DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   the WORST talk show hosts. (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/397806-worst-talk-show-hosts.html)

mersaulte 11-27-04 08:05 PM

the WORST talk show hosts.
 
So who's the absolute worst? The ones that make you cringe, the ones that make you fling your remote at the television, the ones that are so bad you're embarrassed for them?

mersaulte 11-27-04 08:09 PM

Carson has the personality of a piece of carpet lint, and his vapid stare is so blank it gives me chills.

wmansir 11-27-04 08:39 PM

The only one I have never seen is Tony Danza, who I imagine is horrible but will give the benefit of the doubt.

Voted Carson. He has the boring, obvious brown-nosing style of Leno without even the lame whitebread humor to make it less pathetic.

mersaulte 11-27-04 08:43 PM

Danza is of the "embarrassing" variety. It's really sad.

Maury is trying to turn into Springer. I remember when he used to do "real" shows. Now they're all babymamadramas.

das Monkey 11-27-04 08:53 PM

I saw Carson interviewing someone a few weeks back. I can't remember who it was right now, but I remember him confusing the actress with another actress once and then later asking a question based on obviously inaccurate rumor. It was pretty funny in a "I can't believe this clown is on TV" kind of way. The actress, however, didn't find it funny one bit.

das

The Infidel 11-27-04 09:32 PM

This must be about current talk show hosts, because I couldn't help but notice the omission of choices like Rikki Lake, Donny & Marie, Howie Mandel, Wayne Brady, Magic Johnson...and perhaps who I would consider the worst, Chevy Chase.

B.A. 11-27-04 09:46 PM

Jay Leno.

Lara Means 11-27-04 10:14 PM

http://www.howard.edu/schoolcommunic...Johnson175.jpg

Who can forget Fox's The "Tragic" Hour?

Alyoshka 11-27-04 11:45 PM

For my tastes it's Jay Leno

RoQuEr 11-27-04 11:56 PM

connie Chung

Roto 11-28-04 12:34 AM

I went with Jay because Carson will admit to being a tool. I'm also grading on a curve. I think Jay is the least deserving of his show's stature.

Oprah can make me cringe, but she absolutely earned her success. Maury on the other hand, I have no idea how he has stayed on the air this long, outlasting so many other daytime clones.

I'm hoping Jimmy Kimmel and Ellen Degeneres are around for the long haul. I don't think Ellen has to worry about getting cancelled. I don't know what kind of ratings Kimmel gets, probably not good, but I think they've managed to come up with a lot of original ideas. When I first saw that everyone working on the show was an old buddy or family member of Jimmy I thought it would be a disaster, but it's actually a useful tool for them to humiliate each other with :lol:

RandyC 11-28-04 12:35 AM

Jay Leno. I want to like him. He represents LA, car guys.... but I cringe when watching him. I keep thinking "does he think all of his audience is that stupid?"

Frank TJ Mackey 11-28-04 12:54 AM

OK, I understand that a lot of people don't like Jay Leno, but come on people, Leno IS NOT worse than Carson Daly.

NBC should just bite the bullet and give Conan 90 minutes instead of wasting airtime with Daly.

MJG87 11-28-04 01:15 AM

Carson Daly gets worse and worse every night, the monologue's are far worst than Leno's. And whoever votes Conan, I'll hunt you down!

mersaulte 11-28-04 01:21 AM

Conan rules all. And after all these years, he's still getting funnier.

Carson's monologue... his "jokes" fall so flat you can hear crickets chirping. He's got to be the most bland host of any show, ever. His interviews are so awkward. The guests almost seem to act like they feel they have to help him somehow. He needs to go back to Mtv where he doesn't have to say much more than "Here's Eminem's new video..."

calhoun07 11-28-04 01:29 AM

I voted for Carson as well. The guy just has no likeable TV persona to me. Hell, even if I don't like Danza, I can still say the guy has his own distinct TV persona.

