Dealing with "Fatty" on the Plane
#651
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Dealing with "Fatty" on the Plane
That's just strange if they have a policy requiring a person to purchase two tickets if they are deemed "fat". I guess if you board late and there's nothing but singles left you have to get them to move someone so you can get your two seats together!?
#652
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Dealing with "Fatty" on the Plane
No, they do not have assigned seats. But buying 2 seats is buying 2 seats. Otherwise, by the same logic, you could ask a 2-Ticket XL Passenger to please tilt to the left so you can sit under half of them.
Trust me, anyone will be happy to go sit in a different seat rather than having a passenger requiring 2 seats squeeze in. They might qualify for early boarding as well. Sometimes, though rare, passengers have to move as it is for load balancing.
Trust me, anyone will be happy to go sit in a different seat rather than having a passenger requiring 2 seats squeeze in. They might qualify for early boarding as well. Sometimes, though rare, passengers have to move as it is for load balancing.
Last edited by Th0r S1mpson; 02-15-10 at 03:10 PM.
#653
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Malvern, PA
Posts: 5,010
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Dealing with "Fatty" on the Plane
Take all of these statements and replace 'fat' with 'black', 'jew', 'gay', 'young', 'old' or 'disabled' and then you get an idea of how prejudiced you sound. Oh yeah, I know, I know, fat people CHOOSE to be fat. Great way to dismiss your fucked up behaviour. Even if it was true, (and science is still out on that), why would you want to be such an ugly person?

#654
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Malvern, PA
Posts: 5,010
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#655
DVD Talk God
Re: Dealing with "Fatty" on the Plane

#656
Suspended
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 290
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Dealing with "Fatty" on the Plane
You can toss all the sarcasm out that you wish-- it only makes you look bad.
I can't site specific studies on this but there is evidence that each individual has a "preferred" weight that the body attempts to maintain, not gaining or losing much from that weight. Which can result in a very skinny person who can't keep weight on no matter how hard they try, and can result in a very fat person who can't keep weight off no matter how hard they try. Even if both people have the same diet and level of activity. Only in rare (possibly pathological) cases do fat people continue to get fatter for the rest of their lives. More normal is to reach an adult fat weight and pretty much stay there. If you loose a lot of it by dieting and start regaining, you will tend to return to more or less the same weight you were before. So yes, the science is still out on that.
Edit-- found a citation:
http://www.jci.org/articles/view/17953
I can't site specific studies on this but there is evidence that each individual has a "preferred" weight that the body attempts to maintain, not gaining or losing much from that weight. Which can result in a very skinny person who can't keep weight on no matter how hard they try, and can result in a very fat person who can't keep weight off no matter how hard they try. Even if both people have the same diet and level of activity. Only in rare (possibly pathological) cases do fat people continue to get fatter for the rest of their lives. More normal is to reach an adult fat weight and pretty much stay there. If you loose a lot of it by dieting and start regaining, you will tend to return to more or less the same weight you were before. So yes, the science is still out on that.
Edit-- found a citation:
http://www.jci.org/articles/view/17953
Last edited by Deep_lurk; 02-15-10 at 04:38 PM.
#657
DVD Talk God
Re: Dealing with "Fatty" on the Plane
so what you are saying is if you exercise and eat sensibly as a fat person, you won't lose (not loose) weight?

