01: The Untouchables (1987)
02: No Way Out (1987)
03: Bull Durham (1988)
04: Field of Dreams (1989)
05: Revenge (1990)

I deliberately left off 1990's Dances With Wolves because I didn't want his Oscar-victory film to overshadow the previous five.

Probably JFK or Silverado.

Yeah, Silverado

What, did you deliberately pick his worst movies? Even WATERWORLD is better than each of those. And how could you leave out his funniest movie, THE POSTMAN?

...I know we passed the point of not giving a damn but why does Buttmunker keep coming back?

Great poll.

JFK

From that list....No Way Out.

Oh yeah, The Postman is great. Kevin Costner's love letter to...Kevin Costner.

For Love of the Game

From that list... Bull Durham

Yeah, not the choices I would make. Of those listed, No Way Out and Field of Dreams would be my favorites (No Way Out is a nice, simple flick, and Field of Dreams is the best of his 3 baseball movies-and I love baseball flicks). My favorites overall would be JFK and Dances With Wolves. But then I'm a sucker for long overly convoluted movies in general....

JFK or A Perfect World

From the list. Bull Durham. Enjoyable movie.

Have never seen any of those movies.

You didn't find POSTMAN funny?

"Hi, I'm Kevin Costner, and one day I'm going to be a movie star. Except nobody on DVDTalk.com will like me, and that makes me a sad Kevin Costner."

Hey, man, I loved you in Night Shift!

Bull Durham

I voted for JFK (the movie, not the president).

I loved him in The Big Chill

Worst poll ever.

'Open Range' would be his best film all the way around as director and actor.

My favorite would be a hard choice, 'Open Range', 'Wyatt Earp', 'Fandango', 'Silverado', or 'A Perfect World'.

Of the films in that crap poll, 'No Way Out' would easily be my choice. That is an excellent film that fully deserved the rave reviews it garnered, and the 96% on RT it has today. Some notion that 'Waterworld' ranks with that film is nonsense. I might expect that sort of silliness from a teenager on the internet, but not from Ash.

HEY! I like The Postman!

I think Costner is a perfectly entertaining actor/ director. I even like 3000 Miles to Graceland. JFK is on top though.

Here's a poll:

Your favorite sandwich filling (THESE 3 ONLY):
a) poop
b) guts
c) dirt

You sure? I've seen some other pretty terrible Buttmunker poll posts.

''I can only hope this movie will do for these actors what playing a corpse in The Big Chill did for Kevin Costner''

---David Fincher referring to the actors that represent the sins in SE7EN

Jfk