DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Music Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/music-talk-28/)
-   -   One & only Sony "antipiracy" CD thread (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/music-talk/443984-one-only-sony-antipiracy-cd-thread.html)

kms_md 11-16-05 08:48 PM

there apparently are some class action lawsuits in the works. check out here -- about halfway down there are some interesting links.

masetodd 11-17-05 03:44 PM

It is apparent that they were test marketing this new copy-protection scheme. It only affects 20 or so titles (and looking at that list, I can't imagine more than 20 people buying that crap). I bet they were trying to slip this under the radar and it backfired. Hahahaha

I've always hated the way Sony tries to push its technology down people's throat. Buy our MiniDisc! Buy our MemoryStick! etc. etc. Oh well, the one thing to remember is that no matter how smart they think they are, there is always some computer geek out there who will break the code and post it on the Internet. So don't worry people!

Tracer Bullet 11-17-05 05:23 PM


Originally Posted by masetodd
It is apparent that they were test marketing this new copy-protection scheme. It only affects 20 or so titles (and looking at that list, I can't imagine more than 20 people buying that crap). I bet they were trying to slip this under the radar and it backfired. Hahahaha

I've always hated the way Sony tries to push its technology down people's throat. Buy our MiniDisc! Buy our MemoryStick! etc. etc. Oh well, the one thing to remember is that no matter how smart they think they are, there is always some computer geek out there who will break the code and post it on the Internet. So don't worry people!

Actually, it's much more dangerous than that. Sony (deliberately or not) provided a means for all sorts of nasty stuff to get onto your computer. This rootkit hides any file that starts with $sys$, so anyone could write a trojan or a virus to take advantage of that. And the last sales figure I heard for affected CDs was about 500,000.

Digital rights management doesn't work and causes companies to think they can get away with this crap. It's illegal to remove the Sony rootkit from your computer!

kms_md 11-18-05 11:20 AM

i agree with masetodd in that sony was probably trying to see if they could get this to fly under the radar (given the limited number of titles the rootkit was on).

i am pretty surprised with how poorly it was implemented and the ethics behind their methods of installation.

Mordred 11-18-05 11:25 AM


Originally Posted by Mr. Cinema
I think I only have 1 cd from their list. Life of Agony "Broken Valley". I didn't put it in my computer and have no plans to, so I don't think I'll swap.

I got it through that as well, and I installed it on my work machine. Bad idea. It has crashed my machine at least 5x since the CD came out. It also didn't uninstall properly, no matter how thoroughly I cleaned the registry.

I had to reinstall a more recent version, then Sony's rootkit fix, and then uninstall again. So far no problems, but I'm still pissed.

Mordred

masetodd 11-18-05 12:39 PM

I just found some new type of copy protection on Sony's Stealth DVD. The following files appear in the root directory of the DVD:

AUTORUN.INF
dvd-rom.exe
go.exe


When you insert the DVD, the autorun batch does....something...I don't know what. Is this the same thing as the CD rootkit?

Mopower 11-18-05 03:40 PM


Originally Posted by masetodd
I just found some new type of copy protection on Sony's Stealth DVD. The following files appear in the root directory of the DVD:

AUTORUN.INF
dvd-rom.exe
go.exe


When you insert the DVD, the autorun batch does....something...I don't know what. Is this the same thing as the CD rootkit?

Should be easy enough to fix. Just disable the AUTORUN function of your DVD drive.

Drexl 11-18-05 04:38 PM


Originally Posted by Mopower
Should be easy enough to fix. Just disable the AUTORUN function of your DVD drive.

Well, the problem with these rootkits is that if it's already ran once it's on your hard drive, so the damage has already been done. It will prevent future discs from running them though.

I checked one of the Seinfeld discs from last year and those two programs are on there. Dvd-rom.exe is a Flash Player application that launches the disc's special menu viewable on a computer that includes weblinks as well as the disc's content. Go.exe starts your default DVD player, and is what runs when you select the option to play the disc from that special menu.

Gunshy 11-19-05 01:14 PM

Here's a site with a list (from Sony) of all effected CD titles.

Cripes :(

-Gunshy

kvrdave 11-19-05 04:21 PM

I have a few of those. Fortunately, I just illegally downloaded them to begin with so I don't have the problems reported.


And that is the part that kills me about this. If I had actually downloaded this music (I actually don't have any of that music) illegally, I would be fine, computer would be fine, etc. But if I went out and legally bought a copy I would now have a bunch of crap on my computer. :lol:

Stupid Sony.

