DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Other Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/other-talk-9/)
-   -   Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/other-talk/630661-fine-bros-youtubers-attempting-license-reaction-videos.html)

mhg83 01-31-16 10:39 AM

Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 
For those that don't follow Youtube there's a popular channel called React. They have over 5 million subscribers. There other channel Fine Brothers Entertainment has over 15 million subscribers. Now These guys are quickly becoming the most hated people on the internet. It all started with this video:

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/r2UqT6SZ7CU" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

The Reaction to React World was not taken well:

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/CRYnOPJiTaA" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/YN-vhZoO7wM" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Today they issued a clarification/apology video:

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/0t-vuI9vKfg" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

They actually attempted to go after Ellen for her video where she shows kids old technology:

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/3CMS9xnBRkc" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

http://i272.photobucket.com/albums/j...svhzplwtp.jpeg
https://twitter.com/thefinebros/stat...61415016341504

It's ridiculous they're attempting this. They act like they've created Reaction Videos. These types of videos have been around long before they came along. The first i remember was Beavis and Butthead and to an extent America's Funniest Videos.

mndtrp 01-31-16 10:53 AM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 
Can you give me the cliffnotes version, so I don't have to watch over a half hour of videos?

mhg83 01-31-16 10:59 AM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 
Sure:

YouTubers Go to War Over Fine Empire’s Attempt to License ‘Reaction’ Videos

If you want to make a YouTube video of someone reacting to something, you’ll have to go through the Fine Bros. Variety reports that Rafi and Benny Fine, who’ve built a YouTube empire on interviewing kids, teens, and old folks about various pop-cultural phenomena, have set up a new venture called React World. It aims to aggregate and monetize every “react” video on YouTube — as in, "Someone Reacts to Something" — with the Fines handling licensing and taking a cut of the profit. And other prominent YouTubers are pissed.

Here’s how React World will operate, according to Variety and the Fines’ enthusiastic announcement video: Any non-Fine-affiliated channel that wants to make “react”-style videos will be able to get a license from the Fines, which comes with a brand bible ensuring the videos meet the brothers’ specifications. The Fine Bros. will push all the videos through their React World channel, exposing them to a large, preexisting audience, and take a cut of the revenue in return.


This also applies to a bunch of other Fine Bros. video templates, including “Do They Know It,” “People Vs Food,” “Lyric Breakdown,” “Try Not to Smile or Laugh,” “Opinions,” and “People Vs Technology.” And the Fines have acquired the trademarks to go with them: Yes, they trademarked “React” and “Opinions” for the YouTube video market.

This did not sit well with the hosts of popular YouTube video-game comedy channel Mega64, who see the Fines consolidation of their brand as an insincere cash-grab that will stop other channels from using what seem like pretty broad and generic video formats. And on top of that, they fear the Fines will try to … er, fine, anyone whose videos come too close to the territory they’ve staked out.

Here’s their parody of the Fine Bros. announcement, in which they mockingly announce that they’ve copyrighted “Videos Filmed Outside” and “YouTube Videos™.”


They may not be clear on the difference between copyright and trademark, but maybe they have a point. Does anyone other than the Fine Bros. benefit from making sure videos of people reacting to things are aesthetically similar and consolidated under one brand?

The implicit message of Mega64’s video is a solid one, too: YouTubers still have the power of parody. The bigger, more profitable, and more recognizable something becomes, the stronger the legal grounds for mocking it. A sincere “React” competitor might not be able to stand up to the Fine Bros., but a parodic one can certainly try to thumb its nose at them.

http://nymag.com/following/2016/01/y...ct-videos.html

DVD Polizei 01-31-16 11:16 AM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 

The Fine Bros. will push all the videos through their React World channel
As long as a person isn't dumb enough to push their videos through the Fine Bros., you're FINE. :)

What do people expect when they push their content through an online pimp agency, exploiting somebody else's work. :lol:

Do it yourself. Upload your videos to YouTube or whoever yourself.

Red Hood 01-31-16 11:19 AM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 
Isn't America's Funniest Home Videos and other type of shows like this basically the originators of the "Reaction" videos? Where the hell do the Fine brothers get the idea that they came up with this and now they need copyright and trademark the concept? That would be like Major League Baseball saying that they own the game of baseball and no one else can play it unless it's approved by them.

