View Poll Results: Are you done purchasing CDs?
Voters: 89. You may not vote on this poll
Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
#51
DVD Talk Reviewer & TOAT Winner
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
I've been buying CDs since 1985, the only advancement to come along since then has been SACD and that's had generally bad support overall and for the most part replaced by Blu-Ray albums which aren't considered a different format.
I fail to see how more 'convenient' buying digital music is even more than movies- at least if I buy a digital movie I can fire up a few different apps on my Roku and watch it. I don't see any way to do the same for music other than through Amazon or Google Play. I have a bunch of free music on both but the interfaces are a bit awkward. Seems like if I bought a digital album I'd either have to use Amazon Music on the Roku (I don't think there even is any way to listen to Google Play music on that), buy an Apple TV unit to use ITunes, or download it to something- and then how would I listen to it on my main system?
I used to buy a ton of CDs every month, but that stopped when the record labels started RAISING their prices at a time when CD manufacturing costs had dropped. In the 80s there was speculation that CD prices would drop when the costs did, but aside from catalog titles that didn't happen. A few years later DVDs came along and those were priced a lot lower in comparison- in some cases you could buy a movie on DVD with extras for LESS than what the soundtrack album on CD would cost you. Music DVDs were a better value also and that's mainly what I've spent my money on music-wise since then- you usually get the music in multi-channel instead of boring 2-channel stereo, plus visuals along with it. My last big music purchase was last month, the Tangerine Dream box set which has all the music they recorded in the 70s for Virgin Records on 16 CDs plus two Blu-Rays with multi-channel mixes and concert footage- the Blu-Rays were the main reason I bought it. I don't see much point in concert albums with no picture to go along with them.
New music in general seems to have declined, in quality as well as record sales. There are a few recent songs I have liked but not enough to go buy the album and then spend the time listening to it. (In the old days I would usually give every CD a first play with headphones while reading the included lyrics if there were any, otherwise just staring at the liner notes and pictures. I don't have time to do that as much now.) The "loudness war" mixing trend is a definite problem and doesn't give people much reason to buy such music on a better-quality medium. Radio has generally gotten more bland (the top-rated station here right now is "Classic Rock" which only plays older songs, I personally would rather hear new stuff on the radio and buy the older stuff I want to keep hearing again) and of course MTV hardly even plays music anymore (if music videos aren't a "thing" anymore, then why not show concerts and the like, rather than what they've gone to now?) Something needs to be done to bring the excitement back.
I fail to see how more 'convenient' buying digital music is even more than movies- at least if I buy a digital movie I can fire up a few different apps on my Roku and watch it. I don't see any way to do the same for music other than through Amazon or Google Play. I have a bunch of free music on both but the interfaces are a bit awkward. Seems like if I bought a digital album I'd either have to use Amazon Music on the Roku (I don't think there even is any way to listen to Google Play music on that), buy an Apple TV unit to use ITunes, or download it to something- and then how would I listen to it on my main system?
I used to buy a ton of CDs every month, but that stopped when the record labels started RAISING their prices at a time when CD manufacturing costs had dropped. In the 80s there was speculation that CD prices would drop when the costs did, but aside from catalog titles that didn't happen. A few years later DVDs came along and those were priced a lot lower in comparison- in some cases you could buy a movie on DVD with extras for LESS than what the soundtrack album on CD would cost you. Music DVDs were a better value also and that's mainly what I've spent my money on music-wise since then- you usually get the music in multi-channel instead of boring 2-channel stereo, plus visuals along with it. My last big music purchase was last month, the Tangerine Dream box set which has all the music they recorded in the 70s for Virgin Records on 16 CDs plus two Blu-Rays with multi-channel mixes and concert footage- the Blu-Rays were the main reason I bought it. I don't see much point in concert albums with no picture to go along with them.
New music in general seems to have declined, in quality as well as record sales. There are a few recent songs I have liked but not enough to go buy the album and then spend the time listening to it. (In the old days I would usually give every CD a first play with headphones while reading the included lyrics if there were any, otherwise just staring at the liner notes and pictures. I don't have time to do that as much now.) The "loudness war" mixing trend is a definite problem and doesn't give people much reason to buy such music on a better-quality medium. Radio has generally gotten more bland (the top-rated station here right now is "Classic Rock" which only plays older songs, I personally would rather hear new stuff on the radio and buy the older stuff I want to keep hearing again) and of course MTV hardly even plays music anymore (if music videos aren't a "thing" anymore, then why not show concerts and the like, rather than what they've gone to now?) Something needs to be done to bring the excitement back.