For those not on the list, those of the past, what about Alan Thicke? Anybody remember his show Thicke of the Night? God, that was so awful, when he left that for Growing Pains, I didn't watch Growing Pains for a few years because I was convinced the suckiness of Alan Thicke on his talk show would transfer over into his sitcom. Of course, once I started to watch Growing Pains, I loved the show and learned to like the guy again.

And for one not on the list who actually surprised me with his talk show talents is Tom Green. While the Tom Green Show wasn't the best of late night TV, I felt the guy really had a good on screen persona and really made his interviews interesting. Most talk shows I will turn off if the guests don't interest me because I don't find the host interesting enough to keep watching (like Leno) but Tom Green made his show interesting, no matter who he was interviewing. I keep hoping he makes a come back. The Late Late Show needs a new host still, no?

edit: Curiously, IMDB lists Alan's show as "The Alan Thicke Show" but it was called Thicke of the Night. Unless he had another show I didn't know about. But even Jump The Shark comments that Thicke of the Night was the worst talk show ever.
http://www.jumptheshark.com/t/thickeofthenight.htm

mersaulte 11-28-04 01:36 AM

Oh, I LOVE Tom Green!! I don't know if he could ever tame it down to regular network level, though... but yes, that would be great. He cracks me up so, so bad. Him, and Andy Dick.

Unfortunately I do remember the Alan Thicke thing.

I think the poll thingy said I was limited to ten choices, so it just had to be current hosts. Otherwise there were a few more I would have included, some memorably horrid, like Thicke, or Howie Mandel. (And I love Howie, but his show sucked.) (Oh, and Carnie. I think her show was on for like, what, three weeks before it was canned.)

calhoun07 11-28-04 01:42 AM


Originally posted by mersaulte
Oh, I LOVE Tom Green!! I don't know if he could ever tame it down to regular network level, though... but yes, that would be great. He cracks me up so, so bad. Him, and Andy Dick.

I don't know...I don't recall too much wild stuff on the Tom Green Show, the talk show, not his man on the street stuff. I thought that was one reason the show didn't last on MTV, because people were turning the show on to see him act like an ass and he was trying to make an attempt at a genuine talk show. I heard he even got to guest host for Letterman, though unfortunately I missed that episode, but he got a ton of great reviews for his show and even the attention of Ed McMahon. I just hope he can resurface in that genre again, because I thought he had something going and if he polished his talk show persona some more, he could be a major player on late night TV if he plays his cards right.

mersaulte 11-28-04 01:47 AM

You're right, and I do remember that he was trying to bring it way down, and I was so disappointed when his last effort didn't last. But there were some pretty iffy things on that show too. The only thing that comes to mind is their road trip and finding like, a deer head or something on the side of the road, and Tom holding it up to the camera and being silly. It was pretty gross. He does have the capacity to curtail that, though, if he really wants to. Maybe over the next few years his time in the more mainstream type media will come. Hope so. (But I love his goofy gross-out stuff.)

DrRingDing 11-28-04 10:03 AM

i think we might have a definitive winner. he's up by 8 votes over leno and leno himself is 5 in front of the next closest. the exit polling suggests that carson will win this one handily.

Deftones 11-28-04 10:23 AM

My vote is for Richard Bay.

Fok 11-28-04 10:43 AM

David Letterman puts me to sleep.

Me007gold 11-28-04 12:47 PM

its a close call between carson daily and craig killborn(daily show was good, the late late show wasnt)

Rivero 11-29-04 04:10 AM

Jay Leno. I can't see how anyone can possibly laugh at anything this man has to say. His show is perfect for dumb 'Middle America' who can't comprehend really comedy talent.

mullivan 11-29-04 09:11 AM

I voted for Carson. I caught some of his show last week and you could just sense the audience turning against him about 2 minutes into his monologe. It's like I could feel the hatred building inside the audience for Carson wasting their time with a crappy show. Amazing.

peon73 11-29-04 09:50 AM

pat sajak had a show for a bit. my god, it was terrible. almost as bad as chevy chase.
vibe w/sinbad was also pretty short-lived, thank god.