Groucho 01-31-16 12:12 PM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 
The real abomination here is the font in that Facebook screenshot.

Why So Blu? 01-31-16 12:17 PM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 

Originally Posted by Red Hood (Post 12711364)
Isn't America's Funniest Home Videos and other type of shows like this basically the originators of the "Reaction" videos? Where the hell do the Fine brothers get the idea that they came up with this and now they need copyright and trademark the concept? That would be like Major League Baseball saying that they own the game of baseball and no one else can play it unless it's approved by them.

No. Those were clips of people getting fucked up and then we laugh at them.

Reaction videos are stupid.

Living Dead 01-31-16 12:35 PM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 
I've never understood why anyone would watch reaction videos. Never heard of the Fine Bros., but the fact that they've made themselves into millionaires off this shit is just mind-boggling.

It's also incredibly amusing how they look like they're hopped up on coke in their first video, and then in the apology video they're sitting down and look all sad and mopey like someone stole their candy.

Decker 01-31-16 12:46 PM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 

Originally Posted by Living Dead (Post 12711386)
I've never understood why anyone would watch reaction videos. Never heard of the Fine Bros., but the fact that they've made themselves into millionaires off this shit is just mind-boggling.

It's also incredibly amusing how they look like they're hopped up on coke in their first video, and then in the apology video they're sitting down and look all sad and mopey like someone stole their candy.

:lol:
Yeah, that was a really douchy initial video. You mean I can film people reacting to stuff and you can share my profits from it? Really? AWESOME!!!!!!

What a couple of asses.

filmerp 01-31-16 02:51 PM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 
At 2:56, the left brother has a look as if he just cured cancer. I'm enjoying watching these guys' fanbase turn on them as a result of their arrogance.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r2UqT6SZ7CU&t=2m58s

kvrdave 01-31-16 03:45 PM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 
Based on the overall reaction, I'll assume these guys were also responsible for a recent update to Clash of Clans.

DaveyJoe 01-31-16 04:11 PM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 
They had better be nice to their Uber drivers until this all blows over.

mhg83 01-31-16 04:40 PM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 
They're trying to Trademark "Try Not To Laugh" Which is a rip off of "You Raff You Ruse" series on 4chan. Yet they're crying that people are stealing their work :lol:

DaveyJoe 01-31-16 04:44 PM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 
https://i.imgur.com/BUv5bXu.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/Bint0ro.gif

Norm de Plume 01-31-16 05:15 PM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 12711397)
What a couple of asses.

Indeed. They should do an Asshole Tour with Ramkissoon and Shkreli. The latter would headline.

Bronkster 01-31-16 05:54 PM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 
<iframe width="420" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/a1Y73sPHKxw" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

mhg83 01-31-16 07:11 PM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 
<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/Z-Zr7c-J6qE" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

mhg83 01-31-16 07:21 PM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 
Someones livestreaming the sub count. 13.9m and dropping

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PVPwzBrmRwg

Kurt D 01-31-16 08:16 PM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 
What a pair of douchebags. Capitalism sucks sometimes. I'm going to copyright 'Images captured with light'.

Fuck you, peoples eyeballs! You see something, you pay me!

Crocker Jarmen 01-31-16 09:14 PM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 
Is the guy on the left Marty Feldman's grandson?

Why So Blu? 01-31-16 09:20 PM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 

Originally Posted by mhg83 (Post 12711607)
Someones livestreaming the sub count. 13.9m and dropping

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PVPwzBrmRwg




Oh shit, that's quite hilarious. They've got Darude's "Sandstorm" playing! :dance:

:lol:

covenant 01-31-16 10:42 PM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 
Like this one better:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WH0qahqv5YM

EddieMoney 02-01-16 10:11 AM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 
Possibly two of the douchiest looking fucks I have ever seen.

starseed1981 02-01-16 10:15 AM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 
So basically these morons have a product which is based on other peoples content. And they can make money with that model but nobody else can? LOL

Nick Danger 02-01-16 11:26 AM

Re: Fine Bro's Youtuber's Attempting To License 'Reaction' Videos
 
What is a "react" video? Is that like what Allen Funt did on Candid Camera in the 1940s?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:06 PM.


Copyright 2018 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.