Holysmoker

I saw this banner ad and thought it odd.



Dark Side is not depressing to me. It's relaxing, athmospheric...but depressing?

Hokeyboy

It's either complete idiocy, ignorance, or hilarity.

I'm a HUGE Floyd fan, and I wouldn't even begin to call their music despressing. BUT it's definitely moody, evocative, ethereal, atmospheric, any dozen other adjectives. Depressing?? What would that make shit like THE SMITHS?

PopcornTreeCt

Yeah, when I think depressing I think Nirvana.

astrochimp

Yeah for me Dark Side is very soothing.Final Cut on the other hand bums me out,for many reasons.

cungar

Well if you pay attention to some of the lyrics it's pretty damn depressing.

The sun is the same in the relative way, but you're older
And shorter of breath and one day closer to death
Every year is getting shorter, never seem to find the time
Plans that either come to naught or half a page of scribbled lines
Hanging on in quiet desparation is the English way
The time is gone the song is over, thought I'd something more to say

Traxan

Pink Floyd was a study in contrasts, Roger Waters rage-driven lyrics with Gilmour's sublime playing. Depressing only comes into play when you think of Syd, and the band's sadness over his decline. Listening to 'Wish You Were Here' and knowing the story behind it is sad, but that's about it.

Hixx

Agreed, while DSOTM does indeed have some "dark" themes, overall I find it to be a fairly mellow and relaxing album.

It's Animals, The Wall and The Final Cut that are the real downers, especially the Wall which is a pretty much a catalog of human misery, but still genius.

slop101

I like the album just fine, but I've always found it more depressing than not.

story

I never think of Pink Floyd music as depressing, though while driving my wife home from the hospital after her car accident a few weeks ago, I had Meddle in the CD deck and she asked me to turn it off because it was too depressing.

johnbook

Funny that is the first band i thought of also, or really alot of the stuff from the 90's to me is depressing, but Pink Floyd no way i find there music relaxing.

TomOpus

Where did that banner lead to.... so I can avoid that website.

Kent2000

Well, "Dark Side" does features the sounds of mental patients talking and laughing in the background.... but I suspect that's a little too high-concept for whatever site that advertisement leads to! Personally, I find it more depressing that classic rock stations don't just play the full album instead of the abrupt-cut single tracks.

whaaat

The Wall is depressing. DSOTM is sublime.

Hokeyboy

Obscured By Clouds is groiny.

Traxan

If DSoTM is depressing, it's because a lot of what happened with Syd had begun to settle in. 'Brain Damage' is one example.

johnbook

Funny you mention Nirvana, was reading this yesterday..

Killjoy?
“I don’t mean it in a bad way, but I think Kurt Cobain and grunge took the fun out of rock ’n’ roll.”
The Killers’ Brandon Flowers in the U.K.’s Daily Star, blaming Nirvana and Kurt Cobain for making rock music depressing. Cobain committed suicide 15 years ago this month.

boc4ever

DSOTM is not depressing to me. Final Cut is one heartwrenching album, and probably my favorite Floyd disc.

nodeerforamonth

TOTALLY DEPRESSING! That's the first word that comes to my mind. (That and "boring".)

Sorry, I know that's going to be unpopular to say, but I don't smoke pot.

nodeerforamonth

Weird! I find Nirvana to be "happy" music to me! Different strokes...

"Sliver" is a song I can listen to 20 times in a row and it just brings a smile to my face. Even "Endless, Nameless" makes me joyful!

Dr Mabuse

I never listen to Pink Floyd with a loaded firearm handy.

cityslicks

Sorry, but when I hear Pink Floyd all I can do is smile.

al_bundy

my 19 month loves to go to sleep to it, we have an instrumental baby version of it

CharlieK

tcoursen

Not true about the mental patient thing. They went around the studio and asked a series of questions to various people. They cut up the answers to get the various voices and laughing sounds from those interviews.

K&AJones

You said what!!!!...Pink Floyd Depressing!!!....Get a rope....