Oscar 2005 at the Halfway Pole-- Who do you like based on what's been released?
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Special Edition
Oscar 2005 at the Halfway Pole-- Who do you like based on what's been released?
Obviously the Oscar race is well backloaded, but July 1 being 1/2 way to the consideration cut-off, the market seems loaded with some early contenders. What do you guys think? I could see:
-Kirk Russel Best Actor nom for Miracle
-Sam Raimi and Mel Gibson best director nominations for Spidey/Passion
-Passion for Best Picture, possibly Spiderman 2 as well
-Napolean Dynamite best screenplay
Any other early contenders?
-Kirk Russel Best Actor nom for Miracle
-Sam Raimi and Mel Gibson best director nominations for Spidey/Passion
-Passion for Best Picture, possibly Spiderman 2 as well
-Napolean Dynamite best screenplay
Any other early contenders?
#3
TOTY Winner 2018 and Inane Thread Master
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 54,215
Received 1,736 Likes
on
1,423 Posts
From: "Are any of us really anywhere?"
whose Kirk Russel?
i'd 2nd KB v2 but I think DC would get Best Actor no?
i'd 2nd KB v2 but I think DC would get Best Actor no?
#5
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Special Edition
Originally posted by scott1598
whose Kirk Russel?
i'd 2nd KB v2 but I think DC would get Best Actor no?
whose Kirk Russel?
i'd 2nd KB v2 but I think DC would get Best Actor no?
#6
Senior Member
Joined: Jan 2000
Posts: 836
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Dela-where?
Re: Oscar 2005 at the Halfway Pole-- Who do you like based on what's been released?
Originally posted by The Nature Boy
Obviously the Oscar race is well backloaded, but July 1 being 1/2 way to the consideration cut-off, the market seems loaded with some early contenders. What do you guys think? I could see:
-Kirk Russel Best Actor nom for Miracle
-Sam Raimi and Mel Gibson best director nominations for Spidey/Passion
-Passion for Best Picture, possibly Spiderman 2 as well
-Napolean Dynamite best screenplay
Any other early contenders?
Obviously the Oscar race is well backloaded, but July 1 being 1/2 way to the consideration cut-off, the market seems loaded with some early contenders. What do you guys think? I could see:
-Kirk Russel Best Actor nom for Miracle
-Sam Raimi and Mel Gibson best director nominations for Spidey/Passion
-Passion for Best Picture, possibly Spiderman 2 as well
-Napolean Dynamite best screenplay
Any other early contenders?
#7
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Feb 2000
Posts: 3,807
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Twin Cities, Minnesota
As much as I liked Spider-Man 2, and it will take quite a bit to top that one in my opinion the rest of the year, I can't see it getting any serious nominations this year. Just not the type of film the Academy goes for I guess.
As for Kill Bill Vol. 2, I would also be surprised to see it get anything. When the first volume came out, everybody was all over it, about how great it was and it would be nominated for this and that...look what happened. Expect more of the same this year. (That being said, I also didn't think the second volume was anything special. I was actually quite bored with it and thought the pacing was too awkward and the acting just adequate, but that's just my opinion.)
I would hope Kurt Russell is recognized for Miracle, but I get a feeling by the time the nominations come around, nobody will remember that film. It was also definitely one of my favorite performances so far this year though.
The Passion was a moving, yet very flawed, work of art. I would have no problem seeing it get nominated because it made even me, an agnostic, ask some serious questions and examine what I believe, but who knows how Hollywood will go on that one.
Bottom line for me I guess is it's still way to early to even be considering this question. Not many films stand out in my mind other than a few here and there. Will be much easier to figure this out as time goes on I guess.
As for Kill Bill Vol. 2, I would also be surprised to see it get anything. When the first volume came out, everybody was all over it, about how great it was and it would be nominated for this and that...look what happened. Expect more of the same this year. (That being said, I also didn't think the second volume was anything special. I was actually quite bored with it and thought the pacing was too awkward and the acting just adequate, but that's just my opinion.)
I would hope Kurt Russell is recognized for Miracle, but I get a feeling by the time the nominations come around, nobody will remember that film. It was also definitely one of my favorite performances so far this year though.
The Passion was a moving, yet very flawed, work of art. I would have no problem seeing it get nominated because it made even me, an agnostic, ask some serious questions and examine what I believe, but who knows how Hollywood will go on that one.
Bottom line for me I guess is it's still way to early to even be considering this question. Not many films stand out in my mind other than a few here and there. Will be much easier to figure this out as time goes on I guess.
#8
Originally posted by badger1997
As much as I liked Spider-Man 2, and it will take quite a bit to top that one in my opinion the rest of the year, I can't see it getting any serious nominations this year. Just not the type of film the Academy goes for I guess.
As for Kill Bill Vol. 2, I would also be surprised to see it get anything. When the first volume came out, everybody was all over it, about how great it was and it would be nominated for this and that...look what happened. Expect more of the same this year. (That being said, I also didn't think the second volume was anything special. I was actually quite bored with it and thought the pacing was too awkward and the acting just adequate, but that's just my opinion.)
I would hope Kurt Russell is recognized for Miracle, but I get a feeling by the time the nominations come around, nobody will remember that film. It was also definitely one of my favorite performances so far this year though.
The Passion was a moving, yet very flawed, work of art. I would have no problem seeing it get nominated because it made even me, an agnostic, ask some serious questions and examine what I believe, but who knows how Hollywood will go on that one.
Bottom line for me I guess is it's still way to early to even be considering this question. Not many films stand out in my mind other than a few here and there. Will be much easier to figure this out as time goes on I guess.
As much as I liked Spider-Man 2, and it will take quite a bit to top that one in my opinion the rest of the year, I can't see it getting any serious nominations this year. Just not the type of film the Academy goes for I guess.
