View Poll Results: What did you think of Transformers: Rise of the Beasts?





0
0%





0
0%





0
0%





0
0%





0
0%





0
0%
No interest. Don't care




0
0%
Voters: 14. You may not vote on this poll
Transformers: Rise of the Beasts (2023, D: Caple Jr.) -- The Spoiler Reviews Thread
#51
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Transformers: Rise of the Beasts (2023, D: Caple Jr.) -- The Spoiler Reviews Thread
I forgot all about how goofy Psyche Out looked. But yeah I was talking about Dial-tone.
The following users liked this post:
story (08-03-23)
#52
Moderator
Re: Transformers: Rise of the Beasts (2023, D: Caple Jr.) -- The Spoiler Reviews Thread
Which is more than anyone has really said about Dial-Tone in 37 years.
#53
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Transformers: Rise of the Beasts (2023, D: Caple Jr.) -- The Spoiler Reviews Thread
As far as pulling in M.A.S.K. to a Hasbroverse, that's not unheard of.
This 2008 figure merged the franchises together. File card reveals M.A.S.K. was partnered with GI Joe and V.E.N.O.M. was part of Cobra all along.


This 2008 figure merged the franchises together. File card reveals M.A.S.K. was partnered with GI Joe and V.E.N.O.M. was part of Cobra all along.


#54
Administrator
Re: Transformers: Rise of the Beasts (2023, D: Caple Jr.) -- The Spoiler Reviews Thread
Waiting for this genre of Joe to be updated with the release of Cell Tower, 6G, and Brainbeam. And of course, Cobra needs their own guy: Tech Bro
#55
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Transformers: Rise of the Beasts (2023, D: Caple Jr.) -- The Spoiler Reviews Thread
G.I. Joe jumped the shark when they brought Sgt. Slaughter into the line. Then William "The Refrigerator" Perry. And then that Cobra-La nonsense.
And I do think that Hollow Earth, Lemuria stuff is kind of cool, but it was a bridge too far for something that was previously grounded (such as it was) like G. I. Joe.
And I do think that Hollow Earth, Lemuria stuff is kind of cool, but it was a bridge too far for something that was previously grounded (such as it was) like G. I. Joe.
#56
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Transformers: Rise of the Beasts (2023, D: Caple Jr.) -- The Spoiler Reviews Thread
G.I. Joe jumped the shark when they brought Sgt. Slaughter into the line. Then William "The Refrigerator" Perry. And then that Cobra-La nonsense.
And I do think that Hollow Earth, Lemuria stuff is kind of cool, but it was a bridge too far for something that was previously grounded (such as it was) like G. I. Joe.
And I do think that Hollow Earth, Lemuria stuff is kind of cool, but it was a bridge too far for something that was previously grounded (such as it was) like G. I. Joe.
https://www.yojoe.com/action/87/sneakpeek.shtml
He has a periscope. He's also named after Stephen King's son in return for King creating... Crystal Ball. I mean I have fond memories of Battleforce 2000 but they had definitely jumped the shark by then (and Hama infamously just slaughted all the toys he didn't care about in the comic).
I so look forward to the train wreck a crossover movie is going to be though.
#58
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Transformers: Rise of the Beasts (2023, D: Caple Jr.) -- The Spoiler Reviews Thread
I just got back from the early IMAX screening tonight. The auditorium's capacity is 120 and it was completely sold out. Every seat was filled. They gave out a Optimus Primal poster and a Maximals collectible decal.
Anyway, I actually really liked this. Is it good as Bumblebee? No. But, I was entertained and it's not loud and headache inducing like Age of Extinction and The Last Knight. It's actually quite funny. There are a lot of LOL moments. Anthony Ramos and Dominque Fishbeck were actually good human characters. The highlight for me was Pete Davidson. He was absolutely hysterical as Mirage. He and Ramos played off each other so well. A lot of funny moments between them. She has a small part here, but kind of ironic that Lauren Velez plays the Mom here and also voices the Mom in Spider-Verse.
Ron Perlman was great as Optimus Primal. Total badass.
I won't spoil it now because it's only Wednesday and I know most of you who are interested in this likely won't see it until the weekend, but there is a big reveal at the end that I did not see coming. Everyone in the theater was like WHAT??? The guy sitting next to me was losing his mind.
There is one mid-credits scene. Nothing mind blowing. Just a light moment.
117 minutes flew by. The bloated 2 1/2 hour plus movies dragged, but I thought this was well edited and scenes kept moving. I know not everyone will like this. It's gotten mixed critics reviews and the Transformers name is tainted with some pretty bad movies. But, they did a decent job following up Bumblebee. They do make one quick reference to the previous movie.
Probably my 3rd favorite Transformers movie.
Anyway, I actually really liked this. Is it good as Bumblebee? No. But, I was entertained and it's not loud and headache inducing like Age of Extinction and The Last Knight. It's actually quite funny. There are a lot of LOL moments. Anthony Ramos and Dominque Fishbeck were actually good human characters. The highlight for me was Pete Davidson. He was absolutely hysterical as Mirage. He and Ramos played off each other so well. A lot of funny moments between them. She has a small part here, but kind of ironic that Lauren Velez plays the Mom here and also voices the Mom in Spider-Verse.
Ron Perlman was great as Optimus Primal. Total badass.
I won't spoil it now because it's only Wednesday and I know most of you who are interested in this likely won't see it until the weekend, but there is a big reveal at the end that I did not see coming. Everyone in the theater was like WHAT??? The guy sitting next to me was losing his mind.
Spoiler:
There is one mid-credits scene. Nothing mind blowing. Just a light moment.
117 minutes flew by. The bloated 2 1/2 hour plus movies dragged, but I thought this was well edited and scenes kept moving. I know not everyone will like this. It's gotten mixed critics reviews and the Transformers name is tainted with some pretty bad movies. But, they did a decent job following up Bumblebee. They do make one quick reference to the previous movie.
Probably my 3rd favorite Transformers movie.
For fuck's sake, they did so well with Bumblebee, which was fucking awesome and close to perfect, and then comes this, yet another gigantic steaming pile of Michael Bay.
Same stupid story.
Same redundant human characters.
Same awful dialogue.
Same bad designs.
Same ridiculous robots with human accents.
Same stupid fucking insect-like mini-robots.
Same juvenile humor.
And every cliche in the book, repeated.
Not even the action was anything special.
Same stupid story.
Same redundant human characters.
Same awful dialogue.
Same bad designs.
Same ridiculous robots with human accents.
Same stupid fucking insect-like mini-robots.
Same juvenile humor.
And every cliche in the book, repeated.
Not even the action was anything special.
Is very true.