Mopower 11-19-05 05:48 PM


Originally Posted by Drexl
Well, the problem with these rootkits is that if it's already ran once it's on your hard drive, so the damage has already been done. It will prevent future discs from running them though.

I checked one of the Seinfeld discs from last year and those two programs are on there. Dvd-rom.exe is a Flash Player application that launches the disc's special menu viewable on a computer that includes weblinks as well as the disc's content. Go.exe starts your default DVD player, and is what runs when you select the option to play the disc from that special menu.



What if you disable autorun before you even put any disc in for the first time?

Drexl 11-19-05 06:10 PM


Originally Posted by Mopower
What if you disable autorun before you even put any disc in for the first time?

Then you're fine.

Giantrobo 11-20-05 05:03 AM

I guess I'm one of the last humans on Earth who only plays CD's in his cd player deck and DVD's in his DVD player. DVD's and cd's RARELY go into my computer drive. :lol:

Fincher Fan 11-20-05 05:30 AM

Just to be safe in the future, I better illegally download any music released by Sony.

Mr. Salty 11-20-05 06:05 AM


Originally Posted by Vandelay_Inds
and since the pigs won't tell which ones have been tampered-with

Actually, Sony has been clearly marking their copy-protected CDs.

stinkeye 11-21-05 01:28 PM

Texas has filed a lawsuit:


Texas Sues Sony Under Anti-Spyware Law

AUSTIN, Texas - The state sued Sony BMG Music Entertainment on Monday under its new anti-spyware law, saying anti-piracy technology the company slipped into music CDs leaves huge security holes on consumers' computers.

The lawsuit is over the so-called XCP technology that Sony had added to more than 50 CDs to restrict to three the number of times a single disc could be copied.

After a storm of criticism, Sony recalled the discs last week.

To enforce the restrictions, the CD automatically installed the copy-protection program when discs were put into a PC — a necessary step for transferring music to iPods and other portable music players.

Attorney General Greg Abbott accused Sony BMG of surreptitiously installing "spyware" in the form of files that mask other files Sony installed as part of XCP.

This "cloaking" component can leave computers vulnerable to viruses and other security problems, said Abbot, echoing the findings of computer security researchers.

"Sony has engaged in a technological version of cloak-and-dagger deceit against consumers by hiding secret files on their computers," Abbott said in a statement.

The term "spyware" has been used broadly to cover programs that are installed without users' full knowledge and consent, whether or not they actually spy on a user's activities.

A Sony BMG spokesman didn't immediately return a call Monday morning.

Sony BMG initially rejected the uproar over XCP as technobabble.

But after security experts discovered that XCP opened gaping security holes in users' computers — as did the method Sony BMG offered for removing XCP — Sony BMG agreed last week to recall the discs.

Some 4.7 million had been made and 2.1 million sold. CDs that had XCP included releases by Van Zant, The Bad Plus, Neil Diamond and Celine Dion.

Abbott said some CDs remained in Texas stores as of Monday morning.

The Texas spyware law allows the state to recover damages of up to $100,000 in damages for each violation.

Abbott said there were thousands of violations, and that any money would go to the state.

Michael Corvin 11-21-05 01:56 PM

I have to give props to Amazon, I was getting ready to order a cd and it is clearly labeled in bold:
[SONY XCP CONTENT/COPY-PROTECTED CD]

Here is the actual CD I was going to order with a more detailed description. It is now unavailable for order.

Odd how they say Sony requested they remove it, but it is still available at other online sites.

Numanoid 11-21-05 01:59 PM


Originally Posted by masetodd
It is apparent that they were test marketing this new copy-protection scheme. It only affects 20 or so titles (and looking at that list, I can't imagine more than 20 people buying that crap).

It's on the new Neil Diamond cd which debuted at #4 on the Billboard charts (of course, now that the cds have been yanked, poor Neil's chart listing is going to drop like a stone). So quite a few people are going to end up with this.

Deftones 11-21-05 02:17 PM

Virgin Records did this with 30 Seconds to Mars' newest disc. It's a total pain in the ass. I hope they get sued too.

Mopower 11-21-05 02:37 PM


Originally Posted by Giantrobo
I guess I'm one of the last humans on Earth who only plays CD's in his cd player deck and DVD's in his DVD player. DVD's and cd's RARELY go into my computer drive. :lol:


They are pretty hard to copy if you don't put them in your DVD or CD-ROM drive.

Tracer Bullet 11-22-05 09:51 AM


Originally Posted by Mopower
They are pretty hard to copy if you don't put them in your DVD or CD-ROM drive.

:rolleyes:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:13 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.