#52
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
I did this exactly around 15 years ago. The type of stuff I was buying on cd circa mid-2000s, were cd compilations of rare material such as demos, unreleased albums, live recordings, etc ... which were never released back in the day. (I avoided bootlegs and looked for official releases, typically released by indie record companies or self-released by the actual band). Back in the day, many of these were "holy grails" and legendary for the hardcore fans.
Unfortunately I found out the hard way that just about all of these cds I purchased were a huge disappointment. There was a big reason why most of these "holy grails" were never released back in the day: they were a total embarrassment and/or sounded like complete garbage.
This eventually led to my exit from the cd collecting market.
#53
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
I'll always buy them - even with Google now streaming at 320 kbps - I like the tangible and the artwork (even though most artists barely include any artwork nowadays).
#54
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
(On a tangent).
It seems like Iron Maiden releases a live album (or dvd) for almost every single tour since y2k. The few I have purchased don't seem to live up to their old classic Live After Death or a Real Live/Dead One albums. Post-y2k it sounds like they are uninspired or bored during these live recordings.
It seems like Iron Maiden releases a live album (or dvd) for almost every single tour since y2k. The few I have purchased don't seem to live up to their old classic Live After Death or a Real Live/Dead One albums. Post-y2k it sounds like they are uninspired or bored during these live recordings.
#55
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
Only of my favorite band to keep the collection going...so once every 3 or so years?
#56
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
New music in general seems to have declined, in quality as well as record sales. There are a few recent songs I have liked but not enough to go buy the album and then spend the time listening to it. (In the old days I would usually give every CD a first play with headphones while reading the included lyrics if there were any, otherwise just staring at the liner notes and pictures. I don't have time to do that as much now.) The "loudness war" mixing trend is a definite problem and doesn't give people much reason to buy such music on a better-quality medium. Radio has generally gotten more bland (the top-rated station here right now is "Classic Rock" which only plays older songs, I personally would rather hear new stuff on the radio and buy the older stuff I want to keep hearing again) and of course MTV hardly even plays music anymore (if music videos aren't a "thing" anymore, then why not show concerts and the like, rather than what they've gone to now?) Something needs to be done to bring the excitement back.
#57
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
I am perfectly content to use Spotify for all of my music needs, and once upon a time I had 100s of CDs. I think the last CD I bought was Taylor Swift for my daughter, back before she relented and allowed her catalog on Spotify. In fact, I could have gotten a free copy of the latest Raconteurs when I bought concert tickets, but I gave the code away instead.
#58
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Jun 1999
Location: Part of the Left-Wing Conspiracy
Posts: 7,538
Received 204 Likes
on
118 Posts
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
I've been buying CDs since 1985, the only advancement to come along since then has been SACD and that's had generally bad support overall and for the most part replaced by Blu-Ray albums which aren't considered a different format.
I fail to see how more 'convenient' buying digital music is even more than movies- at least if I buy a digital movie I can fire up a few different apps on my Roku and watch it. I don't see any way to do the same for music other than through Amazon or Google Play. I have a bunch of free music on both but the interfaces are a bit awkward. Seems like if I bought a digital album I'd either have to use Amazon Music on the Roku (I don't think there even is any way to listen to Google Play music on that), buy an Apple TV unit to use ITunes, or download it to something- and then how would I listen to it on my main system?
I used to buy a ton of CDs every month, but that stopped when the record labels started RAISING their prices at a time when CD manufacturing costs had dropped. In the 80s there was speculation that CD prices would drop when the costs did, but aside from catalog titles that didn't happen. A few years later DVDs came along and those were priced a lot lower in comparison- in some cases you could buy a movie on DVD with extras for LESS than what the soundtrack album on CD would cost you. Music DVDs were a better value also and that's mainly what I've spent my money on music-wise since then- you usually get the music in multi-channel instead of boring 2-channel stereo, plus visuals along with it. My last big music purchase was last month, the Tangerine Dream box set which has all the music they recorded in the 70s for Virgin Records on 16 CDs plus two Blu-Rays with multi-channel mixes and concert footage- the Blu-Rays were the main reason I bought it. I don't see much point in concert albums with no picture to go along with them.
