DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Music Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/music-talk-28/)
-   -   Most Disappointing Albums of 2012 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/music-talk/607137-most-disappointing-albums-2012-a.html)

Dan 12-10-12 05:59 PM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 

Originally Posted by emanon (Post 11501446)
I haven't listened to Born To Die yet, but I understand that half of it is crap.

Oh yeah?! Oh yeah!?!?!? What do YOU know??

You're probably right. I hated her Video Games song, so I never bothered with the rest.

reverie 12-11-12 09:14 AM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 
My biggest disappointment was Jeff Lynne's "Long Wave". So boring, and what the heck happened to his voice? At least I've got reissues with bonus material to look forward to apparently. :)

CRM114 12-11-12 11:05 AM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 
I'm willing to give it a few more listens but the Fiona Apple album leaves a lot to be desired.

Phodg 12-11-12 11:24 AM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 
Oops - meant to post in best albums thread, not worst ! :)

islandclaws 12-11-12 11:52 AM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 
The Sword - Apocryphon

Just boring, really. The only track I find myself jamming with it the title track, which is the last one on the album. It's like they got into a groove and became stuck there; the album is a midline, middling bore.

Quake1028 12-11-12 01:49 PM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 
Band of Horses - Mirage Rock
Justin Townes Earle - Nothing's Going to Change The Way You Feel About Me Now
fun. - Some Nights
Tennis - Young & Old
No Doubt - Push and Shove

Giantrobo 12-11-12 03:53 PM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 
Rush Clockwork Angels......im usually always into their albums but I skipped through the cd at the store and I felt no need to get it right away.

Thrush 12-12-12 04:03 AM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 

Originally Posted by JHosk (Post 11500805)
Mars Volta - Noctourniquet

This

Also

Bloc Party- Four

The Bus 12-12-12 06:11 AM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 

Originally Posted by Rocketdog2000 (Post 11499668)
Yep, I'd add these two to my list for the same reasons. As well as ...

Ben Folds Five - The Sound Of The Life Of The Mind, for also just being kind of "mehw", after the long absence of a Ben Folds Five release.

This is one of the most disappointing albums in a very, very long time. I couldn't find thirty consecutive seconds I liked, and I've listened to a lot of his stuff.


Originally Posted by Hiro11 (Post 11500995)
Grizzly Bear - Shields - I really liked their earlier stuff and this one initially sounded good. The more I listened, the more it descended into indie-rock bullshit, pretention and pointless noise. Get over yourselves, guys.

All electronica - I didn't hear a single good electronica album this year.

Alabama Shakes - Boys and Girls - came into this year on a tidal wave of hype as a live act.

On <i>Shields</i> play tracks 2, 4, 6, and 9 in a row. Tell me if you still feel the same way.

As for electronica? I am guessing you didn't pick up <i>Fin</i>. If you did, then our tastes are so far apart I can't continue this conversation. ;)

And I agree on <i>Boys and Girls</i>. Really want to see these guys live but that album was a sleeping pill.


Originally Posted by Thrush (Post 11503238)
Bloc Party- Four

Would agree if they had had any good output since their debut.

mattysemo247 12-12-12 12:21 PM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 
No Doubt - Push and Shove
Soundgarden - King Animal
Linkin Park - Living Things

chino77 12-12-12 12:39 PM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 
Band of horses was the first band I thought of when I read the thread title. I love every cd of theirs up until this one. I listened to it once and forgot about it.

Why So Blu? 12-12-12 01:06 PM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 

Originally Posted by Hiro11 (Post 11500995)
Torche - Harmonicraft - huge letdown after the instant classic "Meanderthal". This band was just maturing a hook-filled metal/punk/pop fusion that seemed primed to explode. I really thought they could have been huge. Instead, they went nowhere. I waited for years for this thing and it sounds like warmed over Foo Fighters.

Kendrick Lamar - Good Kid, MAAD City - probably the most critically acclaimed record of the year. I was looking forward to hearing it. I don't get it. Sophomoric, supposedly clever, sarcastic-but-not-really "gangsta" cliches over tired beats. Tried to get through the whole thing four times, gave up.

Grizzly Bear - Shields - I really liked their earlier stuff and this one initially sounded good. The more I listened, the more it descended into indie-rock bullshit, pretention and pointless noise. Get over yourselves, guys.

All electronica - I didn't hear a single good electronica album this year. This is not for lack of trying. Everything from experimental (Flying Lotus) to dance-oriented (Boys Noize) to indie-pop electronica (Dan Deacon) let me down. The entire genre (if you can call it that) just seems stalled and exhausted. Also, dubstep sucks.

Edit: just heard Memory Tapes "Grace/Confusion" which came out last week. First good electronic album of 2012 I've heard.

Alabama Shakes - Boys and Girls - came into this year on a tidal wave of hype as a live act. Supposedly Drive-by Tuckers Southern gothic with a heavy classic soul influence. Right up my alley, I thought. Instead what I heard was a bland Black Crowes-style roots rock LP with a generic blues belter on vocals. A perfectly boring record.



You should check out Julien-K's "We're Here With You" album. They're electronica infused rock. Great stuff!

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/q7da5lEzS6Q" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>


<iframe width="560" height="315" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/ioTlMZwZY20" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Dan1boy 12-12-12 02:39 PM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 
Julien K's first album was miles better than their sophomore effort. Just IMO.