David_M 11-29-04 10:01 AM


Originally posted by peon73
pat sajak had a show for a bit. my god, it was terrible. almost as bad as chevy chase.
vibe w/sinbad was also pretty short-lived, thank god.

I was just going to say him. I remember watching the first episode and falling asleep 15 minutes into it;) Never watched it again, he should stick to telling people to pick a letter.

Jadzia 11-29-04 11:20 AM

I voted for Danza, but Carson Daly was beckoning for me as well.

The current talk show I really hate though is the Jane Pauley show. Mostly because I am at home during the day, and it comes on between Regis and The View.

Her show is just so boring and lacking in focus.

GuessWho 11-29-04 11:45 AM


Originally posted by Rivero
His show is perfect for dumb 'Middle America' who can't comprehend really comedy talent.
...or for those who can't use the word "really" correctly.

Shady12 11-30-04 01:40 AM

Wow, Carson Daly does a monologue now?? I haven't watched his show in a LONG time obviously. What business does someone who isn't funny have telling jokes on TV?

Kal-El 11-30-04 02:30 AM

Conan.

TheKing 11-30-04 08:29 AM

I like Maury. His show is still halway decent, even if 90% of them are paternity test shows.

DJLinus 11-30-04 09:31 AM

I watched almost a full episode of John McEnroe's talk show last night and it was painful.

I was going to say that I couldn't believe no one mentioned him yet, but then I remembered that one ratings report where McEnroe's show pulled a 0 share. No one's watching.

I'm glad to say that Dennis Miller's show has gotten a lot better than when he first started it on CNBC. He seems more comfortable.

resinrats 11-30-04 11:45 AM

O'brien. Way too many of his jokes just get dead silence. There have been some hillarious stuff but the lame/dead jokes just take away from his overall position.

Rogue588 11-30-04 02:28 PM

:hscratch:

You sure you don't mean Carson? Or perhaps Leno?

That was the dilemma that I faced since we couldn't select more than one shitty host. However, since Carson's jokes aren't anywhere near funny [not that Leno's much better], I chose him. He also edged out Jay where interviewing was concerned. Carson has no style. Period.

How he got that show is beyond comprehension.

Rogue588 11-30-04 02:29 PM


Originally posted by Shady12
Wow, Carson Daly does a monologue now??
Yep. Even got a desk too!

djbrown 11-30-04 03:00 PM


Originally posted by DJLinus
I watched almost a full episode of John McEnroe's talk show last night.

so you're the one. I was hoping to met that person at some point.

Ginwen 11-30-04 04:01 PM

I voted Carson Daly-he just seems clueless as a talkshow host.

The other ones I considered:
Tony Danza-got serious consideration, but I've never actually seen it.

Maury Povich-definitely cringeworthy in the big emotional moments, but much more watchable (partly for that reason) than Carson Daly. At least Maury doesn't come across as an idiot, he's just in the wrong format.

oprah winfrey-2nd place. I totally don't get this show.

Jadzia 11-30-04 04:36 PM


Originally posted by DJLinus
I watched almost a full episode of John McEnroe's talk show last night and it was painful.
So did Tatum O'Neal go on that show? ;)

She seemed to hit just about every other talk show promoting her book.

clckworang 11-30-04 05:00 PM

I voted for Carson. I have only seen little bits of his show on a couple of occasions but found it astounding how he could be so blah and unfunny.

The other night I left my TV on in the living room while I was working on my computer in the bedroom. I could hear everything from the beginning of the show. What really stuck with me was this prepared segment. It was a "comical" movie trailer for Oceans 12 with critics praising the film even before they watched it. It was painful, enough to get me off my ass and change the channel on the TV. Even more sad, you could tell that the audience found the segment excruciating as well: no applause or laughter.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:05 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.