Why don't more DVDs have the film's soundtrack / score as a bonus feature?
#1
Why don't more DVDs have the film's soundtrack / score as a bonus feature?
The Thin Red Line DVD has the Melanesian Choir soundtrack on it.
The original DVD release of The Mummy [1999] had the soundtrack as an Easter Egg on one of the menus.
How come more DVDs don't offer the film's soundtrack or score as a bonus feature?
I think this'd be a great feature.
The original DVD release of The Mummy [1999] had the soundtrack as an Easter Egg on one of the menus.
How come more DVDs don't offer the film's soundtrack or score as a bonus feature?
I think this'd be a great feature.
#3
This would have been a great feature on the upcoming Cruising DVD.
The soundtrack is OOP.
I have it on vinyl but would love to have a CD of it.
It would also have been great if it included the instrumental music by Tom Browne & Barre Phillips whick is not on the soundtrack album.
The soundtrack is OOP.
I have it on vinyl but would love to have a CD of it.
It would also have been great if it included the instrumental music by Tom Browne & Barre Phillips whick is not on the soundtrack album.
#4
DVD Talk Gold Edition
I don't have all the details memorized, but I think there have been protests from the musicians' union that the performances used in the film can't be broken out from the movie -- it then becomes a substitute /competition for the soundtrack album/CD, which is covered under a separate contract (even if there is no soundtrack album/CD). Whether this is a clear-cut contract issue or not, I don't know. There have been some recent releases that have this feature (can't remember the most recent older title that had this) so it isn't dead, but it used to be more common than now.
#5
DVD Talk Legend
Pee wee's big adventure has an awesome isolated score track with commentary from Danny Elfman.
#6
Yeah, it's pretty ridiculous it doesn't happen more in region 1 land. There are a ton of releases from Korea and Japan that come with the OST and it's a feature that I would prefer over any other extras (well, considering most aren't English friendly anyway). Though none of these exports are Hollywood films. So there's probably a point behind the musician's union obscure brought up.
#8
New Member
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 18
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Indonesia
on the top of my head:
John Carpenter's The THING (old release) ---- isolated score
Dario Argento's SUSPIRIA Limited Edition DVD ---- separatae CD
Daro Argento's OPERA Limited Edition DVD ---- separate CD
John Carpenter's The THING (old release) ---- isolated score
Dario Argento's SUSPIRIA Limited Edition DVD ---- separatae CD
Daro Argento's OPERA Limited Edition DVD ---- separate CD
#9
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 1,497
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: West Richland,WA
Superman the movie(older release)------isolated score
Jane Eyre (1944)------score and sound effects.
Halloween II (old release)--------isolated score
There are a few more for now.
Jane Eyre (1944)------score and sound effects.
Halloween II (old release)--------isolated score
There are a few more for now.
#11
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
At the very least I would like a track listing. For a show like Scrubs it would be perfect because they play alot of decent songs during the show & it would be nice to know the name of them all.
I'd rather have the film/TV show's soundtrack/score than another one of those boring "Making of" bonus features. I'd also like more "Bloopers" on DVDs as a bonus feature.
I'd rather have the film/TV show's soundtrack/score than another one of those boring "Making of" bonus features. I'd also like more "Bloopers" on DVDs as a bonus feature.
#13
Senior Member
Cine Paradiso 4 disc Deluxe Edition Region 0 (or was it 2) includes the grand Ennio Morricone score CD. I think this a great bonus for any DVD release.
Ocean's 12 score way way cool that I bought the OST CD!
Ocean's 12 score way way cool that I bought the OST CD!
#14
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 5,169
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: On the penis chair
Originally Posted by Shazam
The standard reason I heard from a few years ago was that the isolated soundtracks were being pirated.
#15
DVD Talk Legend
I remember when the LOTR:FOTR EE was first announced, an isolated music track was listed as one of the tentative features. It was dropped because of space issues, along with an effects-only track.
http://www.thedigitalbits.com/mytwocentsa62.html
I'm thinking that a lot of DVDs don't contain the isolated score because it's an extra feature with low demand. I believe that it's sometimes an answer on those "what special feature do you like best?" polls studios do, and I doubt that most people select isolated score over more standard features like making-ofs or commentary tracks.
http://www.thedigitalbits.com/mytwocentsa62.html
I'm thinking that a lot of DVDs don't contain the isolated score because it's an extra feature with low demand. I believe that it's sometimes an answer on those "what special feature do you like best?" polls studios do, and I doubt that most people select isolated score over more standard features like making-ofs or commentary tracks.
#16
Originally Posted by mikelowry
Cine Paradiso 4 disc Deluxe Edition Region 0 (or was it 2) includes the grand Ennio Morricone score CD.
How about soundtracks that were never previously released? Holy Mountain on the Jodorowsky box set.
#20
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 3,586
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Ontario, Canada
Originally Posted by Shazam
The standard reason I heard from a few years ago was that the isolated soundtracks were being pirated.
I do that for my own personal enjoyment. I also go the extra step and edit the music to compensate for the volume changes and revisions, completely customizing them and no one else will ever have one like it. I even include the original album CD tracks, and edit those to include the additional material if needed. So I beat the bootlegs out there. I do it mainly because it's just a fun process to me. I've bought the DVDs and CDs for them and have NO desire to make money off my customized versions.
The original Apollo 13 Collectors Edition from 1998 has the "For Your Consideration" Oscar promo album in its main menu.
Legends Of The Fall and Jumanji special Editions have isolated scores.
The Region 2 Glory and Bicentennial Man DVDs have them as well.
Last edited by Nick Martin; 07-04-07 at 11:59 AM.
#21
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by Nick Martin
The original Apollo 13 Collectors Edition from 1998 has the "For Your Consideration" Oscar promo album in its main menu.




