DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Music Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/music-talk-28/)
-   -   What if?? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/music-talk/200859-what-if.html)

redhenry 04-18-02 01:55 AM

What if??
 
(Edited) What would you do if your favourite artist was to out him or herself as gay? Would you be pissed? Would you burn their albums or just shrug and keep listening?

T

gilbertr76 04-18-02 02:05 AM

:confused:

Is this a reference to suicide or closets?

DumDum 04-18-02 03:14 AM

Well, Stipes gay and I still like R.E.M. so I don't really think it would matter one way or the other...

I assume thats what you're referring to anyway.

Ergyu 04-18-02 10:34 AM

Their sexual preferences should have no bearing over liking them. As long as they keep rocking, that's all that matters.

Lateralus 04-18-02 10:37 AM

I have no problem with it, but when a gay artist sings a love song it makes me wonder.....

Gooch 04-18-02 02:47 PM

It's all about the music.

Gay or straight makes no difference.


Although I can see how the Gay singer singing a love song can be confusing :D

grunter 04-18-02 03:25 PM

If you really think it's true that revealing one's homosexuality has no bearing on whether the fanbase will continue following a particular artist, then why do you think it's so difficult for some artists to come out?

And why is it different in the case of actors/actresses? Or is it?

MJKTool 04-18-02 03:27 PM

My favorite singer Maynard James Keenan has gotten pretty close to that borderline many times dressing like a woman :D :lol:
But to answer the question, absolutely not. It wouldnt affect my listening to them one single bit.

Goat3001 04-18-02 03:29 PM

Well considering that one of my favorite bands is Emperor and the drummer(?) killed a homosexual and if he or any of his bandmates were to come out, then I'd be very very shocked. But it wouldn't stop my from listening to them.

I'd find it hilarious is Eminem outted himself. Consdering his history with gay's.

db27 04-18-02 03:35 PM

wouldn't matter at all. i could care less what someones sexual preference is.

POWERBOMB 04-18-02 04:40 PM

Doesn't matter.

tofu 04-18-02 05:06 PM

if shirley manson turned gay . . i wouldn't care, she's still nice to look at :D
and that doesn't change how i feel about their music as it's still awesome.

JAA 04-18-02 05:31 PM

It wouldn't matter to me at all. It's about the music people! :D

Gdrlv 04-18-02 05:37 PM


Originally posted by MJKTool
My favorite singer Maynard James Keenan has gotten pretty close to that borderline many times dressing like a woman :D :lol:
But to answer the question, absolutely not. It wouldnt affect my listening to them one single bit.

I thought it was pretty well known that Maynard was gay...am I wrong? I've always just assumed...

Anyway, it does not make one iota of difference to me either way, as long as the music's good.

shrike 04-19-02 12:35 AM

Would have no effect on me. What they do in the bedroom is between them and their SO. Long as the music is good why should I care?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:43 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.