They both express how I feel. That would be confusing talking about any movie except Transformers.
I think they just hit it out of the park with Bumblebee. It was just so grounded you really cared for the characters unlike every single other transformers movie. They tried with the guys brother. But it mostly just came across as forced. As for the real stars, the transformers, they were mainly ok. Unfortunately we didn't have the epic opener that Bumblebee had. Again they tried. But mostly failed. It just wasn't as faithful to the source material as the opener to Bumblebee was. The design was very much back to Bayverse transformers.
It's way better than any of the other Bayverse movies except for the first one.
Here's the main problem with the Transformers movies IMO. They focus way too much on plot and not enough on character. We don't really care about the plot, it's always some world ending something or another. They should focus on the characters. That's why the Bumblebee movie works so well. You actually have a connection with Charlie, the girl, and Bumblebee because they actually spent time developing their relationship. In this movie when Bee died I felt nothing. There was zero impact at all. Because it was all plot driven. Versus in the last movie when he's being tortured and zapped you felt sympathy for the robot. They need to stop relying on stupid accents or other ridiculous character traits as that is just lazy writing and not actual character development. To me the more ridiculous the concept of a movie is the more grounded and relatable the characters need to be. Contrast this movie with Guardians of the Galaxy which despite their ridiculous nature, are well developed as a struggling adoptive family which is something everyone can relate to.
#59
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Transformers: Rise of the Beasts (2023, D: Caple Jr.) -- The Spoiler Reviews Thread
OK, well, I watched this after rewatching Bumblebee last week. Unfortunately, it feels like a lot of this fell back into traps that the Bay movies did. MacGuffins, nonsensical logic or story progression, bad Optimus characterization. At least the action and transformations weren't incomprehensible.
But just stupid things like "we've partnered with the humans for hundreds of years to keep the Transwarp key". Why? What do the humans bring to this? They never say. And as soon as the Terrorcons show up, it's "protect the humans". Suddenly they're a liability and not helping protect the key in any way. And then they give the key to the new humans (why did they think that would be a good idea?), and it promptly gets taken away. Optimus' plan is terrible. "We'll lure Scourge here with the other half of the key, and then take the key from him when I kill him. There's no way this could go wrong, and Scourge gets the whole key and ends the universe, even though he kicked my ass in our last encounter." I also didn't like the fact that Scourge was basically invincible until he wasn't. All you need to do if find some lava for him, I guess?
Oh yeah, and why is there absolutely no way they can get back to Cybertron unless they use the Transwarp key? I mean, they all got to Earth without the Transwarp key, right?
I thought Pete Davidson was fine, but if you're going to make his personality like Jazz, why not just call him Jazz? He didn't even use his holographic powers in any meaningful way.
I thought the Maximals were some of the best parts of the movie, even if Rhinox and Cheetor were underused. And I am not even a Beast Wars fan. I more of a G1 guy. I also liked the human characters. I'd be fine with them continuing in the franchise.
But just stupid things like "we've partnered with the humans for hundreds of years to keep the Transwarp key". Why? What do the humans bring to this? They never say. And as soon as the Terrorcons show up, it's "protect the humans". Suddenly they're a liability and not helping protect the key in any way. And then they give the key to the new humans (why did they think that would be a good idea?), and it promptly gets taken away. Optimus' plan is terrible. "We'll lure Scourge here with the other half of the key, and then take the key from him when I kill him. There's no way this could go wrong, and Scourge gets the whole key and ends the universe, even though he kicked my ass in our last encounter." I also didn't like the fact that Scourge was basically invincible until he wasn't. All you need to do if find some lava for him, I guess?
Oh yeah, and why is there absolutely no way they can get back to Cybertron unless they use the Transwarp key? I mean, they all got to Earth without the Transwarp key, right?
