movies that have a rating change due to an appeal with no cuts
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hero
movies that have a rating change due to an appeal with no cuts
here are the one's i can think of right away
clerks Rated R on appeal for extensive use of extremely explicit sex-related dialogue.
Previously rated (NC-17).
As Good As It Gets (1997) PG-13 Rated PG-13 on appeal for strong language, thematic elements, nudity and a beating.
Previously rated (R).
Jersey Girl (2003) PG-13 Rated PG-13 on appeal for language and sexual content including frank dialogue.
Previously rated (R) in (03).
took boys don't cry off because apparently the rape is cut by the mpaa and the europeans have it uncut.
clerks Rated R on appeal for extensive use of extremely explicit sex-related dialogue.
Previously rated (NC-17).
As Good As It Gets (1997) PG-13 Rated PG-13 on appeal for strong language, thematic elements, nudity and a beating.
Previously rated (R).
Jersey Girl (2003) PG-13 Rated PG-13 on appeal for language and sexual content including frank dialogue.
Previously rated (R) in (03).
took boys don't cry off because apparently the rape is cut by the mpaa and the europeans have it uncut.
Last edited by Rypro 525; 03-15-04 at 10:45 PM.
#2
The Wild Bunch was about to get slapped with an NC-17 when it was re-released on video in the early 90's. But the original,uncut version managed to keep an R in the end.
#4
DVD Talk Special Edition
Scarface (1983) had originally got an X rating, De Palma recut his film about three times until he finally won the appeal for an R. He decided to release his original cut since the cuts he made were minimal at best.
#5
DVD Talk Legend
Jaws was going to get an R rating as was Poltergeist.
I believe Indiana Jones was close to doing that as well.
I believe Indiana Jones was close to doing that as well.
#6
DVD Talk Special Edition
I think Midnight Cowboy kept the X-rating when it won the Oscar, but then may have been changed thereafter(perhaps because the Academy or Old Hollywood didn't want the stigma of X-rated best pic?) The content has some harsher moments, but nothing overtly gratiutious or graphic, so it was knocked down to an "R" later on with no cuts.
#7
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hero
Originally posted by Mondo Kane
The Wild Bunch was about to get slapped with an NC-17 when it was re-released on video in the early 90's. But the original,uncut version managed to keep an R in the end.
The Wild Bunch was about to get slapped with an NC-17 when it was re-released on video in the early 90's. But the original,uncut version managed to keep an R in the end.
#8
DVD Talk God
clerks was going to be rated NC-17?
#9
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hero
Originally posted by Deftones, Esq
clerks was going to be rated NC-17?
clerks was going to be rated NC-17?
#10
DVD Talk Legend
but since its miramax, they lowered it to an R
#11
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by Matthew Chmiel
Miramax hired a big name lawyer to scare the MPAA as they thought the NC-17 was unjustified due to just "language." Once they hired that specific lawyer, the MPAA caved in and gave the film an R.
Miramax hired a big name lawyer to scare the MPAA as they thought the NC-17 was unjustified due to just "language." Once they hired that specific lawyer, the MPAA caved in and gave the film an R.
#12
Moderator
Originally posted by Rypro 525
question, does the directors cut have aditional violence thats not in the theatrical cut, is that the reason for the almost NC-17
question, does the directors cut have aditional violence thats not in the theatrical cut, is that the reason for the almost NC-17
As I know understand it, and new MPAA guidelines states that if a film is restored of any 'new' footage, the new cut of the film must be resubmitted in it's entirety and must take a new rating. Previous ratings do not apply for expanded versions of films.
In regards to Clerks - I remember reading that the MPAA had a real problem with the explicit sexual talk specifically the 'snow balling' (I think that's the term) explanation.
Language can in fact ensue a film to get a NC-17 rating. Andrew Dice Clay's, Martin Lawrence and Eddie Murphy's stand-up comedian act films were all given NC-17's for its coarse language, only Eddie Murphy's film Raw had to be cut to recieve it's R-rating.
Last edited by Giles; 03-16-04 at 08:27 AM.
#13
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hero
In regards to Clerks - I remember reading that the MPAA had a real problem with the explicit sexual talk specifically the 'snow balling' (I think that's the term) explanation.
smith also said that the now famous 37 scene and the scene with the guy in the bathroom, had problems also.
smith also said that the now famous 37 scene and the scene with the guy in the bathroom, had problems also.
#14
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 3,509
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: IL
Originally posted by tanman
Jaws was going to get an R rating as was Poltergeist.
I believe Indiana Jones was close to doing that as well.
Jaws was going to get an R rating as was Poltergeist.
I believe Indiana Jones was close to doing that as well.
#16
Originally posted by Giles
both Temple of Doom and Gremlins were the films that initiated the creation of the PG-13 rating.
both Temple of Doom and Gremlins were the films that initiated the creation of the PG-13 rating.
#19
Moderator
Originally posted by Mondo Kane
Weird. I could've sworn that Dreamscape and Red Dawn were the first 2 movies to be rated PG-13 because I remembered first hearing the "PG-13" rating on their TV spots. But according to Imdb (And the Indy bonus disc) it looks like I'm proven wrong.
Weird. I could've sworn that Dreamscape and Red Dawn were the first 2 movies to be rated PG-13 because I remembered first hearing the "PG-13" rating on their TV spots. But according to Imdb (And the Indy bonus disc) it looks like I'm proven wrong.
#20
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2002
Posts: 761
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Actually Speilberg himself pleaded with the MPAA to create an "in-between" rating for films like his own Temple of Doom. What Speilberg wants, Speilberg gets. I think it's mentioned on the TOD doc from the Indy set.
#22
Moderator
Originally posted by DealMan
Actually Speilberg himself pleaded with the MPAA to create an "in-between" rating for films like his own Temple of Doom. What Speilberg wants, Speilberg gets. I think it's mentioned on the TOD doc from the Indy set.
Actually Speilberg himself pleaded with the MPAA to create an "in-between" rating for films like his own Temple of Doom. What Speilberg wants, Speilberg gets. I think it's mentioned on the TOD doc from the Indy set.
#23
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by Deftones, Esq
clerks was going to be rated NC-17?
clerks was going to be rated NC-17?
#24
DVD Talk Legend
Here's my favorite though - STAR TREK: THE MOTION PICTURE upgraded from G to PG for its special edition DVD release, just because some special effects were jazzed up! (it's still the cut that was in theaters - meaning no additional scenes...not even the 12 mintues that was on the ABC and VHS versions)




