~~A Perfect TOOL??
 

What are everyone's thoughts on the Maynard going back-and-forth between TOOL and A Perfect Circle??

Thoughts on A Perfect Circle?
Will they do another album with Maynard after Tool wraps up their Lateralus tour(s)?


I personally have seen APC three times and I love em.

But....Tool is "thee" best. Period.

I love both groups. A Perfect Circle's debut album was excellent and Tool is Tool, enough said. I hope A Perfect Circle is not a side project and that the band will release another album. It would be nice if Tool and A Perfect Circle alternates their release year so every year, we could get one new album from either one. I mean for example, APC's album in 2000, Tool in 2001, APC in 2002, Tool in 2003, etc.

Love APC, but TOOL is the shyte no matter what. I have seen TOOL more times then i can count. every chance i get I'm there. love them both, but if he has to stick to one, let me hear more tool. :)

Love them both, I'm looking forward to the nexy from APC. And now after seeing TOOL the 1st time last night, and dying to get more from them as well!!! What a selfish bastard huh?

I love how Maynard is pulling double time with regards to music....it just means more for me :D

Of course I love Tool more than APC, but hope they can co-exsist for a long time, because APC is an awesome band in my opinion. I think that Mer de Noms was an amazing first effort from a new band, and can only get better with time. Billy is writing new music as we speak, and cant wait for their new CD (rumored to be out next year).

I love them both too. Amazingly, however, I think I've listened to the APC more times than any Tool album. The cd is simply beautiful...I don't think it'll ever get old. I hope for another release.

Mr. Self Destruct, I'm the same way on listening to Mer de Noms.
I think it's because it's shorter and more of a regular album.....just songs.

Tool is more of an experience in my opinion and you can't just put a Tool album on............you have to go start-to-end baby.

Like how basically everyone else feels, Tool is definitely the better group, but I too love APC's first album - and yes, they are currently working on the next one.

I just hope we don't have another 5 year wait for the next Tool album.

Count me in as the first dissenter. I could never get into APC, even after seeing them open for NIN. To me they come across as just another band that happens to have Maynard as a singer (which does make them better than 90% of the bands out there, but still).

Tool is the Bomb..nuff said. I have the APC and all Tool cds (except the EP). Ive seen APC and will be seeing Tool the first time on 11/2. I cant wait. Maynard is a vocal god. I love the Deftones song Passenger; it adds so much to the song with Maynard on vocals as well.

I got into Tool through APC. I saw tool live twice in the past week and it was incredible. I think they are unfairly regarded as 'metal' which can be alienating to some people before they even give them a chance.

do you play an instrument? if my theory holds true you don't. seems as though everyone I know that doesn't dig APC, does not play an instrument. but most that love them do. weird huh?

Well, I own a guitar, but I haven't gotten around to being good at it yet. ;) Anyway, supposedly bands like Rush and Dream Theater are musicians' bands, and I've been big fans of both for years.