I thought Pete Davidson was fine, but if you're going to make his personality like Jazz, why not just call him Jazz? He didn't even use his holographic powers in any meaningful way.
I thought the Maximals were some of the best parts of the movie, even if Rhinox and Cheetor were underused. And I am not even a Beast Wars fan. I more of a G1 guy. I also liked the human characters. I'd be fine with them continuing in the franchise.
#61
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Transformers: Rise of the Beasts (2023, D: Caple Jr.) -- The Spoiler Reviews Thread
OK, well, I watched this after rewatching Bumblebee last week. Unfortunately, it feels like a lot of this fell back into traps that the Bay movies did. MacGuffins, nonsensical logic or story progression, bad Optimus characterization. At least the action and transformations weren't incomprehensible.
But just stupid things like "we've partnered with the humans for hundreds of years to keep the Transwarp key". Why? What do the humans bring to this? They never say. And as soon as the Terrorcons show up, it's "protect the humans". Suddenly they're a liability and not helping protect the key in any way. And then they give the key to the new humans (why did they think that would be a good idea?), and it promptly gets taken away. Optimus' plan is terrible. "We'll lure Scourge here with the other half of the key, and then take the key from him when I kill him. There's no way this could go wrong, and Scourge gets the whole key and ends the universe, even though he kicked my ass in our last encounter." I also didn't like the fact that Scourge was basically invincible until he wasn't. All you need to do if find some lava for him, I guess?
Oh yeah, and why is there absolutely no way they can get back to Cybertron unless they use the Transwarp key? I mean, they all got to Earth without the Transwarp key, right?
I thought Pete Davidson was fine, but if you're going to make his personality like Jazz, why not just call him Jazz? He didn't even use his holographic powers in any meaningful way.
I thought the Maximals were some of the best parts of the movie, even if Rhinox and Cheetor were underused. And I am not even a Beast Wars fan. I more of a G1 guy. I also liked the human characters. I'd be fine with them continuing in the franchise.
But just stupid things like "we've partnered with the humans for hundreds of years to keep the Transwarp key". Why? What do the humans bring to this? They never say. And as soon as the Terrorcons show up, it's "protect the humans". Suddenly they're a liability and not helping protect the key in any way. And then they give the key to the new humans (why did they think that would be a good idea?), and it promptly gets taken away. Optimus' plan is terrible. "We'll lure Scourge here with the other half of the key, and then take the key from him when I kill him. There's no way this could go wrong, and Scourge gets the whole key and ends the universe, even though he kicked my ass in our last encounter." I also didn't like the fact that Scourge was basically invincible until he wasn't. All you need to do if find some lava for him, I guess?
Oh yeah, and why is there absolutely no way they can get back to Cybertron unless they use the Transwarp key? I mean, they all got to Earth without the Transwarp key, right?
I thought Pete Davidson was fine, but if you're going to make his personality like Jazz, why not just call him Jazz? He didn't even use his holographic powers in any meaningful way.
I thought the Maximals were some of the best parts of the movie, even if Rhinox and Cheetor were underused. And I am not even a Beast Wars fan. I more of a G1 guy. I also liked the human characters. I'd be fine with them continuing in the franchise.
I also don't understand why the Maximals don't even transform until the battle, was that a budget thing? AirRazor doesn't transform at all.
#62
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Transformers: Rise of the Beasts (2023, D: Caple Jr.) -- The Spoiler Reviews Thread
I liked it more than the Bay movies, but less than Bumblebee. I definitely didn't like the mech suit, regardless of whether or not it's from the source material.
#63
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Transformers: Rise of the Beasts (2023, D: Caple Jr.) -- The Spoiler Reviews Thread
Oh yeah, I forgot to mention that. When I first saw that suit going on, I got really excited, thinking that they were going to do Targetmasters or Powermasters or something. But then it ended up just being like the accelerator suits in the G.I. Joe movie, which was the worst thing (well, 1 of 10 worst things) about that movie.
#64
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Transformers: Rise of the Beasts (2023, D: Caple Jr.) -- The Spoiler Reviews Thread
Here's some G1-inspired Arcee goodness.