DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Music Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/music-talk-28/)
-   -   Remastered/Reissued Discs. (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/music-talk/212583-remastered-reissued-discs.html)

Rogue588 06-03-02 02:25 PM

Remastered/Reissued Discs.
 
So...

A couple of nights ago i'm listening to Meat Loaf's remastered "Bat Out Of Hell" disc. This being one of my all-time favorite discs, i listen to it straight through [i don't do that with all discs]. Right after the final notes of "For Crying Out Loud" wind down, i say to myself "Damn that's a good album". Then i hear some noise -- sounds like an audience -- then another song starts to play! [two to be exact] "Bolero" & "Bat Out Of Hell". Totally f'd up the vibe of the disc.

This incident made me think of other "remastered" discs i own which have some tacked on "bonus" tracks at the end. Now, i'm never one to refuse ANYTHING that's a bonus. But is tampering with an album like "Bat Out Of Hell" [with a definitive "beginning" & "ending" to it] really wise?

If anything, they should just put these tracks on a separate disc.

jeez.

mike1978 06-03-02 03:00 PM

I'm a fan of bonus material as long as it's on a separate disc. The Elvis Costello reissues are a good example of doing things the right way - separate discs with some worthwhile bonus tracks, and fairly extensive liner notes. On the other end of the spectrum, I think there is an XTC reissue (or reissues) that put(s) the bonus songs IN THE MIDDLE of the album. That's just wrong.

JAA 06-03-02 04:53 PM

For the most part I hate this trend and (almost always) the actual bonus tracks suck for a variety of reasons.

benedict 06-03-02 06:10 PM

Fine in theory; often poor in practice.

I bought McCartney's Back to the Egg and the added tracks were poorly chosen and really jarred: there was plenty of "rockier" material they could have used!

Giantrobo 06-03-02 06:42 PM

I like remasters if,mind you I've yet to buy one, they are able to find better audio to copy from, or they go back to the original album's artwork.

Jason 06-03-02 07:05 PM

I like remasters and bonus tracks, although I agree the really good bonus tracks are few and far between. Plus, so many artists' original CD catalogs were so piss-poor that remasters are essential.

Surf Monkey 06-04-02 01:41 AM


Originally posted by mike1978
On the other end of the spectrum, I think there is an XTC reissue (or reissues) that put(s) the bonus songs IN THE MIDDLE of the album. That's just wrong.
All of the XTC remasters had the bonus tracks in the middle. Big problem. They're all coming out now with the tracks at the end. Good!

Drexl 06-04-02 02:48 PM


Originally posted by Giantrobo
I like remasters if, mind you I've yet to buy one, they are able to find better audio to copy from...
Um, yeah, that's what a "remaster" is. :)


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:20 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.