The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Limited Edition
The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
Life seems easy for picture-perfect couple Ivy (Olivia Colman) and Theo (Benedict Cumberbatch): successful careers, a loving marriage, great kids. But beneath the façade of their supposed ideal life, a storm is brewing – as Theo’s career nosedives while Ivy’s own ambitions take off, a tinderbox of fierce competition and hidden resentment ignites. The Roses is a reimagining of the 1989 classic film The War of the Roses, based on the novel by Warren Adler.
#2
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
The War of the Roses was a favorite when I was a kid, for some reason. I just rewatched it and it totally holds up.
That said, this has an incredible cast and looks like a lot of fun. I’m all for it!
That said, this has an incredible cast and looks like a lot of fun. I’m all for it!
#3
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
Could be fun, or could be horrible. Not sure there'll be an in-between with this.
Love the house shown in the trailer. Not sure if it's a real house or just a set - but that kitchen is gorgeous.
Yes, I've turned into a chick.
Love the house shown in the trailer. Not sure if it's a real house or just a set - but that kitchen is gorgeous.
Yes, I've turned into a chick.
#4
DVD Talk Hero
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 39,229
Received 1,618 Likes
on
1,146 Posts
From: Somewhere between Heaven and Hell
Re: The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
#5
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
Re: The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
It's kind of weird that this and Caught Stealing are coming out on the same day. They feel like they're targeting the exact same moviegoers.
#6
DVD Talk God
Re: The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
I’m not sure that I’m really that interested in this. I’ve seen the trailers many times, especially in the theater, and I’ve found the characters grating. For the record, I’ve never seen The War of the Roses.
#7
Re: The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
The following users liked this post:
Hubbub (11-21-25)
#8
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
Re: The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
Yeah, the original is one of my favorite "mean-spirited, pitch black comedies", a sub-genre I am very fond of.
This doesn't look nearly as mean-spirited, at least in the trailer. Giving the Roses kids seems like a bad decision.
This doesn't look nearly as mean-spirited, at least in the trailer. Giving the Roses kids seems like a bad decision.
#9
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
#10
DVD Talk Hero
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 39,229
Received 1,618 Likes
on
1,146 Posts
From: Somewhere between Heaven and Hell
Re: The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
#11
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
Saw an early Dolby show tonight. This is one of those it's all in the trailers flicks. A few laughs but not exactly laugh out loud. They are pretty harsh toward each other in their verbal sparring. Cumber and Coleman were definitely good together but if you're not 100% interested then just wait.
The following users liked this post:
DJariya (08-27-25)
#12
DVD Talk God
Re: The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
Yeah this is one that I’m not 100% clamoring to see. I’m probably going to sit this one out.
#13
Political Exile
Re: The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
I'm tempted to see it mainly because they are putting it on the premium dolby screen.
#14
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
Now available on Hulu
The following users liked this post:
story (11-20-25)
#15
Re: The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
Meh. The movie spend an hour and ten minutes just getting to the divorce, and now that there's thirty or minutes of less left, all the big scenes are reduced to basically being montages.
This claims to be based on the novel The War of the Roses, which I read over thirty years ago and don't remember well, but I'm pretty sure bares no resemblance to this.
I put on the Danny DeVito movie afterwards just to watch the first five minutes. In that small period there was funny moments, creative cinematography, great music, the feel of an epic story starting. I'll be rewatching it tomorrow evening for sure, and highly recommend it to anyone who wants to see a real unique dark comedy.
This claims to be based on the novel The War of the Roses, which I read over thirty years ago and don't remember well, but I'm pretty sure bares no resemblance to this.
I put on the Danny DeVito movie afterwards just to watch the first five minutes. In that small period there was funny moments, creative cinematography, great music, the feel of an epic story starting. I'll be rewatching it tomorrow evening for sure, and highly recommend it to anyone who wants to see a real unique dark comedy.
#16
Re: The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
The dialogues bewteen Cumberbatch and Colman are really well written. Everything else seems to be written for another movie. I do like Andy Samberg and Kate McKinnon, but they were in a completely different and unfunny movie with terrible dialogue. This ruined the movie.
#17
DVD Talk Godfather
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 57,499
Received 1,681 Likes
on
1,354 Posts
From: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Re: The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
I don’t mind black comedies, but the original movie just seemed nasty, and I never watched it again,
#18
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
I loved the original as a kid (I was 9 years old at the time), but the trailer to this one made it look awful. Despite the two leads, I can't bring myself to watch it.
#20
Re: The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
Did you see a difference regarding the British and American dialogues? I still think those were ritten by different writers. The British dialogues were clever, funny and subtle. The American dialogues were vulgar, cringe and loud.
#21
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Roses (2025, D: Roach) - S: Cumberbatch, Colman, Samberg, Janney, McKinnon
I figured that was intentional, but it did seem like Jake and the alien abduction survivor were there from a different movie.