New music in general seems to have declined, in quality as well as record sales. There are a few recent songs I have liked but not enough to go buy the album and then spend the time listening to it. (In the old days I would usually give every CD a first play with headphones while reading the included lyrics if there were any, otherwise just staring at the liner notes and pictures. I don't have time to do that as much now.) The "loudness war" mixing trend is a definite problem and doesn't give people much reason to buy such music on a better-quality medium. Radio has generally gotten more bland (the top-rated station here right now is "Classic Rock" which only plays older songs, I personally would rather hear new stuff on the radio and buy the older stuff I want to keep hearing again) and of course MTV hardly even plays music anymore (if music videos aren't a "thing" anymore, then why not show concerts and the like, rather than what they've gone to now?) Something needs to be done to bring the excitement back.
I fail to see how more 'convenient' buying digital music is even more than movies- at least if I buy a digital movie I can fire up a few different apps on my Roku and watch it. I don't see any way to do the same for music other than through Amazon or Google Play. I have a bunch of free music on both but the interfaces are a bit awkward. Seems like if I bought a digital album I'd either have to use Amazon Music on the Roku (I don't think there even is any way to listen to Google Play music on that), buy an Apple TV unit to use ITunes, or download it to something- and then how would I listen to it on my main system?
I used to buy a ton of CDs every month, but that stopped when the record labels started RAISING their prices at a time when CD manufacturing costs had dropped. In the 80s there was speculation that CD prices would drop when the costs did, but aside from catalog titles that didn't happen. A few years later DVDs came along and those were priced a lot lower in comparison- in some cases you could buy a movie on DVD with extras for LESS than what the soundtrack album on CD would cost you. Music DVDs were a better value also and that's mainly what I've spent my money on music-wise since then- you usually get the music in multi-channel instead of boring 2-channel stereo, plus visuals along with it. My last big music purchase was last month, the Tangerine Dream box set which has all the music they recorded in the 70s for Virgin Records on 16 CDs plus two Blu-Rays with multi-channel mixes and concert footage- the Blu-Rays were the main reason I bought it. I don't see much point in concert albums with no picture to go along with them.
New music in general seems to have declined, in quality as well as record sales. There are a few recent songs I have liked but not enough to go buy the album and then spend the time listening to it. (In the old days I would usually give every CD a first play with headphones while reading the included lyrics if there were any, otherwise just staring at the liner notes and pictures. I don't have time to do that as much now.) The "loudness war" mixing trend is a definite problem and doesn't give people much reason to buy such music on a better-quality medium. Radio has generally gotten more bland (the top-rated station here right now is "Classic Rock" which only plays older songs, I personally would rather hear new stuff on the radio and buy the older stuff I want to keep hearing again) and of course MTV hardly even plays music anymore (if music videos aren't a "thing" anymore, then why not show concerts and the like, rather than what they've gone to now?) Something needs to be done to bring the excitement back.
#59
DVD Talk Reviewer & TOAT Winner
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
Well, I guess I'm a luddite because I don't know how to play digital music on too many devices. It certainly isn't as easy as playing movies, quality notwithstanding. My main concern is my main system anyways, and that has plenty of disc players- and I've found they DO sound better than 'digital'. I do listen to a lot of online radio and such, but I don't pay for that.
Yes there is still good music being made now, but it hardly ever gets played on the radio or other mainstream outlets. The stuff that gets promoted the most is usually garbage, IMHO. In the 80s I liked the more 'underground' stuff than mainstream also, but even most of the mainstream music was still listenable and deserving of good sound quality.
Yes there is still good music being made now, but it hardly ever gets played on the radio or other mainstream outlets. The stuff that gets promoted the most is usually garbage, IMHO. In the 80s I liked the more 'underground' stuff than mainstream also, but even most of the mainstream music was still listenable and deserving of good sound quality.
#60
Cool New Member
Join Date: Jul 2019
Posts: 47
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
Dead format? It's not like someone purchasing a VHS tape in 2019. Retailers worldwilde still stock CDs and will probably continue to do so for some time.
Digital distribution is convenient, but it's not an all-around superior alternative (much less successor) to audio CDs. I do like to have lossless archival backups of my music via physical media, and CDs of course serve that purpose just fine. Digital distribution services on the other hand usually provide only lossy, inferior encodings that may be locked down by DRM that restricts how the audio can be migrated from one device to another. And vendors sometimes use this kind of DRM maliciously to create a vendor lock-in scenario where customers can playback purchased audio using only certain software or licensed devices. (e.g. Apple music services functioning only on Apple devices - which has been the case in the past)
Digital distribution is convenient, but it's not an all-around superior alternative (much less successor) to audio CDs. I do like to have lossless archival backups of my music via physical media, and CDs of course serve that purpose just fine. Digital distribution services on the other hand usually provide only lossy, inferior encodings that may be locked down by DRM that restricts how the audio can be migrated from one device to another. And vendors sometimes use this kind of DRM maliciously to create a vendor lock-in scenario where customers can playback purchased audio using only certain software or licensed devices. (e.g. Apple music services functioning only on Apple devices - which has been the case in the past)
#61
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
Digital distribution seems to be built almost entirely around everyone using their phone as a listening device. Which is fine for casual music listeners and probably the best business model for record labels, but it's a terribly poor system for serious listeners.