As for Kill Bill Vol. 2, I would also be surprised to see it get anything. When the first volume came out, everybody was all over it, about how great it was and it would be nominated for this and that...look what happened. Expect more of the same this year. (That being said, I also didn't think the second volume was anything special. I was actually quite bored with it and thought the pacing was too awkward and the acting just adequate, but that's just my opinion.)
I would hope Kurt Russell is recognized for Miracle, but I get a feeling by the time the nominations come around, nobody will remember that film. It was also definitely one of my favorite performances so far this year though.
The Passion was a moving, yet very flawed, work of art. I would have no problem seeing it get nominated because it made even me, an agnostic, ask some serious questions and examine what I believe, but who knows how Hollywood will go on that one.
Bottom line for me I guess is it's still way to early to even be considering this question. Not many films stand out in my mind other than a few here and there. Will be much easier to figure this out as time goes on I guess.
#10
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Special Edition
Originally posted by Rypro 525
would the accadamy give mm the award for 9/11, especally after his speech about bush.
would the accadamy give mm the award for 9/11, especally after his speech about bush.
#13
DVD Talk Legend
Fahrenheit 9/11 will be nominated, but don't count out the McDonald's guy.
I'd like to see Uma Thurman get a nom for Best Actress, to recognize her work in Vol. 1 also (like ROTK was recognition for the LOTR trilogy).
I hope The Incredibles is good and beats out Shrek 2 for Best Animated Feature.
I'd like to see Uma Thurman get a nom for Best Actress, to recognize her work in Vol. 1 also (like ROTK was recognition for the LOTR trilogy).
I hope The Incredibles is good and beats out Shrek 2 for Best Animated Feature.
#14
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by Drexl
Fahrenheit 9/11 will be nominated, but don't count out the McDonald's guy.
I'd like to see Uma Thurman get a nom for Best Actress, to recognize her work in Vol. 1 also (like ROTK was recognition for the LOTR trilogy).
I hope The Incredibles is good and beats out Shrek 2 for Best Animated Feature.
Fahrenheit 9/11 will be nominated, but don't count out the McDonald's guy.
I'd like to see Uma Thurman get a nom for Best Actress, to recognize her work in Vol. 1 also (like ROTK was recognition for the LOTR trilogy).
I hope The Incredibles is good and beats out Shrek 2 for Best Animated Feature.
#15
DVD Talk Legend
Although a few nominations major should sneak through, it looks pretty sparse at this point. I could see Spiderman 2 getting a major nod or two if the rest of the year is weak, but otherwise not. I'm sure something already released will at least get a sound or visual effects nomination, however.
#16
Senior Member
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 746
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Oregon
I think The Passion of the Christ should be nominated for Best Picture (at least based on what's come out so far), but I really doubt it will be. I expect Jim Caviezel to be nominated for Best Actor, however, and I also expect the movie to pick up a cinematography and score nod. I also would like to see Uma Thurman get nominated for Best Actress for Kill Bill v.2. It'd be nice if The Prisoner of Azkaban gets nominated for cinematography, score, or director, too.
#17
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Special Edition
It could be fun if we have The Passion and F911 head to head in the best picture category this year. It'd probably be the idealogical showdown of the year and drive one of the biggest Oscar ratings numbers in years, and pretty much guarantee 6 straight weeks of hype leading into the big show.
#18
DVD Talk Hero
The only person that might be nominated for The Passion is Maia Morgenstern for Best Supporting Actress.
#19
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally posted by The Nature Boy
It could be fun if we have The Passion and F911 head to head in the best picture category this year. It'd probably be the idealogical showdown of the year and drive one of the biggest Oscar ratings numbers in years, and pretty much guarantee 6 straight weeks of hype leading into the big show.
It could be fun if we have The Passion and F911 head to head in the best picture category this year. It'd probably be the idealogical showdown of the year and drive one of the biggest Oscar ratings numbers in years, and pretty much guarantee 6 straight weeks of hype leading into the big show.
#20
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally posted by Rypro 525
id put kill bill vol 2 for supporting actor (david carrodine), actress, picture and director.
id put kill bill vol 2 for supporting actor (david carrodine), actress, picture and director.
#21
Originally posted by The Nature Boy
It could be fun if we have The Passion and F911 head to head in the best picture category this year. It'd probably be the idealogical showdown of the year and drive one of the biggest Oscar ratings numbers in years, and pretty much guarantee 6 straight weeks of hype leading into the big show.
It could be fun if we have The Passion and F911 head to head in the best picture category this year. It'd probably be the idealogical showdown of the year and drive one of the biggest Oscar ratings numbers in years, and pretty much guarantee 6 straight weeks of hype leading into the big show.
#22
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Jul 2000
Posts: 3,015
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Brooklyn, NY
The only thing we've seen so far that is a lock for a nomination is "Shrek 2" for animated feature, and "F911" for documentary. As far as the traditional catagories go, most noms go to films released during the holiday season.
#23
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 1,182
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: New York City
I think there is some early buzz on Kevin Klien's performance in De-Lovely. Supposedly he is amazing and worthy of a best actor nomination. Also there is some buzz about Kim Basinger and Jeff Bridges in The Door in the Floor. I think both movies are released at the end of July. Lets see what happens.
#24
DVD Talk Godfather
Joined: Jul 2000
Posts: 54,199
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
From: City of the lakers.. riots.. and drug dealing cops.. los(t) Angel(e)s. ca.
It's summer. Non of these films will hit the oscar season. remember this is the time of year for popcorn flicks not oscar worthy films. Everything that will be in the oscars comes out later after the summer season. simple as that.



