Sub-Zero

Who is your favorite Spider-Man?

The Antipodean

Maguire is the closest to “my” Spider-Man and feels the most comics accurate. Garfield’s movies were pretty awful writing and plots but he isn’t bad, just a bit darker and less nerdy. I like Holland but to me he’s always been kind of an Ultimate Spider-Man character and very different than how I picture PP.

GoldenJCJ

So I guess I should stay out of any thread that even mentions Spider-Man to avoid spoilers for No Way Home.

Sonny Corinthos

Tom Holland

Kennyx

Agreed. I never read the comics, but I always thought PP was the nerdy loner type student before getting bitten. As great as the new movies are, I just never got that vibe from Holland.

mapasu

Shinji Todo (藤堂 新二Tōdō Shinji)

TomOpus

I would, just to be safe. It would take a special kind of asshole to spoil outside of the movie thread but things might slip.

d2cheer

Since there has only been 3 good Spider-Man movies and Toby Maguire was in two of them...I will go with him.

B5Erik

I voted Tom Holland, but Maguire and Garfield both did pretty well. Garfield didn't quite get it in the first movie (too Emo), but in TASM2 he really felt like Peter.

My pick for the best COLLEGE age Peter Parker, though, is Nicholas Hammond. He really nailed the role of the guy in the comics in the 70's, and his take on college Peter would have been great in the 80's, too.

GatorDeb

I've watched ALL the Spiderman movies when they came out. After watching No Way Home,
.

Maxflier

Andrew Garfield

movieguru

If I'm to base it off of whom I feel is closest to the original depiction of Spider-Man from the Marvel comics in the1960's, I would go with Tobey Maguire for Peter Parker and Andrew Garfield for Spider-Man. Andrew Garfield had the best sarcastic quips as Spider-Man, but as Peter Parker he came off as the cool kid that could fit in with the cool crowd but also identified with the nerdier students as well. Holland's version didn't really fully capture either aspect of Peter Parker or Spider-Man, but still made his movies entertaining.

OldBoy

Garfield had best acted Spider-Man and would put him 2nd in retrospect, but Holland is Spider-Man.

JeffTheAlpaca

Tobey and did not care for the ones that followed after him

Hazel Motes

Christopher Daniel Barnes

B5Erik

When they were casting the first Spider-Man movie he stated he was hoping for a chance at a screen test for it. His voice work was really good in that series, and he kind of looked the part. I don't think he was ever considered by Raimi, though. Clearly they did OK with Tobey.