What's funny is that the record labels themselves think digital sales will be dead in a couple of years - they expect almost all future music revenue will be streaming subscriptions. Make no mistake, I believe the major labels are actively pushing people towards this cliff for their own benefit.
What's funny is that the record labels themselves think digital sales will be dead in a couple of years - they expect almost all future music revenue will be streaming subscriptions. Make no mistake, I believe the major labels are actively pushing people towards this cliff for their own benefit.
#63
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
I've seen a list of recent cars with available CD options somewhere on the net. It's a strange array of random models. Many manufacturers have re-engineered their center consoles for computer interfaces, so CDs often have nowhere left to go.
#64
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
I will NEVER stop buying CD's.
Streaming sucks. No streaming service has all the music I want. No streaming service has the sound quality of CD's. Fuck that.
I like listening to what I want, when I want. I can play the CD, or rip a high quality MP3 for my car. I've got lots of options - and a master copy of every album I own. I've had 4 computers crap out on me, and I just lost an external hard drive 6 months ago. So downloads are out. Streaming is out (limited selection, inferior sound quality).
CD's are still the best format - the best way to listen to music.
Streaming sucks. No streaming service has all the music I want. No streaming service has the sound quality of CD's. Fuck that.
I like listening to what I want, when I want. I can play the CD, or rip a high quality MP3 for my car. I've got lots of options - and a master copy of every album I own. I've had 4 computers crap out on me, and I just lost an external hard drive 6 months ago. So downloads are out. Streaming is out (limited selection, inferior sound quality).
CD's are still the best format - the best way to listen to music.
#65
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
I'll agree, but the major labels themselves are starting to gear the system away from CDs entirely. It's pretty clear there's a small contingent of older consumers that would support CD indefinitely, but trends like CD-Rs replacing pressed discs for older and niche material isn't good.
#66
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: True North Strong & Free
Posts: 23,174
Received 2,196 Likes
on
1,501 Posts
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
For some reason, major labels are practically forcing the obsolescence of the CD format themselves.
#67
Cool New Member
Join Date: Jul 2019
Posts: 47
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#68
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
They happen to own most popular legacy content. There was nice Beach Boys archival material released last year only through digital outlets - fans were up in arms. And remember, the average Beach Boys' customer is most definitely still buying CDs.
#69
DVD Talk Legend & 2021 TOTY Winner
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
I pretty much stopped buying CD's in 2015 when I purchase my current car, which doesn't have a CD Player. I ripped all of my CD's to a thumb drive that I keep in my car after that and haven't touched them since. The very few CD's that I have purchased or been given since then have gotten ripped and thrown in a drawer never to be seen again.
#70
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: True North Strong & Free
Posts: 23,174
Received 2,196 Likes
on
1,501 Posts
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
Luckily for me, the genre I mostly listen to (metal) is largely made up of fans who still very much buy all the stuff from bands they like (vinyl, CDs, tapes, t-shirts, etc.) Metal heads are the obsessive collector geeks of the music world.
#71
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
#72
DVD Talk Reviewer & TOAT Winner
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
I've finally resigned myself to buying used CDs- I normally don't like buying used media at all unless it's an obsolete format or something way out of print. Local record store which is going out of business had all their soundtrack CDs at $1 each, couldn't pass those up. Got Xanadu for the car, will keep listening to the 8-track at home
#73
New Member
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
I'm buying more CDs than ever. For me music is a serious pursuit, so I wish to secure access to my favorite recordings. Albums can disappear from streaming services at any moment, and there is a tremendous amount of music missing from them. It is also very rewarding to build up a collection. For casual listeners or for discovery streaming is fine, however for committed music lovers the CD has no substitute.
#74
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
^Wow. Talk about a lurker. That has got to be a record!
And I agree with your post. It's the same reason I still buy physical video media.
And I agree with your post. It's the same reason I still buy physical video media.
#75
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: True North Strong & Free
Posts: 23,174
Received 2,196 Likes
on
1,501 Posts
Re: Have you officially stopped buying compact discs?
I wonder about jazz and blues and physical media? Along with metal and classical, those are two other music genres with serious collectors/fans.