Lost 10/20/04
#76
Admin Emeritus
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 12,842
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
From: Texas, our Texas! All hail the mighty state!
Originally posted by GuessWho
The joys of being Tivo-less -- I GET TO SEE THE WHOLE SHOW
The joys of being Tivo-less -- I GET TO SEE THE WHOLE SHOW

Originally posted by Jadzia
Did anyone else crave bottled water while watching this episode? I just drank a whole bottle!
Did anyone else crave bottled water while watching this episode? I just drank a whole bottle!
Originally posted by Patman
The shakey-cam was a little much in tonight's episode.
The shakey-cam was a little much in tonight's episode.
Originally posted by DocBrass
did anybody else catch the book that was being read by the slimeball?
is this foreshadowing?
did anybody else catch the book that was being read by the slimeball?
is this foreshadowing?
#77
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 630
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Texas
The island granted another wish
Jack was trying to find his father and he did...well his casket anyway.
Did anyone notice the mistake at the beginning? When Hurley and Charlie run to talk to Jack in the tent, the two extras walk by TWICE behind Jack. You see them walk behind him one time, they cut to Hurley and Jack and then when they cut to Jack again they walk behind him again hehe.
Jack was trying to find his father and he did...well his casket anyway.Did anyone notice the mistake at the beginning? When Hurley and Charlie run to talk to Jack in the tent, the two extras walk by TWICE behind Jack. You see them walk behind him one time, they cut to Hurley and Jack and then when they cut to Jack again they walk behind him again hehe.
#79
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
This was definitely the weakest episode so far, and the castaways are really starting to piss me off.
It's been 6 days for them, and they're still just hanging around the beach. A few of them know someone is broadcasting from the island, but they haven't seen fit to go look for it. Hmm... people used to be here, there's power to run the transmitter... could there be a water supply with all that? Instead of looking for it, let's just complain about a few empty bottles of water and otherwise sit on our asses.
It's been 6 days for them, and they're still just hanging around the beach. A few of them know someone is broadcasting from the island, but they haven't seen fit to go look for it. Hmm... people used to be here, there's power to run the transmitter... could there be a water supply with all that? Instead of looking for it, let's just complain about a few empty bottles of water and otherwise sit on our asses.
Last edited by renaldow; 10-21-04 at 10:05 AM.
#80
DVD Talk Legend
Since this is speculation, I'm not going to spoiler it...but I think the purgatory theories that people have been throwing around (or a state of limbo...whatever you prefer) are holding up.
The people on the island see something or do something that will help their passage into the next life. Example: if Jack hadn't rescued that other guy in the water, he probably would have been "killed" - sending him to the next plane (no pun intended!) of existance. When Jack finally caught up with his father, he almost fell off a cliff and died, if not for Locke saving him.
That being said, I did think last night's show was the weakest of the ones we've seen so far...
The people on the island see something or do something that will help their passage into the next life. Example: if Jack hadn't rescued that other guy in the water, he probably would have been "killed" - sending him to the next plane (no pun intended!) of existance. When Jack finally caught up with his father, he almost fell off a cliff and died, if not for Locke saving him.
That being said, I did think last night's show was the weakest of the ones we've seen so far...
#81
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by renaldow
It's been 6 days for them, and they're still just hanging around the beech. A few of them know someone is broadcasting from the island, but they haven't seen fit to go look for it. Hmm... people used to be here, there's power to run the transmitter... could there be a water supply with all that? Instead of looking for it, let's just complain about a few empty bottles of water and otherwise sit on our asses.
It's been 6 days for them, and they're still just hanging around the beech. A few of them know someone is broadcasting from the island, but they haven't seen fit to go look for it. Hmm... people used to be here, there's power to run the transmitter... could there be a water supply with all that? Instead of looking for it, let's just complain about a few empty bottles of water and otherwise sit on our asses.
#82
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Joined: Sep 1999
Posts: 4,681
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Chicago, IL
They can't all be gems. Still more entertaining than most shows.
Did the blonde girl bring any clothes to Australia that didn't make her look like a slut?
Did the blonde girl bring any clothes to Australia that didn't make her look like a slut?
#83
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Jack's mother said something to him during a flashback along the lines of "You have to go after him, after what you did it's the least you can do" or something like that. What was she referring to? Did I miss what Jack did to his father?
#84
Originally posted by movieking
OK, my PVR once again cut off the last minute or so. The last thing that I got was Jack telling Kate that his father died in Sydney, and her saying that she was sorry. What happened after that?
OK, my PVR once again cut off the last minute or so. The last thing that I got was Jack telling Kate that his father died in Sydney, and her saying that she was sorry. What happened after that?
#85
Moderator
Originally posted by johnglass
Jack's mother said something to him during a flashback along the lines of "You have to go after him, after what you did it's the least you can do" or something like that. What was she referring to? Did I miss what Jack did to his father?
Jack's mother said something to him during a flashback along the lines of "You have to go after him, after what you did it's the least you can do" or something like that. What was she referring to? Did I miss what Jack did to his father?
#87
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
This show is just freakin awesome....however I got a question. Why did Jack not encounter "The Monster" while he spent all freakin day in the woods?
I wish this show was 2 hours each week.
wlj
I wish this show was 2 hours each week.
wlj
#89
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally posted by johnglass
Jack's mother said something to him during a flashback along the lines of "You have to go after him, after what you did it's the least you can do" or something like that. What was she referring to? Did I miss what Jack did to his father?
Jack's mother said something to him during a flashback along the lines of "You have to go after him, after what you did it's the least you can do" or something like that. What was she referring to? Did I miss what Jack did to his father?
PEOPLE THIS IS THE POINT OF THE EPISODE! What did Jack do? Clearly his father was an alcoholic who pretty much committed suicide. But why did he go to Sydney to do it? Jack also seems to be an alcoholic. What did Jack do to piss off his dad? Did he lose his medical license because of his drinking? Theories anyone? We've probably seen tons of clues about this already - including the swimming incident.
And ONCE AGAIN for the record - can we please get off all the sci-fi/fantasy garbage. Whoever starts next week's thread please post HUGE letters saying "NO SCI-FI/FANTASY DISCUSSIONS PLEASE!" Those posts are a waste of time for anyone who really wants to read legitimate theories about this great show.
#90
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 3,509
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: IL
Originally posted by GuessWho
The joys of being Tivo-less -- I GET TO SEE THE WHOLE SHOW
Suck me, Tivo!!!
The joys of being Tivo-less -- I GET TO SEE THE WHOLE SHOW
Suck me, Tivo!!!
#92
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 3,509
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: IL
Originally posted by rfduncan
PEOPLE THIS IS THE POINT OF THE EPISODE! What did Jack do?
PEOPLE THIS IS THE POINT OF THE EPISODE! What did Jack do?

