TV Guide's Top 6 Shows You May Not Be Watching
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Legend
TV Guide's Top 6 Shows You May Not Be Watching
A sign I watch a lot of TV: I am watching all 6 of them!
American Dreams
Angel
Without a Trace
Boomtown
Everwood
Alias
http://www.tvguide.com/magazine/issu...331/magftr.asp
American Dreams
Angel
Without a Trace
Boomtown
Everwood
Alias
http://www.tvguide.com/magazine/issu...331/magftr.asp
Last edited by Jadzia; 03-31-03 at 02:39 PM.
#5
DVD Talk Hero
The only ones I don't watch are American Dreams and Everwood.
I'm surprised Without a Trace is on there. It's done pretty well considering it's up against ER. I know it's faired alot better then the Agency did last year.
I'm surprised Without a Trace is on there. It's done pretty well considering it's up against ER. I know it's faired alot better then the Agency did last year.
#6
Moderator
I'm only watching one of them: Boomtown, and probably not for very much longer now that they've completely abandoned the "one crime from different viewpoints" angle.
#7
May not be watching?
I never even heard of 4 of them!
I never even heard of 4 of them!
#11
DVD Talk Hero
Originally posted by conscience
I'm surprised Alias is on there. I thought that was a well received show by millions of audiences.
Oh well. Still great exposure for a great show.
I'm surprised Alias is on there. I thought that was a well received show by millions of audiences.
Oh well. Still great exposure for a great show.
#12
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 1,404
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Houston, TX
Well, I don't really know anything about Without a Trace and American Dreams looks absoultely horrible to me. I occasionally watch Everwood, but I just watch it because I like the genre. I can't believe it's on there, there's not a single thing exceptional about the show. It's so bland and mediocre. The other 3 choices are good.
Since I don't think any of my favorite shows make it into the top 30, my list for the best shows people aren't watching would just be my 6 favorite shows:
Angel
Gilmore Girls
South Park
Curb Your Enthusiasm
The Shield
and even though it's not on right now, I'll go ahead and put the most underrated reality show on here:
Big Brother
Since I don't think any of my favorite shows make it into the top 30, my list for the best shows people aren't watching would just be my 6 favorite shows:
Angel
Gilmore Girls
South Park
Curb Your Enthusiasm
The Shield
and even though it's not on right now, I'll go ahead and put the most underrated reality show on here:
Big Brother
#14
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
Originally posted by Grouchzo
I'm only watching one of them: Boomtown, and probably not for very much longer now that they've completely abandoned the "one crime from different viewpoints" angle.
I'm only watching one of them: Boomtown, and probably not for very much longer now that they've completely abandoned the "one crime from different viewpoints" angle.
Does anyone know if that change is "official"? I hope not. Fox bravely stuck with 24 and now the show is reaping the rewards with much better ratings and good reviews (but not from das
)
#15
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 518
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: NYC
Originally posted by MrX
It's well received by critics, but gets beaten badly in the ratings by Law & Order:CI.
It's well received by critics, but gets beaten badly in the ratings by Law & Order:CI.
Originally posted by nny
and even though it's not on right now, I'll go ahead and put the most underrated reality show on here:
Big Brother
and even though it's not on right now, I'll go ahead and put the most underrated reality show on here:
Big Brother
#16
Guest
Joined: Oct 2002
Posts: 2,650
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: behind you!!!
i'll defend american dreams. it is a good show and i watch it faithfully. it is true to the era and the surrounding of the show dealing with american bandstand and music i like is all the better. the characters are well done, and fun to keep up with. definitely worth a watch.
#17
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Jan 2000
Posts: 4,935
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: The Living Room on the Couch
I'd like to see Angel, but I don't want to pick up in the middle, I want to see it from the beginning. Good thing Season 1 is out on dvd, I hope to start watching someday
#18
DVD Talk Legend
I used to watch Alias. Always trying to figure out what happened led me to stop watching.
I caught a glimpse of Everwood but that was all. I've never seen the others.
I caught a glimpse of Everwood but that was all. I've never seen the others.
#19
• Quoth WiccanPagan •<HR SIZE=1>i'll defend american dreams. it is a good show and i watch it faithfully. it is true to the era and the surrounding of the show dealing with american bandstand and music i like is all the better. the characters are well done, and fun to keep up with. definitely worth a watch. <HR SIZE=1>
I have to admit to complete shock that American Dreams has been as good as it is. It doesn't take a genius to know that the 60s would be an incredible setting for a quality show, but I just expected it to be cheesy and silly with an over-emphasis on pop stuff. Surprisingly, though, they've done an excellent job capturing the era (which does include an inherent excess of pop music and such, but the show doesn't exploit it) and have produced a couple of very memorable episodes. I really expected NBC to screw this one up, but being in a low-profile spot like Sundays at 8pm seems to have kept them safe for the most part. I hope it continues on.
das
#22
• Quoth Red Dog •<HR SIZE=1>In general though, I hate when TV Guide does these lists. <HR SIZE=1>
They successfully used this "Best Show You're Not Watching" to deliver the Kiss of Death to Sports Night, Once & Again, and Farscape.
das
#23
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
I have no idea why W/O a Trace is on that list. It gets good ratings and is the first show on either ABC or CBS to ever put a dent in ER's ratings. It also has about as good a lead-in as you could pray for (TV's #1 drama). I don't think it needs any help.
Getting back to Boomtown, I really hope it makes it. When I saw the pilot, I was very impressed, but I worried that the writing couldn't keep up in subsequent weeks. I have a feeling it's much harder to write a story in a non-linear fashion and make it any good. So far I've been quite impressed, esp with the episodes written by Grahm Yost, the show's creator (who did such fine work on Band of Brothers). I hope that the main "hook" of the show hasn't been abandoned, because to turn this original creation into just another NYPD Blue clone would be a HUGE mistake.
I know if it gets cancelled I'll feel especially bad for Jason Gedrick, who would have seen three of his TV series be cancelled despite high quality for being "too challenging" for the viewer(Murder One, EZ Streets).
Getting back to Boomtown, I really hope it makes it. When I saw the pilot, I was very impressed, but I worried that the writing couldn't keep up in subsequent weeks. I have a feeling it's much harder to write a story in a non-linear fashion and make it any good. So far I've been quite impressed, esp with the episodes written by Grahm Yost, the show's creator (who did such fine work on Band of Brothers). I hope that the main "hook" of the show hasn't been abandoned, because to turn this original creation into just another NYPD Blue clone would be a HUGE mistake.
I know if it gets cancelled I'll feel especially bad for Jason Gedrick, who would have seen three of his TV series be cancelled despite high quality for being "too challenging" for the viewer(Murder One, EZ Streets).
#24
DVD Talk God
Joined: Feb 2000
Posts: 133,147
Received 896 Likes
on
740 Posts
From: Directionally Challenged (for DirecTV)
Originally posted by Decker
I have no idea why W/O a Trace is on that list. It gets good ratings and is the first show on either ABC or CBS to ever put a dent in ER's ratings. It also has about as good a lead-in as you could pray for (TV's #1 drama). I don't think it needs any help.
I have no idea why W/O a Trace is on that list. It gets good ratings and is the first show on either ABC or CBS to ever put a dent in ER's ratings. It also has about as good a lead-in as you could pray for (TV's #1 drama). I don't think it needs any help.
Good point. I assume that Trace does pretty well in the ratings. Far better than the rest of the shows on this list.



