|
Smashing Pumpkins, "Siamese Dream" question?
I was wondering if the cd was released in both explicit, and edited versions? the main reason i ask is because my cd that i have (i just bought it recently), has no sticker, but the words "silver fuck" on the back (and there are no bad words in that song that i can hear.)
also, should i get "Melin coli..." as well? |
Just because a song is called Silverfuck doesn't mean that there is going to be explicit language in it.
Yes, you should buy Melon Collie.... :google: Silverfuck lyrics I hear your winter I hear your rain I've failed your summer ways And I feel no pain I hear what you want And I feel that way I hear what you want And I feel that way I hear you fade away And I hear you crawl I gave my life away And I feel no pain And I feel no pain And I feel no pain And I feel your pain |
Originally Posted by Rypro 525
I was wondering if the cd was released in both explicit, and edited versions? the main reason i ask is because my cd that i have (i just bought it recently), has no sticker, but the words "silver fuck" on the back (and there are no bad words in that song that i can hear.)
also, should i get "Melin coli..." as well? |
Originally Posted by automator
Just because a song is called Silverfuck doesn't mean that there is going to be explicit language in it.
Yes, you should buy Melon Collie.... :google: Silverfuck lyrics I hear your winter I hear your rain I've failed your summer ways And I feel no pain I hear what you want And I feel that way I hear what you want And I feel that way I hear you fade away And I hear you crawl I gave my life away And I feel no pain And I feel no pain And I feel no pain And I feel your pain |
That Greatest Hits disc does sound great...
|
Originally Posted by Rypro 525
also, should i get "Melin coli..." as well?
|
Do you really want to own an album called "Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness"? :lol:
|
Originally Posted by Rypro 525
i also think that they should remaster both albums, since the greatest hits collection that i have sounds superior to the albums (but "Siamese dream" is great)
I would love to get a remaster of SD, but I'd only buy MCIS again if they turned the vocal down WAY WAY much. |
pressing for wal-mart and other family friendly stores recieved versions with the title silverfox or silver****.
this also happened to the nirvana in utero album. the back cover was reworked to not show the fetuses, and the song rape me was retitled waif me. Cobain had tried to have it titled 'Sexually Assault Me' |
Melancholy.
|
Originally Posted by reubs82
Melancholy.
http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B0...CLZZZZZZZ_.jpg |
You should definitely get Mellon Collie. It's great.
|
Should I get their album "A Door?"
|
Originally Posted by Virex
Should I get their album "A Door?"
|
Originally Posted by DVD Josh
0/5
|
Originally Posted by Virex
That bad, huh?
|
Originally Posted by Elldubtoo
Do you really want to own an album called "Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness"? :lol:
|
Originally Posted by The Bus
If it's one of the better rock albums to come out in the 90's, then yes.
Unfortunately, it's not one of the better rock album of the 90's. |
Originally Posted by Elldubtoo
Unfortunately, it's not one of the better rock album of the 90's.
|
Originally Posted by Elldubtoo
Unfortunately, it's not one of the better rock album of the 90's.
|
Anybody who says Mellon Collie is not one of the best rock albums of the 90s hasn't listened to it all the way through. That CD is unbelievable. If you're basing your opinion on 1979 and Tonight, Tonight, then you are missing out on a lot of good music. There are at least 10 songs of pure genius on that album.
|
I was a huge Pumpkins fan back in the day and as such, loved MCIS--every single track. Listened to it dozens upon dozens of times for a good year or two after it came out. A while back, well out of my Pumpkins phase, I put it on again, and could barely get through it all. It's not that there's not good stuff on there; the problem is (like a lot of other double-albums) is that there's too much average (or even mediocre) stuff. Sure, hindsight is always 20/20, but if Billy would have been a little less self-indulgent and trimmed it down somewhat, it would have been right up there with SD as one of those rare, every-track-is-good, from-top-to-bottom records.
Originally Posted by automator
I'm still waiting for you to post your "all killer, no filler" 10 track version.
01. Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 02. Tonight, Tonight 03. Jellybelly 04. Zero 05. Here is No Why 06. Bullet with Butterfly Wings 07. Galapogos 08. Muzzle 09. Porcelina of the Vast Oceans 10. Where Boys Fear to Tread 11. Bodies 12. Thirty-Three 13. 1979 14. Tales of a Scorched Earth 15. Thru the Eyes of Ruby 16. Beautiful 17. By Starlight Leaving off: To Forgive Fuck You (An Ode to No One) Love Cupid de Locke Take Me Down In the Arms of Sleep Stumbleine X.Y.U. We Only Come Out at Night Lily (My One and Only) Farewell and Goodnight |
I could never leave off Stumbleine and Lily (My One & Only).
Not to mention Cupid De Locke. |
Originally Posted by Elldubtoo
Unfortunately, it's not one of the better rock album of the 90's.
|
Originally Posted by Virex
I was a huge Pumpkins fan back in the day and as such, loved MCIS--every single track. Listened to it dozens upon dozens of times for a good year or two after it came out. A while back, well out of my Pumpkins phase, I put it on again, and could barely get through it all. It's not that there's not good stuff on there; the problem is (like a lot of other double-albums) is that there's too much average (or even mediocre) stuff. Sure, hindsight is always 20/20, but if Billy would have been a little less self-indulgent and trimmed it down somewhat, it would have been right up there with SD as one of those rare, every-track-is-good, from-top-to-bottom records.
Here's my whittled-down version, if I were to make one. More than ten tracks--tried to keep it around the length of a blank CD: 01. Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 02. Tonight, Tonight 03. Jellybelly 04. Zero 05. Here is No Why 06. Bullet with Butterfly Wings 07. Galapogos 08. Muzzle 09. Porcelina of the Vast Oceans 10. Where Boys Fear to Tread 11. Bodies 12. Thirty-Three 13. 1979 14. Tales of a Scorched Earth 15. Thru the Eyes of Ruby 16. Beautiful 17. By Starlight Leaving off: To Forgive Fuck You (An Ode to No One) Love Cupid de Locke Take Me Down In the Arms of Sleep Stumbleine X.Y.U. We Only Come Out at Night Lily (My One and Only) Farewell and Goodnight Not bad. There's NO WAY you can leave off Fuck You and XYU though. TOASE and Beautiful have gotta go. |
| All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:28 PM. |
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.