Of course, now he is a wish-granting undead zombie that rides a T-Rex on Polar Bear Island.
#93
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by treszoks
The island granted another wish
Jack was trying to find his father and he did...well his casket anyway.
Did anyone notice the mistake at the beginning? When Hurley and Charlie run to talk to Jack in the tent, the two extras walk by TWICE behind Jack. You see them walk behind him one time, they cut to Hurley and Jack and then when they cut to Jack again they walk behind him again hehe.
The island granted another wish
Jack was trying to find his father and he did...well his casket anyway.Did anyone notice the mistake at the beginning? When Hurley and Charlie run to talk to Jack in the tent, the two extras walk by TWICE behind Jack. You see them walk behind him one time, they cut to Hurley and Jack and then when they cut to Jack again they walk behind him again hehe.
#94
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally posted by Snowmaker
Does anyone else think the Koreans can speak English, but the husband doesn't want them to?
Does anyone else think the Koreans can speak English, but the husband doesn't want them to?
Spoiler:
http://www.dvdtalk.com/forum/showthr...t&pagenumber=9
#95
DVD Talk Legend
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 10,059
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Cincinnati, OH
Decent episode. I suppose that thie episode marks the turning point where
I wonder why nobody worried about Locke not coming back yet? I suppose since he's the scary guy, they don't care about him.
I think the father running away probably happened after Jack killed the lady in surgery and maybe quit being a surgeon. The dad sees that Jack failed as he foresaw and reacted in way that he expected.
Spoiler:
I wonder why nobody worried about Locke not coming back yet? I suppose since he's the scary guy, they don't care about him.
I think the father running away probably happened after Jack killed the lady in surgery and maybe quit being a surgeon. The dad sees that Jack failed as he foresaw and reacted in way that he expected.
#96
Guest
Originally posted by Chew
I'd have to agree, it was one of the weaker episodes so far. But, still entertaining.
That was the last straw: future episodes have now been padded 2 minutes on the tail end.
I'd have to agree, it was one of the weaker episodes so far. But, still entertaining.
That was the last straw: future episodes have now been padded 2 minutes on the tail end.

Chris
#97
Moderator
Interesting that everybody else is losing the end of their episodes. My affiliate keeps starting it early, so I keep missing the beginning.
ABC shows have me doing so much padding lately I feel like a Jack-bot.
ABC shows have me doing so much padding lately I feel like a Jack-bot.
#99
Guest
Now I'm not the world's best swimmer, but if I saw someone calling for help in the ocean, I would try my best to get out there and save that person.
What was with most of the people standing on the beach while they let Jack do all the work? The least one of them could have done was to help Jack bring in the other rescuerer, which would then free Jack up to get the girl who was drowning.
Chris
What was with most of the people standing on the beach while they let Jack do all the work? The least one of them could have done was to help Jack bring in the other rescuerer, which would then free Jack up to get the girl who was drowning.
Chris
#100
DVD Talk Legend
It was impressive that Lost was able to hold up relatively well against game 7 of the ALCS.
Here are the ratings results from yesterday
"Game 7 of the American League Championship Series between Boston and the New York Yankees began the night with a 17.3/26 for FOX. ABC's "Lost" held up well against the game, posting a 10.2/16. The Wednesday "60 Minutes" was third for CBS with a 5.5/9. NBC was fourth with a rerun of last year's "West Wing" finale. "America's Next Top Model" averaged 3.5/6 for UPN, beating The WB's "Smallville" by a few tenths."
Here are the ratings results from yesterday
"Game 7 of the American League Championship Series between Boston and the New York Yankees began the night with a 17.3/26 for FOX. ABC's "Lost" held up well against the game, posting a 10.2/16. The Wednesday "60 Minutes" was third for CBS with a 5.5/9. NBC was fourth with a rerun of last year's "West Wing" finale. "America's Next Top Model" averaged 3.5/6 for UPN, beating The WB's "Smallville" by a few tenths."



