KaBluie

Kylie Minogue has a song called "Love At First Sight" on her 1st album Kylie (1988-07-04) and a completely diferent song with the same name on her 8th album Fever (2001-10-01).

anomynous

Here we go:

Rage Against the Machine - Guerrilla Radio

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0lP0QxX-48U

Tom Morello - Guerrilla Radio

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T4IQmdA0TfM

benedict

Doctor Doctor By UFO, The Who, The Thomson Twins and, er, Just Jack.

EDIT: Rats! Why didn't I read the title properly!? Maybe there's an appropriate thread somewhere....

Travis McClain

George Strait
"She'll Leave You With A Smile" (Jackson Leap) - from the album Carrying Your Love With Me (1997)
"She'll Leave You With A Smile" (Odie Blackmon, Jay Knowles) - from the album The Road Less Traveled (2001)

Same recording artist, same song title, but different writers and hence, different songs. The Jackson Leap song was just an album cut, but the Blackmon/Knowles song was released as a single that hit #1 on the country charts in 2002. XM Radio played the 1997 song by mistake because they had the same title. Also, if you peruse the iTunes Essentials George Strait playlist, you'll see they, too, have included the Leap song instead of the #1 hit.

Gdrlv

Definitely not exactly the same, but the Avett Brothers have:

Pretty Girl from Matthews
Pretty Girl from Raleigh
Pretty Girl from Locust
Pretty Girl from Annapolis
Pretty Girl at the Airport
Pretty Girl from Cedar Lane
Pretty Girl from Feltre
Pretty Girl from Chile
Pretty Girl from San Diego

wishbone

By this stipulation Obituary has (2) different songs titled "Lost."

"Lost" from World Demise – 3:59
"Lost" from Darkest Days - 3:55