Why So Blu? 12-12-12 02:56 PM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 

Originally Posted by Dan1boy (Post 11503854)
Julien K's first album was miles better than their sophomore effort. Just IMO.



I have it and enjoy it, but I like them equally. The first one was more industrial and less trance.

Jam Master Jay 12-12-12 03:20 PM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 
The Killers - Battle Born
Muse - The 2nd Law
B.o.B. - Strange Clouds (really liked the title track but that's it)
Lupe Fiasco - Food & Liquor II The Great American Rap Album, Pt. 1
Linkin Park - Living Things
The Ting Tings - Sounds from Nowheresville

nickdawgy 12-13-12 02:52 AM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 
You guys are harsh. Living Things and Some Nights were great albums.

JAA 12-13-12 06:25 AM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 

Originally Posted by chino77 (Post 11503681)
Band of horses was the first band I thought of when I read the thread title. I love every cd of theirs up until this one. I listened to it once and forgot about it.

A big ditto on this. I am a big fan of their first three albums. This last one left me cold. :thmbsdwn:

Dan1boy 12-13-12 04:40 PM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 

Originally Posted by Why So Blu? (Post 11503875)
I have it and enjoy it, but I like them equally. The first one was more industrial and less trance.

Also, catchier with complex melodies. The new record was flat for me. Sophomore Slump.

Rocketdog2000 12-13-12 09:46 PM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 
Well, it's somewhat comforting to know I was not alone in my disappointment of Band Of Horses. Seems like quite a few of us were.

Giles 12-13-12 10:04 PM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 

Originally Posted by reverie (Post 11502009)
My biggest disappointment was Jeff Lynne's "Long Wave". So boring, and what the heck happened to his voice? At least I've got reissues with bonus material to look forward to apparently. :)

I agree, I'm glad it wasn't only me who noted this too.

Giles 12-13-12 10:10 PM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 

Originally Posted by Hiro11 (Post 11500995)
Torche - Harmonicraft - huge letdown after the instant classic "Meanderthal". This band was just maturing a hook-filled metal/punk/pop fusion that seemed primed to explode. I really thought they could have been huge. Instead, they went nowhere. I waited for years for this thing and it sounds like warmed over Foo Fighters.

Kendrick Lamar - Good Kid, MAAD City - probably the most critically acclaimed record of the year. I was looking forward to hearing it. I don't get it. Sophomoric, supposedly clever, sarcastic-but-not-really "gangsta" cliches over tired beats. Tried to get through the whole thing four times, gave up.

Grizzly Bear - Shields - I really liked their earlier stuff and this one initially sounded good. The more I listened, the more it descended into indie-rock bullshit, pretention and pointless noise. Get over yourselves, guys.

All electronica - I didn't hear a single good electronica album this year. This is not for lack of trying. Everything from experimental (Flying Lotus) to dance-oriented (Boys Noize) to indie-pop electronica (Dan Deacon) let me down. The entire genre (if you can call it that) just seems stalled and exhausted. Also, dubstep sucks.

Edit: just heard Memory Tapes "Grace/Confusion" which came out last week. First good electronic album of 2012 I've heard.

Alabama Shakes - Boys and Girls - came into this year on a tidal wave of hype as a live act. Supposedly Drive-by Tuckers Southern gothic with a heavy classic soul influence. Right up my alley, I thought. Instead what I heard was a bland Black Crowes-style roots rock LP with a generic blues belter on vocals. A perfectly boring record.

don't you mean bro-step? - i.e, the shit that Skrillex puts out - the dubbier, grime-sound of 'early' dubstep is so much better and different.

the best 'dance' albums of the year for me, were from The Egg, Hot Chip and 2Bears (Hot Chip's Joe Goddard's 'house' sounding band), as for the Boys Noize album, the end song with Snoop Dogg really marred the album IMO. Even the new album from Orbital - was a return to form and welcome return for their fanbase.

Dan 12-13-12 10:29 PM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 

Originally Posted by nickdawgy (Post 11504551)
You guys are harsh. Living Things and Some Nights were great albums.

No way, man. Some Nights is terrible in comparison to Aim and Ignite. Far less blatantly unnecessary use of autotune on that older album.

Rocketdog2000 12-14-12 08:42 PM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 

Originally Posted by nickdawgy (Post 11504551)
You guys are harsh. Living Things and Some Nights were great albums.


Originally Posted by SomethingMore (Post 11505787)
No way, man. Some Nights is terrible in comparison to Aim and Ignite. Far less blatantly unnecessary use of autotune on that older album.

There's a song or two on Some Nights that I don't mind, but overall, I still prefer Nate Ruess' old band - The Format - much more than Fun.

Mr. Flix 12-15-12 08:39 AM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 

Originally Posted by CRM114 (Post 11502137)
I'm willing to give it a few more listens but the Fiona Apple album leaves a lot to be desired.

This. I've been a fan since Tidal, and I find the new album unlistenable with the exception of one song. Why critics drooled all over it is beyond me.

DVD Josh 12-15-12 10:19 AM

Re: Most Disappointing Albums of 2012
 
I've listened to the 2nd law about 20 times. I just can't get into it. It's not a good record.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:33 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.