Top Five Smashing Pumpkins Songs
 

Here are the results so far:

Top Five Smashing Pumpkins Songs

1. Mayonnaise/Cherub Rock (tied with 10 votes each)
2. 1979 (8 votes)
3. Zero (7 votes)
4. Tonight Tonight/Disarm (tied with 6 votes)
5. Today (5 votes)

As in the Radiohead thread if you list more than five songs I will only count the top five listed.

Your top five...

Mine:

1. Tonight Tonight
2. Said Sadly
3. Thirty Three
4. Today
5. Farewell and Goodnight

Another agonizing choice...I want to fit Bullet with Butterfly Wings, Disarm, 1979, Galapagos, Cherub Rock, and lots of others.

1. geek u.s.a.
2. f.u. (an ode to no one)
3. porcelina of the vast oceans
4. mayonaise
5. drown

Stand Inside Your Love
Cherub Rock
This Time
Galapagos
Mayonaise

In no order...

Tonight, Tonight
Cherub Rock
1979
Frail & Bedazzled
Landslide

1. Bullet with Butterfly wings
2. 1979
3. Disarm
4. Mayonnaise
5. Zero

Today
Rocket
Cherub Rock
Zero
Never Let Me Down Again

Also in no order.

zero
an ode to no one
who am i
shame
the end is the beginning

1. Soma
2. Luna
3. Silverf**k
4. Mayonnaise/Cherub Rock (I can't decide)
5. Geek USA

As you can tell, I'm rather partial to Siamese Dream.

In no order:

1. 1979
2. Mayonaise
3. For Martha
4. Galapagos
5. Blank Page

(1-4)
Starla
Mayonaise
Geek USA
Drown

(tie for #5)
Zero/I of the Mourning/To Sheila/Rocket/1979/F*You/Dross/Muzzle

Disarm
Cherub Rock
For Shelia
Siva
Bodies

Siva
Rhinoceros
Cherub Rock
Rocket
Drown

I. Cherub Rock
II. Bullet w/ Butterfly Wings
III. Today
IV. 1979
V. Perfect

Soma
Mayonaise
Rocket
Snail
Frail and Bedazzled

And strangely, Mellon Collie is my favorite album..

Today
1979
Cherub Rock
Tonight Tonight
Disarm

I've been listening to Smashing Pumpkins a lot lately, and I need to revise my list.

Mayonaise
Soma
Thirty Three
1979 / Cherub Rock
Tonight Tonight

1979
Mayonaise
Pug
Disarm
Zero

For Sheila?!??!??!

Soma
For Martha
Stand inside your Love
Geek USA
Beautiful

Bullet With Buttefly Wings
Zero
Today
1979
Tonight Tonight

I was never one to attach song names to the songs as I heard them, at least with the Pumpkins. Can I just say the first five songs on Gish, in that order?

I've listened to a lot of their stuff but nothign is better than the stuff on "Siamese Dream," which is slowly becoming one of my favorite albums.

Soma
Cherub Rock
Rocket
Mayonaisse
Disarm

1. Mayonaise
2. Thirty-Three
3. Tonight Tonight
4. Blew Away
5. Cherub Rock

in order:

1. Tonight, Tonight
2. 1979
3. Ava Adore
4. Perfect
5. Zero

1. Thirty Three

2. Spaceboy

3. Stand Inside Your Love

4. Disarm

5. song on Machina that says "radio" in chorus. i think it was a single.

Bump for first tally.

BTW, TeeSayJay, I counted the first five on Gish for you. Frank TJ Mackey, I didn't count your fifth selection since I'm not sure which song that is.