Slayer
5 Babylon
11 Star Trek
2 The X-Files

BRACKET 3
1 Seinfeld
5 The Dick Van Dyke Show
11 Frasier
10 Friends

BRACKET 4
1 The Simpsons
4 Saturday Night Live
6 Sports Night
2 The Wonder Years

THE THIRD ROUND

BRACKET 1
8 The Shield vs 1 Sopranos
5 Law and Order vs 4 The West Wing
6 Hill Street Blues vs 3 NYPD Blue
7 The Wire vs 2 Six Feet Under

BRACKET 2
8 Farscape vs 1 Buffy the Vampire Slayer OUCH! hard choice :(
5 Babylon 5 vs 4 Angel
11 Star Trek vs 3 Twin Peaks
10 The Twilight Zone (original) vs 2 The X-Files even harder!! i'd probably change my mind back and forth depending on what day it is and what mood i am in.

BRACKET 3
8 Arrested Development vs 1 Seinfeld
5 The Dick Van Dyke Show vs 4 Cheers
11 Frasier vs 3 MASH
10 Friends vs 2 All in the Family

BRACKET 4
9 South Park vs 1 The Simpsons
5 The Office vs 4 Saturday Night Live
14 Monty Python vs 6 Sports Night
7 Absolutely Fabulous vs 2 The Wonder Years

BRACKET 1
8 The Shield vs 1 Sopranos
5 Law and Order vs 4 [/b]The West Wing[/b]
6 Hill Street Blues vs 3 NYPD Blue
7 The Wire vs 2 Six Feet Under

BRACKET 2
8 Farscape vs 1 Buffy the Vampire Slayer
5 Babylon 5 vs 4 Angel
11 Star Trek vs 3 Twin Peaks
10 The Twilight Zone (original) vs 2 The X-Files

BRACKET 3
8 Arrested Development vs 1 Seinfeld
5 The Dick Van Dyke Show vs 4 Cheers
11 Frasier vs 3 MASH
10 Friends vs 2 All in the Family

BRACKET 4
9 South Park vs 1 The Simpsons
5 The Office vs 4 Saturday Night Live
14 Monty Python vs 6 Sports Night
7 Absolutely Fabulous vs 2 The Wonder Years

BRACKET 1
8 The Shield vs 1 Sopranos
5 Law and Order vs 4 The West Wing
6 Hill Street Blues vs 3 NYPD Blue
7 The Wire vs 2 Six Feet Under

BRACKET 2
8 Farscape vs 1 Buffy the Vampire Slayer
5 Babylon 5 vs 4 Angel
11 Star Trek vs 3 Twin Peaks
10 The Twilight Zone (original) vs 2 The X-Files

BRACKET 3
8 Arrested Development vs 1 Seinfeld
5 The Dick Van Dyke Show vs 4 Cheers
11 Frasier vs 3 MASH
10 Friends vs 2 All in the Family

BRACKET 4
9 South Park vs 1 The Simpsons
5 The Office vs 4 Saturday Night Live
14 Monty Python vs 6 Sports Night
7 Absolutely Fabulous vs 2 The Wonder Years

BRACKET 1
1 Sopranos
5 Law and Order
6 Hill Street Blues
2 Six Feet Under

BRACKET 2
1 Buffy the Vampire Slayer
4 Angel
3 Twin Peaks
2 The X-Files

BRACKET 3
8 Arrested Development
4 Cheers
11 Frasier
2 All in the Family

BRACKET 4
1 The Simpsons
5 The Office
14 Monty Python
2 The Wonder Years

Only voting on shows I've watched with any regularity...

THE THIRD ROUND

BRACKET 1
8 The Shield vs 1 Sopranos
7 The Wire vs 2 Six Feet Under

BRACKET 2
8 Farscape vs 1 Buffy the Vampire Slayer
5 Babylon 5 vs 4 Angel
11 Star Trek vs 3 Twin Peaks
10 The Twilight Zone (original) vs 2 The X-Files

BRACKET 3
8 Arrested Development vs 1 Seinfeld
5 The Dick Van Dyke Show vs 4 Cheers
11 Frasier vs 3 MASH
10 Friends vs 2 All in the Family

BRACKET 4
9 South Park vs 1 The Simpsons
7 Absolutely Fabulous vs 2 The Wonder Years

BRACKET 1
8 The Shield
5 Law and Order
6 Hill Street Blues


BRACKET 2
1 Buffy the Vampire Slayer
4 Angel
11 Star Trek
10 The Twilight Zone (original)

BRACKET 3
1 Seinfeld
4 Cheers
3 MASH
10 Friends

BRACKET 4
1 The Simpsons
4 Saturday Night Live
14 Monty Python
2 The Wonder Years

BRACKET 1
8 The Shield
5 Law and Order
3 NYPD Blue
2 Six Feet Under

BRACKET 2
1 Buffy the Vampire Slayer
4 Angel
3 Twin Peaks
2 The X-Files

BRACKET 3
1 Seinfeld
4 Cheers
11 Frasier
10 Friends

BRACKET 4
1 The Simpsons
4 Saturday Night Live
14 Monty Python
2 The Wonder Years

Bracket 3
Seinfeld

Bracket 4
The Simpsons

BRACKET 1

Sopranos
The West Wing
Hill Street Blues
Six Feet Under

BRACKET 2

Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Angel
Twin Peaks
The Twilight Zone

BRACKET 3

Seinfeld
The Dick Van Dyke Show
MASH
All in the Family

BRACKET 4

The Simpsons
Saturday Night Live
Monty Python
The Wonder Years

BRACKET 1
5 Law and Order

BRACKET 2
1 Buffy the Vampire Slayer
5 Babylon 5
11 Star Trek
2 The X-Files

BRACKET 3
1 Seinfeld
5 The Dick Van Dyke Show
11 Frasier
2 All in the Family

BRACKET 4
1 The Simpsons
5 The Office
14 Monty Python
7 Absolutely Fabulous

BRACKET 1
8 The Shield vs 1 Sopranos

7 The Wire vs 2 Six Feet Under

BRACKET 2
8 Farscape vs 1 Buffy the Vampire Slayer
5 Babylon 5 vs 4 Angel
11 Star Trek vs 3 Twin Peaks
10 The Twilight Zone (original) vs 2 The X-Files

BRACKET 3
8 Arrested Development vs 1 Seinfeld
11 Frasier vs 3 MASH
10 Friends vs 2 All in the Family

BRACKET 4
9 South Park vs 1 The Simpsons
5 The Office vs 4 Saturday Night Live