DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Geek-off! Marshall vs. Chloe! (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/421283-geek-off-marshall-vs-chloe.html)

Chew 05-05-05 06:08 AM

Marshall, hands down.

cliffzig 05-05-05 08:53 AM

Not as lopsided as I thought it might be, but Chloe managed to pull down a few votes. I think it might have something to do with being a semi-hot chick (hey, I'd hit it!) who can brandish a machine gun. Plays to a lot of possible fantasy scenarios...

areacode212 05-05-05 09:00 AM

I'd also hit it...especially at the beginning of the season, when she was wearing more makeup and nicer clothes than she had last year :hump: Marshall can't compete in that area.

B.A. 05-05-05 10:31 AM

"It's a digital camera. I have it at 42 exposures, but I wanna get it to 47 because... it's a prime number."

"I think I just got Hepatitis."

"They're super-swank."

"That sound that you're- you know, that 'boom'? That's my mind blowing."

"I don't know. I think it was "Go away I can smell you from here" in Ewok."

"My name is Marshall J. Flinkman, and I'm here to rescue you."

Red Dog 05-05-05 10:41 AM

None of the above.

I'd take Mike Cannon from The Montecito. Plus he could park my car.

Tscott 05-05-05 11:21 AM

So as a viewer who bailed after the dismal Season 2 of 24 (the cheap cliffhanger with the president was the final straw) but have liked Mary Lynn Rajskub in comedy sketch shows and Punch Drunk Love, would seasons 3 and 4 be worth giving another chance just to see her as Chole, or would I be rolling my eyes and tearing my hair out at the plot like I did with much of season 2?

Anyway, I guess my answer would be Marshall right now, by default. The Marshall centric episodes of Alias have been some of my favorite episodes of that show.

das Monkey 05-05-05 11:44 AM


Tscott

So as a viewer who bailed after the dismal Season 2 of 24 (the cheap cliffhanger with the president was the final straw) but have liked Mary Lynn Rajskub in comedy sketch shows and Punch Drunk Love, would seasons 3 and 4 be worth giving another chance just to see her as Chole, or would I be rolling my eyes and tearing my hair out at the plot like I did with much of season 2?

Chloe's unintentionally funny. Her character is so annoying and obnoxious that we all laugh at it, and so in some sick way, she's become a fan favorite. It's really twisted, but in a show where nearly every character is a bland puppet, brooding and whispering at the speed of plot, she is a welcome departure from the norm. To answer your question, though, if you thought Season 2's ridiculous plot was painful, you'd be best to stay away from 3 and 4.

das

Shannon Nutt 05-05-05 11:45 AM

I voted for Chloe because she'd have no problem telling co-workers what a horrible job they're doing. Plus, of the two, she's the one I'd most like making a visit to my office. :)

Dimension X 05-05-05 01:40 PM


Originally Posted by Kal-El
Actually, if you're going to throw NCIS in the mix, it'd be "Probie" Murphy.

I'm pretty sure his name is McGee, not Murphy.

Another vote for Marshall.

Brain Stew 05-05-05 01:45 PM

I don't watch Alias or 24, but I'd like to vote for Chloe since Mary-Lynn Rajskub is hilarious and dated David Cross for quite some time :)!

the big train 05-05-05 02:18 PM

Two words: Black Kitty

Bandoman 05-05-05 03:21 PM

Definitely Marshall: because Vaughn invited him to lunch!

Kal-El 05-05-05 03:45 PM


Originally Posted by Dimension X
I'm pretty sure his name is McGee, not Murphy.

Another vote for Marshall.

Thanks. I was half asleep when I answered and a little voice inside me was saying I got it wrong the whole time. Edited to reflect correct name.

Doughboy 05-05-05 06:20 PM

Marshall hands down. He's not only Chloe's equal as a computer geek, but he could also give Q(Bond, not TNG) a run for his money as far as inventing gadgets. Plus the Alias episodes with him in the field are always classic:

(in a cheesy English accent)"If it ain't Baroque, don't fix it!"

FredC 05-06-05 09:55 AM

Marshall seems like a much more well rounded character, he's got the technical skills, the ability to make stuff, has been in the field more.

Chloe is a little wishy washy. Granted she's stuck by Jack but she questions everything and is annoying to no end.

Michael Corvin 05-06-05 11:55 AM

For tech support? Marshall? Come On! He is a pretty cool character, but if you need something on the fly Chloe can get it instantaneously. Not only that, she can open a socket and give you a live sat feed directly to your palm in 30 seconds flat. Not only that she doesn't take shit from nobody. "I'm not watching your baby!" Marshall seems to be a push-over(I've only seen season 1).

If I needed a gadget, I would call marshall. If I needed tech support, definitely chloe.

Zwerchfell 03-20-06 02:29 AM

Marshall annoyed me to tears especially in the first two seasons therefore my vote goes to Chloe. She rocks!

magiccmom 03-20-06 09:10 AM

Didnt Marshall take out some guys eye with a spork? Now that's bad ass! :bow:

Slayer2005 03-20-06 09:15 AM


Originally Posted by magiccmom
Didnt Marshall take out some guys eye with a spork? Now that's bad ass! :bow:

Yep! He failed the first time though. :lol:

Jack Bristow had to give him better directions the second time around. He basically told him he had to treat it like a soft boiled egg when removing it. :lol:

Phil L. 03-20-06 09:31 AM

Although I'm a huge Chloe fan, I STILL gotta go with goth Abby from NCIS.
Last week she was wearing a short plaid schoolgirl type skirt. :drool:

Lara Means 03-21-06 10:03 PM

Marshall is a badass field agent.

HE Pennypacker 03-21-06 11:34 PM

Chloe rules. The other dude from Alias irritates me with his presence alone.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:09 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.