#659
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Dealing with "Fatty" on the Plane
I think I get it, don't say fat. People who are too large for their seats should be required to buy a second. Most 'fat' people fit into their seats just fine and there are certainly huge people who aren't 'fat.'
Is that still unacceptable? (or is the argument that special circumstances should be granted like handicap seating?)
Is that still unacceptable? (or is the argument that special circumstances should be granted like handicap seating?)
Last edited by starman9000; 02-15-10 at 05:06 PM.
#661
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Dealing with "Fatty" on the Plane
now he's going to get kicked from twitter for being too fat (PC: "Over Capacity")
*nice imagery by Twitter showing that he's as big as a whale and not even 8 Southwest planes could carry him.
*nice imagery by Twitter showing that he's as big as a whale and not even 8 Southwest planes could carry him.
#663
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Working for Gizmonic Institute
Posts: 10,428
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Re: Dealing with "Fatty" on the Plane
Take all of these statements and replace 'fat' with 'black', 'jew', 'gay', 'young', 'old' or 'disabled' and then you get an idea of how prejudiced you sound. Oh yeah, I know, I know, fat people CHOOSE to be fat. Great way to dismiss your fucked up behaviour. Even if it was true, (and science is still out on that), why would you want to be such an ugly person?
Oh well, this forum has become a pretty fucking, ugly place as of late anyway...
#665
DVD Talk God
#666
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Apr 1999
Posts: 1,369
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Dealing with "Fatty" on the Plane
#668
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Dealing with "Fatty" on the Plane
I know why I'm fat. I like food. If I get so big that I can't fit on an airplane, instead of whining about it, I'll lose a little weight.
It's not like I would be catering to the "you can't be too thin" crowd, I would just lose enough to get what I want; an airplane seat. Then, I could still enjoy my food, and be the happy person everyone loves.
It's not like I would be catering to the "you can't be too thin" crowd, I would just lose enough to get what I want; an airplane seat. Then, I could still enjoy my food, and be the happy person everyone loves.
#669
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: El Paso, TX
Posts: 1,781
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Dealing with "Fatty" on the Plane
I know why I'm fat. I like food. If I get so big that I can't fit on an airplane, instead of whining about it, I'll lose a little weight.
It's not like I would be catering to the "you can't be too thin" crowd, I would just lose enough to get what I want; an airplane seat. Then, I could still enjoy my food, and be the happy person everyone loves.
It's not like I would be catering to the "you can't be too thin" crowd, I would just lose enough to get what I want; an airplane seat. Then, I could still enjoy my food, and be the happy person everyone loves.
#671
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Dealing with "Fatty" on the Plane
Update: I was just on a short flight from Chicago. The woman next to me was very fidgety and it was slightly annoying. The guy behind me kicked my seat back a couple of times (presumably by accident). The guy in front of me reclined his seat, which made my flight less pleasant. Nobody was kicked off the plane.
No fatties were to be seen, unless I count (I fit in my seat just fine with the armrests down, but I could stand to lose a few pounds).
No fatties were to be seen, unless I count (I fit in my seat just fine with the armrests down, but I could stand to lose a few pounds).
#672
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Dealing with "Fatty" on the Plane
You can toss all the sarcasm out that you wish-- it only makes you look bad.
I can't site specific studies on this but there is evidence that each individual has a "preferred" weight that the body attempts to maintain, not gaining or losing much from that weight. Which can result in a very skinny person who can't keep weight on no matter how hard they try, and can result in a very fat person who can't keep weight off no matter how hard they try. Even if both people have the same diet and level of activity. Only in rare (possibly pathological) cases do fat people continue to get fatter for the rest of their lives. More normal is to reach an adult fat weight and pretty much stay there. If you loose a lot of it by dieting and start regaining, you will tend to return to more or less the same weight you were before. So yes, the science is still out on that.
Edit-- found a citation:
http://www.jci.org/articles/view/17953
I can't site specific studies on this but there is evidence that each individual has a "preferred" weight that the body attempts to maintain, not gaining or losing much from that weight. Which can result in a very skinny person who can't keep weight on no matter how hard they try, and can result in a very fat person who can't keep weight off no matter how hard they try. Even if both people have the same diet and level of activity. Only in rare (possibly pathological) cases do fat people continue to get fatter for the rest of their lives. More normal is to reach an adult fat weight and pretty much stay there. If you loose a lot of it by dieting and start regaining, you will tend to return to more or less the same weight you were before. So yes, the science is still out on that.
Edit-- found a citation:
http://www.jci.org/articles/view/17953
"Nonpharmacological treatments for obesity include behavior therapy, exercise, and calorie-restricted diets. The goal of behavior therapy is to overcome barriers to compliance with a diet and physical activity regimen. Physical activity increases energy expenditure and is a key component of any weight maintenance program, counteracting the reduction in total energy expenditure that occurs with weight loss. In general, patients should build up to a 30-to 45-minute exercise regimen, daily if possible, of the greatest intensity exercise that is safe for their own level of fitness. Improvement in cardiovascular risk is observed through regular exercise even if no weight is lost (25).
In order to induce weight loss a calorie deficit must be created. The optimal macronutrient composition of a weight-reducing diet is controversial."
#673
Re: Dealing with "Fatty" on the Plane
Jesus Christo, JasonF. How many times do we have to repeat this to you.
Fatties don't take short flights.
Fatties don't take short flights.

#674
Re: Dealing with "Fatty" on the Plane
The study you cite, does not say what you say. In fact, it gives several ways to lose weight including this quote,
"Nonpharmacological treatments for obesity include behavior therapy, exercise, and calorie-restricted diets. The goal of behavior therapy is to overcome barriers to compliance with a diet and physical activity regimen. Physical activity increases energy expenditure and is a key component of any weight maintenance program, counteracting the reduction in total energy expenditure that occurs with weight loss. In general, patients should build up to a 30-to 45-minute exercise regimen, daily if possible, of the greatest intensity exercise that is safe for their own level of fitness. Improvement in cardiovascular risk is observed through regular exercise even if no weight is lost (25).
In order to induce weight loss a calorie deficit must be created. The optimal macronutrient composition of a weight-reducing diet is controversial."
"Nonpharmacological treatments for obesity include behavior therapy, exercise, and calorie-restricted diets. The goal of behavior therapy is to overcome barriers to compliance with a diet and physical activity regimen. Physical activity increases energy expenditure and is a key component of any weight maintenance program, counteracting the reduction in total energy expenditure that occurs with weight loss. In general, patients should build up to a 30-to 45-minute exercise regimen, daily if possible, of the greatest intensity exercise that is safe for their own level of fitness. Improvement in cardiovascular risk is observed through regular exercise even if no weight is lost (25).
In order to induce weight loss a calorie deficit must be created. The optimal macronutrient composition of a weight-reducing diet is controversial."
#675
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Dealing with "Fatty" on the Plane
I mean, I know Kevin Smith was fat, but that dude turned into a land orca in the past few years. He's fucking enormous. I know they're not hurting me (except through MediCare and the like), but I'm getting more than a little sick of fat Americans. Mildly overweight is somewhat understandable, but 300+ pounds is ridiculous. I beg of you, have some respect for yourself. It's really not that hard to keep the waist in the thirties...